We love this place. We know we love this place. I live in the valley so we stop here when we can. We got here right at 9:45 after a golf tournament on a monday night, they said online they were open until 10:30. We got there 2 people told us we would be seated soon. We all looked at the menu picked what we wanted. After about 5 minute they told us we can not be seated only Togo. Like I said we love this place but change your hours. read more

I don't know what happened to piazza man but omg Chicken Alfredo what is more soup than anything it was made from a jar I'm pretty sure poured over some noodles yeah The house salad consisted of store-bought lettuce with a slice of tomato on top these people used to have one of the best places their pizza has lately been burnt down the top burnt on the bottom and they just don't care deliveries take hours somebody needs to give Pizza Man a wake up call there is no pried in their food read more

See all

We went for the salad bar but Loved the meal. 9" pizza, baked ravioli, lasagna and steak, rice mushroom soup. We were all happy and very full before leaving! Friendly place with good quality food. read more

TO GO @pizzamanak in Eagle River. I have been meaning to try this as an alternative to childhood familiars such as Pizza Hut. They had fast service and I enjoyed a yummy slice of Hawaiian. Interested to try the BBQ wings next! read more

See all

the inept girl at the desk took down the wrong address, not even remotely close. sent the food to the wrong address. and even after we told them it was wrong refused to refund us because the food was delivered to someone.the manager admitted that they had the wrong address and told us they deliver it to the wrong address but still refused to refund us. the manager was extremely rude, dismissive, and downright combative with my mother who is a 20 year Army veteran. we simply asked for a refund. Worst experience with any restaurant ever. read more

I have had a lot of people hype this place up to me that live in ER or Chugiak. After a quick jaunt to ER my blood sugar dropped and I needed to eat so we settled on this place. I got a small chef salad (the size of a dinner plate, not very small) for $8.50 and I split a chicken bacon ranch pizza (small) with my mother which I think was $16.75. We had to wait about 10 minutes which was fine. There isn't a whole lot of seating and it was fairly busy. The salad was fine. Not exciting or amazing, but it was fine and filled me up that I didn't really need the pizza. I took advantage of it over the salad bar as those aren't my thing. My main complaint was the pizza. While the crust was fine and chewy the pizza was bland. The chicken had zero flavor besides well, chicken. A little salt and pepper would of done it okay. The bacon was crisp and deliciously salty and the cheese actually stretched as I ate it. The ranch wasn't detectable much in the pizza (or much when I used it on my salad for that matter, and I've been told it's crack ranch) Hmmmm! Service was good at first, but we had to get up from our table to ask for refills and extra napkins after our food arrived. Our waitress was not the one who brought the food. There was no real check in after the food arrived. One girl did finally bring a pitcher refill and asked if we needed boxes and we asked for three. She never came back. Our main waitress came over and offered us boxes and we did finally get them. Overall two people could split a small salad and even a personal sized pizza and be completely satisfied. With slow to mediocre service and OK food I don't think I'd really return despite their specials on Facebook sounding delicious. I would've tried the new Greek place in ER instead, but the crowd I was with wouldn't of enjoyed that type of fare. read more

ZERO stars. I have witnessed the management assault their staff on a few occasions. I have lived in Eagle River my whole life, 55 years. I have always been a huge fan of Pizza Man. Since these newest owners have taken it over, it has gone downhill fast. Quality of the food. The wait times. The list is never-ending. But what broke the camel's back.. the rudeness of the child supervisors. I've witnessed yelling obscenities at the staff and throwing things at people. It is uncalled for. It's like watching a child throw a tantrum. I'll never be back. My family my friends and anyone that will listen. Will never be back. read more

If you must eat here, order delivery so you don't have to go in. It's gone downhill since it's been under new ownership. Floors are filthy, booths are ripped and falling apart. Walls are peeling and there are multiple leaks in the ceilings. Inside is in shambles. Also, the reward points system is a joke. We've been eating pizza here for over three years and still don't have enough "points" for a free pizza. This place used to be packed and full of life. We miss the old Pizza Man. read more

