It has been a while since I've been here and decided to give them another try. It was pretty good. The pizza was good. I think having an extra 5 minutes to make it more crisper would make it even better. The sub was a bit dry so I would suggest asking for more dressing if you get the Italian. Other than that, it was good. I feel the wings were my favorite food of choice between the 3. I wouldn't mind coming back for more, but like the pizza I mentioned, asking for extra time on the wings would make it even better. read more

See all

First time trying Don Gino's pizza and it hit the spot! Pizza had light sauce, cheese was layed nicely and tick and crust was a perfect crunch. Looked like an amazing pizza. I have to say the customer service was so nice and quick ! Took 30 mins from the time I ordered until it showed up at my door. read more

Don Gino's Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Good local spot that's been around for generations. Steady customer base that's a good option as opposed to your standard fare run of the mill chains everybody knows. If you're in the area give em a go! read more

See all

The pizza and Stromboli are actually really nice! One thing I would recommend to the wife is to not have your husband take women to the basement. I have Autism and stuff like that freaks me out a bit. Thanks! I can't remember the ambiance because I couldn't get over the whole basement thing. Hopefully it was just playful fun! ‍ read more

We wanted to try something new so I called and picked up a large pizza and two chicken parm subs. They said it would be twenty minutes and it was! The kids liked the subs and the pizza was pretty darn good. The crust was slightly overdone but I love it that way. Delivery to about a mile away was quoted as 1.75 which I think is totally doable. This is NOT a dine in at all place . Lobby is limited to three people. The guys inside were friendly and fast. We would definitely go again. read more

See all

Great food! A friend recommended them and they're close by. I always go with the double or thick crust whatever they call it and the XL pizza. The flavor is great and the pizza is huge for under $20. I always have to order 4-5 cups of their ranch because it's addicting and their sauce cups are great for the crust. I've never had a bad experience here! This place is great! read more

Food is always great! Service excellent. I always get Italian sub and it's always wonderful to eat.

The front window shows a pie cut pizza. The website shows a pie cut pizza. The product is a square cut round pizza. Typical Ohio pizza, nothing special. Don't show pizza that's not your own product on your website. Otherwise, it was just average. read more

Although they messed up my order and the entry to the place is a bit awkward, the pizza was great. Being a pizza guru and rather picky on our local pizza joints, I liked the fact it had generous topping, delicious sauce & crust and mostly, not overloaded in salt. The pie was baked perfectly and I'll definitely be back. read more

Decided to check out Don Gino's Pizza tonight. Val-Pak coupon special of a 14" One item Pizza and a Garlic Bread with cheese for $14.95. Very good deal. We had the pepperoni which was a coarse meaty type, it had a nice layer of cheese on it. The sauce was a really fresh tasting tomato based sauce. Yummmy!! The garlic cheese bread was really loaded with cheese and a nice garlic flavor to it. Counter gentleman was super nice even with the temperature over 90 degrees. Will have to try again for sure. read more

Don Gino's Pizza - Large pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Don Gino's is definitely meant to be a pick up and go place. The space is small and walk in only right now. I ordered a stromboli and some chicken wings. Both give you a lot of food. The stromboli and chicken wings were both really good. I am glad I found a place so yummy that is close to home. read more

I grew up in a pizza shop so we are kinda pizza snobs. We basically only eat mom and pop pizza. Omg. Don Ginos has been our favorite since we moved into our house 11 years ago. We had never had their Stromboli if you can believe that. We just love their pizza and subs so much. This Stromboli is legit people. And look at that pool of dipping sauce. The subs. So good. read more

Don Gino's Pizza - Love this pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

We've only gotten pizza here. Not tried anything else. Like the pizza. Lots of sausage. Plenty of cheese. Close to us. We're becoming a regular. read more

Very good pizza will highly recommend them. Family owned been around for a long time even before I've lived on the west side.

The Stromboli had such strong reviews, I felt it was a must have. I was a little worried about sauce, so I ordered an extra. Very, very disappointed. It came out burnt and as you can definitely see and I did not need an extra sauce. I told the gentleman on the phone that this was my first order; it will be my last. The reason and only reason it got 2 stars, is because it got delivered hot. Such a shame, the sauce was good, but did not mix with the burnt bread. read more

Don Gino's Pizza - a grilled cheese and bacon sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Yesterday was my first time trying, and it was absolutely the best pizza I've ever had, they did forget my garlic butter, but it's okay. I will be having them again soon, and I deff. recommend trying them! read more

Great place! Stromboli is amazing, and so is the pizza! Service is great as well, quick delivery for a Friday night (must have been slow).

