Absolutely adore Pegasus Pizza! The Tom's special is my favorite! I wish there were more locations! The service went above and beyond. The restaurant is clean and not too loud so you can hold a conversation without yelling. We will definitely be back! read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Tom's House (Toms) Special - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Great place! The foods look amazing and it has a huge menu! Nice friendly staff! And is open on Sundays during the West Seattle Farmer's Market so you can come in and sit and enjoy a nice meal! I happen to be there when they had a professional photographer come in and shoot pics of many of the menu items, they all look delisious! Give it try! read more

See all

A friend and I decided we wanted pizza while in West Seattle and went to Pegasus over the weekend. I have not been to Pegasus pizza for several years, so I had not been to the current location before. I will say, I like the former location much better as far as ambiance. The service was great - we were seated right away and our server was attentive and friendly. We started with Caesar salads and meatballs for an appetizer. The meatballs were good and the sauce was nice as well - it didn't taste like it was canned sauce. The salad was fresh and the dressing used was not overpowering, which can happen with a Caesar salad. The garlic bread was just okay - a little crusty/hard for our preference, but the amount of garlic used was good. We split a pizza with half vegetarian/half meat toppings. The pizza was fantastic! The crust was perfect and it tasted wonderful. All in all, we enjoyed our meal here and both agreed we would come back. Side note: The pizza tasted just as good warmed up (oven, NOT microwave) the next day. read more

See all

You have to try PEGASUS PIZZA! I love their Gourmet . Pizzas! They have such a wide variety of yummy dishes! The pizzas, pastas, salads, and sandwiches are amazing! They are tasty and delicious! I have also used their delivery service. The food arrived, hot and on time! I highly recommend PEGASUS in West Seattle! You will not be disappointed! read more

The Greek Pizza is my favorite - and my Birthday dinner always! Sadly, they're harder to get to since moving to the Junction area. Parking is difficult. read more

Please know this review is just an about a flavor preference for me. I was excited to try this place since they were on Alki, just never got around to it. I heard they have good pizza and even have sunflower seeds as a topping (I found that intriguing). My family and I stopped by for dinner recently and I got the Pegasus special (with Sunflower seeds). We did not care for it: we wanted more sauce because it just seemed extremely dry. That being said, you may enjoy it. It's got a nice ambiance and the service was good. read more

I absolutely love this restaurant! I give Pegasus Pizza West Seattle 10 out of 10. Their food is delicious and fresh. Their service is top notch and the ambience is perfect for any occasion. If you are in the West Seattle area make sure to stop by! read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Best pizza I have had. We had pepperoni inside pizza then cheese on top followed by crispy pepperoni pieces on top. The best. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

The meatball subs and cheese bread were amazing!!! The happy hour deals are great too and everything is fairly priced for Seattle. Really nice service and super cozy ambience. Will be returning! read more

I stopped in at Pegasus on a recent warm summer day to have lunch with my nieces before a play date at Alki Beach. In these days of covid, and especially with a couple of young ones along, I was a little nervous about sitting indoors (all of their outdoor seats were filled) but Pegasus did it right. All of the employees were masked and the tables were spaced far apart. Masks were required of all customers when not at the table. I felt much more at ease with these protocols in place. But enough with the scary stuff...let's get to the food! Pegasus has a varied menu of Italian-themed options, salads and (of course) pizza. My nieces ordered simpler items (shoutout to being a kid again and only liking cheese pizza!) and I got the Greek Salad. My salad was delicious! I'm glad I only got the half portion because I could barely finish it. It was loaded with all the things that make a Greek salad so delicious (olives, tomatoes, cukes...) and also had shrimp on it which made it just that much tastier. My nieces also enjoyed their pizza and breadstick lunches. The service was friendly, though I think our server was a little harried with an unexpectedly large mid-day lunch crowd. Still, we were treated well and I'm always appreciative of a kid-friendly space. Next time I'll try their pizza (and maybe a cocktail too)! read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Greek salad. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Go here if you want Olive Garden, without actually going to olive garden. We both got the pasta (not pizza so I can't vouch for that). But maybe don't get the pasta--it's fine, nothing special read more

