This is by far my favorite pizzeria in the valley. They have the best garlic knots I have ever tasted in Arizona. The spot is family owned and operated and everyone is super friendly and nice. The restaurant is always clean. The food is always fresh. They have great salads and some of the most amazing pizza options you could ask for. They have lunch specials from open until four and they're very affordable under $10 per person. This is also a great spot to bring the entire family for dinner. They even have a separate room that can be rented out for larger parties. read more

Very disappointed in their pizza tonight. Brought home two xl pies. Both pies the crusts were flat and hard. I'm a big fan of their food, but tonight their quality was sub par. Hope they fix this read more

OMG! Love their pizza, I'm from NY and I approve! They delivered a cheese pie to my job within an hour! Try it. It ain't crap pizza.

We use Uber Eats and order Sals often. Their food is absolutely delicious! I love their spaghetti pizza, and my daughter loves their spaghetti. It's a win-win! Their large pizzas are on the larger side, so they are perfect for large groups. They also have gluten-free options, so we love Sals when we have friends over with gluten allergies. If you're looking for a really really really good pizza, look no further! And seriously, you have to try spaghetti meatball pizza! read more

We had dinner here last night because we like to try all of the places Guy has visited locally. The garlic knots were delicious. I ordered a 14" Spaghetti and Meatball pizza. It was good but I counted and it had a total of 9 dime to nickel sized meatballs on it...I guess I expected bigger balls or more of them! The sauce also reminded me of the sauce in a can of Spaghettis. It didn't taste like the sauce that came with the garlic knots so they must use different sauces for each item. I was hoping to have my mind blown by this pizza...I was let down a little bit BUT again, it was good enough for me to eat 2 slices! My husband had the Stromboli and said it was good. Service was acceptable and the patio atmosphere was nice. read more

Went to Sal's tonight and yet again the food and service were great! They have great happy hour specials so I had a margarita and we shared the fried ravioli and the complimentary garlic knots you get when you dine in. We took our little ones with us tonight and I really appreciate the manager Domenic making sure the hostess got us a table that was easy to contain them in. We got the baked ziti pizza and it was so good! We also love the spaghetti and meatball pizza and the white pizza and add meatballs. The manager, Domenic, took time to come visit with us and make sure everything was great. Definitely a great local spot that we will continue to visit. read more

Another great Friday night in the bar at Sal's. They had a special- spinach filled gnocchi in a cream sauce. OMG! Not the tough, chewy nuggets you get at the store. These were melt in your mouth pillows of heaven. Had to be house made like their pappardelle. You won't see these on the regular menu but they are worth asking about! Great food, good vibe, neighborhood crowd, nothing hoity toidy. Just nice people and great food. Thanks, Sal! read more

I've had pizza all over the country and Sal's is the best I've had in southwest. Domenic came and talked to my table and was super polite. The garlic knots are great, the ranch dressing they have is reason enough to come here. If they put that much time and effort in a simple condiment then it shows they put that much detail in the food. The pizza is great thin but not floppy and the crust has just the perfect crunch, bend, density. An absolute delight over all around. read more

I come here a lot after seeing a movie at the Gilbert Regal theater. I love getting a glass of wine and the Wheat pasta with chicken. My husband loves getting the baked Ziti pizza. I cheat and get a bite or two from his slices. Easiest the best pizza slices in the Valley. This is a great spot to go with hubby or with the entire family. read more

If you want pizza that's makes you do the happy dance, you have to try Sals! I just found this place and I am so glad. This has to be the best pizza in Valley. I'm normally not a big fan of pizza, meaning I can say no or just have a bite or 2 to keep the waistline down lol... but I cannot help but devour Sals Pizza. I've had pepperoni and my own custom with meatballs, ricotta, and tomatoes. Not super greasy but tons of flavor. Crust just right! No soggy pizzas here! read more

This place has super fresh pizza that was hand tossed and delicious wings! We got the supreme pizza and we have a ton of left overs! Super yum ;) read more

Sal's Gilbert Pizza - Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

My favorite pizza spot around! Always friendly staff! I love that they give you garlic knots when you come in! A lot of places don't offer that, which to me is a huge perk of this place since I have little guys that are so impatient while waiting for pizza! We order appetizers all the time as well, which are great! We came for my son's birthday and they had cannolis that we made as his birthday cake and sang to him! Loved that they accommodated us! Will be my go-to local spot for sure! read more

Best place for Italian food in Gilbert by far. Sal is welcoming and the food is outstanding.

