This is my favorite place to eat from great food and great people definitely reccomend been getting from them for years Best pizzeria in brooklyn if you ask me read more

Its without question that I love a good slice of pizza and my Bay Ridge, Brooklyn neighborhood has numerous places where one can find an excellent slice or square, oh pardon me, "Sicilian". I don't think I've ever referred to that as anything outside of "Square" but I digress. Now a few months ago I noticed people all walking around the area eating pizza and checking little lists that they were carrying. This was apparently some kind of "Pizza Wars" competition and I was saddened to be missing out. From the looks of it, the participants were getting the meagerest of bites of pizza from those establishments that were part of the competition. With the FOMO now passed I decided that maybe once a week I would pay a visit to a different local place outside of my usual go to pizzeria. It would not only up the amount of foodie pics on the Instagram but also give me the chance to Yelp and perhaps direct others to what we found. A win win scenario for sure. So my dear friend from the region joined me for a quick pizza lunch and I ordered a slice and a square while my friend only had a single regular slice. Diet Coke and Sprite were the drinks and we sat and chatted to catch up while enjoying this quality offering. Now I can say that there were a ton of different varieties of pizza at Mancini's but I just wanted the regular versions for this visit. The place itself is cozy and the staff very friendly and I will most certainly go back but only after I get some of the other places on my personal list checked off. Mancini's is a high recommendation for those who happen to be nearby or those who can order and have one of the delivery people bring them something. It's important to share this little bit of news as while we ate my friend told me that Mancini's had actually won the Pizza Wars but I wasn't sure which version of their pies won the prize. Apologies for that detail being missing but congratulations to Mancini's on their accomplishment. read more

See all

Finally got the chance to dine in person and it was really wonderful. Very down to earth Brooklyn vibe. We started with a house salad and enjoyed delicious ravioli and perfectly crafted plain and margarita slice. We topped it off with scrumptious tiramisu. All in all a lovely meal at Mancini's. Special shout out to the young lady at the counter who was so very attentive, helpful, and sweet. She's one of those people where she's doing a million things but doesn't let it show. She had such a unique grace and kindness and made us feel so taken care of. Thank you so much! We really appreciated you! read more

See all

If you're in Brooklyn and love pizza, do yourself a favor and head straight to Mancini's Pizza. I was in town for a week and found myself here five out of seven days--that should tell you everything you need to know. The service? Top-notch. The staff are warm, welcoming, and make you feel like part of the family from the moment you walk in. It's that perfect mix of neighborhood spot with genuine hospitality, which makes every visit even better. Now let's talk about the pizza... because WOW. The classics are done right--crispy yet foldable crust, perfectly balanced sauce, and gooey cheese that makes you close your eyes on the first bite. But Mancini's shines with variety, too. I rotated through the white pizza, chicken parm pizza, upside-down Sicilian, pepperoni, and chicken bacon ranch, and honestly, each one had me saying "this is my favorite" until I tried the next. Flavorful, satisfying, and crafted with care--you can taste the love in every slice. The space itself is clean, bright, and inviting, with plenty of seating that makes it ideal for families, groups of friends, or even a solo pizza pilgrimage (which I may or may not have done ). In a city where pizza competition is fierce, Mancini's stands out not just for their food but for the heart they put into it. Safe to say, I'll be back on my next Brooklyn trip--and probably eating here five days again! read more

See all

Sorry to report their delivery this time was very underwhelming. Crust was too dry, meaning not enough sauce and cheese were used to make it! Oh well, lesson learned. Won't be ordering here again!! read more

Mancini's Wood-Fired Pizza - Looks nice; but disappointing to eat, crust was hard & dry. Not enough sauce +/or cheese used! Delivery guy didn't have keep warm bag. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This was the best pizza we had during our trip to NYC! We hit all the tourist spots in Manhattan, went to several "viral" places on TikTok but after a night in Brooklyn this was the best! The service was also amazing, my friend mentioned she wanted a coffee and one of the employees brewed her a fresh pot..us being in the service industry told her she didn't have to do that but she said "why would I not brew it for you? " I felt like I was home but also got a true New York neighborhood experience. read more

