First, let me start saying that the pasta was delicious! I would rate that at a 4.5 however. I ordered pizza this time and the pizza was very very thin almost like a cracker crust not at all what I expected out of an Italian restaurant. I didn't like it at all, so therefore, I would rate that at a one. Staff and service was excellent. read more

Today is the first day they are back open after 2 weeks doing a renovation and could not be happier. I think the renovation is a bit underwhelming but the food and service could not have been better. Lauren could be one of the best wait person I have ever had. She was absolutely awesome and I hope you manager appreciates her. The food was delicious as always but am curious why the chicken piccata is only available on the lunch specials menu. It was Devine. It needs to be on offer at all times. read more

This is the second location that we've been to. Our first experience was a Moab and I would say it's pretty comparable. We were seated promptly even though it's in a busy location with lots of guests. The staff was quick and friendly and the food is decent. It might be a tad overpriced for the quality but not the quantity. We did order an appetizer and it did come out, unfortunately at the same time as our entrées so we didn't get that full experience, but sometimes that happens. The best thing in our table was the lobster ravioli, which was the feature that day. Boulder has a lot of really good options for food, but we would likely go back considering it's location. read more

Food good Location cool Service at door, NOT good!! I was here for work, looked at this to try out! I love Italian food, I live in South Florida, and there's plenty of it Very cold outside stepped in the door and the Young way at the front door if you could sit on the table in the window. She said it's not available yet, but will let you know we'll get it ready for you. Eight minutes later noticed another couple going to sit at the table as the young lady what happened she could only apologize and say she made a mistake after us sitting there, and having a full blown conversation about having that specific seat because we wanna look outside while we eat to take in everything of this surroundings!! She should have moved the other patrons, sadly put us in a corner looking at stairs. Food: Garlic knots - soft and oily! Needs more cook time for little crunch. I LOOK for good knots! Chicken parm: decent with a small sweet sauce and spicer kick in the end. Our waitress was best part and understood the issue about our seating. Kindly offered us dessert on them. 7 score for food 8.5 our waitress! Great and on point!! 3 for the young lady who did not follow the seating rules for customers! read more

Pasta Jay's - Knots! - Italian Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

OUTSTANDING! In so many ways. We started with spinach artichoke dip and it was the best I have ever had! Then for entrees we got Brisket Mac N Cheese and Pasta Carolena. I chose to get my dish without an added protein and it was plenty! They give you WHOLE mushrooms and huge artichokes! The sauce is like no other! The Brisket Mac came with entire slabs of brisket on it and a delicious homemade cheese sauce. The bread with the entrees and the appetizer were both heavenly. I love the entire decor and atmosphere of the place, and the staff were all friendly and wearing their smiles through our whole visit! If you are in Boulder and looking for a nice spot for supper that is high quality without breaking the bank that is accompanied by a great experience- THIS IS YOUR SPOT. Check out their specials too! read more

Pasta Jay's - Pasta Carolena - Italian Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

Great weekday lunch experience. The entire restaurant was open to outdoors on a gorgeous September day. Food portions are large even for lunch. Service was good (and they weren't very busy). Will be going back for dinner. read more

See all

Great menu that lets you try multiple different types of pasta. My dish bordered on burned. Friendly and fast service. Tables are very close together. read more

Pasta Jay's - The Hagan Option - Italian Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Very cute and cool ambiance! We came here for lunch during our trip to Boulder after a recommendation from a friend. My mouth is watering just thinking of the garlic bread and pasta with marinara sauce. Our waitress was kind and attentive. The outdoor patio seating was ample and they had heaters conveniently above us as the weather is starting to cool down. I love that the prices were affordable too after dining at a bougie restaurant the night before. All pasta lovers should add this place to their list! read more

Pasta Jay's - Margherita pizza - Italian Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

My family and I came here on a Saturday night around 5pm and were seated right away. By the time we left, people were waiting to be seated. The portions are so huge that we had some leftovers. I got the Georgio Bolognese and it was very delicious. The sauce was a little spicy which I wasn't expecting but good thing I like spicy foods. My brother got the Alfredo Williams. I tried it and thought the Alfredo was too rich. The chicken was nice and crispy. My mom got one of the Saturday specials, Seafood Cannelloni, and liked it. All of the pasta entrees come with garlic bread. It comes before the entree which I wasn't expecting. It was just ok. If you want extra garlic bread, it's $5. The water cups are so small, the waitress kept having to come back. At first, I was waiting for water for a while. We ordered some of the chocolate layered cake & tiramisu to go. They weren't that good and were expensive for the size of the dessert. The cake was dry. I would come back for the pasta if I were to visit the area again. read more

