I went around dinner time, and I am not sure if they were sold out, but all I saw were thick square slices and thick round pies. That was a little strange since this is a Brooklyn spot and the round pies are usually thin, NYC style. I took the dive and ordered one of the thicker round slices with chicken and broccoli to stay. The person working the counter was nice and very friendly, but the slice was not heated properly when it was served. The chicken was still kind of cold and firm, and the dough was thick without much crisp to it except the crust but it was the kind of crispy that cuts up your gums if you know what I mean. If you are really craving pizza after shopping at Target or Best Buy, this place might do the job, but it is definitely not for everyone. read more

Pizza D'Amore - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

When you are in the area and hungry for pizza... come here. They are great! *Highly recommend their pizza slices and their pinwheel! I decided to try a baked pasta as I only had their pizza and garlic knots. Wanted something new and I seen other customers with large bowls of pasta. Ordered the baked ziti bolognese while my husband got his pepperoni slice. We also got garlic knots (came with sauce this time) to share and he tried something new too!- pepperoni pinwheel which he loooove! The pasta came hot and cheesy... the sliced bread on the side would have been nice if it was warmed. I enjoyed every bite of pasta... that sauce... yum! read more

See all

Stumbled upon this pizzeria while in the area for work and I must say it was a great find. Zeppoles are fresh and delicious I'm always lucky to get a batch that just came out and the pizza is always flavorful. read more

Pizza D'Amore - Zeppoles - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This place does not disappoint every time we come it is fantastic. Great selection great service and you get your pie piping hot. read more

See all

I actually used to like this place so it's hard to leave this review. I ordered a regular cheese pie was waiting for the pie to be done as I see the server taking out the pie out of the oven. I see him sneeze right on top of the pizza and he boxed it up and took it to the counter to give it to me. I told him I saw him sneeze on the pizza and then I want my money back and I left. read more

This is a pretty long running pizza place do they have a few other locations so I'm not sure if this one's been here since 1998 (presumably the one with 300 reviews but whatever.) Place was pretty crowded with a lot of families with kids. I don't remember seeing the prices on top but there are old photos with the prices so maybe I just misread it or something but I swear they weren't on top or else I likely wouldn't have ordered two slices with toppings. Anyway, I ordered a spinach mushroom slice as well as a penne slice because I was in the mood to do something odd and the two slices combined were $10 which was a bit surprising but they do top their slices with a lot of said toppings. They heated and served with the woman splitting the slices ordered which was a unique touch. In terms of toppings, I could slightly taste the sauce flavor from the penne and it wasn't dry like most other spots which made it a good amount better while the spinach mushroom was fine. Outside of the toppings, the crust of the pizza was a tad thick for my liking though apparently they make the topping slices thicker according to another review and the sauce was a tad sweet. It's generic pizza that'll get the job done. Mid 2/upper 2 read more

See all

First time in New York they had great pizza!! Great quality and great customer service.

Wow. I thought I ordered a pie 1/2 pepperoni, half plain. Instead I received something way better... This pizza was actually a time machine. As I was eating, it unlocked childhood memories for me of being a child in the 90s... after Toys R Us shopping. This pizza is the pizza of my youth and has a wonderful nostalgic old school taste. Ample pepperoni, amazingly fast delivery. Thank you! read more

Pizza D'Amore - Amazing taste - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This was the worst pizza we've ever received from this place. It was reheated until it was rock-hard and completely inedible. It's really disappointing, especially since we used to enjoy their pizza. To make matters worse, one slice costs $5 and this is the size you get. read more

Pizza D'Amore - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Man I haven't been here for over 20 years. This was my place in the late 90's when there was an arcade next door. You'd play and come get pizza afterwords. Not much has changed since. I went with a deep dish pepperoni slice and a fresh mozzarella thin slice. The winner for me was the fresh mozzarella slice. The slice was drizzled with some kind of garlic and oil mix which really made it amazing. The pepperoni slice which was sort of deep dish I would pass on as it didn't really have any flavor in the sauce. Decent place to get a quick bite when shopping nearby. read more

Pizza D'Amore - Fresh Mozzarella slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Their chicken ceasar slice is my favorite!! I think they have the best crust hands down ! Service is great ! read more

