I I ordered online at 4:35pm. On email stated it would be ready by 4:50 another email stated it would be ready by 4:58 pm I went in at 5;00 just in case. We had a little issue communicating because I'm deaf. The person thought I wanted to place an order but I had to explain I already placed an online order. He then went to check and told me I needed to come back in 10 more minutes. When I came back 15 minutes later it still was not ready. There were two men working and they could have been the owners. I ordered the chicken parmigiana. The sauce tasted fake. Like not even from a jar but I'm sure it was. Hey guys a little tip. Learn how to make sauce. Then you can jar it and use it on a lot of your dishes. That will make a difference. I promise you. The bread tasted fresh so keep that up. I did not try the pizza and apparently that's what they are known for because when I was there they were making a lot of them. Maybe I should have tried that instead. Sooo the final question, would I come back? No. Remember my criteria is based on 3 things. 1.ambiance 2. Service 3. Food / taste 1. Well there was none. Unless she was willing to arm wrestle me for the check 2. I received 2 emails with two different times and none of them were right. I had to wait even longer. 3. Taste. Disappointed. Sorry guys but please take this advice. Make your own sauce. It WILL make a difference! read more

Casa Di Pizza - Chicken parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

First time, recommended by a local customer that loves this place. Three of us got subs. Turkey, chick parm and I got the Sicilian Toasted and tasty for sure. Mine came with Focaccia bread. It was a little dry compared to the others that got regular Italian bread. But it was real good and I would get again but ask for the Italian bread. read more

Casa Di Pizza - Sicilian Sub - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Amazing pizza, thin and crusty. The ingredients were freshly cut and the taste amazing. We all enjoyed these two pizzas, the veggies and the all meat, and definitely will come back for more. read more

Casa Di Pizza - Garden Veggie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Rather disappointed by the food here. Pizza crust was bland and the food and appetizers all tasted like they were cheap frozen generic brands that were heated up and served. read more

So excited to try this new place , on this side of town. I really have not found a place I Love! read more

Pretty solid pizza here folks! I've gotten this delivered to my friends place in Upper Arlington a handful of times and it's always been delicious, straight forward pizza. I tend to stick with a plain cheese pizza, but my friends usually get one with pepperoni. The sauce is good and the cheese is always plentiful. I also really like this crust, especially when dipped in ranch dressing. If you're looking for more than pizza, they have subs, wings, and salads, amongst a few other items. The delivery is also fairly quick and the price is great! read more

Great PIZZA!!!!! We live in Westerville...and will definitely order again!!! Great crust Great sauce and generous toppings!!

My boyfriend and I got takeout from Casa Di Pizza using their order ahead system. When we arrived 20 minutes after placing the order, the staff at Casa informed us that they had just received the order due to a glitch and we would have to wait further. To apologize for the delay, they offered us a free order of mozzarella sticks. This was a kind gesture. The pizza was solid! We requested it be cut into triangles (apparently this is blasphemy in central Ohio) and they obliged. The toppings were fine and the crust was solid. The free mozzarella sticks were also solid! Overall, Casa di Pizza offers solid takeout pizza. read more

Casa Di Pizza - Mozzarella Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Casa Di Pizza is a strip mall joint that serves unpretentious food. It's located next to Cliffside Tavern. There's a hole in the wall. It's possible to order from the bar. They serve it right through the hole to you. It has what you would find at a typical pizza place. It's no surprise pizza is the main thing here. They also have ribs and subs. It's not anything mind blowing. Mainly it's pretty good drunken food. It's a nice compliment to cocktails at the bar. You need something to absorb these. I had a vegetable sub. It's about $6 for this. The wait was about 20 minutes, so I headed over to the bar and drank up. A hole in the wall is between the businesses. You can order from the bar and eat something from there without actually having to go inside. Casa Di Pizza is not bad. It compares favorably to other pizza places in strip malls. The bar makes it better than it would be without it there. read more

Casa Di Pizza - Vegetable Sub - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

You've got to be kidding me! Five thick pizzas of sausage on a medium pizza for $26 . Last time I'm ordering! Don't waste your money. So now this guy is accusing me of trying to get free food! Told him I wanted a new pizza with sausage on the whole thing. X read more

