Headed to an award show and you know they don't feed you at those things, so I was on the hunt for a quick nosh before the night started. Angelo's Pizzeria hit the spot! From the second I walked in, it gave me that old-school Brooklyn pizzeria vibe--pizza done right. Sure, the place looks a little divey, nothing modern or gentrified, but that's exactly the charm. This is classic Brooklyn old school goodness. You're there for the pizza, not the chandelier. The guy behind the counter had jokes for days, and we cracked up while I waited. I told him I wanted my slice hot-hot and he delivered--piping hot straight out the oven. I went with pepperoni, extra sauce, and let me tell you: perfect crust, perfect sauce, perfect slice. I grabbed a seat at the bar-style window, watched Flatbush buzzing by, and honestly felt like I'd stepped back into Brooklyn when it was really popping. With all these pizza chains everywhere, it's refreshing to still have a spot that serves up authentic, homemade pizza with the right flavor and the right energy. Angelo's is good old-fashioned Brooklyn pizzeria perfection. read more

Angelo's Pizza - Pepperoni slice extra sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Two pies for $44 when on the website one was $12. Cheese taste funny. This pizza sucks

Food was terrible!!! Not Edible AT ALL My DOG wouldn't even eat this crap. SHUT THIS PLACE DOWN!!! The Zeppoles were hard and greasy. The pizza was cold and the cheese was barely melted. The beef patty and cheese was cold. they forgot my soda and told me they got me next time. Can I got to the Pizza shop and come up short and say I got you next time while leaving With my order? NO!! $40 on straight BS . Oh and they need to retire the delivery driver he is old and senile. Poor guy couldn't differentiate Z from C. DONT ORDER FROM HERE. I'm disputing this charge immediately. read more

Angelo's Pizza - IT TASTE AND LOOK LIKE FREE LUNCH FOOD ewww - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Today I Ordered Chicken Parm With Penne it Was Terrible It Was Bland & Spicy Chicken Cutlet Over Cooked I Couldn't Eat it this is the 3rd time I Didn't like What I Got I Ordered Wasn't Good Not even Italian Plus the Guy Who Answers the Phone for Delivery Sounds like he's in a Mad Mood All the time I'm Done read more

The pizza is good, no it's great -- normally I just get regular cheese pizza, but I decided to be adventurous and try a slice of barbecue chicken pizza. It was quite delicious! The crust, the sauce, the cheese, the toppings... It's all wonderful! But honestly I have to say that I say I enjoy the garlic knots as much as the pizza, if not more. I haven't found a pizza place in the DMV yet that has amazing garlic knots, but Angelo's knows how to do it. There was an Italian restaurant in dc, but it's not properly a pizza spot so I'm not really counting it. Anyways, Angelo's does not have much space to dine inside, it's more of a takeout only type joint. But the staff are super friendly and the service has never been a miss. If you live locally, Angelo's is one of many Pizza spots that will not disappoint you. Cheers to New York pizza! read more

Angelo's Pizza - Pizza boxes - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This spot has carefully considered aesthetics. Their food satisfies completely and their staff always cares. The establishment is compact yet clean and pleasant with urban atmosphere. The people here include friendliness in their service. This place won me over. read more

I work construction and stop in 1 or 2 times a week for slices 100% best pizza in the area and the guys behind the counter are nice personable people. read more

Pepperoni pizza was delicious!! Cooked to order, just enough of everything! The service was great too! read more

Angelo's Pizza - Large Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Day trip to Brooklyn & had to try Angelo's. Let me just say, quality, superior! Handsome guy that took my order was very welcoming. The wait wasn't that long. My kids & I ordered a Philly pie, Penne pasta slice, Mozz sticks & a beef patty. We like to try different things haha...Pie was fresh and hot and the ingredients on the pie, amazing!! Most definitely will be my go to every time I come to visit NY!! read more

Angelo's Pizza - Philly Cheesesteak Pie - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Updating my review because they have really worked out their delivery process. I never have an issue anymore and their food is still fantastic. I always order this when I have people visiting from out of town and they want some authentic New York style pizza. read more

They have my heart with their honey pepperoni slice. The guys are very nice and they also have zeppoles!! A childhood favorite of mine.