This restaurant used to have great service and great food. For the last year or maybe longer, pizza ordered for delivery is either forgotten or is over two hours late and cold. My husband asked to speak with a manager but got hung up on several times. Ever since the new owner took over, service and food have been terrible. We will no longer order or eat in the restaurant due to rude employees and substandard service and food. Such a shame too since we have enjoyed this place for years. We will tell everyone not to eat here anymore. read more

Wtf Pizza Man, who puts 100 cloves of garlic on garlic parmesan wings?! I could only eat three of them. You kinda ruined my perception of garlic and I will probably reek of it for the next month. read more

Pizza Man - Garlic - Pizza Near Me - Eagle River, Alaska

Food: 5 stars for the food. Start with the cheesy bread. Fresh, so hot it'll burn your mouth, and just really really tasty. Crunchy bread, cheesy delicious top. Sauce is included and has a great flavor. Calzone - great size for sharing. Four ingredients plus the cheeses included in a very decent Alaskan price. They have a salad bar that looks as good as Carr's! And that's saying something cause I LOVE the Carr's Salad bar. Ambiance - an older feel. The booths have cracks and marks like they've been there a while. Notables - they get beer. The sizes and the types. They identify the beers as "craft" and "not craft." Only about two of the 50 or more beers are not craft!! Win. Three sizes to choose from! Cleanliness - a little messy. Like the place got slammed before we were there. A little worn. Things like the salad bar are kept in immaculate condition. Service - wonderfully nice, great advice. Very attentive. Zero complaints. I'll try the pizza next time. read more

One thing you can count on for sure, is that the service is always excellent. The wings have really come up over the past couple of years, to the point where they become a staple for every appetizer opportunity. The gluten-free pizza is on par with mousses tooth. As always, two thumbs up... If only we could keep the bathrooms a tiny bit cleaner. read more

My wife and I ordered salads from Pizza Man tonight and they were absolutely fantastic. The ingredients were fresh and the dressings were delicious (Italian and Ranch). This restaurant just keeps getting better and better! My wife also has celiac disease and she has never had a problem with cross-contamination. Thank you Pizza Man! read more

Only pizza place that would deliver out to the Chugiak area. One of my favorite places to get pizza, if you dine in they have a nice salad bar as well. Highly recommend over any of the chains read more

DOG HAIR IN OUR PIZZA WARNING!!! Breaks my heart to say but after 20+ years, I'm having to cut off Pizza Man. After a long camping trip we decided to treat the family to Pizza Man. When we arrived home and and served up our hungry family, I unfortunately bit into a slice and pulled a LONG dog hair from my mouth. Obviously whoever made our food was unclean and owns a long haired pet. Talk about disgusting. I immediately called back and spoke to the same rep who took our call in order and payment at the counter, Michael. He offered to remake the pizza. I declined since we do not live in Eagle River. He offered a credit for a future order but I declined and asked for a refund or that the charge be canceled. He said that a credit would be completed. Well, 4 days later and I see the charge on my cc statement. I called Pizza Man and got run around. Placed on hold several times. Called back again. Placed on hold again and again. Olivia finally answered and said she was a manager. When I explained my issue, she immediately said she needed the kitchen manager and put me back on hold. After 8 min on hold, I called back again. This time Olivia said that due to the dinner rush, she couldn't help me. WTF has happed to values??? 1* reviews suck and I really hate posting any of them. Giving someone a "manager" title but no abilities to help a client is the equivalent of a participation trophy read more

Pizza Man has been my go to for a great pizza for years. The staff is friendly, helpful and really on the ball when suggesting a pizza someone would like that they aren't sure of ordering. The restaurant section is really nice with comfortable seating, it's clean and the staff is there to answer any questions. If someone is looking for a great pizza, go to Pizza Man, you will not be disappointed!! read more

The pizza was soo good! Even the biggest critic in the fambam said he liked it! Which is quite a feat! It's become our family favorite and the kiddos can't wait for the next time they get to sink their teeth into that pepperoni pizza ! read more