Casa Di Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I was finally able to find a BLT pizza in the city ! I've been looking everywhere and finally! A cute to-go pizza spot tucked smack-dab in the middle of the shopping complex. Orders can be made online or by phone call. Not only was the BLT amazing (I really do appreciate the way it's made with the bacon on the bottom! Literally- bacon in every bite!) But the CRUST- oh good lawd have MERCY! Some of the BEST crust I've had in Columbus . I've been three times in the past three Weeks ordering the same personal BLT pizza and it is super consistent on taste and that amazing crust. No fountain drinks available (I'm sure that's most places now due to COvID ) but they do offer Hanks bottled soda (cream , orange, grape, root beer and black cherry flavors). They are great about giving you an exact time for pickup and the employees are always so nice and friendly ! Great place for to-go pizza. Thank me later read more

See all

Not bad pizza for the price. Got the 10 inch with extra sauce ( upcharge of 50¢ which no other pizza place have ever charged me before), 1 topping of mushrooms - that cost an extra dollar, if you order from create your own menu. With a can of pop, the total cost was just over $10. Crispy crust was done just right. Sauce was a little on the spicy side, but not too. I liked the amount of cheese and topping, but I like those on lighter side. Warmed up well the next day. Of course, I will get 3 meals out of it, but big eaters might finish it in one. I took a star off for just having Pepsi products which should be avoided if possible. Also a star off for only cans or bottles. Since only 3 tables most business must be take out. I ate in. I will add this to my list of pizza places, but had much better since I have lived here. read more

See all

Delicious thin crust pizza! Fresh toppings, perfect seasoning and prompt delivery. Highly recommend.

The pizza was very plain and I have had better frozen pizza that was on my freezer for a year.

This place is a hidden gem. The pizza is excellent. The crust is crispy but not too thin. The toppings are very generous. The Italian subs are awesome. Very reasonable prices too. I highly recommend the Double Double pizza. It's a layer of cheese and pepperoni topped with another layer of cheese and pep. read more

Casa Di Pizza - The Double Double. It's excellent - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This is NOT pizza. Am not sure how this "crust" (sic) was derived. I'm 99% sure that pizza-dough (sic) was NO invited to the party. The pizza ate like a flat-bread. Folks refer to it as being cracker-like (sic), and that's NOT pizza. Sure, it's better than Domino's and Donato's, but then that's setting the bar really, really low. Read that to mean subterranean. To call this ersatz pizza (sic)., pizza is a slap in the face to the good men and women around the country and the world actually making the genuine article. And as YELP does not allow ZERO stars, in my book Domino's and Donato's deserve that many stars, in abundance. Do yourselves a favor, and travel the extra miles to Powell, Ohio for Brooklyn Pizza. If that's too far, there's always Cardinal Pizza in Westerville. read more

Fantastic food. Extensive menu. Pizza, sides, spaghetti. Service is excellent from in house to delivery!

Anytime I want hot pizza without anchovies it's never a problem. Casa Di Pizza treat you like a true family member and close to home as well. Meaning straight out of the oven and it's the freshest when it arrives to me. As they say in Business 101 Location is everything. The Best Customer Relationship anyone can appreciate. Stop by Casa Di Pizza or have them deliver to you. They gives me a heads up every time that's love read more

Pepperoni and sausage. Decent pie. Crust has a bit of crunch similar to gatto's. It's not flaky and cracker like as Tommy's is. Sauce is slightly sweet which I normally don't like much, but the pepperoni offset it well. Cheese Is decent. Sausage is nothing to write home about, similar to chain pizza. Overall it is decent, but with sparano's a mile away it's going to be awhile before trying this place again. read more

Casa Di Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

First of all, this crust was CRUNCHY!! but it wasn't burnt! & it had some saltiness to it. The topping coverage was pretty decent and it had good flavor. I'm usually not a big fan of fresh mushrooms on pizza since they dry out, but they weren't too bad on this pie! The sauce had a slight kick to it which was really good. We also threw in a couple Italian subs to the order which had plenty of filling and good flavor, though my sub bun was pretty soggy. That's nothing to cry about though, it happens! Reasonable prices. Close to home. Would probably get it again! read more

Casa Di Pizza - 15" PMS - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Excellent paneer pizza and sub. Excellent service. Love it. Entire family enjoyed. Restaurant is clean .

