Buckeye Pizza &amp; Stromboli

Shout out to this Roosters for coming up clutch. After a Sunday Funday, I needed some sustenance to…read moreend the night in good shape. It was late and approaching close, but Roosters welcomed my friend and I for dine-in service. 45 minutes later, we're walking out full of Roosters goodness in the form of fried chicken and potatoes. Way to be there in my hour of need.

Ice tea was old, and couldn't even get a burger correct, it was so off I thought it was for…read moresomeone else.

Boneless wings, Monday special. Mango habanero top, garlic Parmesan bottom.

Menu

See all

5 Boneless Wings

Hey Hey Bar & Grill

4.0(81 reviews)

8.6 mi•Merion Village

•$

Thank you to the entire team at Hey Hey Bar & Grill for your kindness from the moment we walked…read morethrough the front doors. We genuinely appreciated the warm welcome, the clapping, the high‑fives, and the positive energy. It set the tone for an experience that went far beyond a meal. I loved learning the history of how your restaurant became what it is today. Your hot wings were amazing, and the coleslaw pizza was a first for me -- and a delicious surprise. The service was outstanding; the staff kept the buffet fresh and refilled without hesitation. The atmosphere was full of gratitude, laughter, and plenty of photos. It felt like a place where people come together to enjoy good food and good company. Thank you for making our visit memorable. We truly appreciate everything.

I love this place. The vibes when you walk in as a new comer can be a off putting. But once people…read morewarm up to you everyone is friendly. They have amazing food and drinks (that you order at the bar). The prices are very reasonable. They also have different events going on depending on what night it is. I love to go on Wednesdays for karaoke. https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZThpSsXgE/

Bar (09/28/2024)

Jack and coke

See all

Pecan Penny's

3.9(361 reviews)

8.0 mi•Downtown

Pecan Penny's is an awesome BBQ restaurant right downtown! The outdoor patio vibes makes this a…read moreperfect summer spot! All of their meats are dry rubbed and cooked low and slow till tender and delicious! Going along with their BBQ, they have a ton of tasty sides like their corn bread, Mac n cheese and hush puppies! They also have build your own BBQ bowls to make your ultimate bbq dish you've always dreamed of! Definitely give them a try next time you're craving BBQ!

Solid 3.5 Pretzels…read more&cheese- 4.5/5 crispy soft, perfect salt and butter ratio perfect. Sauces * G daddy- good * Kurt- good, but very watery * Hot grandpa- good not spicy at all, maybe a little twang. Bowl- grits, greens, brisket, jalepeno, cornbread croutons -4/5 portions could have been a little bit bigger. Highlighted the greens being very good. Secondary no greens and green beans are both made with pork. Wings (extra dry rub seasoning)- 3/5 cooked good, but we requested well done. Flavor just okay. Burnt ends- 2/5 not burnt at all. Very fatty chewy. Used to crispy caramelized burnt ends, these were just Ends.. Onion rings/fries- 4/5 nothing crazy meets the need Hush puppies- 4/5 good Cole slaw 3/5 Texas Toast 4/5 Manhattan 3/5 Overall a nice local spot for barbecue. Not slap ya mama good.. but the casual environment -dog friendly patio with games & good service definitely makes it worth returning to for a quick bite or Night out with family.

6.8 mi•Short North, Italian Village

Corn bread, collard greens, chicken wings and brisket

Brisket, wings, corn bread, greens

See all

The Eagle Short North

4.3(822 reviews)

Came in on a Friday night for an early dinner. We were promptly seated. Our server was a college…read morestudent that recognized my tee shirt (Birds Aren't Real) and commented that he did a research project on the same. Really nice kid. He also helped us with the menu. We both got the fried chicken BLT, the spoon bread and mac & cheese. The spoon bread is simple corn bread, but it was really good. The mac & cheese was homemade and delicious. The sandwiches were outstanding and huge. My daughter and I could have split one between us. Instead, we brought two halves home. Not sure what this place used to be. High ceilings with barn beams and an old style post office mail box layout, like you might see in an old hotel. Regardless, would not hesitate to come back.

The Eagle was delicious! The southern food and drink offerings was awesome. I got the 1/2 fried…read morechicken, sweet potato casserole, and a 1/2 chopped salad. This place is known for its chicken and boy was it good. It was juicy and packed flavor! I would recommend getting it with the Hot Honey that is offered. The sweet potato casserole was also spot on and reminded me of the holidays. The staff is super nice and service is quick. Overall ambiance is great and you have a large choice of different beers!