Best pizza in West Seattle! I love the view of Alki Beach out the windows, and the staff on the inside aren't so bad to look at either, especially the little itali read more

I ordered a pizza to go. It was ready quick and no problem. When I got it home it was soggy on the bottom....like greasy Domino's gross. The pieces were literally falling apart when you tried to take them out of the box because they were almost soggy on the bottom. I called and asked for a refund because at this point, it was supposed to be dinner and we didn't have time to wait for another one. The manager, then informed me, that he cannot do a refund. He stated he didn't know how to do one, but would give me a credit back to the restaurant. Why would I want that? I told him this isn't the first time (and in good faith, I wanted to give them another chance) and I was done. He then told me I needed to call someone else --- who doesn't work there or even lives in the state of WA who could possibly help me? You're the manager of the restaurant. How do you not know how to offer a refund? read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - The bottom of the pizza was totally soggy with grease. It was so gross. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

We had take out for a company lunch and the pizza, pasta, and salads were excellent. Will have to try in restaurant in the near future.

Service as great when I did an order pick up. The food was okay, I ordered the wings and 2 slices. The sauce was good but the wings looked like they boiled them in water and then added the sauce. My pizza came out a bit burnt and hard in the middle. The out crust was really soft and tasty which was weird. read more

ordered ravoli with garlic bread and meatballs on the side. the 3 cheese ravoli was very good with alfredo sauce. the meat sauce and meatballs were very plain, not much flavor at all. the garlic bread has very little garlic flavor at all. we had delivery and it correct and very quick. read more

I don't know what the hell happened tonight but our server should probably find a new job because serving is not for him. Who tells the table they've only been here for two weeks and still don't know the menu? Like you shouldn't even be on the floor on your own. Dude literally stood on the floor half the time looking lost. I ordered wings, artichoke dip, small caesar, ice tea, and a pizza. Waited for my iced tea as my boyfriend got his beer. It never came. Thankfully another server brought us waters. 20 min passed by and still no salad, but the table behind us who got sat after us definitely got their appetizer and salads before us???? Asked a nearby server about it and she went and got our pizza instead.... Our server came up to us after seeing our faces and blamed the missing appetizers and salad on blamed it on the kitchen. After eating, my boyfriend goes to the bathroom and the server comes up to us with his arms crossed and asked if I ever got my iced tea. I was in disbelief and uncomfortable at this point. He then proceeded to say "wow I really messed up your order, I've only been here a week sorry". Like what? WHAT??? I couldn't help myself at this point, I looked at him and said "I thought you said the kitchen messed it up. I also thought you said you've been here for two weeks, not one?" He walked away and didn't say anything, arms still crossed. Service was 0 stars but Im bumping this review to 3 because there was a nearby server named Cesar who helped us out more in 5 min than our original server. He knew exactly what we were experiencing and tried to diffuse the situation. MANAGEMENT: stop making these servers pool their tips so that the few good servers you have don't get punished. Train your servers to use proper lingo so that they don't look like idiots to their tables. read more

Delicious food, great service & ambiance. Highly recommend them. We shared a Hercules pizza & the Penne Rose pasta dinner. The balsamic vinegarette was so good on a fresh, crisp salad. Yum! We'll be back! read more

Cute little place on alki that I come to about once a year for the Tom's special pizza. If I didn't know the Tom's special was so good, I'd never order it but it was recommend to me and I've been coming back for it ever since. The shredded pepperoni on top is so good! I went here yesterday though and was very disappointed with the salad, which was drenched in dressing so much so that there was a large puddle at the bottom, see my photo. The service was also nonexistent, we were seated quickly but then forgot about. We sat waiting for someone to come take our order 10, 20, 30 minutes and eventually went in to ask for someone. We got our food, but they then proceeded to forget about the beer my boyfriend had ordered and never brought it and never came around to check how we were doing. Overall, the Tom's special is still great but it seems everything else here is going downhill. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Pegasus has always been an absolute favorite of mine. I worked there years ago at Alki location so I got to try the whole menu over time. The toms special is the pizza choice for sure! The way they do the pepperoni sliced up is to die for. Feta bread with marinara and meatballs can't go wrong! Salads are fresh and dressings are to scrumptious! Definitely try this spot for lunch or dinner! read more