Angelos pizza is finally back and better than I remember. My husband and I stopped by and couldn't decide which slices we wanted because they all looked so good. The spinach Alfredo did not disappoint! The penne vodka slice was amazing and not as heavy as other slices with pasta I've had in the past. The barbecue chicken slice was really tasty too. I can't wait to come back and try their hot plates. Welcome back Angelos!! read more

Angelo's Pizza - Specialty pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Stopped in to the flatbush ave location. We had the spinach alfredo and buffalo chicken slices. They were delicious!!! Best specialty slices I have had in a really long time. We will definitely be back to try some of the other slices that looked really good, too. read more

Work needs to be done in regards to customer service; Whenever I walk into a place of business and they make me feel as if I am bothering them that will be the last time that I provide my hard earned money there. As far as the pizza, I've had much better. read more

See all

one of the best pizza spots in brooklyn dudes are all cool asf 11/10 every time i go - enzo

This used to be my go-to neighborhood spot for pizza, more for location than taste, however there are so many reoccurring issues with customer service that I'm not going to patronize this business anymore. I've seen the guys who work here treat a Muslim customer in a rude and dismissive way and use the same hands to make your pizza as they use to take your money, completely unsanitary. The last straw for me was when I asked the older guy who makes the pizza for 2 slices of cheese from a particular pizza pie that already had 2 slices missing. I chose this pizza pie because the other pizza pie, wich also had slices missing, looked like it had been made earlier in the day and was dried out. He told me I could only have slices from the old pizza and asked if I was going to take it or not. Not! Last time I patronize a business that doesn't respect the community it makes its money in. There's Bona pizza on Flatbush and San Remo on Cortelyou, I won't be going back here. read more

This place has the WORST costumer service ever!!! First let me rate the pizza - it's not the best, the cheese is dry, & the crust is extremely dry. Taste isn't the best, if your desperate and need to eat to take a pill I guess get a slice. Also the mozzarella sticks look like the freezer kind, dry/hard garlic knots. Lastly these people have the worst attitude ever. They don't speak or treat you like a valuable paying customer. They're rude and short on the phone. The delivery drivers are slow and full of excuses. read more

Walked the store and the worker was extremely rude.. 7182843054.. I said wow nobody speaks.. he claims I was looking for problems.. when I had 3 children with me that I was asking what they wanted to eat... Very rude individuals read more

Mushroom and pepper pizza :)) very very yummy. I haven't had NYC pizza in a while and they sure didn't let me down. The staff is super friendly and awesome :)) 10/10 would go again. read more

Angelo's Pizza - three slices of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

People seem to not be fans of this place, but I am. Though in their defense, I've never ordered anything for delivery from here, because I live a few min away so I can just call in the order and walk over. That being said, this place is yummy, and the guys who work here are always nice and are most CERTAINLY old school brooklyn, which I'm a fan of, as an old school Brooklynite myself. There's a special sort of charm and feel you get from these classic, local BK pizza places that you can't get from some fancy shmancy place that just popped up out of nowhere in the hood and has a michelin starred "chef" as the pizzero. To be fair, I don't mind those places, but sometimes I wanna have pizza from a place like this...which I've done a few times, including yesterday, and as per usual it hit the spot. yum Yum! read more

Good pizza...lots of choices. Their white slices and vodka slices are great! Nice counter service. Delivery times same as most other places read more

I have never dealt with a less professional delivery service. The driver wasn't even in the right neighborhood. The restaurant claimed to not be able to contact the driver even though he was calling us... WHAT?! We were told there was nothing they could do until he came back and then they wouldn't remake the order. We spoke to the driver and 3 people inside the restaurant and got a different story from each person. 1 of the 3 of them in the restaurant showed any respect at all. In the background, you could hear yelling about other orders from other angry customers. Honestly, I would love to be able to review the food but it never came. So disappointing after a long day. I would advise to avoid angelos until they get their act together. To fail your customers, then be disrespectful to them is mind boggling. read more

Don't tell anyone else about the spinach Alfredo pizza and the grandma pizzas. They're amazing.

