We got there around 4:55 and there was already a line. Didn't wait for too long to get seated but the burger took a long time to be served. Honestly, the burger is meh, definitely not worth the hype or the commute. It is juicy but the bun was so dry and the patty is a bit too salty for us. The pasta is more impressive than the burger imo read more

Red Hook Tavern - Black ink Tagliatelle with lobster - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Rating: 9/10 Date Last Visited: 9/6/2025 We ordered the Dry-Aged Red Hook Tavern Burger ($32), Fish and Chips ($28), French Onion Soup ($18), and a side of bacon (+$8). The burger was absolutely amazing, and it was definitely one of the best burgers I've had. The meat is super juicy and cooked perfectly while the bun is the perfect vehicle for the meat. For how simple the burger is - bun, patty, cheese, pickles - they do an amazing job elevating the taste to the next level. For over $30, it's a bit pricey but well worth trying at least once. The fish and chips were good too, but pretty expensive for the portion sizes. I would not get the french onion soup again - it was decent but again, too expensive. And skip the bacon too, 100% not worth $8. I would come back again, but only get the burger. The service was great, and the restaurant itself had a nice cozy vibe to it. Overall, I would recommend this place to anyone who loves burgers, it's worth coming out and trying this place at least once in your life. read more

See all

The experience was cool. We had great bartenders and atmosphere was terrific. The burgers were good. 32 bucks pricey but good. I don't think they were best but are good. However. The transplants love it. Would I go again? Probably. But the best burger no but good. read more

We were lucky to score a same day reservation for Monday evening. When we arrived at 5.30 the place was already full (both tables and bar seats). We were seated promptly and although the seating is a little tight we didn't feel too crowded. Graham was our server and he made us feel welcome straight away. We ordered the large shrimp cocktail and the croquettes to start. We thought the large shrimp cocktail was good value at $20 for 12 shrimp (they were huge). The croquettes were nice, although there was a strong cheese flavour (something to be aware of if you aren't the biggest fan of cheese, like me). The wine menu here was good and we both started with a glass of Riesling, which was very nice. We both ordered burgers for our main, done medium well, and I had a glass of off menu French red with this. The burgers arrived and photos really don't do justice of the thickness of these. They were seasoned perfectly and really live up to the hype as one of the best burgers in NYC. The fries that came with the burger were delicious as well and so well seasoned. The price of $30 is high for a burger but I promise it's worth it. We decided to end the meal with a cocktail each, a Caffe Amaro for me and an Irish coffee for my other half. Graham was nice enough to bring us a complimentary rainbow cookie each to try which was a nice touch. Our total bill came to $250 (inc tax and tip) which is on the high side but we did have 3 drinks each. You could definitely visit here for less and we will be back in the future. read more

See all

For sure on the podium of best NYC burgers! The hype regarding the dry aged burger is real and it was cooked to perfection. Cozy space and we had about 1:30 wait. The wait was worth it! Service was good and they served Boulevard Farmhouse ale on tap which is a plus for this Kansas City girl! read more

Red Hook Tavern - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We have been trying to come for a while now. Last time we came, we were told there was a two hour wait. This time we were smart and made a reservation and ultimately, this was exactly the meal we needed for a snowy day. They open at noon, which is when our reservation was. Checked in outside and waited minimally. We were a bit worried as we were one of the first sat and so our table, close to the door, was experiencing a lot of the draft coming in with everyone else seating. This improved dramatically once the tables were sat. The brunch menu is not terribly extensive and there wasn't a ton we were interested in. Again, it was super cold, so we had to go with the French onion soup. Don't get me wrong, this was delicious. The Gruyère was delectable and the broth itself was nice. What I will comment on though is that it's a bit of a small soup, fine, but there is way too much bread. We felt there needed to be a significant shift in the bread:soup/onion ratio to make it truly a great course. For mains, we got the beef on weck and the dry-aged burger. The former was fine, nothing terribly special but exactly what I expected in terms of slices of meat on a delicious bun with a great au jus sauce. The bread does get very soggy, which is to be expected. And the chips it comes with (literal potato chips) I don't feel add much. But everyone comes for the burger. And let's be clear, the burger is delicious. I'm not sure if it's the crispiness of the onion or the crunch of the bun in combination with such a nicely prepared bit of meat, but it's worth the hype. I am absolutely not a fries guy, and the fried potato chips it comes with were very nicely seasoned and perfectly crispy. In the end, though, I think the best part, as many other reviews comment on, is the service. The waiter was such a delight and the attention to detail (swapping out our dishware, folding a napkin when we went to the bathroom, etc.) was really above expectation. read more

