A great pizza place if you wish for a change in the usual "Pizza chain." I enjoyed the Sicilian pizza pie, and the dough was not very thick. Therefore, able to enjoy the pizza. You live in the Canarsie area, give it try. read more

Two stars may be a little harsh, the pizza is serviceable, but I'd go out of my way to get it elsewhere. The plain slice definitely had a weird texture. Not enough sauce and what was there wasn't flavorful, overly chewy thin crust, and the cheese was just off. The supreme slice tasted fresher with chopped tomatoes and basil, but nothing remarkable. No pizza spices available at the counter. read more

Original Pizza - Plain - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Unfortunately, this pizza is inconsistent. They're all about pumping out as many pies as possible but that sometimes means quality suffers. The taste of a regular slice is often good and so is the dough. But because it's often falling apart and not crunchy it ruins it. Maybe one day they will achieve more consistency. read more

I love this pizza place . The best pizza in nyc. I live in queens and I travel to Brooklyn to get this pizza. The pizza must be great right..... Welllllll yesssss it is. Its just a bit pricey. I always say good things are worth paying for. I always get a buffalo pie, and their pepperoni wheel. Omg soooo good. I mean to die for . Now that im writing this review i wanna go get a slice (yes its that nice) worth every penny. read more

Large seating area. Friendly service. Lots of customers. Clean. Pizza is good. Not sure why but it has been my experience that delivery does not taste as good. The pizza delivered has a much different taste--not unlike the Chef Boyardee canned pasta I grew up on and now have a serious aversion to. I will pick up my pizza or dine in. There's is nice outdoor seating as well. read more

Original Pizza - Outdoor seating - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Good tasting food but not worth the price you can find similar good pizza at sunny John's or pizza damore for a much more reasonable price. They have started to price gouge since Covid read more

Love it! Quick delivery and great taste. Been going for over 20 years. Love the garlic knots too

Food is amazing especially the pizza! Service is quick and staff is friendly and accommodating!

I have been coming to this pizza place for years and their name suits them very well because the taste of their pizza remains ORIGINAL. The staff is very friendly, the place is clean and their pizza taste absolutely delicious . I highly recommend this pizza joint. The only thing to keep in mind is to come with cash because they don't take cards but they do have a ATM machine for your convenience read more

See all

Customer service is horrible. I ordered a plain pie and waited over an hour for it to not be delivered the delivery guy lied and said he called when he arrived to deliver it but he did not I did not receive a call or any thing I called back to be told that if I want my pizza I have to pick it up at the restaurant which I do not live near. I tried to order a new pie and they told me if I want it I have to come get it, and continued to hang the phone up on me. The workers are disrespectful and horrib skills. read more

This in my opinion is one of the top 10 best pizza places in Brooklyn. I have been going here for quite s while now and every time I try something different. Thus far I have had the following pizza slices: Buffalo Chicken Chicken Parmigiana Plain Peppers & Onions Mushroom Extra Cheese Penne Alla Vodka Ham and Swiss bites (non pizza) All were good but the Buffalo Chicken and Penne Alla Vodka are by far my favorites. They call it Original Pizza for a reason. You get that authentic taste of mozzarella and parmesan cheese and a nice flavorful rich herb tut tomato sauce with perfectly cooked crust. Also, you have an option to dine on or sit outdoors for a real Brooklyn feel. I will always go here when I want a real good slice of pizza as long as as they are here. Great pizza hands up read more

See all

I've been here a few times and I have no complaints. I usually don't have to wait too long to place my order and they have a large seating area--so this place would be good to accommodate large groups. There's seating outside as well, so when weather permits, outdoor seating is an option. I've had their plain slice and pepperoni--both were good. I hear good things about their Caesar salad pizza so maybe I'll give that a try when I visit next time. It's a cash only joint so remember to bring cash or use the ATM inside. The employees are polite yet quick. It isn't the best pizza I've had but it's still good. If you are in the area, I would recommend giving them a try. read more

One of the best Pizza parlors in NYC! My favorites is the traditional Plain Slice and the Grilled Chicken Ceasar Salad Slice. I also enjoy the grilled chicken ceasar salad. It's Cash Only! read more