First time getting Pizza here and I must say I'm really disappointed in the poor quality cheese n dough n thin ass crust. The garlic knots and beef patty with cheese wasn't bad at all. It was the pizza! Horrible.. my suggestion would be to try a slice before u throw away money on a whole pie here. I literally forced myself to finish a flimsy salty ass slice. The guys that work there seem pretty cool n down to earth, they jus gotta do better with the quality and integrity of their Pizza. read more

Throwback vibe with excellent slices! The guys tossing the crust have the Moonstruck look- muscles, tattoos, and that Sicilian smile. Won't win the cleanest restaurant award but who's looking when you taste a crispy slice with charred broccoli, mushrooms, peppers with extra sauce! read more

I took my dad here for a quick pie and sat at one of the 3 tables (I know it's not an eat in place) The fellas who took our order were very sweet and even brought the pizza over for us when I know they didn't need to. We ordered a medium pizza with mushrooms, onions, spinach and pepperoni. Came out piping hot, they were generous but didn't go overboard with the toppings so as not to drown the pizza. The crust was crispy and not too bread-y. We really liked it and I'm switching to Angelo's for my go to delivery pizza in the neighborhood. I took home the remaining two slices and they heat up just as well. Yum. read more

I called Angelo's Pizza to see if anyone from Grubhub had picked up my order because it was late . A guy answered and when I asked if anyone from Grubhub had picked up for my address . The guy was so rude and not polite at all . All he had to say was the guy is on its way but instead he was very rude and what he said was uncalled for. read more

Picture the scene. Crazy cold day in Brooklyn. You want some pizza, you say to yourself "well, I'm not going out there!". You remember a friend who tells you wonderful tales of sicilian Saturday's at her house. She mentions Angelo's pizza. I said cool, let's do this! ,Pleasant delivery person, always a plus. Pizza comes, very nice. I was concerned the sicilian didn't fit the whole box. I digress. . The flavors were there, fresh homemade sauce and basil, proper cheese placement. I would have preferred a firmer crust, that's just me. So why 3 stars out of 5? Well, next time i ordered a regular pizza. I figured, what's the harm? Same pleasant delivery person appears. What a difference, really just bread with sauce. Don't know whether it was an off night. In hindsight maybe, I should have said thinner crust, better cheese?‍ So, moral of the story..its a reason why my friend and her family are happy with silician Saturday's at Angelos. And not regular large pie Monday thru Friday. read more

This place has a terrible customer service. I placed an order at 8pm and I called them at 9:00since they closed at 9pm and the promised delivery window was 8:40 to 8:45,to make sure everything was ok. They said the driver was on his way, after 30 minutes I called back and they said they would just refund the money that the driver got into an accident. I understand if this true and me not getting my food, what I don't understand is why they kept waiting for me to contact them for any information on my food, I could've ordered from somewhere else and maybe give them another chance but nah read more

Stopped had a slice was good. Started getting delivery it's been good fast and reasonably priced. What I've been looking for in the area proper Brooklyn pizza place. read more

I'm giving it 4 stars because the pizza is better than most of the others in Flatbush -- especially than those of South Flatbush/Flatlands/Midwood -- but compared to Manhattan pizza, it would only get 3 stars. They have an issue with their delivery service, though. I've ordered from them before on a weekday evening (sometime around 6pm), and the service was fine; it took about 45 minutes to an hour, which was fair considering I live pretty far south of the restaurant. However, the delivery this second time around on a Sunday night (albeit Labor Day Weekend) took almost TWO HOURS. (I ordered at 8:34pm, the pizza arrived at 10:20pm, and I was yelled at for calling twice at the 1 hour and 1.5 hour marks to check on the delivery time.) The pizza was lukewarm by the time it got here, and I had to put it in the microwave for a few seconds to get it back up to standard. That being said, if you're craving a slice and live within 2 miles of the place, it's the one you'll want to order from. Maybe just pick it up, though. read more