See all

Went to Red Hook Tavern yesterday evening and was so excited as finally got a reservation. So the burger is one of the best per Infatuation and Eater and we were so excited! Started off with a cocktail each and shared the kale salad, they were delicious! Then the main event 2 medium rare burgers, and they smelled delicious, but then bite in it and both are well done, like that's the opposite of what we ordered. But thought no worries it happens, we tell our server she apologizes and fires 2 new ones. Excited for our new burgers and they came out again well-done! And the fries tasted like cheap frozen unseasoned potato slices, I had one of them, and 1 was enough. How can you make the same mistake 2 times!? We were so disappointed with our grey dry looking burger, we gave up and left. Our server was very kind and apologized, just felt bad for her having to serve 2 extremely overcooked burgers, and felt bad for ourselves traveling all the way to Red Hook to get one of the most disappointing burger experiences in NYC. 5 star for service 0 star for burger 4 star for drinks and kale salad read more

Red Hook Tavern - Kale salad - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Red Hook Tavern gets busy with people waiting in line before opening. The majority have come to try their dry aged burger. The hype and the price of this burger did not live up to the hype in my opinion. In my opinion, this is a double edged sword because they could charge like 40 bucks for a burger because they have the demand but even a great burger probably wouldn't live up to the price tag (currently 32 dollars). The burger was good with a nice bun, nice thick juicy burger (patty needed more seasoning), and tasty salted fries. However, at the price tag it was not life changing nor would I wait in a super long line for it. Good burger nonetheless. read more

Red Hook Tavern - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Food awesome. Burger is sick. Server was skittish af. Not sure what he was on, but jumped out of his skin when I tapped him on the shoulder for some cream for my coffee. They may be overworked, but zero serving skills beyond just bringing you your food. read more

Red Hook Tavern - Burger and beer - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Came to Red Hook area and had to come here after hearing all about the amazing dry aged burger. My friends and I came around 5pm to put our name on the waiting list and we were told to come back around 730-8PM. We got a text and when we checked in we were immediately seated in our table outside. The seating was nice and cozy and the waiter took care of us. We decided to get 2 burgers to share and the croquette appetizers. The croquette appetizers were cooked perfectly and the béchamel was creamy. The star of the show was the burger of course and we all thought the beef tasted delicious! They are on the pricier side but worth to get it every once in a while. We were happy with our experience and will come back soon! read more

Outstanding! Delicious the beef has this flavor that is indescribable. I heard it is dry aged for 3 months. So the longer it's aged, the more tender and flavorful it becomes. So hard to describe, just go and taste ie! You'll be addicted! read more

My favorite burger ever. Came for lunch with a reservation, was seated immediately. Service was super friendly but not overbearing. Drinks were yummy and strong. The burger was the best I've had in a long time (possibly ever). So juicy, simple, and flavorful. The crisps on the side were great too. Can't wait to come backkkk!! read more

See all

I really wanted to love this burger. But the buns were overly toasted and the onion was much thicker than the pictures, making it difficult to eat. Overall still a delicious burger and highly recommend it. The service is choppy but they serve a lot of people through out the day so it's understandable. The ambiance is typical of smaller tavern. read more

Red Hook Tavern - Burger medium rare - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Legitimately the best burger I've ever had. Very kind staff and great cocktail and beer selection as well. One of my new favorite restaurants in NYC read more