Sal's Gilbert Pizza is Gilbert's finest. Used to come to Gilbert from North Scottsdale just for the Ziti Pizza, worth the drive every time. I recommend the garlic knots and wings as well. read more

So my Mother and I went to Sal's this evening to order a well done sicilian take out Pizza for dinner. Pizza was ordered and I waited 35 minutes to find out that the pizza never went in the oven. They refunded our order and made us a larger pizza. Waited another 20 minutes and the pizza was taken out and not even close to well done; it went back in the oven for a couple minutes and again it was taken out. I arrived home and opened the box to find that there was more the double the amount of sauce that goes on a Sicilian pizza. I spooned off over 1 cup of sauce and tried to put each slice in my oven individually. The bottom of the pizza was mush, the pizza itself was soup and not even crispy AT ALL. And I sat at the pizzeria for an hour to be absolutely disappointed. I have to say that I myself am from New York and have made pizzas in Westbury, Brooklyn, and Manhattan, and I hate to use this verbiage on Yelp to a fellow New Yorker but this pizza was an absolute disgrace. I will say that they gave us some free stuff for the wait and the original errors which was greatly appreciated; but being that there was already an outstanding issue should've brought further attention, as well as tender love and care to the preparation of the pizza; and I have to say that whoever made this pizza needs to be 100% retrained in how to make a NY style Sicilian pizza. My Saturday night dinner was ruined and I dedicated an hour to be even more let down. My entire family can't eat the pizza that I waited an hour for. I'm ordering from somewhere else and throwing this in the trash. Granted I can deal with mistakes on an order, but twice in one night back to back on the same order with the most terribly prepared pizza I've ever seen or tasted in my life being the solution to the original problem, to me is completely unforgivable. Even my 85 year old grand mother was appalled and she is the easiest person to please on THE ENTIRE PLANET when it comes to food. read more

Sal's Gilbert Pizza - Pizza soup - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

The real deal pizza. I learned about this place from Guy Fieri's triple-D show and had to try it while passing through Phoenix. Terrific pizza with yeasty dough and excellent sauce. If I lived here I'd definitely be a regular! read more

Pizza here is scrumptous!! One of my top 3 pizza places in AZ! Definitely recommend getting here a little early on weekends because it fills up quick! I'm a fan of the classic or the chicken pizzas. Their bottle of wine and appetizer for $20 is a rockin' deal as well. read more

Since I came to Arizona from NY, where I believe the best Italian food is, I consider myself a good judge of Italian food and pizza. In my opinion, Sal's is the BEST in the Valley of the Sun. (P.S. maybe it's because Sal was originally from NY). Tonight my husband had pizza w/meatballs and I had Penne bolognese. Both were outstanding! Joe our server was very, polite, attentive and accomodating. Dominic V., a great addition to the staff, stopped by our table to check to make sure everything was as we ordered and chatted with us for a few minutes. He was a very pleasant, Italian from Boston who moved to Arizona. Although I didn't personally see him tonight, rumor has it that Dominic Cefalu (from Apache Junctiuon) is making cookies and desserts.Don't know who is making the delicious pizza, but... In any event, kudos to Sal for having such great servers, great food and an all round GREAT restaurant/pizzeria read more

OMG! The best pizza I have ever had. We got the chicken pesto pizza. Had lots of chicken and very flavorful! Highly recommend this restaurant! read more

Ordered a half baked ziti/ chicken Marsala pizza for delivery. Based on the reviews we expected a great pie. Unfortunately, our pizza was not up to par. While the flavors where are quite good, the crust was awful, tough and flavorless. Maybe it was just my bad luck and dough hadn't proofed well enough. The ziti on top was lovely so I think I will steer clear of the pizza and go for the classics read more

The spinach and ricotta white pizza is DELICIOUS!!! Love this place. Great for a quick slice on a lunch break or a sit down.