See all

Came here on a Wednesday evening for a quick dinner. The customer service at this location is absolutely amazing super friendly and they can make you whatever you want. We sat down by the window and our order was brought out fresh and piping hot. We started with a Margherita and a vodka slice, followed by Buffalo chicken. All were yummy and the vodka was my particular favorite with ample amounts of sauce and a nice cheese pull. The Buffalo chicken had a nice kick to it and all three pizzas had a yummy light crunchy crust. We ordered a Philly cheesesteak hero to share, and this was a bit too cheesy for my liking. At this point we were stuffed and took leftovers wrapped to go. Overall amazing spot and very fresh will definitely be back. read more

Mancini's Wood-Fired Pizza - Buffalo Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We've always enjoyed their Grandma Pie even though it's a bit pricey. I never had an issue until this past Friday night. We ordered a pie at 8pm. Literally 8 mins later we get a call asking for more delivery details as the pizza was already on its way. Doesn't take a rocket scientist to deduce we were not going to receive a freshly cooked pie and as expected the pie was terribly overdone because they gave us a reheated pie with blackened bottom and crusts. Now if any slices were leftover and there were many they couldn't be reheated so essentially I paid more than 30 dollars for 3 slices the rest got thrown out. I won't get setup like that again too many better places in the neighborhood to tolerate this. They lost these 2 customers for good. read more

Customer service, customer service, (Tell the people in the back) customer service. I came here one Saturday afternoon. The service was terrible. I was so disappointed. It was so bad it impacted on how the food tasted. Overall I would not be back. The food was lack luster. read more

OUTSTANDING!!!!! DELICIOUS!!! Generous portions and very kind staff! We order at least 2x a week. read more

Went here after work to get a slice and was very impressed. The ambience of the place is spacious and has a feel of a real Italian pizzeria mixed with a rustic homey feel. A fish tank and nice vintage looking decor on the wall. The service was friendly and attentive. The gentleman behind the counter explained what was in each pie I asked about. I got my 2 slices within 5 min and the price was very fair for the quality you get. I got a grandmas slice and a white slice. The Dough was perfectly crunchy with a great taste and the pizzas were very cheesy and fresh full of flavor. I paid $9 total for 2 authentic fresh gourmet style slices. Definitely highly recommended. read more

Mancini's Wood-Fired Pizza - White slice and grandmas slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Came in here a while ago after a long day of apartment viewings and had the best couple of slices I've had in a very very long time. Crust was fantastic with a great char, great topping ratio (I had pepperoni). Yes it was a bit pricey but for the high quality of ingredients it was definitely worth it. Service is really the difference here too. They are very friendly here, and the one lady in particular was super nice. I had a smile on my face watching her point out the fish to some kids who were staring at the aquarium. And she talked me into taking a slice of homemade tiramisu cheesecake home that was amazing. Definitely making this a go to when I move into the area. read more

I have been to Mancini's a few times since it is one of my favorite places to grab pizza in Brooklyn - it has the perfect crisp to it and the sauce is nice and sweet. I ordered the grandma slice and a pepperoni roll (pinwheel) this time around. Service is really kind and attentive - they brought the food over to our table and cut up our pepperoni roll so it was easier to share and dip into marinara sauce. I saw they have a huge selection of gelato now, which is the perfect! Must try it when I come back. :) read more

See all

Awesome pizza and try the espresso crema drink it's really good. They have an upside down slice that rivals l & b read more

See all

Doesn't matter what you order, the food is always amazing & so is the service. Very accommodating. It can be expensive, but they typically make up for it by giving you large portions or decent sized pieces of bread, etc... I moved to Bay Ridge 2 years ago & was ordering from different pizza spots in the area because I didn't know where to get good pizza from; but once I got put-on to Mancini's, I have never ordered from another spot again. Great food besides pizza read more

Mancini's Wood-Fired Pizza - Large plain Pizza pie - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The food I'd always on the money‼It's not just another Pizza joint, they take great pride in all their offerings. Ambiance Pizzeria! Delivery service always within the time frame, that is given‼ read more

I love a business that stands by their product shortly after my review the owner Frank reached out to me and did apologize for my bad experience was adamant on making it up. He sent over two pies the next day and they were great. Perfectly well done, great flavor, and taste. Both pies were delicious but the winner by a small margin was the original pie. They have definitely won my continued business going forward and I will be ordering from here again. 4.5 stars read more

Mancini's Wood-Fired Pizza - Original pizza pie - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

In a world where good customer service is dying, Mancini's is keeping it going! I've been here multiple times, and the pizza is always fresh, perfectly cooked, and full of flavor. Every single dish I've ordered has been absolutely amazing & the portion size great. I can't say enough about the staff--every time I visit, they're so welcoming and friendly, even when it's busy, and even when taking your order on the phone. Delivery is fast & the delivery person is pleasant! I've never had a bad experience--highly recommend this place! read more

Asked for large pie, extra sauce , which he repeated , and I added pepperoni. Picked it up. No extra sauce. In fact , who makes a pizza with less sauce than normal. Won't go back. read more

I love Mancini's Pizza I was there the other day for the first time. I am from Brooklyn New York visiting from LA and the food was absolutely delicious they have 20 different types of pizza"s also meatball sandwiches lasagna spaghetti with meatballs I highly recommend this place to anybody who is in Brooklyn NYC Sunset Park Bayridge area I must stop in place. read more

See all

Used to be a great place for pizza - I used to take out personal pizza and used to be great. However lately the pizza seemed to be warmed up not made at that moment - There is no point to buy a pie if it is not prepared at the moment - if you want just warmed up pizza you go with the slice. Another issue they lately hiked prices They hike prices the wrong time when most people are tired of price hikes read more

Been coming here for three years and it's still my go-to. The Prosciutto Arugula pizza is outstanding. Wood-fired crust, fresh toppings, perfect every time. Service is always friendly and on point. Highly recommend! read more

Still the BEST cheese slice in Brooklyn- delicious! This time I tried buffalo chicken slice and chicken parm. The buffalo sauce was very hot! I normally eat mild wings, so it was quite an experience. The customer service is outstanding. Even the customers were friendly waiting at the counter. They were recommending their favorite slices. Mancini's is not just a pizza place/ it has a full menu with entrees, appetizers, salads. The decor is beautiful read more

See all

I'm always reluctant to order pizza from a new place. Will their sauce taste sweet? Acidic? Will they be stingy with the cheese? When I ask for "Well Done", will they know what I'm asking for? But I still haven't found "My Pizza Shop". Definitely found some good ones but not THE one. So, I'm still looking... And this time, I tried Mancini's Wood-Fired Pizza. I ordered a Large Pie, well done, with 8 garlic knots. I received a Large Pie (not well done but done enough) and 8 garlic knots. The Pizza was... transcendent. The cheese was abundant; Almost as though I had ordered extra cheese. Sooo yummy. The sauce was on point; Not sweet, savory, no acidity discernible on the pallet. Crust was crispy, but slice was slightly floppy - I don't shame them for it. The knots were mezza mezza. They were flavorful but missed something; Could have used an extra schmeer of garlic/butter/olive oil. Overall, I'll definitely order from Mancini's again. read more

Mancini's Wood-Fired Pizza - One slice & one knot - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We had a delicious. Burrata pie Prompt and friendly service Finished off with great gelato. read more

I go here way too often. But it's worth it every time! That's why I keep coming back. The workers are so nice, they even remember my order. The food is great esp the pasta meals. I usually get the chicken parm with penne alla vodka (instead of the bread, I ask for garlic knots) or keep it simple with pizza. But the best part about the pizza is they have beef pepperoni if you ask! The hot honey slice is everythingggg. You can also dine in here. It has a family atmosphere but unfortunately I've come a few times when the kids in the neighborhood were there, being slightly inappropriate and one of the workers saw I was about to leave and asked them to leave instead since they weren't eating. I appreciate that they cared about me enjoying my experience in the restaurant. read more

food was exceptionally phenomenal and the service is by far the best I have experienced in quite some time, will most definitely be coming back. read more

Delicious and fresh. Took awhile to get our food delivered but we did order like 15 pies lol.