See all

Excellent food, great service and a really neat atmosphere. Waitress was on top of things but seemed to have a lot of tables which made service a little slow but it's a neat place to enjoy. read more

Pasta Jay's - Ravioli Josephina - Italian Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Ambience and service perfect. Wide selection of classic Italian. Everyone on group raved about their food Would not hesitate to come back when in town. read more

Some of the best to Italian food in Boulder, hands down I've been coming to pasta Jay's occasionally for the last 40 years. Fabulous food, great garlicky marinara sauce. The trickiest thing downtown Boulder is parking. read more

Places like this that serve decadently large portions are part of the reason Americans are obese. The food is decent, but it's incredibly wasteful. read more

I LOVED this place!! The pasta and wine were great, the interior was cute and the service was good. Highly recommend the Buffalo Ravioli! read more

Pasta Jay's - Italian Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

We loved this place. Stumbled across this on Christmas Eve, straight out of a hallmark movie. Friendly staff. Great way to spend our evening. The beef rigatoni was very delightful. The ambiance is delightful, super vibe city in there. read more

Pasta Jay's - super cute festive dining area - Italian Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

Visiting Boulder for a CU football game game, Pasta Jay's was recommended by some friends. If you get the right table near the window you'll get an amazing peekaboo view of the mountains, Awesome! Very friendly and attentive service for this quaint Italian pizza and past joint with reasonable prices and a variety of options. Caesar Salad was okay. The Seafood Stuffed Shells was an amazing special recommended by waitress. The Orgy Pizza was thin traditional crust with fresh toppings and really good as well. Baked Rigatoni was lackluster, a bit over cooked and could have had more cheeses and meat. The gelato from a gelato joint nearby was amazing. Overall we loved it. read more

See all

Got lucky with parking, so our experience was already off to a great start! Since the restaurant wasn't that busy when we arrived (after the lunch rush,) we were seated right away. I ordered from the lunch menu--chicken piccata--while my dining companions ordered from the specials menu, listed on the chalkboard. Shortly after ordering, the complimentary garlic bread was brought to our table, and it was just as good as the Yelp reviews had said. Although I will say, it could've been a bit less crispy--just a personal preference. When the food arrived, my first impression was that the portions were huge. This is a good thing, so please don't change anything! Presentation was also nice and the aroma was just so heavenly. We absolutely loved our meals, but ended up having to take some food to go. Service was good, but we felt like we were also kind of being ignored by our server once larger parties started filing in. At least we didn't have to flag someone down to pay the tab though. For the quality and quantity, I'd say the cost is very reasonable. Definitely worth another visit. read more

Pasta Jay's - Italian Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

Was it 5 years since my last visit? Nothing has changed except a nice happy hour! Great '50's music, sidewalk cafe, and good service from Kaili! read more

See all

Passing thru Boulder and looked at a bunch of food spots before deciding on Pasta Jays... we ordered meatballs and Brussels sprouts for an appetizer and the waitress brought out only the meatballs that were absolutely delicious but unfortunately they were raw in the middle.. Instant regret happened and as they dropped the food at the table we paid the bill and took the rest of the food to go. Waitress never asked why or if we had a problem she was happy to see us leave. I was disappointed because the flavor was amazing but raw meat is a no go for me. read more

Oh my gosh was it good! I am a pasta lover but some might say a picky pasta lover. I was amazed at the food. The pasta was hot and the menu had so many options. Out waitress was also the SWEETEST girl ever. The service was outstanding because he was so kind and attentive and gave us all the advice on the menu. The place is also so cute! read more

