Wanted pizza while in town and I hate chains. So I dugouts this place and glad I did. The pizza was way better than the decor lol. Go Blue!!! Awesome pizza and service even if they pull For the team down south. read more

See all

We were in Ohio for a Convention. A name brand chain did not deliver to our hotel. Found this place and they were great! Easy online ordering. Text updates and super friendly delivery guy. Garlic knots were on par and meat lovers pizza was excellent. Wasn't fond of the marinara sauce as it was a little sweet. Would definitely recommend if visiting the state and wanting pizza. read more

We have had this several times when we are at a friends house who lives near this restaurant. It is consistently amazing every time we get it. This is the first time I was able to get pics for a proper review lol The Stromboli is to die for. It's my favorite. The pizza is really good too. We got sausage and we got sausage and banana peppers. Both were really good. The garlic knot things that they call Buckeye bites were very garlicky and delicious. The sauce they give you was really good as well. The Stromboli is where it's at. I have had several combinations of fillings and all delicious. We will definitely order from here again. read more

See all

I have food allergies and have struggled to find a gluten free pizza that I love. There are a lot of good places, but the crusts have never been more than adequate, until I tried Buckeye Pizza and Stromboli. Their gluten free crust makes me feel like I'm cheating and having gluten. I physically crave this pizza crust and enjoy every bite of it. I even enjoy the reheated leftovers. Most gf crust does not reheat well. So if you need gluten free, please try this one & you'll have a new favorite! read more

This had as much to do with YELP as identifying it as close as the location between a dispensary and a liquor store with bars required on the door. The Stromboli we ordered didn't come close to the now closed Morone's. We thought we'd give it a try because YELP had identified it as close with 3.9 rating. Food was okay, not what we are used to. read more

The pizza was ok - the cheese sticks were blah. The worst part is we had it ordered to our hotel and the delivery person just left it on the credenza outside the elevators for anyone to take. read more

First time ordering from here. Love local places, as I hate chains! I ordered the medium pizza with mushrooms, pepperoni, black olives and sausage. It was ready in like 10 min. Super easy ordering, about $20 - not bad at all. Walked in to pick up the food. Gentleman was friendly and quick. Place looked nice and clean. The medium pizza was a little smaller than I expected however, it was PERFECT for two people. No left overs! I could have ate more, but glad I didn't get a large! Pizza was thin crust and nicely cooked. The party cut topped it off! We definitely agreed that we will be going there again and definitely want to try other items as well! Do yourself a favor and try it out. It's a top notch local restaurant! read more

Very simple but tasty menu options, with large pies about $15 each. We got a meat and white pizza for four people and we had plenty left (they cut the pies in squares). The crust was very good, the sausage was ok. It filled us up quickly because there is a ton of cheese where I could really feel it afterward. When I had some for leftovers the next day, I could feel all the cheese again go straight to my insides again. I'm sure customers love the cheese though, I prefer a little less. Our family that lives nearby like this place over others but I'd prob try something else next time. read more

Buckeye Pizza & Stromboli - Meat Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Great Stromboli and always a super quick to have food ready when calling for pick up. Staff is friendly.

Ordered thin crust pizza for delivery. It was really thin which was fabulous and the toppings were fresh and good.

Absolutely incredible. We order from Buckeye at least once a month. The delivery always shows up much earlier than expected and the drivers are so sweet--they put our pizzas on the planter they move over so the boxes don't touch the ground! We ordered our own small pizzas this go around because we were adamant about what we wanted and sharing was not in the forecast. There's just something addicting about this place. Eventually I'll branch out and get something other than the white pizza but I can't foresee not craving that every other week! It has clouds of ricotta on top and is an absolute dream. **White Pizza** read more

Buckeye Pizza & Stromboli - The White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This neighborhood pizza joint has very good house Stromboli recipe their Gyro platter is pretty decent and affordable good value for the money you get fries a canna soda and a well-made Gyro on a pretty thick pita bread they are always glad to see you and they're very courteous and helpful read more

Buckeye Pizza & Stromboli - Pizza, pasta Stromboli and Gyro and Salads and dessert. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The service was quick and easy. The staff was friendly. However, I didn't like the pizza. Nice OSU decor.

