I dined here twice recently on a visit to Cincinnati a couple weeks ago. One visit was for lunch and the other was for dinner. Good, quality steaks! I also particularly enjoyed the loaded baked potato I had on my dinner visit. So good! I appreciate when a restaurant does the small touches which greatly enhance the taste of your dishes, like making your own bacon bits, rather than packaged! Service was great, friendly, and attentive on both visits. Pleasant atmosphere. I had dinner in the dining room and my lunch was enjoyed in the bar area. read more

Prime Cincinnati - 6oz. 6 oz. Filet Mignon with sidewinder fries. - Steakhouses Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

We did a small 16 person party event off of a planned menu and it was really good. There was a charcuterie board that was really nice, but the star of the show was my 12 ounce. New York strip with onions and mushrooms and a side of béarnaise sauce. Steak was cooked correctly and tasted tender and great. We also had crabcakes as an appetizer and asparagus. read more

See all

My conference programmers recommended Prime, so I gave it a shot. Bar staff were friendly and laid back, but I'll come out and say it: the food simply wasn't worth the price. I don't mind paying more for a great chef-fired steak, but this was the most unremarkable over-$70 steak I've ever seen. (Maybe the chef had the night off?) Steak was dry and with almost zero marbling on the ribeye it lacked flavor. Felt like a Ponderosa experience at Ruth's Chris prices. Maybe I just caught them on a bad night. I'll stick with the Chicago steakhouses and eat something else next time I'm in Cincy. read more

Prime Cincinnati - Dirty martini - Steakhouses Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Prime is now our go to for steak; we have sworn off every chain steakhouse and Johnny & Carlo's/Jeff Ruby's (TBH, it wasn't about the steak, it was inattention to detail, like lukewarm mashed potatoes with my mom's steak at her 88th birthday celebration; the restaurant was, like, half full ;-) Prime is consistently excellent on every detail: the ambience, the food, the attentiveness of the wait staff! Try it, you'll like it... read more

Audrey gave great service! Very friendly and accommodating. The restaurant helped make my Mom's birthday special overall. Food was as expected, no standout; but the grippo brownie is a must try desert! read more

See all

Thought I would treat myself to lunch and decided to try Prime Cincinnati located downtown. The place is upscale with soft jazz playing at just the right volume. I was greeted, seated and quickly waited on. The staff was very informative and make excellent suggestions. Started with the vegetable soup which was very hearty , Great flavor with lots of veggies. (Made with chicken stock) Perfect for this cool rainy day. My lunch entree was Beef Tenderloin Tip sandwich was very tender with onion straws and a horseradish sauce. Very tasty & it's Certified Angus Beef. My sandwich arrived as soon as I finished my soup making for a relaxed enjoyable eat on a lunch hour. On Friday and Saturday evening they offer entertainment. Singers and musicians Happy hour is from 4 to 6 pm. Great food, excellent service, reasonably priced. We'll be back. read more

See all

I could not be more pleased with the experience I had for my 40th birthday dinner at Prime. I contacted them the day of the event after another venue fell through, and Zach, Lilse, and the staff made everything effortlessly perfect--impressively professional service from Mario and Mariano, customized menu and display screen in the private dining room, and perfectly timed serving of perfectly prepared food. Many guests had never been to Prime and remarked that they were absolutely impressed and plan to come back. I now can't recommend any other restaurant or venue for a special dinner party in all of Cincinnati, and I will always remember the experience at Prime as a central part of what made the gathering so special. Thank you! read more

Prime Cincinnati - Steakhouses Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Had a reservation for 6 people. 2 dropped at the last minute because they were sick. They then seated us at a 4 top table Then the bill came and then they added 20% for a large party!! They didn't wait on 6 and we sat at a 4 top table. Ridiculous. They would t take it off. Wont go back. Not worth the money. Go to Tony's or Ruby's!! read more

Stopped in for an early dinner on a Friday night. We didn't have reservations but could get seated. The staff were exceptional- friendly, attentive, knowledgeable. We ordered the creamy crab dip for an appetizer and it did not disappoint. I had the lamb chops for dinner which were very good. It's definitely a nice elegant setting for dinner. read more

See all

Food was delicious and our servers were awesome. I ordered the 12oz new york strip with their roasted shallot mashed potatoes and my fiancée ordered an 8oz filet mignon with a caesar salad. Both steaks were cooked very well with a good crust, and the potatoes were great. I had requested the $2 truffle add on for my potatoes, but I did not receive it nor was a I charged so no harm no foul. We had ordered the crème brûlée for dessert which was very good. We were sat in the front corner with a great view of the city, as we were right up along the front windows. The overall volume in the restaurant was quite comfortable, I did not feel as though I had to speak up or quiet down. Made for a nice conversation. read more

