Cancel

Open app

Search

Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell

3.3 (62 reviews)
Closed • 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

Order Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell Takeout or Delivery

Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell Photos

Business Info

PIZZA COTTAGE & TIPTON TAVERN - POWELL ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

More like Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell

Recommended Reviews - Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Chrissy W.

They can never seem to get our order correct. Too bad because my toddler absolutely loves their chicken tenders. Our order is always wrong. Ordered two pizzas, one plain cheese, one pep and onion, received two different sized cheese pizzas smh.

Sausage and onion pizza
Tara F.

Hot, fresh and really great service . First visit , but not the last ! Cute tavern attached with live music too.

Mimi B.

First time ordering here and we won't be back. We weren't impressed with pizza because it tasted very salty. Coupled with the fact that a 14" thin crust pizza was over $20. I had purchased a Clipp promotion that should have given me $20 worth of food but they refused to honor and only gave me $10. There are so many far better choices for pizza in the area but I thought I would try bought the promotion only to be scammed.

Chef Salad
Lisa K.

The service is absolutely amazing. The workers are always so kind and helpful. The tv in the booth is so helpful with 2 kids. I did the chef salad which has very fresh toppings and filling. The Wednesday $10 large one topping deal is great. We did sausage, pepperoni, cheese and onion. All were delicious!! The dessert pizza is a favorite way to eat dinner.

While Whole Hog Pizza

I came here a few years ago when it opened and had some of the worst service I've ever experienced....figured it survived this long, must have gotten better...spoiler alert, it hasn't. 2 servers....working a full restaurant with probably 35 tables...TWO....whats worse, these two were also hosting, bussing, answering the phone, and cashing out carry out customers. The two were working their hardest, but it simply isn't possible. If the management and ownership simply seem unwilling to staff for the business they are running. Table next to us was dirty when we walked in. It took 15 min to get our drinks, and well over 40 to get 2 kids spaghetti's and a personal thin crust pizza....and when we left after being there over an hour, the table hadn't been touched...if you want a refill, take your cup up and do it yourself, it will be 25 minutes till a server comes back to your table. If this was a delivery only business fine, but you CAN NOT run a full service restaurant with this little staff. I gave them a second chance, I will not be giving them a third. To any staff that reads this, RUN! The slightly older female blonde server and young high school guy spent more time apologizing for everything going wrong than they did providing service. You two worked hard, but you deserve better! Run far from the owner of this place who doesn't seem to want to run a restaurant.

Menu 3/16/21
Ellen M.

Why it takes 40 minutes to get a personal pizza at 4pm I don't get. There were 8 employees standing around not doing anything and barely any customers in the dining area.

14" pepperoni pizza, thin crust
Kevin C.

Delicious, fresh, hot and tasty! The official start date is January 11, 2021, but they opened for business on 12/28/2020. Pizza Cottage will open its seventh location in Powell, Ohio. This will be the first Pizza Cottage located in central Ohio. I placed an order ahead of time for carry out. When I arrived I was greeted at the door and my order was ready. The food was hot when I got home and everybody agreed that this food was really good. Order: 14" pepperoni pizza, thin crust Calzone (pepperoni, ham, bacon) Tenders, small order, teriyaki The food was fantastic and tasted amazing. I'm not sure how they did it, but the pepperoni was crispy. They had a little heat, but the sauce was sweet, making a nice combination. The thin crust was cooked just right. The Calzone was stuffed with pepperoni, ham and bacon, and that delicious sauce oozed out here and there. The top was dusted with a wonderful blend of spices. Very good! We chose tenders over bone-in wings. There were 5 good sized tenders covered with a tasty teriyaki sauce. They were crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. Our toddler said they were "so good" and then asked for seconds. @ohiofoodlover

Thin crust pepperoni pizza

See all

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Good Food and Amazing Staff. They have two separate rooms for parties. Restaurant was super clean.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Amy D.
1
15
3

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of David H.
13
46
16

5 years ago

KETO FRIIENDLY! Thin crust pizzas. My cauliflower crust was amazing. Very clean store and restrooms. Wait staff was awesome too.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 14,559 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Wings and Rings

Wings and Rings

3.1(152 reviews)
0.1 mi
•$$
Locally owned & operated
Kid friendly

I love, love, love this place. From NY and I have been going here for 9 years now when I am passing…read morethrough or staying in Columbus. Excellent service here as always and very clean and nice setting inside. Some of the best wings/onion rings I've ever had, and unique and extremely good sauces! I will always come back here!