See all

The Thurman Cafe

4.0(1.3k reviews)

9.0 mi•German Village

Somehow, after all this time, I finally made it to Thurman's and I'm already wondering why it took…read moreme so long. From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel right at home. Kind, personable, and genuinely warm exactly the kind of energy that makes a meal feel like more than just a meal. If you've seen The Menu, you know that scene where all anyone really wants is just a perfect, unpretentious burger done right. Thurman's is exactly that. The burger was everything it needed to be no gimmicks, no shortcuts, just a beautifully made sandwich that delivers on every level. The fries? Equally on point. Honestly, I have no notes. None. This is the kind of place that reminds you why simple food, done exceptionally well, will always win. If you haven't been, go. If you have, you already know.

So while in Columbus to look at a vehicle with my best friend we had to stop for some plumbing…read moresupplies near by and I had this location as a bookmarked location I wanted to eat at. I am so glad we stopped. Parking can be a pain as it is all street parking and there are 2 coffee shops and two restaurants basically next door. With parking aside, we were stopped in and was greeted as soon as we walked in and then taken to a seat. The bar staff handles all tables and the bar. This place isn't huge and the lobby hold as many people as the seats and the bar. So plan accordingly. The bathroom was clean and the restaurant was clean as well. We ordered drinks. And our burgers and sides. The burger is literally at 3/4 pound burger. I took half home as it is a big burger. The fries were perfectly done fresh cut fries. These are not frozen bag fries. This burger was one of the best I have had. The fries are also very very good. Highly recommend. If you are anywhere near here and want a good burger why are you not here yet.

Juke box

Zucchini Fries

See all

The "Thurmanator" with cheese fries.

Sycamore

4.2(501 reviews)

8.3 mi•German Village

*This review is based on a Thursday during Happy Hour*…read more Overview: *Food Quality: Small portions but each bite is flavorful and fresh. Very much tasting, not necessarily to get full *Service: Friendly, attentive, but not hovering *Ambiance: Clean, quite during happy hour, however, starts to fill up as the evening continues. * Menu: Limited happy hour menu, don't expect a full menu, but what they offer is done well Must Order: * Sticky Roasted Carrots. I don't like carrots and I couldn't stop grabbing a piece Drinks: * The Sycamore Old Fashion... very strong, but I like strong drinks Cost: $33 w/o tip | $44 with tip (split between 2 people) * What we ordered: Sticky carrots Meze Scallops (not on happy hour menu) The Sycamore Old Fashion Italian 90 *Comes with complimentary bread. Also, gluten free options* Best for: Casual check in Low key date maybe if you work near German Village. Traffic during happy hour is a bit backed up I wouldn't go for solo dining, unless I sat outside during warmer weather. However, the feeling is best for a quick get together with 1-2 friends. Would I come back? ... Yes! Definitely for Happy Hour.

I went to The Sycamore last weekend for a friend's bachelorette, and it was truly a 10/10…read moreexperience--from the service to the food to the overall atmosphere. It was the perfect spot for a relaxed, drawn-out dinner where we could enjoy drinks, take our time, and really soak it all in. We had a reservation and were seated right away, which set the tone for the night. Everyone ordered cocktails (I've heard the espresso martini is one of their best, even though coffee isn't really my thing), and honestly, you can't go wrong with anything on the drink menu. We started with the Meze, which included house-made falafel, tzatziki, hummus, sun-dried tomato couscous, assorted vegetables, and naan--everything was fresh and so flavorful. They also brought out complimentary focaccia right away, which was such a nice touch. For my main, I ordered the seasonal scallops, and I also tried the chicken thighs with fig, goat cheese, asparagus, parmigiano reggiano, and couscous--both were absolutely amazing. I'd go back in a heartbeat just to try more of the menu. We were there for about 2-3 hours, and at no point did we feel rushed or like we were inconveniencing the staff. The entire experience felt thoughtful, welcoming, and just really special. Highly recommend The Sycamore for your next date night or girls' dinner!

Bar area

Cubano

See all

Old Fashioned

Local Cantina Brewery District

3.9(222 reviews)

8.6 mi•Brewery District

We had been reminded that Local Cantina serves Brunch until 3:00, which enticed us in. We always…read moreget friendly service at the bar and had a nice meal. The tacos are interesting and I enjoyed the jalapeño cornbread.