Pizza here is good. I had the Pegasus Special, #23, and #29 off the menu, as well as the lasagna. I like the BBQ Chicken one the most, because I like the taste of BBQ sauce. All the toppings on each pizza went well together. Crust is crispy. Alki in the summer is a bustling, especially when the sun is out. I'm glad I stopped in to get some food here. I enjoyed my meal. The menu doesn't seem too expensive, considering that it's on Alki. read more

Quickly seated but long wait to order and receive food and drinks. Salads came out before drinks. Drinks came out staggered. Pasta was fine, but I would equate it to something you could make at home with dry pasta noodles and jarred sauce. (We had the alfredo with chicken so maybe the others are better.) Flavorless cubes of chicken and very little for the upcharge ($5.50). Bread came out after the salad and pasta, which also had little flavor. No fresh pepper or parmesan available, only the powdered kind that stays on the table. Took awhile to get the check. Prices on the check were different than listed on the menu. Had items on our check that we didn't order which were quickly removed. Friendly service, but unfortunately would not visit again. read more

The Pizza and Salad were amazing and I expect I will be coming here again. The Pizza is extremely pricey but I do think it's worth it for special occasions. The reason for the three stars is that kid working the register. He was fantastically terrible, not friendly, and had this conceded-ness to him. If working the register is too much for him, let him do something in back like washing dishes so he doesn't have to interact with people. Just a thought. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - The Pizza was amazing. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I contacted Pegasus Pizza both via email and through their FB page about making a reservation (see screen shot of FB response) for my dad's 79th birthday. The response to "Do you take reservations?" being "Absolutely" led me to believe they do take reservations and that I had made one. When our group of 11 showed up we were met by a young man who informed me they never take reservations and when shown the FB communication told me he doesn't run that page -- the wait to seat 11 would be an hour. When inquiring about reservations I would have preferred an honest reply of "I am sorry, Pegasus does not take reservations" which would have allowed me to make reservations at a restaurant capable of hosting 11 people for a birthday party. Poor and dishonest customer service. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I am a pizza fanatic. It's the perfect meal--it has your carbs, fats, protein, and veggies all in one! One of my favorite pizza places in all of Seattle is Pegasus Pizza. The pizzas are heavy with browned, melty cheese. The browning of the cheese is always to perfection. I also make sure to get extra sauce because that is my favorite part of a pizza. Pegasus has been running a 20% Off Special lately (Code: Alki) and my partner and I decided to grab an order. I had my typical Mushroom and Salami on one half, my partner had his ham and pineapple on the other. Perfect as always. Pegasus never fails to deliver! If you are in Seattle, especially West Seattle, and are looking to support a wonderful, local small business that is a staple of the neighborhood, think about grabbing a pizza from Pegasus. I cannot recommend it enough. Accessibility : Gluten Free Pizza available. Online Ordering Available. No delivery, only take-out. read more

See all

I had a pizza Togo from here before and full transparency, maybe it was the different toppings we ordered, but today ain't it. My friends and I went to this restaurant with the assumption that they had bottomless mimosas because 1) It's on the website and 2) well it's on the menu. We asked the server when they got rid of it and he unconfidently said a week ago. Didn't argue but that's frustrating. Cross it out of the menu. We ordered the chipotle chicken pizza and the flavor was lacking. Another reviewer mentioned heavy cheese and yes it is true. However, that did not compensate for the lack of flavor in this pizza. The cheese garlic bread was great but also that's difficult to mess up. This two star rating was only helped by this bread. If you don't mind flies flying around indoors, not bottomless mimosas, below average pizza, this is your place. Please reconsider, West Seattle has better pizza spots. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

