Decent Brooklyn pie, fast service, place looked clean. Guys behind the counter seemed pleasant. A line formed while I waited for my order, so it seems the local community liked this place. I thought the crust could be crisper, a bit white and doughy. But all in all, I would eat another slice and try other items while in the area. read more

Brooklyn Pizza II - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This was a quick weeknight dinner bite for us! We both ordered calzones and added some veggies as toppings. The cheese was melty and they had a pleasant garlicky taste but the veggies were not fully cooked. The total was around $26 for calzones and sauce, which we thought was a bit pricey for the quality of food. This is a no frills place but we may stop by again to grab a slice, but probably not a calzone again. read more

Brooklyn Pizza II - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Very typical pizza joint headquarters!!! I enjoy speaking to the staff learning the neighborhood and most importantly connecting with people is my ultimate passion and mission when traveling. However, the ambiance was your typical small cozy pizza parlor. I'll give the pizza 5/10 read more

See all

Very kind service. Looks clean inside. The place is a pretty typical slice joint. Pizza was edible but nothing to say about it beyond that. I'm not sure if there's better slices nearby in the area. It was cheap. I'd probably opt for something else if I was looking for quick cheap eats in the neighborhood. read more

See all

I got severe FOOD POISONING from the House Salad with Grilled Chicken from this place. The food quality is very poor and the service was slow. The overall sanitary condition is extremely poor with the cashier touching the food (especially delivery orders) with his bare hands right after touching cash etc. The counter surface was unclean either. Would not recommend and definitely will not come here again. read more

I'm literally giving this place 5 stars. This was the BEST pizza I ever had in my life. This place is authentic and real Italians. My son reported that he would live in Brooklyn just to eat this pizza. My son was influenced to learn the Italian language because the pizza and customer service was pleasant. This place is in East Brooklyn surrounded by islanders. There is a hustler on every block and of course I purchased a few purses. I digress, my bad! Lol I had 4 slices of pizza and honestly could of ate a whole pizza to myself. I'm trying to watch my carbs but it didn't work with this pizza joint! It not a large pizza place but it stays busy and they are quick on their feet. They are not worried about you ordering and leaving and coming back. The pizza is so good, your going to come back and pay your money. I usually compared pizza to a place on the west coast called Round Table Pizza. If my sister is reading this, she would give me the side eye because this pizza joint is so much better. I don't think I will find better pizza unless I come back to Brooklyn . ‍ read more

Brooklyn Pizza II - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Pizza was stale, hard like cardboard, no cheese and drowned in bbq sauce with rubbery chicken placed on top. BBQ chicken pizza.

Solid authentic neighborhood 'za. No fancy marketing or thrills, just quality pizza for a budget friendly price. Pizza: 4/5 - Delicious and authentic. Authentic in the quintessential NYC pizza joint way. Location: 4/5 - Church Ave is super busy. There's a ton of stuff near by though so there's that. Service: 4/5 - Authentic pizza joint aka You Order. You Pay. You Enjoy. Value: 5/5 - Budget friendly. Slices aren't going to cost you $5 each. read more

Strong 4.5. This place is close to me so I finally tried it. I got the "baby" (12") Buffalo chicken pizza $12 and garlic knots 5 for $1.50. I ordered through the slice app and they didn't see my order so I had to wait for it to be ready but I got free beignet like things. I'm not sure if this was compensation or free with every order but I appreciated it. Anyway the pizza was v good. It didn't have marinara and instead had a Buffalo sauce base, cheese, grilled chicken and ranch. The crust was very good as was the whole pie and definitely big enough for 2. Garlic knots were soft and very garlicky but the garlic was completely raw and thus too peppery so that's where I would knock. But the beignets were good and it was ready quickly. Would order again. read more

See all

Bravo! I love my little Neighborhood pizzeria. It's NYC style hot thin and cheesy. I usually order the $8 pie as it's small enough for two people or two meals. They are quick and generous. There's usually a free sugar dusted fried donut. read more

They don't even deserve a star which is completely sad. I have ordered quite a few times with average service. Today, I order buffalo wings that are stated on the menu to be $7.75, yet I was charged $11 dollars today as per the person I spoke to. "Who didn't take my order". I order a Sicilian slice that's $2.50 that miraculously became $4.00 dollars.... Then I was asked for ID and my card when the delivery was made. Which I have NEVER experienced. Make it make sense. I live in a gentrified neighborhood, but support small business seems to be above me at this point. Thanks for nothing! And if not aforementioned. I will never order from you again. read more

See all

Friendly and always quality. Pizzas are always cooked well with lots of topping options. Stromboli and pepperoni rolls are always a great option too read more

Been coming here for years. Their Chicken Vodka Sicilian slice was my go-to before the Pandemic, but they removed it from their everyday rotation due to low sales. You can still order Vodka pies, however. I've ordered Chicken Vodka Pies, and just ordered this delicious Vodka-Margarita Personal Pie that was even more delicious than it looked. It had Vodka Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, Tomatoes, and Basil. Can't wait to order another sometime in the next week or two. read more