Local Cantina gets all of the details right when it comes to takeout. I ordered takeout for pick-up…read morearound 10:00pm. I appreciate the option to order takeout after the dining room closes. They included chips and salsa, lime wedges and all of the condiments I'd need and have access to if I were dining in. The parking lot it's a bit dark but it is great that there is designated parking in an area where most places only offer street parking. The staff were attentive and brought my order to the door as soon as I arrived. I also liked that there are several side dish options and I could order fries with the steak fajitas. The steak was inconsistently cooked. Otherwise it was a fantastic meal.

See all

Hot Chicken Takeover

4.4(1.6k reviews)

7.2 mi•Short North

I have been to Hot Chicken Takeover so many times in different locations but never had the…read moreopportunity to try it at North Market. Finally came to for lunch on a Sunday and it was pretty quiet inside, very clean and plenty of space to seat and eat. Parking is available at Vine Street Garage and I believe all the vendors at North Market should be able to validate parking. Ok now for the food, I ordered the chicken sandwich but I opted for the Range dressing, because I just love HCT's ranch. I can have the ranch with everything. The sandwich came with 2 sliced of white bread on both sides, pickles and slaw. I have never had the sandwich before this event, and let me tell you, the sandwich is huge. You will make a mess, but it's worth it! It was delicious especially when you pair it with their sweet tea! As always the staff at any HCT are very friendly and prompt, this location was no exception. Good food and good service, can't beat that! Can't wait to visit HCT again!

Ordering is kiosk-only. The lids were messy, and the floor felt very sticky, which made the space…read moreseem a bit neglected. I also noticed a large fridge being used in the back, which made me wonder how fresh the food really is. Chicken Tenders: came out hot and moist. Still, Hatty B's holds the top spot for me. Pickles: Much sweeter than expected--if you like sweet pickles, you'll enjoy them. Hush Puppies: These were a standout. Super crispy and well-seasoned. Fries: The wavy cut was fun, but they were pale, under-seasoned, and needed to be crispier. Mac & Cheese: Creamy and cheesy, just how it should be. But why was it served in prepackaged containers? Sauces The hot honey ranch was excellent. Their regular ranch and comeback sauce were also surprisingly good.

These are the Tenders and are really good.

See all

The Old Mohawk

4.0(469 reviews)

8.6 mi•German Village

This is a nice "divey" kind of place that has good food and a good atmosphere…read more Everyone was mostly pleased with their meals with one issue (out of the 4 of us). My wife ordered her Cheeseburger Med-Well and it came to her Med-Rare which always grosses her out. They cooked it more for her. We had the Crab Tater Tots and the Potato Cakes and they were delicious. I also had the bratwurst sandwich which was also delicious!

It's been a while since we've ventured down to German Village to visit The Old Mohawk but it never…read moredisappoints. The Old Mohawk is a German Village institution and rightly so. The place has a great old tavern atmosphere, a great menu, good food and great service. We had a seat right next to the front window and were able to enjoy the activity outside while enjoying our meal inside. If you're anywhere near German Village, you owe to yourself to give the Old Mohawk a try. Just a couple of blocks north of Schiller Park.

7.3 mi•Discovery District

Lots of local artwork on the walls for sale.

Rey

See all

Great bar fantastic ambiance

ClusterTruck

4.2(92 reviews)

Large group friendly

Vegan friendly

Love this place, have ordered lunch for work here many times…read more Website is super easy to use and lets you make adjustments as necessary. Even during the lunch rush our large food was delivered quickly and to order. I had the Roasted Chicken Green Goddess Salad which was light, delicious, and refreshing. I would recommend getting the dressing on the side. Can't wait to order from here again!

It was my first time trying Cluster Truck, The Cheeseburger with Bacon was delicious. I thought I…read moreordered was the sidewinder fries, it tater tots which was okay. I enjoyed the Red Velvet Cookie because it decadent and yummy. I will try the chicken fingers next time with BBQ sauce. I had a Diet Dr. Pepper to wash it down. Very impressed with Cluster Truck.

Group Ordering is simple!

The Famous Nashville Chicken Hot Sandwich

See all

Leafy Perfection

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

12 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Erin S.

0

1

0

11 years ago

My husband and I have been ordering from this place for over a year! We have had extraordinary service every single time! From the kindness of the drivers opening my front door for me to carry in food, to even helping me add the total, ha. We absolutely love there gyros, and there prices! We strongly recommend for great food, wonderful service, large portions, and amazing prices!! BUCKEYE PIZZA!!!! And they deliver!! Erin Shaffer read more

Amaal F.