great scenery because it's across from the water, but that was probably the best part of my visit here. i came here on a saturday afternoon to get drinks and food with some friends. the waitress was super friendly & accommodating so shout-out to her!!! i started with a cucumber cooler which was DELICIOUS! super calm not too much going on & perfect for a chill saturday afternoon. we then shared the italian chef salad, pretty good n not too salty definitely hit all the right flavors. half salad were also pretty big portions so their good to share with friends. solid 3/5 for the salad it was good but nothing too special!! the pizza was the disappointing part, we waited 45+ minutes for our pizzas & it was pretty frustrating seeing people get their food before us when we were there long before them! anyways, pizza came out it wasn't extremely hot pretty luke warm & underwhelming i guess it just sucked waiting as long as we did. we ordered half shrimp, mushrooms + green onions n half chipotle chicken. underwhelming. not sure if i'll come here again. food is expensive, mediocre & from my experience not very hot coming out. scenery is great though!! read more

See all

Great location at Alki Beach with outdoor seating and waterfront view. The staff is super friendly, and the bartender is fun. If you give her the go ahead, she'll make up a drink for you. I had a version of a French 75 that was great. I think the highlight of the pizza here is the shredded pepperoni which is fantastic if you like it crispy almost to a well done bacon characteristic. I loved the pepperoni! The pizza was good. I would like a choice option in crust because I am starting to really like thin crust, and Pegasus is a little bit thicker but soft crust and still good. We had the Tom special which had several toppings including feta cheese. Definitely a repeat visit for me. read more

See all

Pizza hits the spot had to go back just for their veggie pizza. My kids annoyed their spaghetti and the husband enjoyed their pasta! DELICIOUS written all over! Mahalo nui loa staff until we fly back again! And for the staff that decided to dance with my daughter! I truly appreciate you! Great experience with you all! read more

Toms special is the. Best. Pizza I have ever had. I have had NY pizza in. Brooklyn and deep dish in Chicago that were fantastic and they were.. more the perfect version of the traditional incarnation jog when a pizza should be Toms is. creative with sunflower seeds and the pepperoni chopped fine on top baked to be crusty and chewy. Cut into skinny slices with plenty of stringy cheese under. Mmmmm A treat for your. Whole mouth. read more

Nope. Our visit started with the young kid at the host counter telling us to just "sit down". Did not direct us to a table just, "sit down." We found a table and he followed. Our server had about as much ambition as a sloth.We ordered a couple house salads with Italian dressing, garlic bread, fettuccine Alfredo, and manicotti. The server returned with the salads/dressing. Absolutely no flavor in the dressing whatsoever. The garlic bread was not toasted. After a short time, our pasta dishes arrived (surprisingly fast for pasta). The fettuccine Alfredo was liked by my kids, but my manicotti had to be the absolute worst I've ever tasted. The pasta sauce was flavorless, and the dish lacked garlic, and flavor in general. As we were eating, we noticed two other tables that were being ignored by our waiter. Ours was the same. Not sure what was occupying his time, but it was not his customers. Eventually, when we finished eating, I looked around and still saw no sign of him. I ended up walking to the bar and asked the bartender if there were any adults working in the place. She asked what the issue was, and I explained we hadn't seen our waiter in 20 minutes or more. She acknowledged that she understood that he obviously was an under-performer. I paid the tab and gave him the tip he deserved; nothing. While we did not make it known that it was my daughter's birthday, it was, and we had hoped for a much better experience. This was obviously not the place for the celebration, or even for a bite to eat. read more

I thought the service was really great! I've only been here twice but this time it was really a nice time. I had such a nice meal. I got three small pizzas (house, pegasus, and hawaiian) and they were all really good. We got served when there was only one waiter, but he was super competent and we didn't feel like we were neglected even though there was only one person to serve us. He was very quick about everything and always apologized if he was late for things. I didn't get his name, but I think he was the manager maybe?? Anyway, this place has good food and good service (that's I've seen) read more

Fun cute 80's music https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ylrfJ5bL-r4 Ambiance and more Importantly: Legitimate Out Door Open Air seating, that's appropriately mindful of social distancing in terms of the sidewalk and other tables with other patrons etc.... Cadillac Margarita, open tell approx 9:30 during Covid-19 phases etc.... Ps Joke: It's fun, creative, artistic etc... In places like Vegas and Specialty restaurants when the bartenders light up the drinks on fire! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1G1-DuIoNvY The pictures are intended to be a suto implied improvisational substitute during Covid-19, tribute to that lack of live performance art concept etc..... Cheers to Pegasus Pizza for providing a great place in the community to be able to enjoy legitimate, mindful classy and Warm Outdoor dining: Quality place for a Quality drink after work! read more

