Pagliacci is an amazing restaurant company to do catering business with. I had to cater an event with a short turn around time. Their customer service was superb! They were so polite and helpful. I had to change my order a few times and they were very accommodating. The food arrived on time. Their pizzas were delicious!! There was plenty of food at our party and everyone enjoyed having leftovers to take home. read more

I am genuinely impressed with the West Seattle Pagliacci. They know how to make a pie! Great, unique combinations listed on the menu if you're feeling indecisive, otherwise you can use the awesome toppings they carry to create your own. We've been ordering take out from them about 3 times a month now, and we have been beyond pleased every single time. They are generous with their toppings, their thin crust is baked just right and their salads are fresh and tasty. We can't really imagine going anywhere else now! read more

Good for Take-out only. The service here is TERRIBLE. But the pizza is good. My personal recommendation would be the chicken primo. But again, if you want to try their pizza I'd either get it delivered or order ahead for take out. I also frequently walk in and get their Hawaiian by the slice for $3.50. As an establishments in the junction, there's fun things to do in the area, and that means street parking and you can bar hop before/after. But really, silverware here is dirty, they always seem grossly understaffed for rushes. You'll be waiting a solid 35-45 min for a pie when you dine in. Almost every other time they forget something. Like bringing out the salad or bread sticks before the pizza, or at all. Basically anything that could be wrong with service, it's bound to happen here. read more

Pizza was done to perfection !!! Crust had the perfect amount of chew while still having the right amount of crisp read more

Pizza is always good and hearty. I've been having problem using the app for a while now and my card shows an error message. When I call in with the same car the sale is able to be processed. I'd like to give more stars but they cannot seem to figure out this app issue. When I call the guy on the other end told me it's a known issue but they haven't been able to resolve it. I don't mind calling but so really enjoy the convenience of the app. read more

Good deal for anniversary day, .69 for a slice. Went and enjoyed a few slices and waited in a long line that didn't take much time at all. When it comes to actually ordering from there, I don't think I ever will. Saw the "normal" prices and was mortified. If quality is similar to slices I had, I would think prices are quite high. Pizza, even with fresh ingredients, shouldn't be marked up that much. Lower prices and likely you will have my business, keep prices this high, and I won't ever suggest going there read more

It was very delicious pizza but once my husband and I got home we both had food poisoning from it. It was a bad experience.

Not sure what happened tonight, but my partner and I both got food poisoning from this place. We've had their pizza before, but tonight something smelled off. I had tried a new topping so I thought maybe I was making things up, but I ended up sick within 30 minutes. Threw the rest out. read more

I recommend Pagliacci Pizza to all my friends who live in Seattle or West Seattle. Especially, this storefront in the Junction (that's in West Seattle). Although, if you don't know what you want... I don't recommend Pizza. I tasted a few of the salads when I lived in West Seattle prior to 2002. When I was working in the neighborhood. Did you know... there is no line for salads?! I know,.... Right?! Also, there are very few Tourists that are willing to wait for their Pizza to be made on Saturdays and Sundays. I tasted a slice one time... it was very good. I don't remember exactly what was on it, though. It's been a few years since I've ordered anything at Pagliacci Pizza. I had driven by a few months before I started working in this neighborhood in the late 1990s. The Clerk back then said.... "If you have any questions... just ask." I asked a few questions." There is a Goat Cheese Pizza. There is also a Spicy Chicken Pizza. There is a Hawaiian Pizza. There is even a Goat Cheese Pizza with Mushrooms finishes with fresh tomatoes after baking. I guess,... if you could dream about any kind of different topping on Pizza... it might be already made at Pagliacci Pizza. If you're like most Tourists,... and require a "frou frou Pizza"... they can make it at Pagliacci. It will cost more than you think... because... you're Extra Special... aren't you. I ordered the Lasagna once. It was tasty... but, I ordered a salad the next time I was inside Pagliacci Pizza. I was told the sauce on the Lasagna is a Bolognese with Bechamel. I was asked on my last time inside Pagliacci Pizza did I order a Calzone earlier. I replied,... "I don't think so. And what was the name given?" I guess the person that ordered was fighting traffic and decided not to show up for their Calzone after their order was ready. The Pizza baker was a friendly dude. I'm not sure why he wanted to work in a hot kitchen in the middle of the summertime, though. There is a nice selection of soda pops, Martinelli's still apple juice, and sometimes... there is Mexican Coca-Cola if that's your jam. I don't think that the Clerk is the same person as it was in the 1990s... but you never know. read more