If you are a burger lover like me, you've probably heard this place is on a must-try list which makes sense just by seeing the pictures alone, but trying to get in is a whole separate adventure that turns most folks away. Assuming you've finally found a time on RESY or OpenTable or risked waiting in line for an hour before they open, the ambiance is warm but small, the menu gives a classic tavern/bar vibe with limited but rich options and the drink menu is solid with a good amount of martini options. Our waiter suggested starting with a salad, then splitting a burger and a pasta between my fiancee and I, so that's what we did. The Romaine Wedge Salad: 9/10 It's 7 green leafs, a giant slab of bacon and a really solid bleu cheese dressing. Upon first glance I didnt think it would satisfy that much but after cutting up a few small slicer of bacon and pairing it together with some chunks of bleu cheese and buttermilk dressing, the romaine provides a nice crunch that makes made it work really nicely. Surprisingly good The Oxtail Ragu Cavatelli: 9/10 At first, I thought it was just good. I couldnt really find the oxtail at first between the chunks of tomato and the flavors seemed muted with some spice and crunch from breadcrumbs and red pepper flake. I think this is just a problem with hot pasta. I wouldve given this an 8/10 but I brought my leftovers home, re-heated it, and overnight this just tasted so much better. I'd order this dish to-go, stick it in the fridge and eat it the next day every time because the next day flavors were awesome and bumped up the score a little. Dry Aged Burger: 8/10 The smell, the look, the cook (medium rare) and the buns altogether made the expectations extremely high before taking a bite. After taking a bite, a little left to be desired. The dry aged smell and flavor really comes through, but it stops short because there just wasnt enough salt on the patty to pronounce the meaty flavors more. A few bites and I started adding some ketchup to it and bam, instantly better. The tangy and saltiness from the ketchup really started to make the flavors bounce around and made for a better eating experience. I think most solid burgers shouldnt need the addition of help from condiments which made me shocked this one needed it, alas, I think it was necessary. The size of the burger for the price is a great deal though and the fries were solid, so I wouldnt say this burger was disappointing at all, just compared to other top places I expected a little more. Overall, solid place, highly recommend a visit if you can get in but the reservation system is rough. read more

See all

The below was removed by Red Hook Tavern: BEWARE WALK-INS - Like many of us that don't have a reservation (there's nothing 60 days out on Open Table), the drill is you show up 30 min before they open (4:30pm) and get on the cancellation list. So, we stood in line for 45 min last night to get on this list. Single digits with wind chill. It wasn't pleasant, but we were YOLO and knew we'd at least get a table at some point. Finally speak to the host at 5:15pm. She's pleasant, takes our phone number and says we'll text you when your table of two is ready. Fair warning, we're told 8:30pm. Oof. 3 hrs and 15 min wait. We go to San Pedro, throw back some pre drinks, obsessively check our phone over the next three hours. Our new bar friends and the bartender at San Pedro (love you Annie!) are all invested with us, cheering us on for the $32 burger that's about to come and then, and THEN, we get the below texts. Look. You can't tell people to hang out for THREE HOURS and then not come through. You are a well oiled machine, who handle a high volume on the regular! You have to kick a message out sooner than this. See snapshots. FYI: We weren't the only ones this happened too as we chatted with a few people in line. At complete disbelief, I physically walk back into the restaurant, show the host my text and say 'please tell me this isn't true'. Nervously, she reads it and says absolutely nothing. I explain how incredibly uncool this was and that they need to be honest upfront. Even, "there is a chance after waiting 3+ hours, you STILL might get locked out". We would have walked! It comes across greedy. Which is insane given their popularity. Then, icing on the cake, sitting on our couch at home, we get ANOTHER update 45 min later that our table is ready? You really can't make this up. Terrible communication. C'mon, RHT. Do better by your locals! read more