I was craving pizza from a mom & pop shop and Casa Di Pizza fulfilled my desire! I wanted that cracker thin crust and square pieces. While they didn't deliver to my address I was able to have it delivered via Grubhub. They offer pickup as well. Loved everything about my experience and will order again. read more

Casa Di Pizza - Pizza - pepperoni, banana peppers, tomato & spinach - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

What an unfortunate fall from grace. The whole 'judge's choice' thing that they still put on the box was from almost 20 years ago, and that was a different pizza and a different owner. This place used to be hands down one of the best pizza shops in the city. I'm not sure what changes have been made with new owners over the past couple of years, but after my third bad pizza in a row from them, I think it is time to say farewell. Website says 'voted best pizza in the Columbus by restaurant guru 2023', but restaurant guru (whatever that is) has them actually listed at #112...probably because there are actually over 100 better places. What used to be a crispy, somewhat sweet/spicy and seemingly fresh pizza is now a chewy, flavorless circle of mediocrity. It was like I ordered a pizza that sat around from yesterday. If you order from them, I really hope it turns out good for you. Three back to back kind of gross pizzas in a row for me, and I'm checking out after close to two decades as a customer. I'll give it two stars, because I'm pretty sure it is still food. read more

My partner and I used to get this place a lot. It powered us through the pandemic as we live less than a mile away from it, and it was our absolute FAVORITE pizza in the area. For as long as I can remember it was always an Indian run pizza place or at least all the workers were Indian. It was so good. The last two times I have gone the workers that used to be there aren't there anymore, and the pizza has changed drastically. It just doesn't taste the same. I thought maybe the previous time was a one-off but I just got it again the other night and it was confirmed that it's just not as good as when it was the old workers. Pretty disappointed that I will have to find a new pizza place to love. Did they change ownership or what? Does anyone know? read more

The pizza was very good. Thin cracker like crust, sauce is delicious (my daughter called it a "little spicy") I like some heat to my food so I don't notice any spice. The people working in the shop were all friendly and accommodating. I placed my order online incorrectly and needed to add on to it so when I called, they were nice about it and accommodated us. Would definitely return. Prices were a little on the high side (why I gave 4 stars rather than 5) read more

Way down hill. Used to order often. Taco salad. Extra meat. Barely any meat at all. New owners Very RUDE

The crust was burnt and crunchy. The sauce lacked flavor. This pizza was not the same as the good thin style crust I had a few years ago.

If this is truly "Judges' choice best pizza," in Columbus, the judges don't know good pizza. We tried two different pizzas. The combination/ supreme was not the worst we've had but the bbq chicken sucked! It has about 4 strips of red onion and maybe 10 chunks of shoe leather dry chicken breast. And to top it off, the crust was burnt read more

Casa Di Pizza - Burnt crust BBQ Clucker Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

First time we've had this pizza. Loved it. Thin crust was awesome. Will definitely order again! Z's Cheese is awesome, we add pepperoni. read more

The sign on the door reads "Pizza and Ribs". I took it as a sign and ordered "pizza and ribs." Focus, man, focus! Casa di Pizza appeared to be primarily a take out/delivery joint. They also serve up the grub at the bar next door (Cliffside Bar) through an old school hole in the wall between the two joints. I slipped into Cliffside for a beer while waiting on my pizza. One day I will put that experience into a review, but for now I need therapy. CdP's ribs literally fall off the bone. Picking them up by the bone to eat them is really not even an option. The sauce is not your normal BBQ sauce (tasted orangey to me). I enjoyed the ribs. The wife did not. Split decision on the ribs. The pizza is a traditional, edge to edge, square cut Ohio pie. The crust is slightly thicker than most Ohio pies, but also very light and crispy. The peps were nice and spicy, the way I love them. The schrooms were fresh and the sauce was decent (with a slightly sweet note that really played well with the spicy pepperoni). The cheese ratio was nailed. Casa di Pizza won the Judges' Choice for Best Pizza at the 2007 Slice of Columbus event, so it is definitely worth checking out. I thought it was a very solid, A-OK pizza, somewhere just north of three stars. read more