Everything about Pagliacci had me hyped. From the box art to the customer service. However, after the first bite I was slightly disappointed. The sauce being flavorless is the biggest issue here. Crust? On point. Toppings? Could use some work. The sauce needs to pop. The sauce needs to make you smile. This sauce did quite the opposite. 3/10 on my pizza scale. read more

I've eaten a lot of pagliacci. It often feels like the safest pizza to get. It's in the normal price range for decent non-Neapolitan pizza. And the cheese is very good 9/10 times and still totally fine 1/10 times. The pagliacci salad is good if a little heavy. The crust is great. And the cheese and sauce are both solidly good, while the other ingredients are high quality It's really best hot, but the leftovers are still pretty good. The in-store slices aren't as good as whole pizzas but definitely still satisfy, and aren't to overpriced If memory serves. Pesto primo is great. 12th man primo is good. Pepperoni is good. The grand salami kinda just makes you wish you got pepperoni. The one with ricotta and a bunch of meat isn't great. But if you take a look at the menu it's pretty easy to find something you like. I hope they never decrease in quality which I feel like is a possibility if they continue to expand. I mean look at ezelles, but so far I do love them best for there consistency. read more

My mom has been coming here 4 20 years. I feel like these people r expensive for a very small pizzza with very little cheese & pepperoni. There crust is the only reason they got 2 stars. The salad is so-so. There was dirt in it which is the crime of the century. I mean this the layup of all layups. My 1 year niece could phone this in. How hard is a small pizza & dinky salad? If u want 2 be the best u have to act like it. I don't know why they aren't in Des Moines. They would get 6 stars compared 2 what we have here. I'm going to check others. Maybe there is some leeway into something that is 3 1/2 stars. Not really a high bar. My barbequed bacon is way better then this. read more

Pagliacci's pizza is delicious. Full of flavor, not greasy, and amazing signature pizza selection. My favorite (so far) extra pepperoni and south philly. Store appeared clean not cluttered. Just wish there was a Pagliacci Pizza in the Southcenter mall area. read more

Meh. A smallish, rock-hard slice of pizza and an underdressed salad for 11.00, no drink. Passing on pagliacci next time.

****UPDATE 4/7/08****** This Pag HAS explanded it's delivery radius by a few blocks. They now deliver (approximately) as far South as Holden and as far East as 28th ****END UPDATE*** Um, wow, Mary..."It must be nice" to be able to get them to deliver to you....Lucky somethingorother. My house is out of their delivery area, but I pick up here when I get the overwhelming urge to pay a lot of money for a very good pizza. This is essentially the southernmost Pag delivery kitchen and last I heard they don't plan on expanding any farther south. Apparently the rest of the south-end is the "Ghetto" and we folks in the ghetto don't deserve to have delicious pizza delivered to us. Yeah, I'm a little bitter. Standard Pag fare can be acquired here, but the pasta in the pesto salad always seems a bit undercooked and the crust seems soggy in the middle even with only one "wet" ingredient (or "moist", if you will). My heart still resides with the Broadway Pizzeria, but I'll keep WS in the bull-pen just in case I need some hot pizza action in my "ghetto" 'hood. read more

I get take out and delivery from here often. The pizza is always fresh, on time, hot, and tasty. I also love the Pagliaccio salad. Whenever I get delivery, I like that the drivers always leave the food at the doorstep, but wait a distance away until you open the door to make sure you get it. read more