Prime Cincinnati - crème brûlée - Steakhouses Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Unexpected, their Bourbon Speakeasy, was unexpectedly... lackluster. Entrance - we get a "tour" on the way which to be honest is a little cheesy. It just feels like a bunch of name dropping. The entrance is through a bookcase that never closes all the way and definitely needed to be stylized better. Drinks - 1 drink per person, 3 total. Drinks weren't bad enough to send back, but weren't good enough to entice us to try others on the menu. And for $17 a drink, they should be phenomenal. Ambiance - you're in an expensive steakhouse, there's classy jazz music playing, luscious seating, and... green rave laser lights? Amazon table lamps in blue? It does not match. Service - our waiter was great. That was the redeemer. Overall I was severely disappointed and the $17 price tag per lackluster cocktail and dreadful ambiance killed it. With over 30 other speakeasy/speakeasy type bars in the area, this needs to up its game. read more

Prime's food is so good. A hidden gem here is their happy hour, where you can try some of their food at a great price. I love to get the prime burger with a cosmo - 10/10! For dinner, I've also had their steak which is great, salmon, Mac & cheese, and other dishes. They also sometimes do live music, which is a great touch. read more

Was not busy, yet service was still very slow. Tended to be visibly ignored by staff. The food was only okay, the center cut ribeye seemed to be more like a filet. The ambiance was not great either, very squished almost feels like you're at a banquet. Maybe just my servers, but overall experience was not enjoyable. read more

Here's the deal: it's okay .. a nice upscale place for dinner around the theaters in the area ! The bar area looks like a real nice place to grab dinner . Food was okay . Couple service glitches which can happen (people are human). Overall good was "ok" not great ! read more

See all

My first time here was for burger week. WOW!!!!!!! Possibly the best burger I have ever had. And the Tator tots?? The name does not do them justice. Topped it off with a vodka based mule. Fun!!!! I cannot wait to go back for a steak. It's lovely and classy and great service! read more

Prime Cincinnati - Hamburger and Tator tots - Steakhouses Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

The service was adequate and the and the drinks as well. What was not adequate was the steaks. My wife's filet was grainy and undercooked then when it came back it did not taste right and was still grainy. My ribeye was one of the worse ones I have ever had. Bland, lots and lots of fat. You will do yourself a favor. read more

I visited Prime Cincinnati on a Saturday night before a show. We were a party of 6 and our dinners were mediocre. I had the seafood salad which was fine except for the avocado that was less than fresh. I don't even serve avocado with black spots on it at home. My husband had the seafood carbonara which he said was flavor less. My friend ordered the lamb chops which she had a difficult time cutting because they were very fatty. Some one came to our table ( man in a suit I assume a manager) to ask about our dinner and when she mentioned the amt of fat all that was said was sorry. At those prices , I would expect excellent food and service. Also please invest in an expresso machine if you are going to offer expresso martinis. Less expensive restaurants make real expresso martinis. read more

We went to lunch with a client around noon on a weekday. The place was quiet with only a couple other tables in service. The place was spotless and the service was flawless. I was surprised to see the lunch prices being so reasonable. Myself and our client both ordered the grilled chicken Caesar salad for $12 plus $9 for the added chicken. Was it the best? No but it was good and the dressing was a mild version with great taste. The lettuce was not as crunchy as I prefer but that didn't stop me from eating every bite. Our other attendees both ordered a "Prime Stack". These are sandwiches. Both ordered the Tenderloin Tip stack with Parmesan Frites. Both really enjoyed them, especially the frites that were cooked perfectly. I am not sure how much value this review has because I have a feeling that dinner service, when you might enjoy a bit heavier meal, would be more delightful. I would especially like to try their theater menu sometime. However, if you are in downtown Cincy at lunch time, Prime would be a fine choice that gives you a relaxed atmosphere, great service, good food and an overall great value proposition. read more

Great service by Todd. Wine suggestions were spot on and food was fabulous. Oysters and shrimp cocktail to start. For Our main course I had short ribs and pappardelle and my partner had surf and turf with filet mignon. All excellent! read more

I like coming here during restaurant week to get a good deal on a great meal! We really enjoyed our meal, especially the steak, which was cooked perfectly. Ambiance is the the typical dark steakhouse vibe, with candles on the table. Service was friendly and helpful with suggestions. read more

See all

Had a large sampling of apps and for diet we got the lamb chops and the salmon. Everything was excellent and we added this place to our list of places to eat at when in the city. read more

Prime Cincinnati - Baked Potato that was HUGE! - Steakhouses Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Food are amazing the music and everything. Cocktails are soo perfect! I have a dutifull experience read more

We had the most perfect Thanksgiving dinner here. After years of laboring in the kitchen, cooking and taste-testing, and being unable to actually enjoy eating on Thanksgiving, this year I took a stand and said "NO." I decided to switch it up this year and after perusing menus, landed on Prime as they were the only one to offer both turkey and ham. For starters, we shared an order of traditionally prepared deviled eggs. Hubs and I opted for their Thanksgiving special for which included a salad. The adult special of turkey+ham was accompanied by mashed potatoes, dressing, Brussels sprouts, and cranberry sauce. I also ordered their truffle mac/cheese for the table which had a crispy panko topping and was cooked perfectly. Everything literally tasted like Thanksgiving (well seasoned and just overall delicious-ness.) The kid-sized version also received high marks from the littles. The only low-point was the dessert (banana pudding which didn't have enough wafers for my preference.) Overall, we had a lovely time and will make eating out on Thanksgiving day a new tradition. read more