So all you Joe Schmo citizens of Eagle River can shun me and hate me all you like. You might as well close your eyes for this review because o boy this lovely pizza joint boutta be on a lower pedestal then Sicily's Pizza. For starters the wait was 2 hours long which I totally knew before hand as everyone in there Mama mentioned it on Yelp. So das coo. Somewhat. So the pizza arrives 2 hours later and it is cold. Okay all good it's obviously been 2 hours I'm not that mad. Perhaps. All around the crust of my pizza is burnt so that's pretty damn gross. I pop it in the oven to prepare to chow down and the Mediterranean pizza instead of pasta sauce uses pesto sauce which actually is quite unappealing. As for the bootleg buffalo chicken which had no buffalo flavor just extremely large pieces or chicken and bacon was just not delightful at all. Let us rejoice and NOT forget the damn "Greek salad" which honestly makes me laugh. Contained inch cut pieces of nearby Hillshire Farms deli cuts and about a total of 3 olives. Sweeeet. Sounds like a mentally challenged antipasto to me. Overall as the jingle goes "Just Call Sicily's Pizza, 333-8000" because wow this badboy ain't worth a dime. Yes I'm drunk & Yes I'm serious. read more

See all

Going on 2 hours 15 minutes and still waiting for delivery. Called at 1:30 and they said "it's out for delivery". Pretty sure that means they forgot and we'll make it as fast as we can. This isn't the first long wait we've had but it's the longest. Also the quality varies, can be soggy or burnt or cold or perfect. Never know but this is the last order I make with them. read more

Pizza Man used to be great. It's not anymore! Long waits indifferent servers and mediocre food. I've tried dine in and almost evaporated waiting for a beer. I used to be a regular delivery customer but then started facing 2 hour wait times only to have burnt cold pizza delivered. At one point we decided we would only order takeout from Pizza Man but now they have become so slow and unreliable that we don't even bother. It's good pizza but I can drive into Anchorage, eat and return before Pizza Man can have a takeout order ready. Bella Vista in Peters Creek or Muldoon Pizza are better choices! read more

Pizza Man is Eagle River's hometown hangout for pizza, salad bar, and tie-dye shirts with there logo. I think everyone in town owns a t-shirt if they have lived here for more than a few years. But the pizza is only okay, nothing special, nothing unique, and while it held its own in our hearts when it was the only option, now it is outclassed by better quality competition. The place is still busy, yes, but because of nostalgia and not quality. The lack of quality extends to its salad bar, it's parking, its dining room, it's everything including its identity. The best thing about Pizza Man is their long established presence and their t-shirts. Go once for the experience and buy the t-shirt. But regularly get your pizza somewhere else. read more

We love pizza man. It's been around for a long time and never disappoints. Best pizza around the anchorage area. Always nice fluffy crust, lots of toppings, great salad, and dressings (especially ranch). After having a horrible experience with mooses tooth (think food poisoning), this is the only good pizza place left in town. Their staff is also the best! read more

Why didn't my friends tell me about this historic pizza restaurant sooner? Great old fashion pizzas and Italian dishes bplus new and savory combinations. They also have a great selection of local and national craft beers. read more

Pizza Man - Pizza Near Me - Eagle River, Alaska

See all

Tried the Mediterranean pizza with peat sauce - it was great! Good selection and amount of toppings and the were generous with the cheese as well. Yum! read more

I have been ordering from Pizza Man for over 10 years. Lately the past three pizzas I have ordered were not the same as the ones I have enjoyed in the past. The ingredients were not complete as listed on the menu and the crust was soggy and under cooked--over all, just not the same quality. Also, the dressing tasted different and was watered down. Don't know what changes you have implemented, but you need to go back to the original product. read more

My order is always wrong, I've been here more than a handful of times. Waiting at the counter and no employee to greet me. Soggy fries here are the best, they Saran Wrap (plastic wrap) the fry boxes for to go orders which traps the moisture and makes the fries soggy. read more

Everyone always raves about this place so we decided to check it out. After waiting forever for the waitress to come see us, she took our order, and then we didn't see her again until she brought our cooled pizza and disgusting macaroni 45 min later. It was really a terrible experience. read more