See all

Being a Boulder Native, I have eaten at Pasta Jay's for an incredibly long time and have always loved them as a tried and true staple in Boulder. We recently used Pasta Jay's Catering for the first time to cater a large event we were hosting (80 people) that had incredibly tight time constraints to feed everyone and the team was flawless. From the coordination in the weeks leading up to our event where I was able to easily communicate with our coordinator Jackie, who helped create a menu that was perfect; to the day of where everything was ready to rock and roll at 10:30am (we had to have everything ready to serve at noon) for us to pick it up. We elected to pick it up because of access and location, but they did have an option for us to utilize their team for delivery, set up and service (as well as break down). I have used caterers quite a bit for everything from professional events to personal gatherings and this was by far the most easy with some of the best food! They even (without asking) made sure to be mindful of those with dietary needs and provided a pan of vegan & gluten free pasta, and gave us info about allergens in the other items we provided. All in all, not only will we use them again, but I will refer their catering program to anyone and everyone! Thanks Pasta Jay's!!! read more

My mom and I wanted a ~festive~ meal to cap off our day of holiday shopping in Boulder, and Pasta Jay's turned out to be the perfect choice! With red tablecloths and Christmas decorations, it offered exactly the cozy and cheerful vibe we were hoping for. We didn't have a reservation so we had a bit of a wait, but the staff invited us to sit at the bar and enjoy a discounted "welcome drink" (wine or beer), which was a fun way to kick off the meal. About 25 minutes later, we were seated. The waitress was kind and patient as we put off ordering a couple of times. When our plates arrived, they were saucy, cheesy, bready, warm, and delicious--just the way we like our red sauce Italian food. We started with the baked burrata, recommended by our waitress. For our entrees, we chose chicken Parmesan and stuffed shells, both of which were incredibly satisfying. I paired my meal with a Cabernet, which was the perfect touch. By the end of our meal, we were absolutely stuffed, but luckily we had a walk down Pearl Street to get back to our car and work off a little of our indulgence. We really wanted to take home a jar of their sauce, but unfortunately, we forgot. Nonetheless, we told everyone in the family about our wonderful meal and will definitely return on one of our next trips to Boulder. read more

Pasta Jay's - Stuffed shells, chicken Parmesan, Garlic Bread - Italian Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

Pasta Jay's is a good Italian Italian restaurant. They have a lot to offer, including pastas, of course, salad, soups, and pizzas. They have outdoor seating, which is fantastic on a warm spring boulder evening. When we got there, there was no line, which was great, but later on the line started to develop, which I get, as the food here was great. Service was good, and the overall experience good. I had the shrimp giacomo which had linguine, shrimp, sun dry tomatoes, in a delicious creamy sauce. I really enjoyed my dish. The cheese bread that we got as an appetizer was pretty good too. The amount of gooey cheese on the flatbread with parsley was great. The complementary garlic bread was good too. If you're in the Pearl St., Mall area, where there are plenty of restaurants to choose from, and you're in the mood for Italian, definitely check out Jake's pasta read more

See all

Super cute restaurant! Was really busy but staff brought everything in time. Super delicious pastas and pizza but the garlic bread was the best for sure! read more

See all

Ordered what they advertised as the $8 special. The girl who checked me out didn't seem like she knew what she was doing. I asked her if the red and white lasagna was $8 and she told me to specify "red or white". She charged me full price. Afterwards I see it's not the special from their kitchen white board. Brainless people running this place. read more

See all

Hailey was an amazing server. We ordered all her recommendations and they were on point! Manhattan martini was top shelf. Salmon Parmigiano was delicious with spaghetti! Great location on Pearl downtown Boulder with many celebrity and local athlete sightings. Can't wait to return! read more

Pasta Jay's - Salmon Parmigiano = delicious - Italian Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

It's small place but, it's very homey ! The wait was not bad at all. Our server Jax was very kind and made me feel comfortable, I asked his recommendation and got the seafood stuffed shells. Best Italian I've ever had!!!! The Cesar salad was great and I loved my entree as well. Would definitely be here all the time if I lived here :) read more

We were a party of 13. The waitress was excellent (wish I got her name, blonde and worked the Saturday shift around 1p) and so was the food. We pretty much ordered everything and everyone seemed to really enjoy. Will definitely be back when visiting my son at CU again. read more

See all

Great food! As always. Been many times to Pasta Jays, I will say the service is not what it use to be. Kinda disappointed because it's always been great, but the last 2 times I've seen a definite change in their commitment to customer service. Kinda sad! Ambiance is still nice read more