Maybe try cooking the pizza that usually helps!! Lately the bottom is white as a sheet and everything slides off. And god forbid you say something nicely, all those workers are nasty the owner lets them get away with everything. So either it's not cooked or so small it's a joke. And at $4-$6 a slice it's not worth it. I hear the employees complaining about the customers all the time when I'm there. read more

I am sad to report Original Pizza is on the decline. Gone are the days that the sauce had taste rather than something out of a bland industrial can. This place got lazy. Staples like the buffalo slice are now just slapped together. The favors which used to be sharp and powerful are now drab. Same with the Penne Vodka Slice. It is still packed with pasta but it's missing the distinctive seasoning it was once made with. Their regular slices are limp--just perfunctory. It's tough. I still go because I remember how it used to be. The staff are nice. But it's missing what used to make Original so great. read more

Sauce to cheese ratio: standard-a little dry. Sauce quality: not very robust, simple and slightly sweet. Cheese quality: average-nothing standout and slightly salty. Pricing: standard, though I'd maybe pay like 50 cents less for it. I can't imagine any New Yorker saying this is the best. Such a typical neighborhood pizza joint. Like if you're hungry and don't want to drive too far for better pizza then yes, go ahead. Super average. All these 5 star reviews must be locals who grew up on this pizzeria. I'm sure they would say the same of Dani's House of Pizza but they would be wrong. read more

Original Pizza - ATM - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best pizza in the area. Never have too much selection but what they have is delicious. I wish they also had beef patties like their other location does. Other than the place is huge, clean and bright. read more

Original Pizza - Pizza galore! Caesar salad pizza was AMAZING - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Its that typical Brooklyn pizza. It doesn't taste Italian, this is not a fancy place were you take a bite of pizza and are like wow that was amazing. Its the place were Its late you are hungry and you want a quick slice of pizza with no expectations. Definiely not a huge selection of pizzerias in this area but I wouldn't go back unless I needed to ie: friend wants to come back or really hungry. Good idea is to head to another pizzeria in the area despite paying a bit more for a slice drive a few minuites to the key food mall and get a decent slice from the pizzeria in that mall. Don't want to advertise them on this yelp page but do your research. A good place if you just want some sauce cheese and dough. Definitley wasn't impressed. read more

Neighborhood staple. Pizza is pretty good. I prefer their slices over their pies( they tend to be messy). Recently started carrying mozzarella sticks and wings, which are a nice add on( though overpriced). I did suffer food poisoning twice eating their sausage roll, hence four stars instead of five. I'd suggest sticking to the basics. read more

Yes, It may be original, but It isnt exciting, exceptional or even that good. Amazing to think that the Italian stronghold of Mill Basin cannot support a better pizzeria than this- Let me know - Where is the amazing slice spot around here! A place like this can be found throughout the city- In a mixed residential/commerical area, does good business, maybe sells to alot of schools and supports the local community, and just doesnt need to produce an exceptional product- These places usually get good reviews because of the dreaded "pizza nostalgia" factor- aka "i grew up on this place and ate it when (insert awesome childhood memory involving pizza (most things are better when pizza is involved)). Its original and average. read more

Original Pizza - Albino dalmatian - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Wanted to like it but feel like its too soggy. Pizza was not crispy which is what I like. It was kind of sloppy, cheesy with no structure. read more

Original Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The tag for 2 stars sums it up perfectly. "Meh, I've experienced better." The pizza was way too greasy and heavy. I really couldn't tell if it was the cheese or the crust that was too heavy it was all just....together. The taste wasn't amazing or exceptional either, I didn't even finish too full slices, those of you that know me can take that as a benchmark for how good the food is. This place is also very unfriendly to those of us with extra girth. You'd think a PIZZA PLACE would know better, but they have no open seating. All of their chairs and benches are in fixed positions with the tables. Even the round tables have fixed spinning chairs, so a fat person will never be comfortable eating here. Honestly I took it as a discouragement from ever coming back. They sell pizza and their seating design serves to only remind people they are too fat to be eating the stuff. So, I'll oblige them, the chances that I'll ever go out of my way to come back are about nil. If someone orders a pie to their home or to some event I might nosh on a slice, but if there's something better I'll most likely pass too. Oh, one final pet peeve, they didn't have 20z pepsi, only cans. If you must, give this place a try, but really if you don't then you certainly wont be missing anything. read more