Delicious and good size lamb gyro! Could use a table to sit at though. Maybe even an outdoor two person set since it's getting nice out.

Every time I always get the coolest delivery driver you have ever had. He's always so nice and happy to see you. Food is really good, catfish nuggets tasted way better than they looked and my white cheese pizza was good. Next time I would of added sausage and not had ricotta cheese put on. Stromboli is where it's at though, it's delicious! Best place to deliver in the 43231 area code. read more

Buckeye Pizza & Stromboli - White cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

While they have the typical Midwestern style pizza, it tasted like some generic kit pizza. The pizza was ok, nothing to brag about and it was a little saucy. I just hard to describe how generic the pizza really was. read more

Buckeye Pizza & Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We had never ordered from Buckeye but received their mailer and was impressed with the selection. We got delivery on INTERNATIONAL PIZZA DAY! Delivery was 1 1/2 hour wait. We stacked it up to the snow. We will try again for that. The spicy pickles were good, but not spicy. They were served with a very good ranch sauce. I know, ranch dressing "how cliche", but done well, it is undeniably tasty. It was done well. The Asian teryaki wings were great and a great price. Crispy, bone in, no breading. My husband enjoyed the buffalo chicken stromboli. I'll take his word for it. He said most if the heat came from jalepenos. It looked yummy. We got NY style crust and peperoni pizza. Large semmed to be 14'. I loved the pizza. It reminded me of a small, regional chain I grew up with in Southern WV. *memories* The soda was cold and napkins were in. Will check back on the delivery time with our next order. :) read more

Buckeye Pizza & Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

First time eating here (not sure how as we live super close and love Stromboli) and I can't rave enough about this place! Experience was great as well! We ordered the veggie and the meat lovers Stromboli and they were to die for! Crust was the perfect consistency, the innards weren't all wet and mushy, and the sauce was PERFECT! He forgot to make our garlic knots and threw them in for us for free and I still couldn't have been happier!! Highly recommend buckeyes pizza if you're a fellow Stromboli lover like I am! Great job! read more

I have lived in Columbus for six weeks and have had Buckeye pizza three times. I'm absolutely overtaken by how amazing they've managed to make a cheese pizza--globs of ricotta make up 1/4 of the cheeses found on the white pizza and its a fluffy, garlic-y dream. AND the delivery is the fastest I've ever experienced from a pizza restaurant but that doesn't keep me from checking the time every minute and a half after ordering. Could not recommend this pizza enough to strangers on the internet. read more

Was just ok. Bad delivery experience on this one. Meatball Parmesan Pizza would of been better if not all on one side of the box.

Actually very genuine ppl. Food is very good, made to your specific liking every time. Prices are great.

Hello, I ordered my first stromboli and pizza from buckeye pizza. We also got fried spicy pickles and a kids meal of nuggets, mini corn dogs and fries. All this cost me 35.00 Well we were dissatisfied with this pizza and stromboli. The stromboli was burnt on the bottom, as was the pizza. The burnt taste over powered everything else. It's sad to see a mistake like this sent to the customer. read more

After moving to the Westerville area a few weeks ago we wanted to try out a new pizza joint. My family, including a picky 8 year old, absolutely loves this pizza. It's seriously delicious! We ordered New York style which is full of flavor and the crust is nice and crispy. Not only is the pizza awesome, but the workers are really nice and accommodating. This will be our go-to from this point forward. read more

We LOVE Buckeye Pizza. and Stromboli on Westerville Rd. The Pepperoni Pizza is exelactly the way I LOVE it. The fried catfish dinner is another favorite. Huge pieces. Yum. Fried mushrooms are tasty, and the stromboli is always delicious, and the portion size is quite generous. The delivery person who regularly comes to my home gets a good tip every time because he is friendly, attentive, and you can tell he cares. And, the food always comes fresh and hot. He never forgets anything. Please keep doing what you do! I think I'm going to call you soon. Tummy is rumbling... read more