Been here a few times. Never disappoints. The food is flavorful, comes out hot and always looks good. The service is always good. Servers are friendly and helpful. Gets busy so I would suggest reservations if possible. We like to get a side of marinara to dip the bread in. Decent choice of wine and beer. Fun for a family dinner or date night. read more

See all

What a difference a year makes! Pasta Jay's has fully been redeemed from our terrible experience we had last year- and more in line with the fabulous food and service we knew in all years past. Our annual CO trip was upon us and we decided to try this family fave once again and I'm glad we did. Jax, the waiter- fantastic!!! So friendly, articulate, and helpful! Food was delicious ( specifically the Tortellone Alfredo) and overall this was a great experience. Perhaps new management?Whatever you're doing, it's working! Thank you! read more

See all

Cute Italian restaurant. The meal started with some crispy and buttery garlic bread. I ordered the bolognese with no pancetta and the waitress was super nice and added some extra sirloin to make up for the no pancetta. Garlic bread: 7/10- a little too crispy and puffy for my taste. But the flavor was great. Georgio bolognese: 8.5/10- basically 2 portions. Creamy with a good amount of protein. What you expect from this flavor. read more

Pasta Jay's - Georgio Bolognese - Italian Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Update: the manager has reached out and assured me that I was incorrectly charged for my drink. She has issued a refund and taken care of this to my satisfaction. read more

See all

I rarely leave bad reviews, but this restaurant truly deserves it. We were originally told the wait would be 30 minutes. Instead, we ended up waiting over TWO hours with zero communication or apology. To make matters worse, we later from The hostess that was in training informed us that the manager gave our table to their friend. But we were told for our understanding we could get a free appetizer. Which at this point it didn't even matter because this was 2 hours after waiting. This was hands down the worst dining experience I've ever had in Boulder and I didn't even sit down to eat because at this point after dealing with the manager with the slick back Hair, I did not think that they were worthy of my time and or business If you value your time, respect, or basic customer service, I would strongly recommend going literally anywhere else. read more

We came here for the first time before a concert at the Boulder Theater. We sat at the bar and had Wynne as our server. He was very efficient, kind and overall wonderful! The tortellone was delicious. We would recommend this restaurant to anyone! read more

Honestly, I feel like the quality and taste here is going down. I first came here with my husband a few years ago during my first visit to boulder and i remember how amazing the pizza here was. I've come here a few times since and every time I feel a little underwhelmed. We came here recently and I brought my parents for them to try pasta Jays. The pizza was okayish, the pasta was meh. I think the one new discovery in their menu for me was the Italian soda which I liked. Ofcourse it was very sweet but different none the less. I will skip coming to pasta jays in boulder and try other restaurants on Pearl street. read more

Pasta Jay's - Italian Soda - Italian Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Pasta Jay's used to be one of my go-to spots. The food had heart, and their Salad Rustica was awesome served on delicious pizza crust that made the whole dish stand out. Now it comes on a burnt, thin, tasteless cracker. Portion sizes have shrunk noticeably, and the overall quality just isn't what it used to be. It's disappointing to see a longtime favorite go downhill. Sadly, I'm taking it off my list of favorites, and I won't be recommending it to friends as I had in the past. I hope they find their way back to the quality that made them special. read more

We were walking around Pearl Street and this place caught our eye because husband's name is Jay. Had to eat here. We walked up and chose the sidewalk tables so we could people watch. Great spot on a beautiful night. I chose the homemade cheese ravioli and husband had the tortellini Alfredo with chicken. Our meals came out steaming hot! The basket of garlic bread was a nice compliment to the pasta. Service was good. Lots of menu options. We enjoyed our experience, especially with mountain views from our table. read more

See all

From being sat down by the two super sweet hostess to our amazing waitress Kaytee, we had an amazing experience with yummy pasta!!! I always come here when I'm in town! Thank yall for being amazing!! read more

Came in for a light meal, ordered a pizza... have to say it was Hands Down one of the BeST Tasting PIZZa's I've had in this life time... Great JOB to the CoOK/CHEF/family Recipe!!! Located in a great spot here in Boulder! Definitely a must have when visiting! read more