Brooklyn Pizza II - Small Vodka Margarita Pizza. Vodka Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, Tomatoes, and Basil. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The absolutely worst pizza shop on planet earth. Horrible delivery guy and customer service. The food got me sick. Stay away at all costs

This place is not the place to go. The prices for two pepperoni with bacon slices was not great and it was overall bland. Before my boyfriend, who is a white male, was not treated with kindness the first time we went. There was an employee that mocked him for not being able to speak Spanish unlike me and thought it was acceptable to make him feel uncomfortable. Aside from that visit, our visit yesterday was not good and I regretted buying pizza from this place. The pizza seemed soggy under the cheese, either it had been sitting there for a long time or the dough was not fully cooked. Also I give this place one star because of the lack of masks from some of the staff. There were two people that walked out what seemed like the kitchen without wearing any mask, no mask IN SIGHT! The guy that prepared our pizza had a mask on, but I guess forgot to pull it fully above his nose after taking it off for a sip of water. Do not plan to go back here. read more

I just ordered from them again yesterday after not having it for a year. Just. So. Good. 4 years strong of being in my top 3 in brooklyn. Perfect sauce to cheese ratio. Nice delivery guy. I just love them!! read more

These guys are our go to pizza spot in the neighborhood. Reliable and solid. Would definitely recommend

The school I work for always orders from here for employee celebrations, class pizza parties or regular staff lunch. The food is delicious and the service is exceptional. Marco is so accommodating and truly cares about his customers. The pizza is delicious, pasta is stellar, wings are perfect and prices are very reasonable. read more

Brooklyn Pizza II - Delicious Penne with Shrimp - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The food here is VERY pricey but the good thing about it is that you wont regret spending money here.. it's worth every penny!! read more

See all

The food was great when I ordered it but tonight I was faced with the most absurd level that because they are busy they cancelled my order. The craziest excuse is that where I am located the rehab center makes their delivery people wait. Have they bothered to think that this is a rehab filled with sick elderly people many on vents emergencies happen so you get held up. The other thing I tell delivery folks in advance I can't come down just leave it at the reception desk. I don't tolerate nonsense like this at all!!!! read more

Fastest delivery I received during my summer in Ditmas Park. The delivery man was amazingly friendly, too! I was hesitant to order from here but their gluten-free pie sold it to me, though I couldn't help but shy away from splurging on toppings ($3 each!). All in all, the pizza could have had more sauce but they threw in free zeppoli (sp?) so who am I to complain? We also ordered calzone and while I did not try it, my boyfriend said he preferred the pizza. The good- speedy as hell The bad- food taste is average Final verdict- a good option if you're in a hurry and friendlier than most delivery services. Not the beeeeeeest pizza but pizza is pizza. Service is so good it bumped the place up one star read more

The food was great and helpful people. Would order again. Service was great. We ordered for delivery

Ewww. They are too busy making jokes instead of dealing with customers. They drink alcohol behind the counter. & pour water into the sauce. I have not eaten here in years because it's truly horrible. It's sad it's the only pizzeria around. read more

I ordered some pizza to my friend who's a doctor and at a nearby hospital to cheer them up during this crazy time (COVID-19) - and man did they deliver. They went out of their way to make sure it made it to them on time and genuinely were happy to do it. They also put some extra zippolis!! We're all so lucky to have businesses like these to help support our healthcare workers! 5 stars for Brooklyn Pizza II - we love you!! read more

Brooklyn Pizza II - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Good pizza great on delivery's. They treat you nice. Would recommend this place. Nice selection of things. read more

Decent food, but with my latest order there was a shard of wood about 2-2.5 inches long inside my pizza. I only found it by eating the pizza, which I stopped doing when I found a splintered piece of WOOD INSIDE MY FOOD. The owner refuses to do anything because "there are no toothpicks at his restaurant." As if accusing me of lying about it. Let me reiterate: it is not a toothpick. It is a SHARD. OF WOOD. INSIDE THE FOOD. Probably came from an old and deteriorating pizza tray or something, I don't know, but this is not how you respond when a loyal customer tells you your food literally put them in danger. I hope this restaurant gets shut down after inevitably failing a health inspection. Don't waste your money supporting this business. read more

Brooklyn Pizza II - Piece of wood found inside my pizza from Brooklyn Pizzeria. Owner refused to do anything. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Had a really great visit! I moved out of the city last year and the staff still remembered me. Convenient location off the Church Ave stop. Always great pizza and the indoor dining is open as well. Must stop in Flatbush! read more

Basically it's like this: Always reliable. Always on time. The pizza is good. The pasta is good. Everything here is good. It's not the #1 greatest of all time, but are you the #1 greatest anything? no, so chill. it's better than a lot of other places. And-- they are always giving out random goodies. Is it a bribe? yeah but i'll take it. read more

Ordered pizza delivery and thought it was really good. We got the vegetarian pizza and it was loaded with tons of vegetables. The garlic knots were pretty good but I think if it was a bit softer it'd be nice. It also came with yummy donuts. Not sure if they charged us or if it was free or a mistake but it def tasty. I think if you do delivery either pay credit card over the phone or have cash for when the delivery person comes to pay. I ran around scrambling for cash when they arrived cause they didn't take card. read more