Original Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This has been our family's go to pizza spot for over 50 years!! My dad use to bike to get a pie for my mom. I now drive 15 minutes and never get anything less than a pie.. They are nice, efficient and the food is so so good!! The Fortuna restaurant next door serves a great meal as well.. read more

Let me be straight. I only eat one thing here - The Original Supreme Pie - been eating it for 20 years. Still kicks ass today. The Supreme pie is unlike any I have ever had. Fresh mozzarella made daily and San Marzano tomatoes grace this slice, along with an ample serving of diced basil. This is not an every day slice, this is a special occasion item. The ingredients stand on their own, yet blend together perfectly. My only issue is the crust. It is almost cracker like and lacks the smokiness of New Park and Di Fara. If this pizza was made in a coal oven, there would be no stopping it. Photo credit to Hope Glassman. read more

Original Pizza - Original's Supreme pie - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Lorrrrd talk about great tasting & delicious pizza! Truly heaven on a slice . I got the supreme Sicilian slice(nearly ate my fingers with it ) and beef rice ball. I don't understand why this place is not jam packed as other well known pizzerias that people flock to because this pizza is dear I say it : better than what I've tasted there. The magic of the crushed tomatoes on top of the slice literally sends good feelings to my toes and back. Gosh! Definitely an experience I love having over and over as I've been back several times... you should too! read more

No excuse for staff wearing masks on their chin while food handling during the pandemic. Love ur pizza but safety is paramount.

If you want great Italian pizza, this us the location to visit. The staff are friendly and they open real late. So if you have the munchies, pick up them on the phone and make your order. Update: Their plain cheese pie is now $16 dollars. read more

Original Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

10 minutes to get a great pie. I've missed N.Y. Friendly staff, that's all business, they get you in and out quick. The cheeses pizza is tasty, and not overbearing with spices. Has the right amount of cheese, and the crust... fabulous. Now it's not my favorite pizza joint but if your in the neighborhood, it definitely satisfies. read more

Original Pizza - Fresh pie - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Damn!! I forgot how good their pizza is. After winning an argument with my son about not ordering Dominos, he caved in and we ordered Original. They still don't work with debit card or credit cards, only cash, but they can afford to be selective. This is good pizza. It's a bit pricier than it used to be, but what isn't? Good! Good! Good! Loved it! read more

Long story short, I've been ordering from here for years, it used to be good but now the cheese is VERY gross. You can tell it's not real cheese. It literally falls off the pizza in one big piece. To be sure, I put it to the test and put a lighter to the cheese that a ripped off the top of my slice and the cheese didn't melt, it just blackened VERY slowly and gave out rubber smell. Very disgusted. Eat somewhere else. read more

Best pizza in BROOKLYN ‼‼‼ I love this place . Been coming here for years The Italian icees are amazing read more

Originals have the best pizza I have ever had. However, their prices have risen astronomically. When purchasing pizza from here you have to pay in cash. They do have an ATM in the store. read more

What I like about this pizza is the consistency. The pies are always baked the same, or maybe I've just been lucky for the past 20 years. This isn't the best pizza you can find in NYC, but it's solid and consistent. I hope their prices settle. read more

Delicious , cheesy, pizzas. The crust is delicious and the service is great! Love going to this pizza shop and they deserve to be added to a must visit while in NYC! read more

The absolute best pizza in the area and in general. You can't go wrong with a classic slice of plain or pepperoni but their chicken Caesar salad slice is surprisingly delicious! They are cash only but it's always worth the effort to stop by your bank or ATM to get such a great classic pizza. read more

Years ago their pizza was great but for the past 2 years the cheese taste weird. I did an experiment and lit cheese with lighter and it didn't melt. I think they are using some fake cheese or something read more

I love their pizza, it's cooked to perfection and done just right. The sauce is on point in the different pizzas. The service is impeccable and there's plenty of seating to eat . read more

Original Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The best Brooklyn pizza in the neighborhood I cant wait for Fridays that's my cheat day and I cheat with Original Pizza

Still the best slice on Brooklyn. My kids always want to come back here after all these years. read more

Original Pizza - Great slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

By far the best pizza I ever had in Brooklyn. When you say New York pizza this pizzaria is the example of that saying. "You haven't had a good pizza till you have New York pizza." Every other week I take a ride to have a pie with my family. And its always tasty ! Always. Thank you for your wonderful recipe that never changes. read more