Pizza D'Amore - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

i love this pizzeria, I had hoped this slice would have had more taste. I believe it was because the cream from cheese was watered down. At $6 a slice i don't regret it but I'll choose different next time. read more

Pizza D'Amore - chicken ceaser slice. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

When I used to live in Brooklyn I would frequent this spot often as a meal after shopping. Target runs would result in pizza runs inside of pizza d'amore. After moving I've realized the thing I missed most from pizza d'amore wasn't their pizza slices or garlic knots and not the spinach pinwheels. But the wings ! I swear I can never get wings as crispy and as seasoned as this place. My family can contest this as well , we've gone to the extent as to ordering four portions of wings with Buffalo sauce on the side. I personally don't enjoy eating them as I am a carb girl and will go for the pizza and garlic knots before the wings but I must say. The winner truly are the wings, if you ever come and want something to pair alongside with your slice I highly recommend getting an offer of wings. As for the pizza I would say it's average and decent. The plain cheese slice is thin and crispy , not too filling and the slices are moderately sized. Nothing too fabulous to mention other than it's a convenient spot for after shopping munchies. The place is pretty old and a bit dirty of course like any other pizza spot. The service is okay-ish but the workers are nice and fast with their job read more

Just so much nostalgia ordering the chicken caesar salad pizza from here. I know, it sounds strange to those who haven't tried it. But as a native new yorker and someone whose favorite food is 'NYC Pizza', I crave the CCS pizza from D'Amore every time I come back to Brooklyn. It's so rich in flavor and a really good value. I feel like you can feed 4 adults easily with one pie. read more

Pizza D'Amore - Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I always receive great customer service and good quality food. I order from here once a week as my favorite choice of takeout. Highly recommend the no*4 panini, soft and fluffy zeppoles and the pizza d'amore wrap. read more

Pizza was good. Service good. Place still looks the same. Pizza definitely changed from what I remembered as a kid. I think new owners. But it was still delicious. Would go back. read more

Pizza D'Amore - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Absolutely amazing pizza! Friendly staff. Highly recommend. Try chicken Caesar pizza (spicy or regular one) and you won't regret. read more

Pizza D'Amore - My absolutely favorite pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Decided to try here after passing it a couple of times being in the target and best buy area. Came in to get a large pepperoni pie. Had to wait about 20-25 minutes. Pizza came out to be $25. It was alright, quite greasy. Not too, too bad but also nothing special. read more

Pizza D'Amore - Pepperoni Original D'Amore (8 slices) - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Service is absolutely horrible. Primo in the front asked me what my order was 3 different times because he was too busy trying to flirt with some ladies that came in. Pizza slice was super mid, made me wait 20 minutes for 2 regular slices and garlic knots. The garlic knots were horrible and dry. Would not come back. read more

Pizza D'Amore - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Friendly counter workers. Great selection of pizza. Good music choice too. Surprised read more

The Margherita pizza was too overwhelming. The flavor AND the ingredients were too much. The tomato sauce and cheese was too much, everything was starting to fall apart. Even La Bella Express' Margherita pizza was better. The garlic bread was way better than the pizza but I suggest that they cut it into smaller pieces like L&B does. Otherwise, it's just a clump of garlic in the middle of the bread. read more

Pizza D'Amore - Margherita Pizza Garlic Bread - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Bad! My boyfriend and I wanted to order pizza but they went somewhere else we tried telling them the place we were ate but they started yelling and being impatient saying "I HAVE KIDS" like it's not our fault that he went the wrong way! FIRE THAT GUY PLEASE! read more

We ordered a pie and garlic knots! I called in advance and had no issues one i got there! Great staff!