0

9

3

1 year ago

The guy Osman is a creep. He likes to also give' your phone number to other men. If you call the shop. The food is mediocre. He is NOT the owner but likes to act like he is.. He is not! Also. He is really rude to the guy that works with him. Monsieur tanqueray is his name, He is a liar. There is no honest bone in his body. This is why, the reviews will stay terrible. read more

Zed L.

0

6

2

1 year ago

Ordered the Buckeye Pizza for the first time and was seriously impressed. The delivery was quick, the pizza arrived hot, and the crust was perfectly crispy. Toppings wer generous and flavorful. definitely not your average takeout. Highly recommend if you're craving great pizza and reliable service. Will definitely be ordering again!!! read more

Mohamed S.

0

1

0

3 years ago

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Buckeye Stromboli, and I must say it was an exceptional experience from start to finish. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by the warm and inviting ambience, setting the stage for a delightful evening. read more

Bryan K.

0

3

0

10 years ago

I haven't had anything there is haven't liked. The pizza and strombolis are delicious. Wings- good. Salads- good. Buckeye bites- good. Delivery is always early. Wish they would bring the perch dinners back though..... read more

Travis S.

Elite 21

67

70

44

8 years ago

First time having this pizza as many times I have driven by it, was not disappointed at all. Very delicious and definitely will be back. Next time I'll have to try a Stromboli read more

Matthew H.

0

2

0

4 years ago

Ordered the veggie pizza with sausage. It was delicious. You can tell the ingredients are fresh. Will definitely be my go to pizza spot from now on. read more

Osman A.

0

5

13

7 months ago

Love this place great food I love the atmosphere. Great customer service. I will definitely come back very soon.

Arlee S.

20

92

88

11 years ago

I have eaten here before. They do have some good food if I must say.. I will continue to eat their

Ozzy O.

0

8

2

4 years ago

Great food great people just love it...... ... ... try it. Love the wings and Stromboli....:: read more

Cajiib M.

0

1

0

8 months ago

aye this place was delish and I like the Mozzy sticks and that stromboli was mmwah._.

Austin V.

0

1

0

4 years ago

great wings great pizza and Stromboli

Buckeye Pizza & Stromboli - pizza - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Buckeye Pizza & Stromboli also viewed

Pizza Fresca

(68 reviews)

I've enjoyed their pizza several times and this is my first review. Just wanted to share how much…read morewe've enjoyed it every time! They have been consistently excellent! Want to mention how much we've loved the Cajun pasta with chicken ...the veggie with added pepperoni is my go to for pizza. All the veggies are fresh and crisp and they never scrimp on the toppings. The dough is above average and I wish the owner would tell me how he makes the sauce! Tastes fresh and homemade and not from a can! The service is great, the food is always hot and fresh even when we've had it delivered. And thanks for being available at 330am for those late weekend nights!! Prices are very reasonable for the quality, service and delicious food. Oh and don't forget to order some Dessert!! The Oreo pie and cheesecake are sooo good and you can't beat their prices!! I've included a pic of my fave veggie pizza with pepperoni which prompted my current review. If you've never tried them please give them a try! I've had others that charge a lot more and get more word of mouth that have been a disappointment...but Pizza Fresca deserves your business! Thanks for a great pizza guys!

We ordered food here after a concert last night. The pizzas were out of this world delicious. The…read moreChicago style pizza has a ton of cheese in it!! Their menu is very extensive. The food was fast and steamy hot. Definitely going to keep this place on our list.

Beyond Dough Pizza

(13 reviews)

Ever since I first tried this place, I've been nothing but satisfied. Everything is prepared in a…read moretimely manner, the service is good and the food is delicious and filling. I've had the "build your own" calzone, lasagna, wings, pizza and fettucine alfredo (added chicken) and salad. Never had an issue and always met with a smile. I usually order online, being a member and I enjoy how easy it is to accumulate points towards discounted purchases. You all definitely have to try this place out.

I would but can't rate them in the negative star territory otherwise I would. This is easily the…read moremost foul pizza in Pickerington. Worse than Speedway pizza. Real trash.