See all

Our second visit to this restaurant was disappointing. My daughter reported the lamb chops were "just OK" (not as good as I make for her). My spouse found the filet in her salad to much too salty. My seafood cacio e pepe was mediocre, at best. The shrimp were way too salty, and the pasta was so dense that if you packed it into a musket on top of some gunpowder, you could kill Redcoats with it. For the very high prices here, we won't be back. read more

Did a corporate event here, person hosting the event told the planner that people could order whatever they wanted to drink instead of a set menu. So this place set up a bar with all super expensive booze and no menus so people thought their only booze options were the expensive stuff. We went ridiculously over our budget because they did this, when I tried to talk to the manager his response was "well when you dont limit us we are a business and have to make money too" The whiskey tab was thousands. On top of that they served burnt chicken parmasan that was horrible and should have never been served. This was cruel to do to a corporate event, they could have put people's jobs at risk and did not care at all. read more

Great appetizers! The calamari was excellent. Very well priced also. The drinks were good. The servers were really respectful.

I've been to Prime several times over the last year. Service is always outstanding, I love to sit at the bar! Food is delicious. Their new short rib dish for fall is definitely worth the try. The ambiance is classy without being pretentious. read more

Loved the holiday decor, seemed so festive and warm. The staff was outstanding. Especially working on Christmas Eve. Our meals were tasty and well prepared. I'd recommend Prime to others. read more

Trystan was my bartender and server. Outstanding service throughout. The New York Strip was seared perfectly and so flavorful. Other staff checked on me and savored the selection. My only suggestion: Allow the sides to be half-sized. Family style is not the answer for single diners who do not want to take left-overs during travel. read more

Omgosh!!! Yes yes and yes again. My salmon was perfectly made. My husbands short rib was tender and tasty (shhh no need to let him know I had a bite) My husband love oysters. And he said these were GREAT!!! I would definitely come back. Nothing like traveling back home to more great food. Great job Prime. Our server Julie was AWESOME! read more

See all

My hubby surprised me with a birthday dinner at Prime. We choose the Valentine's menu with wine pairing since it's right around the corner. First I have to say, the service is excellent!! The waiters are on top of their games, very friendly, fast and efficient. We started off with the tenderloin. So tasty and so tender! Next on the menu: very good lobster bisque. It was really! good! My hubby choose paella as a main course, I opted for the sea bass. While my hubby was raving about his paella, I was disappointed with the sea bass. The fish was cooked well but the risotto tasted like over salted broth and was not good at all. Our dessert, tree leches was not bad but I was hoping for a more moist cake. Unfortunately it was on the drier side. read more

See all

Solid place for a steak dinner. Excellent staff, good appetizers, and was overall a positive experience.

Great happy hour. Nice bar area. Great to have a casual dining experience at a nice stake house. Love the burgers at the bar!!

A decent steakhouse that doesn't break the bank. Very attentive Waite staff. Great recommendations for appetizers, entrees, and dessert. Skip the big chains. Head to Prime. read more

Burger week, burger was meehhh, the Mac and cheese was overly salted, but the service was so sloooww, downtown lunchtime business luncheon, let me pay the bill and go. read more

Perfect environment before heading to event at Taft Theater ( walking distance). No kids in sight-great service very welcoming-accommodating. Food choices diverse! Pricey but worth it. Bar separate from eating area. Clean! Steak cooked to perfection-margarita is like no other ( pineapple). Dessert Crème Brûlée White Chocolate is a must!!!!!!!!!! Chocolate Chip cookie dessert not recommended! read more

See all

"Here" for a few days and only one sit down dinner, so I was looking forward to this. The appy (calamari) was pretty good, but for me a bit more crispy would have been better. Went for the salmon and I did like it. The service was outstanding. Not a big meal, but big enjoy. Was there a couple of hours enjoying the afternoon into the evening. read more

Prime Cincinnati - Steakhouses Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Big portions of food for an upscale place. Pork chop and mussels were on point. Bar staff was great and attentive. Service overall was great. And good atmosphere read more

Prime Cincinnati - Pei Mussels - Steakhouses Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

The steak was not a prime or grass feed for $72 bucks. Was an half inch thick. The blue cheese on top tasted old.

Service was excellent. However if we are enjoying a $400 dinner, I would atleast expect my steak cooked to order. I asked for my filet mignon to be cooked rare, it came medium-medium well. My boyfriend ordered a tomahawk steak, and it was ordered medium rare, also came medium well. Sides were great, but the actual steak itself.. not the best. I've had better meals for the price in San Francisco. Not sure who is paying these prices for mediocre cuisine in the Midwest, but hey, they're in business for a reason I guess. read more