For a very long time, whenever I visited the Caesar's Bay Shopping Plaza, I would catch Pizza D'Amore with the corner of my eye as I walked into a store. It sat in the corner by Modells and I always ignored it ... until finally my hunger caught up with me on a Sunday afternoon. My wife and I walked in after some errands and, to my surprise, the restaurant was packed. There were a few booths left and some stool seats. Although the place is not too big, there are plenty of seating booths inside to accommodate the many shoppers coming in for a meal. Once we walked in, we could see all of the pre-made topping pizzas sitting behind the counter. There was a pretty good variety of different pizzas, including, spinach, eggplant, mushroom, sausage, pepperoni, ham and pineapple, just to name a few. Besides pizza, they also made different appetizers, rolls, heros, salads and wraps. For us? We were craving pizza and that's what we went with. I won't go into detail about the toppings of the pizzas we ordered, except that they definitely don't skimp on toppings, so you'll get your money's worth if you go with a pizza with toppings. On the other hand, we did notice something odd about their pizza with toppings versus their regular slices. The regular slices were thinner and less doughy, while the pizzas with toppings had a very thick bottom crust. It wasn't really a problem, but it felt like it didn't need it. We preferred pizzas with thinner crust and believed the pizzas with toppings would have tasted better if they didn't have thick crusts. With the lack of meal options in Caesars Bay, especially pizza, Pizza D'Amore is going to really win out with the kids. By no means is it a bad food option. The pizza isn't that bad, but it can be a bit pricey. read more

See all

Tucked away in a corner of the shopping center, but with easy, convenient free parking. The menu covers a wide range of Italian specialty dishes for lunch and dinner. We had slices of pizza, which were hard to choose from so many different toppings and crust styles. They were delicious, obviously freshly made for lunch. The crust was not a thin style, but it was light & toasty. Not greasy at all. There is plenty of seating, booths and counters with stools. The staff was friendly and patient as we tried to decide from the many options. We definitely would come back again on our way to Coney Island. read more

Pizza D'Amore - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The pizza here was tasty. However it needed to be cooked longer as it was kinda soggy. The sauce was good though. Buffalo wings here are spicy so you've been warned. However, pricing here is quite higher than other pizzerias. Not too sure why the heroes and wings here are at least $5 more expensive than other places. read more

Pizza D'Amore - Large Square (Thin Sicilian) Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best square pizza def recommend They even made me a heart shaped square for Valentine's Day :) read more

We used to order from here all the time. Today we found small glass pieces inside the margherita pie!! read more

Pizza D'Amore - Small glass pieces found in the pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I have always seen this place while walking around Caesar bay and never had a chance to try it. Finally decided to buy pizza for my family and came here for the very first time today. Overall, the pizza was pretty good. The slices weren't super thick but it was definitely laden with cheese and the other toppings I had asked for (AND THEY DID IT CORRECTLY THANK YOU T_T - because my family likes plain but i like pepperoni and mushroom so they did half and half with the pie. sometimes, other pizza places do half pepperoni on one side and mushroom on the other and it's just.....sad beucase my family won't eat it ): ). Taste wise, it was great and I definitely would recommend this place. Maybe it'll be my go-to pizza place when I want pizza near home and am unwilling to go to Costco for cheaper slices. read more

Nearly 3 hours for a barely warm pizza that costed 26while I live 10 minutes away from the place is insane and it barely came with any of the toppings I ordered with it, At this point give me an uncooked pizza I'll bake it myself. read more

Ordered takeout on a Friday night with my boyfriend. The workers overcharged us. When my boyfriend asked about the charges, the workers refused and denied overcharging. They insisted they charged us properly and the menu misstated prices. So, my boyfriend asked for a receipt. We waited for a receipt to print. The receipt showed overcharges and after asking 4 times, we got our proper change. The next day, I had diaherra from this place's salad. Now I understand the poor Yelp ratings. Avoid this place. read more

I love ordering from this place! They make a great meatball pie that I think everyone should try. One thing was off with my last order. The buffalo wongsgarlic knots and zeppoles I ordered for a delivery last time I ordered from them were burned, so I couldn't enjoy those which was disappointing. But I'd at least prder pizza from here again. read more

So heres the deal I know pizza. I know pizza real real well, also was in the business. The food is ok not horrible but not great for the same price or less you can eat at casa bella right over there about 10 blocks. The place is the only pizza place in the middle of the shopping center. Ingrendients are cheap, crust is not that great sauce is good. Its a step up from Dominos but not by much. Staff is pleasant Place ia real clean Years ago the food was much better like 15 years ago, maybe new owners The issue Is the prices, the place is a rip off. I could eat at di fara's for that But they have you by the balls because theres nothing there except 5 guys or Wendy's A real rip off. Slice with a topping is 4.50 drinks are 3 bucks And its not even good. If it was good id say fine no problem If your there and starving then ok better off ordering from a real pizzeria like casa bella read more