This is probably the most best pizzerias in the Church /Flatbush area I'm not a tough food cridet but a lot of pizziara or ordinary food establishments are bogus they just take your money for disgusting food , I work on foster so from all the let downs I had I gave this one a try & I'll tell you my honest opinion the slices are great .. it's a nice wet BROOKLYN Pizza I enjoyed it the chicken parm sandwich was also good the only con with what I had is I didn't like the beef patty at all but everything was freshly made , & the service was good read more

:-( Must be under new management. The only thing nice I got to say now is that the pizza was hot. I ask for thin crust, got think and it hurt my delicate stomach. Never again. #whysomethingsgottochange?? read more

I recently started working in the area and let me tell you the best n quickest pizza to get I have finally found my spot the slice was melts and warm n toaaaaasty!! read more

First of all Angelos pizza is over price it's not original Italian pizza it's horrible it's only good when you're really hungry because you don't know what Italian food really taste like the guy that took over from the father or the grandfather is a horrible customer service person he's rude and there's no reason for him to be there. That's his grandson the pizza was horrible I called to tell the grandson he's so rude and nasty he didn't care that I was disappointed with my food. Customer service is very important. read more

Great service great pizza .I been there a few time now the best on flatbush for sure have that old school vibe going

Fast and reliable and they gave free zippolis too . If you are in Brooklyn please Order from Angelo pizza . You will not be disappointed

Terrible service! We ordered a pizza at 6.50pm and it was supposed to be delivered between 7.30 and 7:40pm. We called at 7.50pm and was told that the delivery is a minute away. We called back at 8.15 and was told "they tried to get to us but couldn't." When I asked for clarification the guy on the phone said "I don't know what to tell you." Well, I know what to tell anyone thinking about ordering from this place, this was one of the WORST customer service experiences I have ever received. I will never order from here again and suggest others do not either. read more

Angelo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I will never spend my money at this establishment again! I have been coming here for over 2 years and the food was always good and the guys were nice and friendly. Last week I placed a relatively small order for delivery, waited almost 2 hours for it to come and to my surprise HALF of the order was missing. I called them and was told by a man that doesn't speak good English he does not know anything and I have to call back in 3-4 hours when the owner was around. I ended up packing up the food and taking it to them directly where I was yelled and cursed at by the old man behind the counter! Even after I explained what happened and had the food to prove it he called me a liar and said he cannot open the register until the owner came (in another 4 hours - which was right at the time they would close). I was furious and would not accept that. After 20 mins of arguing one of the cooks from the back came out and spoke to me nicely, apologized and refunded my money. After the huge mix up, lack of attention and HORRIBLE service I received I will never return or do business with them again, nor will my family or colleagues in the area (we ordered a large pie every Friday for the office) but no more. They lost several customers. read more

TERRIBLE PLACE WITH TERRIBLE PEOPLE. Ordered pizza and waited until it had been over 1 hr 30 mins before calling the restaurant, well over the estimated time. I was apologized to and told the delivery man was on his way. It was all fine until someone took the phone & started telling me it was my fault, and I shouldn't have ordered from them because I live "very far away". Which, if they think that way, they should re-adjust their delivery perimeter instead of turning away a customer who has already paid. An additional 20 mins goes by & we decide to call Grubhub. Grubhub tells us they are going to have a discussion with them due to their lack of professionalism. While on the phone with Grubhub, they call us saying they don't have the soda we ordered. I stop and ask, "how are you figuring this out if the delivery man left 20 mins ago?" That resulted in an additional backlash claiming 8pm is rush hour...which is just insane. I'm already hungry and angry. Don't add to it by lying again. Delivery guy shows up and decides he has to tell his side and clear his name before letting me have the pizza. In fact, I get scolded for reaching for the pizza I have now waited 2 hrs and 20 mins for because I have to hear him out. There's no way he wasn't stoned on something. This is a family neighborhood with kids and the fact that he's driving around like that is deplorable. We ordered a large and it's much smaller than any other large pizza I've seen. read more