Red Hook Tavern - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Boys holy sh!t. This is it, this is the burger they serve in heaven. This is the burger that you will tell your grandchildren about: *The Year is 2079* "I remember going to the Red Hook Tavern in December of 2024, I had the best cheeseburger I ever had, by golly!" They'll usher you back to your room, and because they've never had a cheeseburger before, because they are all vegans, they'll say, "Our Grandpa, what a kook, cheeseburgers, no one eats meat!" Anyway - this place is great, the star of the show is the burger but the supporting cast is phenomenal as well. Soup and salad, check, check. Tight but good dessert menu, check. Oh and did I mention a loving and caring staff and an ambiance to match? Well yeah that stuff in spades as well. Head down to the Red Hook Tavern, it'll give ya something to tell your grandkids about. read more

Red Hook Tavern is often recommended and said to have one of the best burgers in the city so we decided to venture out to Red Hook to check it out. This did not disappoint! I'm not the biggest burger fan but this was a perfect one. Cooked so well, great beef taste, perfectly balanced and seasoned. Also love the waffle fries. Aside from the burger, tried a bunch of other stuff. Mussels were soooo good, especially with bread. Even the wedge, as simple as it looks, was so good with the dill ranch dressing sitch. Loved the vibe of the place. While the menu is quite limited, the food was killer. Honestly, a total case of when the food is so much better than the photos. Must go. Service was also great. read more

See all

I got there 30min before it open so I was able to get a seat. Seating is very limited. I sat down and bout 3 mins later I heard the hostess telling other people the wait would be a hour and a half. It's extremely small inside. Very nice but small. The burger was good. Was it the best I ever had, no. But it was good. Fries were bang'n. Few suggestions. They don't serve tomatoes. How you going to cook an American burger without tomatoes. They could use a different bun. But overall it was a great burger. read more

See all

It was a good burger but nothing spectacular. Having tried it I don't think you'd need to go out of your way to get it. I really don't have much to say hahah. It had a medium rare patty, grilled onions, and cheese so it's super simple. read more

Red Hook Tavern - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Got a reservation at the patio, it's really far from any subway stop so the only way to get here is either a long walk from the F train or the bus. When we got here though, we were seated very promptly. Wish we had an indoor reservation since the tavern felt so cozy and french-like, but the outside was cute too and they had heated lamps that were almost too hot honestly. We got a french onion soup to share, which is perfect for the cold weather. tons of filling and flavor. We each also got the burger and you can order the meat either medium or medium rare. I got the medium rare and the meat was so tender that blood was oozing out (in the best way possible). There was also a nuttiness flavor probably due to the dry aged meat. The chips were okay - seemed homemade but nothing special in flavor. read more

Visited RHT yesterday for lunch after snagging a reservation for 2 seats at the bar 2 weeks in advance. My son and I each had our own burger to see if it lived up to the rep. Happy to say it did! We are a bit of burger-obsessives so we have a lot of great and not-so-great burger experiences under out belts. This is a top 5 all time great burger for us. This burger delivered in every way. From the first bite, it was clear the patty was an absolute star: meat had great flavor and it was seasoned perfectly. The bun was perfect for it - just the right combination of softness and heartiness. I'm not a fan of raw onion but the bartender convinced us not to skip it since the heat of the burger softens the onion before you start to eat it, and he was absolutely right. Great accompaniment to the rest of the burger. Cheese was done just right too. This is a simple presentation for a reason. All of the components are balanced and add to the overall flavor. No sauce other than ketchup is provided or needed. If I had one gripe it would be that the cottage fries could have used a bit more crispiness and flavor. But I didn't come for the fries. I came for the burger and it delivered. (The French onion soup that we shared was also top-notch. Rich flavorful broth with perfectly crusty cheese. We didn't need the extra food but we had gotten a recommendation for it so figured, why not?) 4.75 out of 5 on our burger-quest scale. Note that we went with medium since the bartender said their medium tended toward the medium-rare side and I've been burned by under-cooked medium rare burgers. Next time I'll come back and go with the recommended medium-rare and I expect this burger will be even better. Also, shout out to the 2 bartenders. They were each super friendly, attentive and helpful. Great overall experience. read more

I came here for the burger and it did not disappoint. Though I think my favorite item was the ham croquettes. Also got the French onion soup and the oxtail cavatelli. Ended my meal with the tricolor cookies which were good but from the fridge so served cold. Highly recommend a reservation. I arrived here at exactly 5pm without a reservation on a Thursday and was able to get a bar stool window seat. There were already a few parties waiting. read more

See all

Visited Red Hook Tavern for a solo lunch on a chilly Saturday in Jan. I usually have no issue with solo walk-ins at most restaurants, but this one I was actually close to not being sat before they closed after lunch service. I showed up at about 1:15pm, and was lucky to be sat at 2pm. Their last seating is 2:45pm before dinner service. I sat at the bar and ordered the burger and French onion soup. I understand this burger is a top nyc burger, but if you don't love thick burgers, it will be somewhat underwhelming. Personally I just prefer a thinner burger, so I won't be running back for it anytime soon. The soup was very good though, and the service was top notch. I never felt rushed to leave, my water was always full, and the playlist was top notch! If I go back I would love to try the beef on weck! read more

Red Hook Tavern - French onion soup - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Food: The food was delicious here! The burger was amazing and one of the best burgers I've ever had. The bun was fresh and the burger was cooked perfectly. I highly recommend the burger! The ham croquettes were also very tasty but on saltier side. The French onion soup was delicious especially with the melted cheese on stop. I would also recommend getting the soup here. Service: Service was good here! Staff were attentive and friendly and checked on us throughout the meal. Ambiance: This place has both outdoor and indoor seating and can accommodate large and small groups. The decor and feel of the restaurant is nice, and seating is comfortable. Tables are spaced very closely together with only a few inches between your table and the next. Overall, I would recommend this restaurant! read more

See all

Red Hook Tavern has one of the tastiest burgers I have ever had and that's just what I wanted to say. Made reservations and had this place for dinner and everything that we had was just fantastic. We were blown away at how tasty, and juicy this dry-aged burger was. I know most people wouldn't talk about a burger but I think this place got it down. Not saying they don't make a mean Wedge salad as well. We also had some shrimp cocktails and some tasty mussels filled with some magic sauce which is also a must-order. If you are ever in Brooklyn you got to make a reservation to Red Hook Tavern. The service was perfect and even though the place was packed our meal went off without a hitch! read more

See all

We came for one thing only, and that was the burger. Our friends raved about how delicious it was and we had a pretty good burger at Rolo's a few weeks ago, so we wanted to compare. We came early at 11:00 on a Saturday, but we were the first in line since they don't open until 12pm. The line got pretty long behind us, but 11:00 was definitely too early, maybe 11:30 if you want to get into the first seating. We came with a group of 6 and got 6 burgers + oysters and the kale salad to share. The kale salad was good and a nice starter! The burgers do take a while to make, so be patient because it's worth the wait. It's a single, super juicy patty that is thicc. I love how simple it is with just raw onions and cheese on a sesame bun I wasn't a fan of the fries, which were more like fried potato rounds.. I would've rather had regular fries. Compared to Rolo's, the bun is not as good, but it's definitely more juicy! Rolo's also has 2 patties vs the 1 at Red Hook, but it's so thick, it's basically the same amount of meat Highly recommend if you're a fan of gourmet burgers! It's close to $30 though so make it a treat read more