Great pizza! It is NY Style with a crispy crust, and plenty of options for everyone (well, I am not sure about Vegan options). What I really like about this place is that they are great with customer service. I call them to order a pie, and they let me know my previous order and whether I want to get the same, or switch it up. They also are very polite. I look forward to being a Pagliacci Pie fan for long! As for now, it is the only pie I order for delivery. Eat up! Pizza has all your necessary food groups! ;) read more

Pagliacci has been a go-to pizza joint in West Seattle since it opened in 1996. I remember as a kid I loved getting a giant slice of pizza from the annual street fair in the Junction, and it's just as good now as it was back then. Pagliacci has truly mastered the art of the thin crust pizza--it's always nice and crispy topped with high quality ingredients. While lately I've been partial to Proletariat Pizza in White Center, I recently picked up a Pagliacci pizza for a change of pace. I ordered the Salumi's Spicy Pepperoni with onions and mushrooms. Of course, coming from Salumi (Mario Batali's father's meat shop), the pepperoni was so yummy. It definitely was not as greasy as some other pepperoni you often get on pizza. Overall, a really solid pizza. It's great having this local pizza restaurant in the heart of West Seattle! read more

See all

Pagliacci is my #1 go to! Let me just say, my craving for pizza is fierce and my passion for getting my "slice of pizza" stamp card filled out borders on obsessive. Their salads are delicious too. Also love the select-o-rama coca cola fountain soda machine. Then why 3 stars? Swung by for after yoga pizza... don't judge, it's a thing. Anyway, while enjoying my pizza in the dining area we observed (and more than overheard) what looked to be a manager disciplining an employee who appeared to be on break. Seemed undignified for the employee and unprofessional of the manager to have this discussion in front of customers. It was loud and carried on for some time. I understand these conversations need to happen, but perhaps behind closed doors would have been more appropriate. read more

Absolutely love this place! After being away from home for years, it was awesome to have a mini family reunion on a Tuesday afternoon over a couple of pies and salad. The staff was very friendly and the food was just like I remembered it outstanding! read more

Soggy and gross. Hosted family and decided to order a few pizzas to make it easy. I was embarrassed by what was served. Never again.

Nice modern version of this chain. Clean. Staff nice and thoughtful. They got our complicated pizza order (4kids, 3 adults, all with different tastes), correct. Caesar salad was okay; dressing a little too oily rather than flavorful. Walk there, don't try to park. read more

Pizzas good but their only way to order over the phone is one common phone line. That line being down today and no other direct phone to call, I tried the website. Just wanted to order a regular Pepperoni and olive pizza. Painfully, I gave up. The 2 font webpage writing sucks and you have to choose a specific pizza. When I had to go back, it forces me to resign in and I gave up on the third try. Went in to order with no apology given or direct line to call in the future. Wow. For a local pizza place, they don't care if ordering is easy read more

Mmmm I love Pagliacci. Before I lived in my current house, I used to only get pizza from Zeeks or Abbondanza because they were within walking distance to my apartment. After I moved there was no pizza place within walking distance so I had to start ordering delivery. My roommates turned me on to Pagliacci. First of all, could the people at the call center be any nicer? Every time I call the person on the other end is totally chipper. If you call from the same phone number each time they even greet you by name. The same can be said for the delivery drivers, totally friendly. Their pizza is pretty good too. I've ordered many of the veggie pizzas and they are always great. The crust is thin and tasty and there are always lots of fresh ingredients. Most recently I got the South Philly and it was delicious. The ratio of ingredients was perfect and the sausage was thinly sliced. I will be ordering delivery from here for the foreseeable future. read more