Bridge Street Pizza

4.2

(100 reviews)

Soooo I really wanted to like this pizza, I did, but it was awful. I read that they changed…read moreownership, and man I really wish I had the chance to try them before they did. Older reviews and pictures looked bomb so I decided to give it a shot. Friday night we ordered 2 cheese pizzas and a chicken parm sandwich. Today is Tuesday and I've been trying to force my kids and the neighbor kids to eat it there's still a whole pie in the fridge that's about to go in the trash. Like imagine how bad pizza has to be that I can't get 8-11yr olds to eat it. I did try one slice I don't know how to describe it, kind of like frozen pizza but worse bc you've obviously paid a lot more for it than you would have a frozen pizza. Let's not even talk about the chicken parm sandwich that I tried to "fix", and I still couldn't save the rubbery chicken they put in there. That all wound up in the trash as well. I hate throwing food away, honestly I hate it, but I couldn't stomach anything we got from them.

Great service and great pizza. Dined in with my family on a weekday night and the two guys running…read morethe shop were so friendly and welcoming. Support your local pizza shop!!

Gatto's Pizza

3.8

(104 reviews)

•$

Lonely wintery night, we were the only sit-down customers. There were plenty of to-go, and delivery…read moreapp orders all night. They've been around since 1952, and man were they were on their game tonight. We love their sauce, crust is on the thin side and done nicely. We ordered a small double classic pep, and wings (they are oven roasted not deep fried). Both were 5*. A top 10 Columbus pizza for sure. Plenty of parking.

What a surprise. First time visitor and will be a very long time customer…read more The pizza was so delicious. I ordered double pepperoni and wow! Tasty sauce, delicious cheese and great pepperoni. Cooked to where it was crunchy, the way I like it. I can't wait to be back to try their subs and other toppings.

Tony & Enzo's Pizzeria

3.7

(19 reviews)

The deep dish is just a ton of bread with very minimal toppings. If you've had wizard of za, it's…read morelike that. The cheese and toppings also just peeled off so I'm assuming the bread was pre made and then they just added cheese etc at a later point. The NY style was just ok and was kind of bland even though the one we got was smothered in sauce.

Srsly - I wonder about Columbonians' taste in pizza. To me, T&E was one of the worst edible pizzas…read moreI've ever had. (There are pizzas that belong in the trash. This wasn't that.) Canned mushrooms? Tasteless onions? Vinegary olives? Nearly nonexistent sauce? No. The staff was nice. The pizza was hot. It's fairly easy to get to and easy to park. It's a very clean store. But I went for the pizza and found it lacking. Can't tell you to go there.

Brenz Pizza Co. Dublin

3.8

(54 reviews)

Great pizza, great service…read more Located in the shopping center at Avery Square, this restaurant has ample parking outside and a few seats for those who want to dine in. I highly recommend trying the Heritage Honey pizza which is loaded with classic red sauce, cheese, pepperoni, sliced sausage, and creamy ricotta. They finish it off with shaved parmesan, fresh basil, and their signature hot honey drizzle . This pie is absolutely delicious.

Recently tried Brenz Pizza Co. for the first time and it was so good. We did pickup, and everything…read morewas still really fresh and hot when we got home. I especially loved the margherita pizza! Simple but really solid. Definitely see why it's a local favorite in Dublin. We'll for sure be going back.

Sparano's Pizza

3.8

(93 reviews)

We got take out from here last night for the super bowl. The pizza is delicious! The crust is thin…read morewhich a slightly doughy crust. The sauce is slightly sweet and the cheese is generous. It kind of reminds me of Bridge Street Pizza in Dublin with a slightly thicker crust. We also got garlic cheese bread, macaroni and cheese bites, and mozzarella sticks. The macaroni and cheese bites were good as well as the GCB although a tiny bit cold. However considering we got take out on a snowy Super Bowl Sunday they were pretty good. I think the mozzarella sticks might have either been taken too quick out of the fryer or not at all. Fortunately after putting them in the oven they weren't bad. We will definitely try Sparano's again because the pizza was amazing but will pick a time when things will hopefully be more calm.

Same great food but new location. They have moved to 3947 W.Broad,directly across the street from…read moreDrive Time auto sales. Inside is clean and service is friendly and fast. Try the Heavy Meat pizza,it will put you to sleep!

Ange's Pizza

(68 reviews)

Service 100 % The Spaghetti and meatballs was not worth serving. The garlic bread was lacking…read moregarlic and just a sub bun buttered. Meatball was worse than GFS premium. Sauce ? Absolutely no labor or care went into the creation of this order. It was horrific. Thankfullly the staff had humor. Do not Order this for any reason!!!@

Great quality food. Always delicious! Delivery is spot on & food is always hot. Love Ange's…read moreeverything. The three cheese garlic bread is sooooo good.

Rotolo's Pizza

(86 reviews)