Overall: Red Hook Tavern has been on my list of best burgers in NYC for a while now. We finally got a reservation (several weeks in advance) and got to try it. The food was delicious - the burger lived up to the hype. The line can be absurdly long at times to get in, but with a reservation we were able to enjoy the day in Red Hook and pop over for dinner. The food was good, service was friendly, and overall it made for a great dinner. I'll be back at some point, hopefully with a larger group. Food: 5 Drinks: 3 Service: 5 Value: 4 Atmosphere: 5 Food: We split the country ham croquettes and each had a burger. The croquettes were amazing - they were filled with gooey cheese and had a thin layer of fried breading on the outside. We wouldn't have ordered these without the bartender insisting on it, but they were worth it. The burgers were the star of the show. They only come with meat, cheese, and onion on them, but thats plenty. The patty has a thick layer of black pepper on it that has a strong and distinctive taste. I thought it was good, but it was a powerful taste that I could see being polarizing for some. But overall, the burger is in contention for one of the best in NYC. Drinks: We each got a cocktail. The drinks were all pre-mixed so they came out quickly, but they weren't the best. I had the "Isle Old Fashioned" and my girlfriend had the "Thunderbird", but neither blew us away. Service: We sat at the bar but still got very attentive service the whole time. The bartenders were friendly and talkative - every time they came by they would strike up some sort of conversation. They had great food recommendations, suggestions on other places to try in Red Hook, and even a list of other top burger places in the city we should try. I was a little nervous about the service we might get sitting at the bar, but it was top notch. Value: Our burgers were $29 each, the croquettes were $14, and the drinks were ~$17 each. We got a ton of food, but thats still kind of steep price for a burger and drinks. Atmosphere: We had a great time at this place. The bartenders and staff were all friendly, the place was full of people, and it was very lively. read more

Red Hook Tavern - Dry Aged Cheeseburger - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Our friend said this was one of the best burger she's had so naturally I had to verify the accuracy of such a bold statement. When we tried to make a reservation for Saturday, they were all booked out. We decided to tempt fate and trek over for walk-in. We got there 30 minutes before they opened for the evening and there was already a line! This must mean it's good right? 5 comes, and they start walking people in. Luckily, since we were 4th in line, we got seated in 15 minutes at the 2 seats by the window. The person handling the check-ins was very friendly and so was the staff inside. We got to ordering. We got the burger and cavatelli. The staff warned us there may be a 20 minute wait for our entrees but we were fine. The cavatelli came first and it was a good start to warm you up from the unusually chilly April we're experiencing. The texture was chewy and the sauces tasty. There were some pepper flakes that kicked and kicked my body heat up as well. We get the burger and it is THICCC. Probably one of the thickest I've seen smothered with that cheesy goodness. The burgers do automatically come medium rare and some may not like the texture (I loved it). It was so juicy and flavorful and the cottage fries paired well with it. I would say it's definitely worth to come for the burger. Try to make a reservation because from what it seemed, if you're not the first 8-10 parties in line, you may not get a seat. read more

See all

Stop reading this review, head to Red Hook Tavern, and get the burger. You will not regret it. Seriously, I didn't have "lunch" here, I had a religious experience. The burger gets a lot of hype, and I can confirm that all of it is deserved. They keep it nice and simple to let each component shine, and shine they do! Let's work our way from the outside in -- the bun is something special, toasty without being too crunchy, the perfect vehicle for this burger to get to your mouth. The meat is seasoned perfectly, you can taste the salt and cracked pepper with each juicy bite. I got mine medium, and it was easily the best burger patty I've tasted in years, maybe ever. The cheese is so decadent, and adds a nice sharpness to go with the heavy patty. And then the onions are a nice touch, adding some crunch to each bite without taking away from other flavors. The fries were also great, shaped more like chips than traditional sticks, and also seasoned really well. Charming old school interior, and it fills up quickly! Make a reservation or go at an off hour if you don't want to deal with a wait. Everything about this meal was memorable, I can't say enough about my experience here. read more

See all

walked in snagged a table for 1 at 6pm on sunday evening and was honestly so happy to not have an hour half wait. burger was solid peppery and tasty. it was juicy without soaking my bun which is A+ for me. The fries even had pepper on it. would definitely return fast and efficient service. they could use better ac to be honest. read more

Red Hook Tavern - Dry Aged Cheeseburger - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

2nd time back and even better than the first. Food and drinks all top notch and evident by the long reservation list. This time I booked a week and half ahead so each day leading up, I was salivating at the thought of sinking my mouth into their signature burger. Red Hook Tavern is no doubt a favorite of mine and will be back over and over. read more

See all

BEST BURGER IN NYC (so far). There, I said it. This place really lived up to the burger hype. I was not let down one bit. Now I understand why a reservation is so hard to come by. Was able to get one for a Sunday evening. Please allocate time to get there since this is out of the way no matter what. Staff was nice and was able to accommodate food allergies. Ordered the following: 3 different cocktails - all great 3 burgers - so much great meaty flavor. Simple burger without any BS toppings... just meat, cheese, onion... amazing... came with crispy cottage fries that were perfect Oxtail Ravi - great. Would definitely order again Wedge salad - bacon on top was as good as you'll get at any steakhouse in the city Steak tartare - a little salty but great overall Definitely worth the trip! read more

See all

Red Hook Tavern serves a burger that's hard to forget. From the first glance, it's clear that this is a place that respects its ingredients. The meat is displayed proudly, unadorned, with nothing except for a slice of onion (similar to Peter Luger's hamburger). No elaborate sauces or toppings...just a perfectly cooked burger on a bun that supports rather than overwhelms. The tavern itself complements the food with a casual, unpretentious atmosphere. Wooden tables, soft lighting, and the hum of conversation create a space that feels welcoming whether you've come solo, with friends, or with family. That said, Red Hook itself is quiet. Beyond a handful of other restaurants and bars, the neighborhood offers little in the way of entertainment and getting there requires either a ferry ride or a bus trip. But for a burger this memorable, the journey is part of the experience and entirely worth it. read more

Went for the burger. Very overrated and overpriced. My husband and I both thought the meat lacked flavor and bun was too hard. Didn't taste like it was toasted or buttered either just like a stale roll. Had much better burgers in NY less than $34. read more

When we got dropped off out front, I thought we put in the wrong address. No big sign or lights out front, which really matches the vibe of the entire place and I love it. It's not large inside, maybe 8-10 tables total depending on the size of the parties. It's tight but too much so. What this does allow for is great service. The staff were super attentive and helpful when picking out food and drink pairings. Ended up getting the cheese board to start, and then the mussels and I had to try the cheeseburger. The cheese board was nice, with some great charred bread to accompany it along with honey from the bartenders farm which was a nice touch and delicious with the blue they were serving. My wife loved the mussels. I honestly have no idea how they arrange them all into the bowl to present such a beautiful display of mussels, but hats off to the chef there. The burger was great. Best in NYC? Wouldn't go that far, but it's a matter of opinion and this one is definitely in the conversation of top 10 for sure. Would definitely come back. Feel like there were five other items I wanted to try and again can't thank the staff enough for a great experience. Perfect cool first date spot. read more

The French onion soup was a little overrated. The shrimp cocktail was very good but the oysters were off. The burger was the star of the show read more

I got the burger and it definitely lives up to the hype. There's nothing special on it, just good meat and cooked well. The fries were really good too read more

Red Hook Tavern - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The burger is next level and the antithesis to the current smash burger trend. Definitely a Top 3 burger in NYC. That being said, don't know if I feel compelled to make the trip to Red Hook regularly for this? read more

My family and I decided to experience Red Hook area for the 1st time. Two hour travel. We called to make reservations and were told they don't take reservations! Once we got there by 2 there was a line. I was informed how there's a waiting list. The greeter had taken my name and phone # how they will call us. Now I went across the street to a dive bar to kill time. After and 1 1/2 I decided to go back to check while there was few empty tables especially outdoors and she couldn't accommodate us. However there was a gentleman who my husband had spoken to And he asked my husband if we have reservations? feeing confused. Hubby told him how we called etc but the gentleman was quick to apologize but how we needed to wait as they were running a waiting list. The girl had jump into our convo and said to us how we needed to wait. She estimated around 9:20! Now how would she predict timing! Luckily we decided to go bar hopping and ended up at few nice places. We had apptz drinks and ended up eaten at hometown BBQ. A small Line but worth it. Can you believe RED HOOK TAVERN texted and said how our table was ready!! It was 9:20pm same time the host mentioned. Kitchen closes at 9:30!! Shame on this establishment!! Perhaps she was racist!! Stay away from this place! Not worth to spend $ or support small business! ! There's plenty of nice places In RED HOOK walking distance. Beware and walk away is not worth the wait! read more