Two firsts for me tonight. I never leave a bad review and I never fail to tip for delivery. Up until tonight this was my go to place. Now I am done with them. Food arrived an hour late. I was ok with that. Delivery guy calls and tells me I'm not home. I have to come down to lobby to get food. I was ok with that. I get down to lobby had to wait for elevator I'm on 9th floor. Delivery guy gives my order to some guy in the lobby. I had to chase down this guy for my food. Delivery guy does not apologize and gives me an attitude. Food is good but I will not be disrespected and given an attitude over your multiple mess ups. read more

I saw this place and want to give a try but so disappoint because you would like a place to take responsable of how they handle their food, first when I ordered the person and employees weren't wearing a mask and cap, I ordered for take out and for my surprise it comes with hair but the most important thing is that when I called they said our people don't have that kind of hair...So rude and means that I cooked and it's my hair. read more

See all

Wow, Pizza D'Amore is certainly pretty darn cool. Location for this place is ideal. These guys got a great menu as well. Team is extremely pleasant and definitely will help you with anything. Pizza D'Amore, I keep coming back for more. read more

I don't eat cheese so I come in here once in a while to grab garlic knots, zepolis or chicken fingers which are really good, especially the garlic knots with marinara sauce. Tonight I called to pick up the knots and asked them if they can make a plate of grilled chicken for my little fur buddy and asked for minimal or no seasonings. As usual the knots were amazing, but they cut the chicken into tiny pieces for my dog and I found that to be really nice. The workers are also very friendly. I definitely recommend this pizzaria. Great food and great staff who are all smiles which is always a plus. No wonder it's usually packed in here. read more

I've been eating at pizza d'amore for years, a fan of their thin Sicilian slice I've gotten it since I'm a kid with the original owners. But I don't know who's baking now but the last two times I've ordered it the pizza was very very well done. Not burnt but just under. All the cheese and I mean all the cheese was browned and crusted over, the sauce was dried out and the crust overcooked. Very disappointed as a life long customer that the quality has dropped so significantly. I know times are tough during covid but this is when you put your best effort in, and not serve a pizza that's so over cooked you can't eat it. I literally threw it out. read more

This place had quick service and ample tables to eat. 1 of the entrance double doors isnt working. Bathroom is tiny. Make sure to bring your own soap and toilet paper. I ordered a large pepperoni for take-out. Pizza was ok, I definitely had better pizza. The crust sucked. There was little to no sauce on it, but I like my pizzas like that (very little sauce). They do add very generous portions of cheese on it, which I enjoyed. All that aside, I believe the Health Department should take a look at this place. My biggest complaint is that 2 of the food handlers where also handling cash/credit cards. Money is one of the dirtiest, if not the dirtiest thing there is on this earth. I have no idea why they dont have 1-3 people handing orders and 1 person at the cash register. 2 of the guys would grab food with both hands, handle cash, then handle food again without washing their hands. Pathetic.... Luckly for me, the one that made my pizza wasnt handling cash. The person that was handling the bigger orders (delivery and take-out) was a Mexican. This dude looked funny. He looked like a character that came out of the movie Grease. -Minus 5 stars for not handling food properly -Minus 2.5 stars for the pizza -Minus 1.5 stars for not fixing the front door, as posted by another Yelper -Minus .5 star for the Grease looking dude Good job D`Amore, youve earned -9.5 stars. Sadly we cant score you less than 1 star.... read more

I have been going to this pizza joint for many years. Now being a Brooklynite I can't help feeling guilty that I love these deep dish pies so much lol. This pizzeria is located in the shopping center of Caesar's Bay. The restaurant is always clean, the staff is always friendly, helpful, and professional. The owner is always present and still on top of his game. I have tried everything they make in this restaurant. But I find myself ordering the margarita slice more times than not. Sandwiches are good as well as their rolls. Honestly the only thing they need work on are their mozzarella sticks. But it's not bad enough to give this establishment less than 5 stars. They have a good niche and have the deep dish pie down on lock. I will be coming here for many more years to come. read more

Pizza D'Amore - Fresh mozzarella slice. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York