Brooklyn Pizza II - Vegetarian pizza with jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Brooklyn Pizza 2 is the spot. This is regular New York pizza from regular guys. Call any other place five minutes before they close and try ordering a large regular pie. It's gonna be like that scene in American Psycho, where Patrick Bateman tries to get a "rez" at Dorsia. Now call Brooklyn Pizza 2 five minutes before they close, what do you get? How's a perfectly medium rare, large cheese pizza with a goddamn chicken roll thrown in (on the house) sound to you? That's what I thought. Unfortunately these guys won't make you a prohibition-era cocktail in a teacup. And nobody here's got a man-bun let alone stubble past a goatee, but what the hell did you come here for? Ambience? Aesthetic? Gimme a goddamn break. You won't find your latest gentrified crush here, but you will get a helluva pizza from great people. UPDATE: I wrote that review drunk, and by God, I stand by every word of it. read more

Earlier this year when I was looking for a genuine, high quality pizza, Brooklyn Pizza II was the place for me. Since I was with a group of four, we decided to go with a whole pie. It was hot and fresh with just the right amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings. So, fast forward to this month, when Jessica E. and I are back in the same neighborhood and again craving some delicious New York pizza. Given the pizza deliciousness of last time, it's a no brainer to come back here, right? Well, we should have used our brains. Not hungry enough to split a pie with just one other person, I got a slice of Hawaiian (ham and pineapple). Admittedly, at first glance, it looked a little bit stale in the glass window, but I figured that all pizza gets a little off looking when it's been out of the oven for a bit and ordered it anyway. After it arrived, it was barely edible. Reheating it in the oven had sucked just about all the moisture out of the slice, so that the toppings had no flavor to them and the thick crust was like eating a hard piece of toast. Those of you who know me know that I never throw away pizza. In fact, when others leave crusts behind, I often finish theirs. But, on this visit to Brooklyn Pizza II, history was made when I threw away 2/3rds of the dry, bland slice. I may return again, but if I do, I'll only get a whole pie to avoid the risk of stale, dried out pizza. read more

A serious Brooklyn neighborhood slice-factory. No delivery, so you've got to be local if you want a taste. And a taste is well worth having. The veggie pizza is topped to heaping, and has always pleased the crowd. The price of their large pies compared to the amount of food you get and the quality of what you receive makes Brooklyn Pizza II a fantastic value and a staple for the neighborhood. The service has always been prompt and polite, a full pie taking only 15 minutes for preparation. When picking up a takeout pie, they will always offer to put whatever spices you want on the pie and tie up the box with twine to create an easy carrying handle. With a place like this nearby, it is an absolute CRIME to order from a major chain. Save some money, get a better pie, and order from these guys. They'll do ya right. read more

I've been coming here since I was a child before the name was change and the pizza still taste the same as it did years ago.....Con: they really need ice like seriously its been years , no ice REALLY?!!? read more

Brooklyn Pizza II - The best - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

It was OK but lots of cheesey pleesey goodness but I'm on on s diet only had one slice crowded

Don't eat here. I ordered an appetizer and a pasta. The plastic lid on the To Go container was old and brittle from heat exposer. It broke apart into my pasta. I asked for a refund on the whole meal. Because really, what's the point of ordering an appetizer and paying a delivery fee, if your not going to have a full dinner? The manager on duty was extremely rude. Questioned if I perfect person, if I ever made mistakes. I make mistakes, I just didn't want to pay for food I can't eat. Took no responsibility for the company's mistake. I understand he was stressed with many phone calls and it was busy, but that's part of the business. He was extremely condescending. I would of accepted an apology and refund. But instead, we went back forth on the phone over a clear NYC health code violation. read more

The food is great, a little too pricey! BUT BEWARE OF ORDERING WITH A CREDIT/DEBIT CARD OVER THE PHONE! we usually don't have cash, so we order over the phone with our card thinking that it's safe. until we found out that the lady who takes our order tried to make a $104 purchase on my card for a skin cream. and she thought no one would find out. that's our fault for trusting this place. read more

I have been going to this pizza parlor for most of my life, roughly 25-30 years....having said that, since they changed ownership the pizza has become lifeless....the sauce is too sweet and the crust is too doughy. I do like the fact that they now deliver, but with delivery comes higher prices for sub par pizza. I can honestly say that the only thing I enjoy ordering from there now is the Italian ices and that's a shame. read more

This is the place if you live around the area. Pizza is good, Pastas taste good (I go for the Baked Ziti). Delivery always fast and food is always still hot! read more

Speedy delivery. Solid pizza. I used to visit this pizzeria when I took the Q regularly because it's fast and good pizza, diagonally across the street from the B,Q Church Ave Station. Now that I no longer walk passed it on my commute back from work, Im happy to see them on SEAMLESS for when I want to order from a dependable pizzeria. read more

This is what pizza should be. Nearly perfect pizza. Had the pepperoni and sausage and it was maybe the best we've had on our week long trip that included 5 or 6 pizza stops read more

Brooklyn Pizza II - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York