Jason was our server and he told us about the special on the wings so our fat butts order 20 wings…read morefor 20!!! lol Sooooo we got lemon pepper hot bbq chicken and sweet Thai chilli and ALL FLATS! u hear me all flats and no up charge! Than you Jesus! Finally a place where us flats ppl can go and won't be charged an arm and leg just because we don't like eating big parts of the wing for once! AMEN!!!! plus my fience and I won't have to fight over who have more flats! Lmao But anywho loaded fries was bomb! He orders a beer on draft and he said it was delicious and cold cold! He tore into them lemon pepper wings! I mean messed them up! Lmao he said them were the best lemon pepper wings he has had in the city! We will definitely be coming bk for more and I loved the sweet chili wings and they was extra crispy crunchy who ever was in that kitchen cooking's them wings THANK YOU FOR COOKING THEM WINGS BOO! The place was clean and the women's bathroom was really clean it smells like oranges it was so clean it shocked me! The whole restaurant was clean! It smelled good and the booths wasn't all torn up and tables all wobbly etc! The TVs had the games on and we enjoyed ourselves! WE WILL DEFINITELY BE COMING BACK AND HOPEFULLY BE MOVING INTO THE AREA SOON!

Photos
Wings and Rings
Wings and Rings
Wings and Rings

See all

OH Pizza & Wings - Worthington - Buckeye Garlic Pizza

OH Pizza & Wings - Worthington

4.1(218 reviews)
2.1 mi
•$$

I was just at the Worthington location and it was absolutely amazing. The store was clean. The food…read morecame out fresh and fast. Very efficient service. Customer service was great to not attend. Definitely will be coming back. Keep up the good work guys.

The worst customer service I've ever experienced in Columbus from ANY BUSINESS. This place used to…read morebe my families go to for good pizza yet we will never return. My husband and 7 year old daughter went to pick up at the Worthington Location and we called ahead to place our order and Alicia was who handled us from beginning to end absolutely horribly. On the phone she was extremely irritated with having to take our order so at pick up my husband walks up and she goes what's up, what's up aggressively before he can even say I'm here to pick up. He then said to her hey can I be honest she said sure he said when working in customer service I think it's important to be patient and kind when handling customers and she completely flipped out on him saying all kinds of curse words in front of a child. Saying you can get out of my store right now and you have till the count of three to get out or I'm calling the police. My husband then said you're gonna speak like that in front of a 7 year old, she then told him she'll be giving our pizza order away to the people who worked there. For $67 for two pizzas and 10 wings, we'll take our money where it's appreciated. Reached out to the owner he said he would deal with it and that he was reviewing footage only to not say anything else in response not even an I'm sorry for the way you were handled for this terrible and completely unprofessional behavior. Never again.

Photos
OH Pizza & Wings - Worthington - Mozzarella Meatball Sub

Mozzarella Meatball Sub

OH Pizza & Wings - Worthington - Funnel Cake

Funnel Cake

OH Pizza & Wings - Worthington - Old work pepperoni pizza

See all

Old work pepperoni pizza

Rooster's

Rooster's

4.1(106 reviews)
5.2 mi
•$$

My wife and I been going to Roosters since 2001, and when we moved to Powell in 2020, the Sawmill…read moreRoad location quickly became our go-to restaurant. One of the things we love most is the variety of food. Whether we're in the mood for wings, a salad, a wrap, or a sandwich, there's always something great on the menu. The prices are also very reasonable, making it a place we can enjoy regularly. What truly sets Roosters apart, though, is the people. I'm always amazed by the longevity of their employees. In fact, two of the servers we knew back in 2001 have gone on to become managers at other Roosters locations. That says a lot about the company and how they treat their team. The staff at the Sawmill Road location has become like family to us. They're always friendly, welcoming, and genuinely eager to make every visit a great experience. You can tell they enjoy what they do, and that starts with great leadership. General Manager Randi has created a positive atmosphere, and it shows every time we visit. I often tell people that if I were 30 years younger and looking to build a business, I'd open a Roosters franchise. In my opinion, it's one of the best-run restaurant concepts I've ever experienced. Great food, great value, outstanding people, and a culture that keeps both employees and customers coming back year after year. Five stars without hesitation!