Casa Di Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I ordered a Deluxe and a large pepperoni and could hardly wait to take a bite, looked so good!! Omg, delicious!! Everything about it was perfect the sauce was great, the toppings were fresh and evenly proportioned......and then the crust....crispy, light and the flavor was spot on. The lady on the phone was very nice and the delivery driver was equally as nice. Will definitely order this perfect pie again!! read more

Casa Di Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Great pepperoni but pizza doesn't compare to other places in town. I'd try a different spot. Pizza cold Multiple slices without toppings or even cheese. Cheesy bread is a sift open face sub with melted cheese no spices or toasting. read more

So glad to have found this pizza shop. The people there are very nice and the food is wonderful! The double double is great-and ribs are outstanding. Who thought you would find fabulous ribs at a pizza place?! read more

The pizza itself is good. Good crust. Price point is little on the higher side but I guess this is not a domino's. $11 for most 10 inch pizzas. Side note: The personal 7" is just ridiculously small. 10" should be called personal and the 7" should be renamed "mini-snack". Ok maybe Snack. I'll be nice. It was a group of us (six people) on a slow weekday. What could possibly go wrong?!. can't say anything in particular went wrong but lets say it could've gone better. I think they need to work some of the ordering process flaws they have. When you have a dining group (dine-in sitting on a table), their order should not fall back behind other pickup/delivery orders they receive on the phone. Whole thing was weird. Some of us got their pizzas before others. I can tell they received a huge order over the phone about the same time we gave our order in. It was easy to tell because we could hear it. The place is tiny with very few tables, mostly for big group setting , if you put the tables together. I did not complain about the wait. I've had worse elsewhere. I get it. Another person in the group did complain and was offered their pizza "half-off". I think they expected it on the house, since they had to wait 50 minutes for a 10" pizza. Would've been fair. I did not exactly like that extra sauce was a 50 cents upcharge, but it's not a big deal. I think if you're in the area or live close, it's worth trying it out. read more

What a nice little find this place is. The smell when you first walk in will tell you the love that goes into their food. Great people and their pizza ingredients are fresh! They have a diverse menu so you should check it out. Off the beaten path but def worth it! read more

This place came highly recommended by my buddy Bradley. So I got high, and I figured I'd give them a chance to "wow" me... and they absolutely did. I asked the sweet lady at the counter what I should order. She told me to get the wings and a pizza. The Hot wings were quite hot and quite flavorful. I tasted some habanero and some turmeric maybe. So good. I also ordered the Garlic Parmesan. And let me say... they were balls to the wall good. The homemade ranch dressing was fresh... and was a tasty offering. And the pizza? I got the Double-double. And I was very pleased. Garlic cheese bread was average. All being said, I can't wait to return and try that BLT pizza and keep exploring this menu. My new favorite pizza joint. read more

Great undiscovered pizza, thin cracker like crust, your favorite toppings ready quick, delicious!

On a lazy Friday night when my bf and I were hungry and didn't want to wait for delivery we ordered Casa di Pizza since it is close to our house. It is located in a plaza off of mckinley next to a convenience store and a bar. I wasn't expecting much but was pleasantly surprised by how good it was. The crust was extremely thin and cracker like with plenty of toppings. Also, when I went to pick it up there must be a weekend special because it was only $10 for a large pepperoni mushroom pizza. We will definitely be ordering again soon. read more

It took too long to discover this semi-hidden gem! I always get a pepperoni/mushroom/extra cheese pizza and it is ALWAYS delicious. Tonight I tried the ribs, and they were very literally fall-off-the-bone tender with absolutely ZERO gristle. I'll be back as often as I can! read more

We would have really liked this pizza if they didn't put Kalamata olives on it. We specifically asked if they had black olives and the lady said yes. My hubby brings it back to the hotel room and they are not black olives but Kalamata olives. They were so salty and gross. The kids wouldn't even go near it and our dinner was ruined. We would never go back to this place. I also ordered the loaded fries, not so good. Just not how I like loaded fries. Overall, the pizza would have been pretty decent if we had gotten just cheese. read more