See all

Coming from someone that works In the food industry, I love this place. Service was great, host was genuine and pleased to see us; as our "young blood" waiter was also in a great mood and seemed like he enjoyed being a part of such a great restaurant. That was just the service. The food was fantastic. My lady and I were initially stopping for a quick bite, which then turned into the best pizza and margarita I've had since moving to Washington. If you're in the area, stop by! Highly recommend, and will be returning in the near future. Also great views! read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Yummy - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I came here Sunday during the Seahawks game and it was surprisingly pretty empty. Maybe 2 tables taken and the bar stools full (8 or so people). We picked a table in front of the big screen that was playing the hawks game. The hanging lights above each table blocked a little of the view but no big deal. We ordered off the lunch menu which goes until 4pm and then happy hour 3-6 so it overlapped for a little but unfortunately there's no Wells drinks on happy hour. Started off with 6 buffalo wings and they came out hot and were good. I ordered cheese ravioli with a mix of their marinara and Alfredo sauce, it comes with bread and a salad. Came out on the colder side so I asked her to microwave it a bit and it came back perfect temp. Pizza was good as well but a little too much cheese for me, I only had one bite though. Our waitress was extremely nice. I would come back. read more

See all

I order the Chicken and Mushroom White Spaghetti Best pasta ever, everything was good and delicious. Good environment and service was excellent. I recommend this restaurant if you are looking for a Italian restaurant. Pegasus it's the one. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Chicken and Mushroom White Spaghetti - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Was way underwhelmed with this place. We ordered the clams, chicken fettuccine Alfredo, the penne, and the white spaghetti. Clams were delicious, they came with a delicious pesto sauce and had tomatoes, definitely recommend this. Chicken fettuccine Alfredo, I recommend just the fettuccine Alfredo. The sauce was 10/10, so so good. The chicken was super dry and tough, and would recommend the plain fettuccine Alfredo without chicken. White spaghetti was so-so. It was bland, but that's to be imagined with white spaghetti. Noodles were really dry, cheese was clumpy. Penne was decent, but again the chicken was super dry and tough. Spent almost $80 here and definitely not worth the money. read more

Great pizza, but I have trouble with one of the hostesses who can never get my order correct because she doesn't know the whole menu. In my second time ordering the pizza (first time by phone), I thought I'd be good with describing the pizza because I couldn't remember the name. I specified that it had artichoke. But I ended up confused and eventually agreed to the pizza she believed to be the right one (which didn't even have artichoke, a unique and easily identifiable ingredient IMHO). I ended up taking home a different pizza than what I wanted (It was good, but that's an extra star for the company and kitchen staff.). Third time, I specified clearly that the pizza I wanted was an item on the white insert inside of the full menu. I was disconnected because that same hostess took too long asking the kitchen staff if the pizza was still "available." I called back and ordered with another hostess. When I went to pick up, I wanted to point out the menu item to the hostess I continue to have issues with so that there would be no confusion in the future. I ended up settling with one of her coworkers and hoped they would mention this with her at another time. Fourth time, I figured I had all the kinks worked out that somebody on their first day could find the pizza that I wanted to order. NOPE. Same hostess, same "availability" issue. But this time, I was able to speak with her and she said it'll never happen again. We'll see. For now, all I have are three less than satisfactory experiences that could have easily been remedied by an employee learning the simple menu offerings. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - All day Specials - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Let me start by saying Yummy yummy yummy! The ambience and the service was outstanding. The shredded pepperoni pizza was delicious and got a half size Caesar salad which fed 4 of us! So good, so bomb and worth the visit. Thank you Pegasus read more

Service was good. Got the Pegasus Special which was great. Their prices have gone up but you get plenty of toppings and cheese. Would not get the Shrimp Salad again as we both didn't feel well right after we left. read more

Pegasus Pizza West Seattle - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all