You had Tortilla soup, I love it, but you rarely have it , don't know why!…read morePoblano soup is another good Soup that you don't have often !

Photos
Rooster's
Rooster's - Buffalo chicken pizza

Buffalo chicken pizza

Rooster's

See all

Wings Over Columbus - Worthington

Wings Over Columbus - Worthington

3.8(46 reviews)
3.9 mi

Man, I accidentally ordered lemon pepper tenders instead of wings and these did NOT disappoint, I…read morewill be coming back for more they hit the spot! Service was quick and amazing very kind people and place was very clean.

I've been here a few times but somehow never reviewed it; I think because the first visit was a…read moreYelp thing soon after they opened. Well, today was another special event, because Wings sent me an email for a free meal. Essentially buy a drink, get some chicken. I popped in while running errands. They were shorthanded but the new guy did his best to get me taken care of, dealing with my ordering issue while handling others. I got the three tender box, which comes with fries or toast. I went for toast, and got Carolina Gold sauce since it was new and I like it. It was okay, fine but not the best I've had. The tenders were big, crispy outside/moist inside. The whole thing is a smallish meal, a light lunch or a snack (I mean, free meal, I expected that.) Good enough, filling enough. At a super good price and with good service. Regular price is about $10, not bad for what you get. Place is small, mainly carryout but with 10 or so seats. Clean, decent parking in the strip mall, easy highway access. I'll keep this in mind (and maybe go back for free meals before the offer ends. Oh, and there's a minor aviation theme, keeping with their name. I didn't order one of the sauces or deals using aviation names, but as a plane buff I was amused.

Photos
Wings Over Columbus - Worthington - Outside

Outside

Wings Over Columbus - Worthington - 3 Tender Pack

3 Tender Pack

Wings Over Columbus - Worthington - Menu

See all

Menu

Two Rivers Restaurant - Biscuits and Creole Sausage Gravy

Two Rivers Restaurant

4.5(102 reviews)
3.9 mi
•$$

First time here when I came for the Restaurant Week menu. It is in a strip mall at the corner of…read morePowell and Sawmill and is a fairly large space with a patio. I was early enough for happy hour and had a wonderful Cucumber Gimlet. The service was excellent. I ordered the House Chopped Salad, Lake Erie Walleye, and Lemon Blueberry Panna Cotta. The salad tasted really good and fresh. The Walleye too. I liked the fennel salad with cilantro lime rice. I ate half to take some home and not be too full for dessert. The panna cotta was good, mostly because of the topping. It is not something I would order again, being kind of bland, but to no fault of the kitchen. I'm not a custard-y kind of gal, but wanted to try it. I would definitely come back here for another meal.

I've been meaning to go to this restaurant for a while. We went on a Saturday evening and there…read morewere plenty of tables available. The ambiance is low key but nice. Everyone from the hostess to our server was very friendly and nice. They have a full bar and a decent selection of beers. My wife and I decided to share their whipped ricotta appetizer and their French onion burger. The appetizer came with thinly cut crusted baguette. The ricotta cheese was mixed with some strawberry flavor. It wasn't bad but I would have preferred it to be thicker in constituency. The burger and fries came out perfectly cut into half portions for each of us, which was a really nice touch. We had asked for the burger to be cooked medium rare and I think it came out more like a medium well. The patty itself was a bit dry. This may be a one off issue and we hope to return to try some other dishes.

Photos
Two Rivers Restaurant
Two Rivers Restaurant - Pork Torta and housemade chips

Pork Torta and housemade chips

Two Rivers Restaurant - All-American Cheeseburger and fries

See all

All-American Cheeseburger and fries

Pizza Cottage & Tipton Tavern - Powell - pizza - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...