! It's all in the crust! The consistency and the flavor of the crust was prefect. I haven't found a lot of solid pizza places in the PNW. Pagliacci is definitely a pizza place I could take my Chicago relatives! read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pagliacci on california - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Ordered delivery. Food arrived within the promised time frame. The caesar salad wasn't great. It arrived coated in dressing and pretty soggy. The lettuce looked a little old. The pizza, however, was pretty darn good. It wasn't the absolute best pizza I've ever had, but it was definitely a nice, solid, tasty pizza. It's what I would expect out of a good delivery pizza. The crust and ingredients, in particular, were better than those from the average place. All in all, it was a satisfying meal, and I'd order from them again. read more

First - their delivery is awesome - but their special this month is bacon FAT (they left that out) and hot sauce. It is literally disgusting. I've uploaded some pictures, but I'm not sure how they expect anyone to pay for this (unless you love bacon fat)... The translucent things you see in the photos are what they are calling "bacon" - bacon isn't simply translucent - and the "brown bits" that you see are simply charred parts of the fat. It's horrible and a company like Pagliacci should aspire to better... this is horrible. I encourage everyone to order this pizza so that you can also throw it away - I couldn't even feed it to my dog in good conscience. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pagliacci's version of "bacon". - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Hard pass. Decided to stop in to place an order for a chicken salad for lunch and they gave me grief about adding specific ingredients like tomatoes and onions on it. I asked if they were already pre-made salads and that's why they couldn't do it, and the guy behind the counter just said the chef doesn't do that and he'd have to get permission from the manager. Umm...permission to give a paying customer what they want to eat? LOL. I'm sorry but that's ridiculous. If you're going to act that way you obviously don't want my money. It all worked out though because I got a great salad from West 5. I definitely recommend that place over Pagliacci because at least there you can get what you want. Don't waste your time. The food isn't worth the attitude. read more

$66 for two medium pizzas...I would gladly pay that if they were the most amazing pizzas I have ever had. Product was sloppily put together, mediocre quality and delivered 20 minutes past promised delivery time. Step up your game, Pagliacci or at least lower your prices. read more

Recent orders have been screwed up - 3 times. Every time, however, they offer a coupon or other ways of apologizing. Last time we ordered a pizza, I told the order taker about recent problems and said "just please make sure they get this one right". They did, and also gave it to us for free, which caused my husband to remark that it was sad that we didn't really care that it was free, we just wanted it right. Anyway, when they get it right (which they always used to), the pizza is delicious. Good crust. nice ingredients (featuring local suppliers whenever possible). They have a good order system that remembers order history, so it's convenient. read more

I had driven by this place multiple times when it finally dawned on me that this was a chain, and that I'd been to one in Queen Anne last year. We came on a Saturday night, unsure how packed it might be. It turned out that it was steady but not insane, so we ordered our four slices, two slices each, and it was no muss, no fuss. Hubs ordered 'shrooms, I ordered a 'shroom and a slice of pepperoni, all good. I liked that they have one of those fancy coke dispensers that have every other kind of coke product in it. They do a nice job here, not the best pizza I've ever had, certainly not the worst. Good stuff. read more

Love this great pizza, quick delivery service. Love the pizza and salad, great place to order if you are having a party.

I've been a Pagliacci customer for 25 years (since I moved to Seattle) and I even know how to pronounce it! It's still my go-to pizza for delivery if I'm the lucky one who gets to pick the place on pizza nights, and I often walk to one in the 'hood near my office for some slices. Admittedly there are now some serious competitors around who have also earned my love and respect, but Pagliacci is my long-time favorite. I'm posting a review to air a few opinions that have come to mind a few times: 1. I like getting the 13" size pizzas. They are the perfect size for me and my family, especially with the double cut. But the order takers STILL try to keep asking me about whether or not if I know that I get a better value/more pizza for the $$ if I get the large. Yes! I know. If you checked your records...which I know you have, you would see that is a consistent size I order, so please don't keep asking me. 2. I prefer to not have the delivery person open the pizza box on my chilly doorstep to have me inspect it upon my arrival. It's an awkward balancing act, and the hot pizza drops in temperature 10-20 more degrees. Last time the guy almost argued with me about how he would get in trouble if it was the wrong pizza. I told him that I trusted that it was the right pizza and if it wasn't that I would take the blame. I get it that there are sometimes mistakes made but can't I sign a waiver or something to decline the eyeball check? 3. Every year I order the mushroom primo hoping it will be better. And still, it tastes like "a nurse log" (to quote my teen daughter). We LOVE mushrooms over here, but perhaps if you could saute or marinate some of those big beefy ones first, then they would get cooked and not be flavorless and sorta raw tasting. Thank you for reading. Ciao! read more