I love there food. Especially they're gyros, fried mushrooms, philly chesse steak and pep pizza. I get those items in different combinations whenever i eat there and have always been happy. I love their customer service especially the deliery drivers, they remember me and make me feel special. I used to get them about once every 3 months now i have to have that gyro and mushroom every month. read more

The guy at the front desk was a dick. Good pizza though. Especially if you don't mind the ghetto people in the parking lot that have no clue how to drive it's a nice little adventure to say the least. Wouldn't recommend bringing the kids though. But yeah I guess you could say it's a solid -1/10 for me. read more

I really was looking forward to this pizza and Stromboli because they got such good reviews. The pepperoni, mushroom, onion pizza was quite bland and left a lot to be desired between the crust and the sauce. The Stromboli was rather bland as well. Unfortunately, we won't be having anything again since first experience wasn't so great. read more

Probably the worst pizza in north Columbus. North Columbus has a lot of very good pizza joints. This is not one of them. We ordered The Works pizza. It looked like a 3 year old had worked on it. It was a glob of greasy cheese and over-cooked everything else. The crust was soggy and under-done. First and last time for them. read more

Best halal/no pork pepperoni. Very flavorful and enjoyable for everyone of all religions. Customer service is pretty bad tho, they're not very patient. read more

I really do love this place. I usually get the stromboli which is amazing, but one of the workers suggested the chicken veggie pizza and it is probably one of my favorite pizza of all time already. They are really fast too. Brian K. read more

We really like this place! Everything we've gotten has been great except the Margherita pizza. Wayyyyyy too garlicky. If u like huge hunks of garlic on ur pizza, go for it! The lasagna is as good as Olive Garden. Nice large portion. The small pizzas r huge and Stromboli too. My husband and I get a small and split it and have leftovers for the next day. Pepperoni pizza is as good, if not better, than Masseys. Give them a try. Fast delivery and affordable. read more

I haven't had nothing but wings here and they're really good; many flavors to chose from--try garlic and cheese for a twist-I love them!!!

Absolutely terrible. The food is good and it sucks I have to write this. EVERYTIME I order from them it is 2+ hrs before I get my food! Or they will charge my card and not even deliver my food, I'm literally 5 mins down the road and if I could leave work to go get it, I would. Every time I call to complain, my money isn't even refunded. One time they even debited my card 3 times for one transaction and I didn't even get the food nor dos they return my money. Never will I order from here again. read more

This was my first time at Buckeye Pizza and I LOVED it! Staff was super friendly and welcoming. I'll be back!

The BBQ pizza is amazing. Truly reminds me of the pizza from Buffalo, New York. The wings are cooked well and the staff is friendly. This is my new favorite pizza place. read more

What has normally been a wonderful experience for years turned me off for a lifetime. Never once have I ever called to tell a place I didn't get what I wanted and have the chef put on the phone to tell me I'm wrong. When I order a Philip Cheese steak with no onions or banana peppers, I still expect there to be green peppers, mushrooms, lettuce and tomato. But what I got was a sub with lettuce, tomatoes and steak with mayo. No cheese, no green peppers and no mushrooms. I was then told that he was going to come pick them up because he knew they had the green peppers and mushrooms and cheese on it because he saw it come out of the oven. read more

Great NewYork style pizza! Real slices of steak on the philly cheesesteak pizza! Our other favorite is the meatball parmesan pizza. Had it 3x and same delicious pizza each time. Definitely our favorite pizza in Columbus! read more

Good food! Their lunch deal is pretty hard to beat. Will definitely be coming back. Only downside is that their delivery can be slow at times. 1.5 hours plus read more

This was the first local pizza place I tried when I moved to town and I have to say it is absolutely amazing. I can eat just thier cheese pizza and be satisfied. The prices on thier menu are great and the customer service is quuck and easy and they are super nice. I will keep ordering from them. read more

Best pizza i've ever had! For the price, you really can't do any better. After having this pizza, Donatos and all the big pizza chains are put to shame! Strombolli was amazing and very, very big for a medium! Got a large cheese pizza and medium strombolli for under $20! The man at the front was very nice and ill definitely be back for more!! read more

See all