Pizza Man is consistently one of the best pizzas I've ever had, and, yes, that includes that famous pizza joint in town. Should I ever move from Eagle River back into Anchorage, I will drive out here for the Pizza Man pizza. We've dined in a couple times and it has a real charming dive feel, but we usually get delivery. Either way, Pizza Man rocks! read more

We always get a 50/50 chance of getting our food cooked right when we order from the old bodybuilding menu. And on cheat days the pizza tends to be really greasy. But to add insult to injury the staff that usually answers the phone is indifferent. The other day when I called I was placed on hold only to be answered with "we are closed" and no explanation. Will not be ordering again. read more

Quantity of food and pricing is aggressively good. Pizza is outstanding other items are hit and miss. Prompt delivery, and unlike chain places here in ER they get the order right the first time. A must have local place. read more

First off- we love this establishment. We frequent this restaurant often and it is our tradition that we come to with visitors out of town on our way back to Anchorage. I called 2+ hours in advance to inform the staff that we were coming with a party of 20. They stated As long as we were there before 10pm they will be able to accommodate us. When we arrived at 930 they informed me that they could not sit us. I told them that we did not have to sit together, we could sit in tops of four or five. We were turned away and told they cannot serve us. Very disappointing and a waste of time. We ended up going to Chepos and had great service. read more

After (multiple) recent disappointing visits to pizza man I feel like I need to update my review, as I definitely do not feel the same. It has always been slammed busy here and that was never an issue for me, but I do have an issue with poor service from visibly flustered servers. I've been there, but don't treat people poorly just because the restaurant is busy - find a new job? That goes to multiple servers there. Also, the salad bar I used to daydream about has gone completely downhill. The lettuce and spinach is now always wilted/slimy and clearly past its expiration date. When I brought this to the attention of an employee, she acted annoyed that she had to do something about it. Last but not least, the straw that broke the camels back, the no water incident. They did not have water to serve because their system was "backed up." What I think she meant to say is that because they refuse to turn the heat on, the pipes froze. The entire restaurant was FREEZING. If you have been a PM customer for a while, you know its ALWAYS cold in there. This time, is was wayyyy colder. Why even be open? You have no water to serve customers, your toilets don't flush, you can't do dishes, and your servers are pissed? Lovely. read more

Usually am super pleased with the quality of service and our orders. This time we received completely raw chicken wings, meat was pink. And it was consumed before realizing. Super dangerous and Fr disappointed. Also concerned with current cleanliness because of this. read more

Cold all the time. Can't get what you order, they either forget, or it's out. And the service is S.L.O.W. Disappointing! It used to be great! read more

A 16 year old kid named Jason maybe 6feet 5inches was really nice such a great person

Lately they have had the worst service. They keep forgetting items and even the manager seems like they don't have time to deal with petty mistakes. They forgot to add the Caesar dressing to my order for my Caesar salad and proceeded to ask me if I really needed the dressing! WHY WOULD I ORDER A CAESAR SALAD IF I DIDN'T WANT the dressing. Their pizza is good but I can def do without it after the terrible service. Saverios is far but their pizza is better and service is amazing!!! read more

Place has gone downhill faster than the Jamaican bobsled teem in cool runnings. The new owner seems to be cutting corners faster than Ricky Bobby. Sandwich bread has changed. Pizza crust is different. Salad bar has gone to shit. This used to be a pretty iconic pizza joint In alaska, but word is spreading quickly. New owner is crushing this place. There is a reason that none of the old waitstaff works there anymore. This was one of our favorite places to eat for the last 20 years in eagle river, no longer on the list. Sucks how quickly a new owner can flush a local buissness down the toilet. read more

An Eagle River custom. Good food and love the hours. Open late at night for when you're hiking in the summer.

This place has been my favorite pizza place since 2006 . It still is . I love everything about this place .

My wife has been coming here since she was a child, and on a visit to my in-laws I finally got to try it. Pizza is delicious, so is the garlic and cheese bread, salad bar is what you expect at a small town pizza place. But the best thing on the menu, in my opinion, is the Chicken Parm Sandwich. I have dreams about that sandwich and every time I'm in town I have to have it. Join the rewards program if you live in the area, my in-laws have it and it's so worth it. read more