Delicious pizza! I would definitely come back here. We got the large extra pepperoni pizza. The price was reasonable ($27-30); considering the other prices options in the area. read more

This Pagliacci made one of the best pizzas I've ever had. I got pizza for some friends who were helping another friend move all of her stuff out of a warehouse venue back into her house and garage. Honestly the meat pizza could have had more... you know... meat. But the vegetarian one was great! I'm trying to transition from more of a carnivore based diet to more of an herbivore based diet (long term goal to be vegan since I hate the way animals are treated at farms). I'll definitely give this place more business though. read more

Oh my God, I was a customer since 1996. This summer I ordered a pizza and it never arrived (not the first time this happened). I called the call center and the guy I spoke with called the store I ordered from. The store told him they couldn't find my address. I said that was strange since I have been ordering from the same house for 10+ years and there had never been a problem before. The call taker said yes I can see over 100 orders in the past. He offered to make it right or resubmit my order. I didn't want to wait another 45 minutes or so, so I just asked for my original charge to be reversed. Well, it gets better. I was told by another Pagliacci rep upon follow up that the driver knocked and called but there was no answer. This is a bald faced lie! I was home the whole time sitting within a few feet of the door and phone. No one knocked or called and I have detailed call records which will prove no inbound calls. But wait, they originally claimed they couldn't find my address. So which is it? Which lie are we going with? Finally I was told I would get an email or a call from corporate to discuss the issue. Neither arrived so I emailed corporate to ask why. They basically doubled down, said they did call and tried to reach me on the night of the delivery. Lies! It has been 6 months + and I haven't ordered and will never order or go into one of their restaurants again. Pagliacci wasn't like this in the past. Not sure what changed but it's a downgrade for sure. read more

When does fresh mean fresh? I asked for a fresh slice of pizza...after the employee told me the ones that are available are 'fresh' as of 20 minutes ago. They avoided my request to wait for a new slice; instead choosing too sell those same 'used' pizza slices only reheated...that's when you loose my trust. I will NEVER patronize them again - in short, they are '86'd from my wallet!!! Spread the word!!! read more

I had a craving for Hot Mama's pesto pizza, but my boyfriend had my car so I couldn't drive there. Instead, I called Pagliacci's and noticed they had something similar. I told the nice guy on the phone how I wanted my pizza like Hot Mama's Pesto, and he was sweet enough to special order one that was similar and delivered it to me! Thank you! thank you!! So happy! read more

Pagliacci Pizza - So happy! I asked them to make me a pizza similar to Hot Mamas Pesto, and they did! Also added red peppers on half! - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I am from Chicago. As a result, my pizza palate is spoiled. This pizza is perhaps the first time I have tried pizza in the Seattle-Tacoma area where I truly enjoyed the meal. It is not deep dish or pan style like we have back home. Instead, it is a thinner crust similar to more of a New York type of pie. As you can see, I approach my pizza with the seriousness of one who plays fantasy football. I look forward to enjoying many more slices of pizza here. I do not look forward to the extra miles I will consequentially need to run to offset the extra calories. #WorthEveryStep read more

Prosciutto and Fig Pizza is a seasonal option at Pagliacci Pizza. It's an olive oil based pizza, which has so much favor when you bite it. If your like the Canadian bacon and pineapple pizza, you would love this one. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Prosciutto and Fig Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington