I've been ordering and coming into Pagliacci's for 25+ years. We are fairly new to this neighborhood and I've only ordered twice. Once, I would say was typical of what you would get from a Pagliacci's... a tasty well-made pizza with a decent amount of toppings. The last time we ordered however the pizza was slightly undercooked. The sauce was thin, and the toppings were sparse to say the least. The pizza still tasted good, but did not live up to the high praise that I had given it when lobbying where to order from my teenage kids were unimpressed, although teenagers typically are. We are hoping that our order placed minutes ago is up to the high standard I expect from a Pagliacci's. The Columbia city location is clean, and the staff is polite and courteous. read more

Been spending a fair amount of time in Columbia City and finally got around to trying Pagliacci. There was nothing wrong with it - it just didn't impress me very much. Pizza looked great but overall flavor experience was just okay. I don't eat a lot of pizza but sometimes a slice is just the right thing. So when I do crave and slice and decide to indulge myself, I want it to POP and be memorable. I've had better. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Absolutely love their CRM system used for placing orders and the professionalism of the customer service gentleman who makes the entire process nice and easy. We have tried many different toppings so far as well as combos. They are all good. Just go for it read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Chkn&spinach + south Philly goodness - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Great team and staff. I was having a very rough day and the customer service here was spot on. I appreciate this team! Don't forget to tip these hard workers. read more

I've been coming to the Columbia City location for the last 6 months now and initially I thought that this was the best pizza in Seattle. However, over the last few months I've been noticing that this location is falling off a bit. Sometimes the pizza is really good and other times it is undercooked or the ratio of the toppings are off. My slice tonight was badly undercooked! May not come back to this location. read more

The pizza here is very good. It's more high-end that what you would expect from a place like my pizza. For example, the prices are higher but the ingredients are probably fresher. Service was excellent ambience is great. I would highly recommend and come back here again. read more

Delicious pizza. By far the best in the neighborhood. I wish they delivered before 4pm, but they don't have to, I will go to them!

Really good. Dough cooked a little too crispy for my taste and a pit on the expensive side, but finding out a pizza chain (that you can find all over Seattle) has both vegan cheese and vegan sausage was. It was a great day to say the least. My friend got the regular cheese and loved it, he also suggests the Hawaiian. Really great sauce. Definitely recommend getting pizza here. read more

This is a great pizza place. You can get pizza by the slice and the staff are friendly.

Best slice on the block and their crust recipe is on point! cant wait to come back. Glad we stopped in for a midnight snack

There's no other pizza place that has won me over as much as Pagliacci's. I really like the Columbia City location for the atmosphere of other businesses around. It's always clean and the employees are always so friendly and nice. read more

Came to this location for dinner for the first time since its so close to the house now. My fiancé and I grabbed a couple slices of pizza and shared a salad. The person who helped us was Imani Artis and he had excellent customer service. When our salad was done he brought it to the table and even walked over the jar of forks for us as well. This gesture alone made my night because typically whenever I go to any other Pagliacci's location I always have to go get my food at the counter when I order it (nothing wrong with it I don't mind it) and he went out of his way to grab us forks so we didn't have to. Definitely making this location our new go to Pagli's read more

Awesome, amazing local pizza chain establishment! Been around for 40+ years and they are only located in Seattle! Wow. I'd recommend trying it just to try a slice of local pizza. I only tried the regular cheese and it was good. Pagliacci you're so amazing! :) :) read more

I'm going to need to try this place again. Ordered the chicken salad and it needs some help. Unevenly chopped, not well mixed, inedible artichoke, and largely missing the chicken altogether. It just wasn't good. Hoping one of their other salads will perform better next time. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - The mediocre salad that I kinda hated (partially eaten and hand mixed by me). - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I went there today and got two slices the was sooo fire that crust is just right the pizza was sooo fresh and the guy at the counter was very nice I will be back read more

Solid, solid pizza. You can't go wrong. This is a great location. Friendly staff, quick service, and they're taking covid precautions seriously. read more

What's not to love? Seattle's best pizza since back in the day! Plus all the sides, desserts, beverages, and extras to complete the experience! read more

So it's Halloween and this place is packed! Now I have to point out that the staff is rocking it. They are taking orders filling orders and this place is pumping. The pizza was nothing short of amazing. The crust crisp and the sauce is on point. It is exactly what I want when craving pizza! read more

See all

Decent pies but very inconsistent. Occasionally really good, occasionally off the mark, but mostly it's average. Bad is generally result of an undercooked crust and/or toppings & sauce are sparse/poorly placed. Avoid the salads. read more

Don't rely on their printed map and description of delivery areas---, very misleading. They do not adhere to what they have published and it has cost them this customer who has patronized them for decades. Bye, bye!!! Very disappointing. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

My friend and I were in the mood for pizza and she recommended this spot. We got a small plain cheese pizza. The pizza was ready in about 12 minutes. It was golden and cheesy and the small was the perfect size for my friend and I. The cheese was melted perfectly and the dough had the most perfect crunch. The size of slices were really small like kids size but we didn't mind it at all. Make sure you get some Parmesan on the side and enjoy! They have some delicious toppings options as well like sautéed garlic. read more

See all

The pizza was bland and so was the salad. I'm not from the area so I don't know when I'll be back to try again. I did enjoy my gelato very much so I was not completely disappointed. I guess my expectations were high since I was told it's a great pizza place. Maybe next time. read more

Great pizza and local fast delivery! Can't ask for much more than that. You can tell all the ingredients are fresh and of high quality. Delicious every time! read more

First and foremost I was confused about the Covid protocols because instructions on door said to stay out. Then I saw a person walk in so I open door, and ask can I come or is it minimum 1 person. The cashier (long hair, latino) responds with a nod.I give him the order chicken pizza and 2 orders of breadsticks. He asks my name, which I give him my name, he responds with a hunh!? My beautiful name is unique, so I calmly repeat. While all this happens he gets my order and hands it over...no customer service...two ladies behind me, both white he greets, and says have a good day all chirpy...ok dude your ceo supports black lives and sends every customer letter of support. Yet you have workers that dont know how to provide equal customer service. There is always another pizza place; He was looking real annoyed...give us a break, I was marching for Mexican people chanting si se puede during the deportation protests...now I know alot of this PC rhetoric is full of shit. Thanks Pagliacci but no thanks. All due to selective customer service. read more

Really delicious pizza. We had the chicken, mushroom and spinach. When they opened, they did a fun promo where they gave free slices to everyone who lined up. read more

See all

walked in door with my mini poodle. no barking running around ( she is my esa not service animal ) incompetent worker asked if she was a service animal.. not your job.. job is to sell pizza. never coming back read more

Came here tonight for a slice of pizza for an easy dinner with my Husband. As we entered, we were greeted immediately by the staff, one at the pizza post and one at the register. I got a slice of their vegetarian pizza which was the Primo and my Husband got their regular cheese pizza. The Primo reeled me in because of the abundance of button mushrooms it had all over the slices. It was so good. I absolutely love mushrooms. So for anyone who loves mushrooms, this pizza is for you. I would have given this place five stars if one of the staff members whom was a Caucasian man with an untamed beard didn't decide to pick a tiff with the African American young man who rang us up about telling us we can have free soda due to the broken water filter in the machine. He was telling the young man to not tell that to customers and we need to charge still for soda but was really mad that since he told us we weren't going to be charged. I would have had no issue with paying for our drinks, it was not a big deal at all. But beard guy was just not having it and kept rudely telling him to just hurry up and finish the transaction. Not only was that situation super awkward for me, it was awkward for all of us who had to witness it. There's a time and a place for those kind of conversations, he could have waited to discuss those matters once the transaction was complete. Overall, definitely would go back because everyone is pretty much friendly except for the beard guy and the pizza is always delicious. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

My coworker and I were in the area and thought Pagliacci would be a good idea for lunch (we were right). It was my second time at this location and they did a nice job maneuvering tables/chairs to adhere to covid guidelines and still have a large space. There were only two pizzas out: cheese and the tomato gorgonzola. They said the pepperoni and spicy chicken were both still in the oven but I wish I could've seen the traditional margherita or spinach and chicken. We got the plain cheese and the tomato gorgonzola and I don't think I've ever had gorgonzola cheese so I'm not sure what to compare it to, but I'd definitely get this pizza again! The fresh tomato topping cut the saltiness of the cheese and it was both savory and refreshing at the same time. I'll be back (: read more

Had the rosemary potato primo as well as the Sicilian cauliflower. I had specifically asked for no chicken on the potato pizza, but they had forgotten about it but served us the pizza anyways while immediately starting make us the correct order. They also offered a free pint of gelato! Great customer service and would definitely come back for the great pizza, but also the amazing service! read more

I normally avoid pizza spots because I'm really not a pizza person ... but we gave it a chance ... and it was not a good experience. They forget your pizza is in the warmer, and not only do they burn the damn thing, they serve it to you burnt and hard as fkn rock ... they're super unorganized, walking around to every table asking who ordered what ... Maybe make use of those NUMBERS for orders so you don't look like a fool trying to figure out who had what. And to the leprechaun who tried to tell me not to tell his co worker they sucked, go educate yourself on excellent food and customer service ... read more

Not impressed. Don't dine here often but happened to be in the area visiting family so decided to order some pizzas and salad. First I had the order for delivery since it was dumping outside but delivery would've taken an hour and the restaurant was only a few blocks down. Decided to call and order for pick up because most places are much faster but no, order still wouldn't be ready for another 45 min, ok fine. Finally drove to pick up the order after 45 and still wasn't ready. While waiting we noticed none of the staff had hair nets, beard coverings nothing. One of the girls working was carrying peoples boxed pizzas on her head from the kitchen to the service counter. Boxed or not that's definitely improper food handling and plain gross. Quality of food for the price was mediocre at best. Don't think we'll be ordering from here anytime soon. read more

Searching around for good pizza? Pagliacci Pizza is the perfect place to go for an entire pizza or just a slice or two. The pizza is worth the wait. Descent varieties of pizzas on the menu. The 12th Man Promo pizza has pepperoni, salami, chicken, Mama Lil's peppers, olives and mozzarella on our seasoned tomato sauce was quite delicious. Good amount of flavor per slice. Cheese, seasonings and vegetables in one! The Tomato Basil had roasted Roma tomatoes in olive oil, balsamic vinegar and herbs and combine it with with fresh basil and mozzarella over an olive oil base was tasty, but a bit plain. The Italian tradition and hand-tossed crust was very good. If the crust was stuffed with cheese then the pizzas would be amazing! Might have to come back to taste the other pizzas. Friendly cashier. You can go get delivery, order online or pick-up the restaurant. read more

So we were staying at an airbnb in the general vicinity of this pizza place, and after already taking public transit back from downtown to our airbnb, decided we were still kinda hungry. It was also around 9:30, so not a huge amount was open. My wife said she really wanted pizza, so I pulled up yelp, and this place wasn't too far away and was open late, so I suggested we try it. We didn't need a whole pizza, though, just a slice - it is very possible that I'd be more impressed with their pizza if we had had the ability to pick from their whole menu, instead of just between pepperoni or the one other pizza they had out for slices at the time, in that particular instance, mushroom. Their slices are large but not enormous, and good but not amazing. For $4 a slice, I expect them to be at least one of those (enormous and/or amazing). They were still pretty good, though - I'd give their ready-made slices a solid 4 stars, with bonus points for being open later than any other cheap quick food in the area (but not enough bonus points to be worth 5 stars.) read more

My wife and I have tried numerous locations and I have to say, the Columbia City location is by far the best! They are clean and friendly, which is important during this weird time we are going through. They are one of the only to-go restaurants we will go to during this time. The pizza is ALWAYS fresh and delicious! The salads are never bad, like literally never. I will be happy to continue to give them our business. read more

Came here on grand opening day for their free 2 slices. First in line to enter and they let me walk out with 4 slices for free! Came back a couple more times and service is always fast and friendly. Love their crust and agog primo. read more

So many fashionable Seattle establishments treat South Seattle as if it were the dark side of the moon so I nearly wet my pants upon discovering that Pagliacci had expanded their tasty NewYork-esque offerings into Columbia City. Thank you, thank you, thank you Pagliacci for boldly going where no decent pie had gone before. With any luck we may see a Renton location by the time SpaceX lands on Mars. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Basic cheese pie (Large) with a small Pagliaccio salad. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

No matter which other pizza place I try, I always regret that I just didn't go with what I love! Pagliacci! My only gripe is that their delivery area stops 2 blocks away and they refuse to go any further. read more

I LOVE pagliacci. I do. It's my first choice whenever I can order pizza. But lately, I've noticed their delivery timing is off anywhere from as little as 5 minutes to upwards of 15 minutes. I've been ordering pizza for about 5-6 years both for office functions and personal functions and delivery arrival has never been a constant issue like it has been with this particular location. I will highly recommend the pagliaccio salad, spicy chicken pizza and the pear and Gorgonzola pizza though. Also recommend going in in person, they're pretty quick and hot out of the oven is always better :) read more

I usually get a slice of pepperoni. I recently discovered that adding every possible seasoning to the pizza creates the best combination of flavor. I love the pizza and the taste reminds me of a pizzeria I went to when I was just a wee lad. Very nostalgic. Possibly the best pizza in Seattle. I come here quite often with my family. It's great if you just want to pop in and grab a slice, and they also do delivery. I often find myself ordering their Margherita pizza, as they don't usually have it in store. Overall a great place and a great location. Your best bet for a quick bite! read more

They've worked hard to iron out the delivery kinks and added beer and wine to the menu, which is very cool. They'll occasionally be out of everything but, Rainier, but even that's not too bad. Service is virtually always on time, and they respond immediately to problems. We order from them 2-4 times per month. read more