I wanted to love this place because my mom was excited to go there, but the pizza tasted like cardboard with very little cheese. Thin crust is one thing but this was also over baked. The antipasto salad was just okay, could have added more to it. while we were having dinner the employees decided to use the table next to us to fold pizza boxes which I just found odd and a bit disruptive when one is trying to have a nice dinner. read more

I am a pizza junkie who favors no style but only what I desire. Crisp crust....check. Was crust tasty. ..Yes. Quality of toppings. ...ummmm yummy. ...Yes. Beyond that I can't remember much. Only that yes I believe in the hype. Damn good pizza. The dedication and craftsmanship shows in each pizza pie and in the side dishes. Loved the Greek Salad. Will I return. ..Yes. Do I recommend this place. Yup. read more

Sal's Gilbert Pizza - To authenticate that I actually ate some. - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

After reading all that praise, and getting recommendations from friends, I decided to give it a try. We've had difficulty finding really good New York style Sicilian pizza. With all the promise of great food, my wife and I were very disappointed. Sam's Sicilian pizza consisted of small and not very thick slices. They are chintzy with cheese and the sauce was watery. The meat topping was spare. If you want the real thing, give Nicantoni's a try. Their Sicilian is much closer to what you get in New York City. The difference is night and day. read more

Our family split two thin crust pizzas, a sausage pepperoni and a pepperoni mushroom black olive. The pizza was okay but after all the great reviews we were expecting something great. After spending $40 for the two pizzas we decided it was underwhelming and a bit disappointing. Flavor was okay but for the price, we'll stick with Barro's. read more

Wow first time and I'm so impressed! They were so busy but got our wait time pretty much right on the nose, the employees were also so very friendly. We got a Sicilian pizza, wings and garlic knots and everything was delicious. The employee who brought the food out to my car (they're doing curbside for Covid-19) even opened and shut my door for us! Love to have not only great food but such kind employees, we will be frequents here for Update: okay went again and the ziti pizza is a MUST! It was so good. read more

Best pizza!! I love it. I am from West Phx so it is a drive for me to get there but i love to stop here if I am in this side of town.

Ordered the baked ziti crust by accident it's delicious! Toasted ravioli is great. Pretty good ordering system for curbside.

Honestly great pizza! It's always fresh even during take out. Ate in once with my family and it was probably one of the nicer pizza restaurant I've been to. And you don't find those often. read more

We absolutely love this place. We make it our first place to visit every time we come down on holidays. Everyone is so friendly and the service has always been great. Sometimes you'll even get to talk to Sal himself. He's such a great dude. They will bring you out free garlic knots -- these are absolutely delicious. We have always had pizza here, so not sure on the rest of the menu, but their pizza has always been the comparison to other pizzas we will have. "This isn't as good as Sal's" is usually what we will end up saying. Sal's is the best pizza we have ever had. End of story. read more

The best pizza west of NY! Dinners are delish too! Italian food cooked by an Italian from New York!

Worst pizza ever nothing but dough and took over an hour and and a half to get and expensive as hell Sicilian Pizza

Loved the arancini/rice ball, garlic knots, hot wings, antipasto salad, and Sicilian style supreme pizza. Packed on an early Friday night! Estimated for 20 min wait and it took less than that which was great. Huge lines for takeout and pickup. Servers and host are all in high school and were very cordial. All that food for 4 people plus more than half a large pizza for the next few days was about $70. read more

Called for a take out order and ended up changing my mind due to pricing. I was apologetic and the woman on the phone was rude and hung up on me. I understand that it can be frustrating that I changed my mind but I was very apologetic and the lady on the phone did NOT care. I also work in the food industry and would never abruptly hang up on a customer as they're apologizing. Called in at 12:30 on aug 24 2022 read more

I love Sal's. Very good pizza at a very fair price. The staff are great. This is one of those local gems people always talk about.

Sal's is the best Italian food in town! The staff is always amazing and Sal himself is a gem! You feel like family here!

It took a little time to get seated but once we were at the table the service was great and the food was better. The garlic knots are a must and the thin crust pizza was very good. read more

Wow. Just wow. I pizza picky and am building in the area and came around 6 months early to find my new pizza place. Been to Italy several times and this place has the feel of authentic Italian restaurants. Pizza was creative and crust was out of this world. Joe our sever is a gem. No need to search any longer for my Friday meal. Thank you! read more

Nice to find a New York Style pizza all the way down in Arizona! Great surprise!

This place is awesome! Food is fantastic and our server Joe was outstanding!. HIGHLY RECOMMEND! I can't believe it took us so long to try it. Prices are also low in my opinion for the quality of food and service you get. read more