This place isn't in the safest of neighborhoods, but it is worth the drive for a good calzone. I ordered a pepperoni and sausage and it was delicious. Part of it was over cooked a bit, but it was large enough that I could toss the burnt parts and still have plenty to eat. The dipping sauce is sweet. Definitely recommend this place! read more

Don Gino's Pizza - Pepperoni and sausage calzone was really good! Definitely recommend!! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

BEST pizza place ever! The pizza was killer! The sauce a little sweet which was great. The calzone was amazing and the wings were spectacular. Italian sub was really good too. I kid you not- "affordable" GREAT pizza. Most places are super expensive and the quality is typically just fine. This place is reasonable and tastes like it's worth much more. We will be buying this pizza read more

Don Gino's Pizza - Sorry- it was too good to stop and take pics. We had to eat it! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We have tried a number of pies on the west side and this one wins for us. Quick and price is unbelievable. It will be our go to while we stay in the Alton RV Resort. After recommending this place to friends in the area they were already fans. read more

Don Gino's Pizza - Large pepperoni mushrooms banana pepper for $15 - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The Calzones are to die for in this little hole in the wall place. It is a small shop that doesn't look like much but the food is outstanding, my wife and I have never been disappointed by anything we've gotten here. A cut above and beats out most of those fancy pizza places easily. read more

After my wife's mom was released late in the afternoon on Wednesday from Doctor's Hospital, we were all hungry and thought we might order Italian subs and pizzas for the eight of us. Normally, from the west side of Columbus, I would suggest getting pizza from Joseppi's Pizza, (especially the store on Sullivant Ave.) But, everyone else wanted to order from Don Gino's instead and since I'd never eaten the food from D.G.'s, I went with the majority decision. The prices were awesome even without getting the Monday special price of large 1-item pizza for only $6.95. The normal price for two pepperoni and cheese pizzas is only $19.95 (again, a great deal). We also ordered two other extra-cheese pizzas and 4 Italian subs that we planned to share. Next time I think I'll order light sauce on the pizza and Italian dressing on the side of the subs. I don't know if we were asked about the sauce we wanted or if we wanted the dressing for the subs on the side or not. So, I can't fault Don Gino's for that. For an early evening order, the food was ready in about 30-40 minutes, which was a fair speed for the amount of food we ordered. And, the food was really hot, which means it didn't sit around to get cold. And, they move food out pretty quickly so that everything is ready at the designated time. The double-cheese was especially good and the pepperoni pizzas had lots of meat spread throughout each of the pies. The Italian subs were full of Italian meats; Genoa salami, Capocollo ham, pepperoni, and maybe Italian mortadella (sausage), salty cheese like sliced provolone, sliced onion and of course iceberg lettuce and just the right Italian seasoning on a fresh, baked sesame seed Italian sub bun. read more

Don Gino's Pizza - Coupon that shows prices and Monday special, pizza and subs taken for carry out. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Stromboli's are amazing! Pizza is great too! Wife says the salads are huge. Never had anything to complain about so far.

Good pizza and subs. Stromboli's are killer..I order often . I can't say anything bad about the place..

This place is a gem. They aren't flashy but the pizza and Stromboli's are FIRE. After having this one time I haven't eaten any other pizza joint since. read more

By far one of the absolute best pizzas I've ever eaten. My new go to for sure. In all my times I've ordered, delivery is faster than expected, food is amazing and service is amazing. read more

Quirky - the door being on the side of the store. Large windows to see in, but if you're stopping by for the first time, it might take you a second to realize the entrance is not out front. Old checkered linoleum floor. Obviously years of being walked on. But the walls were covered with new dry wall. I'm sure once paint is up, probably a few tables and chairs, the joint will look esthetically pleasing. Since there's no tables during their renovations, we had to order, wait and take it home to chow down. The few yelp pics of Don's Stromboli looked good, so me and my sister decided to share. Our Stromboli (three toppings): Sauage, mushroom and green peppers. We also go the Antipasto salad to split. We waited a little less than 20 minutes. The smells? Oh man!! Amazing whiffs of pizza/spices. Box was warm all the way through. Stromboli was super good! Came with a large tin of pizza sauce. I actually like the tomato concoction. I'm not sure if they make it from scratch... It has a mild sweeter flavor, as opposed to a bitter, tangy taste (a personal yuck!). The The bread had a light garlic butter swiped on top. Oregano. Great dough! And the toppings were abundant! Tons of mozzarella cheese. The sausage - that was different: broken up crumbles. I liked that it wasn't just chunks. The crumbles were spread over the entire half-moon. And I love mushrooms and peppers :) read more

See all

Definitely one of the worst most bland pizza places I've ever bene to... highly disappointed. Inside of building was not clean. Staff was not clean... not professional... read more