Really good pizza, full of cheese and nice crust on edges too. We ordered 1/2 pepperoni & 1/2 margarita topping to go, ate it right in the car since it's fresh off the oven. Would give it 5 stars had the crust being slightly crunchier! Nevertheless, would rate this place one of the best in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn! read more

We love this place! Our family orders pizza from here all the time, and it's hands down our favorite. The pizza is always delicious and made just right. Once you try it, it'll be your go-to too! read more

I had such a great experience at Mancini's thanks to one of the staff members who went above and beyond! A lovely lady took such good care of us me and my daughter. she was warm, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed without me even having to ask. Her kindness and professionalism made the whole visit memorable. You can really tell she cares about her work and the people she serves. The food was great too, but her service was the highlight of our visit. She deserves recognition -- I'll definitely be coming back because of her! read more

Great pizza place in Bay Ridge. Workers are all friendly. Pizza tastes great especially the vegetable pizza that is full of all different types of veggies. Lots of tables so that you can sit down and eat if you like. Highly recommend if you are around the area. read more

OK... I'm late to the party, but please don't judge me, lol. Let's talk about Mancini's. I just ordered a chicken Parm hero with vodka sauce. This was the best chicken Parm hero with vodka sauce that I've ever had and I've had my share. If that wasn't enough, the energy that the staff has with the customers is a sight to behold. While I was waiting for my food, one of the customers told Elaina (sp?) how awesome she is. And I have to agree. Her energy is so positive that it makes you want to keep coming back. I order chicken Parm hero's with vodka sauce regularly from another place. Guess what? That other place just lost a customer. Thank you Mancini's! read more

Good pizza! I've never had a bad slice of any type. Chicken Caesar is currently my fav. A good-looking pizzeria, a great place to sit and eat on-the-quick. Free advice for the owner: get rid of the fish tank or keep it crystal clear, not swampy. read more

The place is kept clean and neat. The pizza has the prefect crust. Lots of seating space and great spot to have lunch and dinner. Definitely recommend this place. read more

Another Bay Ridge slice shop (okay, they do more than pizza here), and I confess, while I had high hopes for this pizza, I am walking away rather disappointed. Later in the night, it was more upsetting that none of my meal stayed down. As a result, I go back to my rule of thumb. If the food does not stay down, my rating goes down. The slices, huge as they are, do not overwhelm me in other ways. Mediocre in taste, too globby, and floppy. The only thing that I did like about the slices, the crust, is not enough to make me want to get more pizza here. It is a shame because this is a shop that defines Brooklyn, with its old school employees that resonate from a different era. Speaking of which, as I ate my dinner, the music playing overhead was of the tunes I remember well from my time in junior high. Coincidentally enough, this is what this pizza reminds me of. The pizza I ate when I was 13-15 years old. A junior high slice. It has a nice ring to it, no? read more

Mancini's Wood-Fired Pizza - Plain, Margherita, White slices. Just like the old days. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

the best pizza in the world, served by the kindest people you can ever meet, all day, every day......highly recommend their homemade chicken soup. read more

We Loved it pizza was amazing and plenty of flavor 10:10 our server was great our server payed special attention to Our kids and kept them entertained . read more

Best Buffalo Chicken pizza out there, but make sure to get it right out of the oven. I had big expectations for the Cheesesteak calzone. It was gigantic I'll say that, but was a little disappointed. I would recommend they switch to steak slices instead of what seems like ground beef. Overall, very good. read more

Mancini's Wood-Fired Pizza - Philly Cheesesteak Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This place is amazing I ordered the margarita pie which was excellent. I also got the penne alla vodka and the container size could feed a family of 5 but it was so good I finished it by myself. 5 stars read more