You just don't know what to expect when walking into Don Gino's. Literally, the front windows are covered up and there's no front door. Instead, you have to pull open the windowless steel door on the windowless side of the building and take your chances. Of course your encouragement comes from the fantastic smells that somehow waft through all of this cinder block and steel out into the parking lot. Once inside, you'll find a large empty "waiting room" with a checkerboard floor and a few chairs scattered about (no tables, this is take-out and delivery only). Service is super friendly and attentive. Taking a cue from other Yelpers, I made the stromboli the main event and ordered up a small pep and shroom for posterity purposes. The pizza is a traditional Ohio style. The thin, crispy crust is very buttery, leaving behind a greasy cardboard box (and a greasy car seat). The toppings are all decent, but nothing spectacular. Kee's review had my mouth watering, so I infringed on his stromboli order with the meatball, bacon and onion combo. The stromboli is gigantic. The dipping sauce was nice, with the right sweet/tart balance. I enjoyed the flavor of the stromboli, but it was also fairly greasy and loaded up with a TON of cheese. If you like cheese, this is for you. The cheese was a lot too much for my tastes. At the end of the day, Don Gino's is A-OK. Not spectacular, but definitely quality. I enjoyed the food, but it's a bit off of my beaten path to make it a regular haunt. read more

See all

This pizza really hit the spot for us. We wanted to try a local pizza spot and this one seemed to be only take out. They do charge $4.50 for delivery too which isn't bad. We ordered a pizza and garlic bread and some cheese sticks to share with a group and it all came out great! We ordered on a Saturday night and it was ready in 10 minutes for carry out. After seeing the place, it's definitely not the type of place you would eat in but the food is great, very reasonably priced and we will order from here again. It was so good I forgot to take a pic! read more

Great deals. Monday nights you can get a large 1 topping pizza for $6.95, but that's a carryout only deal. Their stromboli is frakkin HUGE. Delivery was quick, I think they charged $1.75 for the convenience. We're about a 10 minutes drive, so worth it for me not to leave on a rainy night. read more

Don Gino's Pizza - X-large 1 topping, $10.95 - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Bang for your buck: 10/10 Quality: 10/10 Service: 9/10 Ambiance/Location: 9/10 Overall: 9.5/10 Don Gino's is a hidden gem in the far west side. Their Stromboli is literally the stuff food dreams are made of. We always order the meatball with extra cheese and it is truly heaven. Super cheesy, but not too cheesy so that it overpowers the meatball. The meatball is the real star of the show. Perfectly seasoned and cooked, the ratio of meatball to cheese to dough is supreme. All of it is coated in a garlicky butter sauce and served perfectly baked with a marinara sauce for dipping. read more

7 stars out of 5 Where to even begin ?! First I was on the phone asking for a reccomendationn between their garlic cheese sticks and cheese bread The guy on the phone told me his opinion and stated that he'd give me both and charge for one !!!! Very friendly in person too! I tried to leave a tip and he said they do not accept tips (not sure if true but regardless they gained a customer!!!) Oh yeahhhhh and their pizza is pretty great too ;) read more

Good first experience! Got the pizza that was 10.95 for extra large 1-item. Great size. I love the thin and crispy crust. The toppings were good too (I got pepperoni). The pizza was rally greasy though, which is kind of expected of pizza. I did carry out and had friendly service on the phone and also when picking up my pizza. I will definitely think of this place again when I need a place to order a nicely priced pizza. read more

Don Gino's Pizza - pepperoni xl pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We had Italian subs tonight. They were excellent! Great place, very consistent. Also Monday pizza special is a good deal. Thanks guys!

The toppings are plentiful and this is how pizza should taste, I ordered all pepperoni with half mushroom and sausage, the Italian sausage is definitely the Best I have ever had on a Pizza. I will be returning soon read more

I am 61 years old I've had a lot of pizzas in my life I've had thousands of pizzas this is the best pizza I've ever had I really mean that I mean I've ate a lot of pizzas I'm very picky when you ask for extra cheese they put it on there Exra Sauce they put it on this is a very very good pizza place and I never had a favorite because other pizzas places are the same on their pizzas they will not do as you ask what you paid for it but this place really really puts the ingredients on it please give them a try you'll be very happy read more

Don Gino's is the best Stromboli I've ever had hands down! So glad I stumbled on this family owned pizza shop! Highly recommend!!! Pizza is good as well, but I prefer their Stromboli read more

Don Gino's Pizza - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Very disappointed in their pizza. Tried them numerous times more than half the time it's was burnt. Told them a few times about it being burnt. Obviously they don't care. Will not go back read more

PSA: Just had a delivery from Don Gino pizza. Delivery drivers shows up, hands me my receipt to sign and my CC #, expiration date and CID # are printed on the bottom of the receipt. I was shell shocked, never seen that in my life. This driver had my entire card information. I called the business and they were very confrontation about it, I was told "well we have to put the information somewhere." So my whole CC information is on the street. Cancelled card immediately. Do not recommend doing business with this place. read more