Being that Originals on Ave L is the pizza I grew up with, it is still my favorite slice that I often crave. I try to make it by at least once a year. (Honestly I'm not that far away I'm being dramatic) Most recently I stopped in for a slice (had 2) couldn't resist it was just as delicious as I remember. I also bought 3 tshirts ! Red punch too! Writing this makes me want to go back soon. read more

Original Pizza - Best pizza ever - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The food is better than the pizza. Parking makes it difficult to dine there. I didn't find the counter staff very friendly and stopped dining here. read more

I have tried this location a few times over the years and for some reason the pizza tastes like something is missing. There is another location Ralph and there's pizza is to die for. I'm not sure if they are still connected but I prefer the other location. But if you are close and want a quick bite they are friendly and have indoor seating read more

So I'm walking up the block, and I notice that the local pizzeria has Santa Claus spray-painted on their storefront wearing a red MAGA hat that says "Make America Great Again," along with something mentioning "Zohran"--which I don't even know what that is. But my question is: when did politics start crossing paths with restaurants? I always thought businesses were supposed to remain neutral. I stopped going to that pizzeria even though I'd been going there since I was a young girl. The turning point was when I spoke to the owner and he openly told me he was voting for Trump because he didn't want the minimum wage to go up. He said he didn't want to pay his workers any more money. That disappointed me deeply. The way the world is right now--everything going up except our pay--you would think a business owner would want to take care of their employees. If you want people to work well, you have to treat them well. I was very disappointed in the pizzeria, in his attitude, and honestly surprised by his stance, especially with him also being a man. You would expect someone from a marginalized group to be sensitive to certain issues. But clearly, that wasn't the case. He will never get my business again. read more

Original Pizza - Santa clause wearing a hat saying make American what happened to Santa original Hat ??? - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

A Staple in Canarsie. I grew up on this pizza and Original pizza is my go to for a Brooklyn style slice .

What a peculiar establishment. They charge $4.25 (!) for one slice. A slice that is often very thin, but always dripping with oil. Last time (and I mean the LAST time) I was there, I was given napkins which I used to sop up the oil. Napkins with Trump on them, along with an adjacent QR code. Hmmm. Is that something people look forward to seeing when they go to a pizza place nowadays? Or any days? Doubt it. Keep your beliefs to yourself. Just. Make. Pizza. read more

tried square slice. Disappointed . Bread tasted like wonder bread from supermarket. Used to be much better

Great pizza!!!!!! Regular slice with fresh garlic is always delicious. Definitely must try.

Kinda disgusted with them TODAY. My son went and got some slices 2 were with sausage and two were supp osed to be veggie. Didn't like the presentation of the sausage and the veggie was not good at all. I was so hyped about getting thia all week and the veggie had some type of meet on it I gave it to my dog because she eats anything and I couldn't describe it SMH read more

Original Pizza - Supposed to be a veggie pizza with some kind of meat on it did not like it at all - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

FAMILY'S FAVORITE SPOT FOR OUR FAVORITE FOOD! Alway hot, never just ready! Because it's fleshly made, and delivered shortly after! Tried to UberEats pizza one night since we didn't have cash, won't mention they're name, but we were left highly disappointed and upset. I vowed from that day to NEVER order pizza from anywhere else! If we don't have cash, we go to the ATM and enjoy our pizza, ALWAYS! Thank you for the consistency! Particularly during this time, having something consistently pleasing is a real treat! read more

Absolutely amazing pizza been coming here for year's it seems to be getting better and better every time

​I stopped by here for lunch and ended up getting a couple of square slices. I thought they were ok and nothing great. The crust had a nice crunch to it. It's pizza but nothing special. Cash only. The place is clean and there is plenty of seating. read more

Original Pizza - two slices of pizza and a drink - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This Pizza shop is a neighborhood staple. It's been around since my childhood. This is the go to pizza spot I'm Canarsie. There's metered parking available and it's accessible by MTA public transportation nearby. The service is quick they'll greet you and get your order right all the time. It's a family dinner business too. I usually get my pizza to go. The pizza is very good. The sauce is tasty and robust. The crust is thin and the pizza has an overall great traditional NY flavor to it. Check out this spot when you're in the area read more

Original Pizza - Regular Slices - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is your neighborhood pizzeria with tons of history and a gem to those who grew up in the area. I LOVE pizza and this is Babes' favorite spot to order pizza from in Canarsie. So I'm a fan of the garlic knots and artificial "pineapple drink" which always hit the spot for me. Unfortunately, everything else isn't as consistently good. Solid slices with decent sauce and a good amount of cheese but always taste like they are missing something. If you are in the area, have extra cash to spare and want to seat down for a quick slice then definitely stop by. The service is prompt. Price point is on the high side for a pizzeria. I will be back and continue to try something new in hopes that something on the menu will truly knocked my socks off. read more

Original Pizza - Oblong Pepperoni Pie - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Every time my travels bring me to Canarsie in Brooklyn I make it a point to stop by Original Pizza of Canarsie. It is by far the best pizza around. I hear of places that claim to have the best pizza and after I try them I realize nobody beats this place. But forget about the pizza for a minute, the Sicilian and the grandma slices are even better. They are both so good you can eat the whole pie. The Sicilian is flaky and crunchy and has the best crust I have ever had. Not the big wad of dough that you get in most places. Every time I come I'm torn between the two, so I have to get both. They are stupendous! read more

Original Pizza - The best damn Sicilian I have ever had - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

My husband grew up eating this pizza as a child. We love returning for slices and reminiscing about his youth growing up in Canarasie. We have now taken both of our sons back whenever we return for a trip to explore the city. The neighborhood has changed but it's awesome to see this pizzeria thriving all these years. It's honestly a gem and true NYC-style pizza. Their freshly made mozzarella and marinara are the best read more

See all

Love this pizza shop It's a staple for the floss, growing up couldn't go without grabbing a slice after school or on a hot summer day. I have no complaints yes the food has changed but it's still yummy I remember back in the days the guys who ran the shop were og Italians I don't think anyone can touch them but as it still stands original pizza is the best pizza in the floss read more

I placed an order over the phone today and the experience was so pleasant. Its everything of what I receive in person. I can tell that they appreciate their customers and that they truly love what they do. Their customer service is a win EVERY time! It could be all about the food if they wanted; when you talk about a business the customer service is a must for me, but the food is equally as important and never misses the mark! If you want to prove a point about what a NY slice can do for the soul - this'll help you win the argument. Period. read more

So this is def the best pizza in Canarsie. I've been coming here for over 10 years. The slices have been pretty consistent. A tiny bit too oily for me but I still eat it. The garlic knots are yummy. They're always busy but the wait time isnt bad. Plenty of seats and tables to choose from if you want to dine in. read more

Original Pizza - Waiting for our slices - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I've only ever had the plain pizza and garlic knots here and they're very good. When it's right out of the oven the hot gooey cheese and crust is superb. It has the right amount of salt, and the sauce is tasty. This place beats a lot of the pizzerias in the city. Their service is also great as I sometimes order 10+ pies for work and they have it ready in 30 minutes. They also asked if I need plates and napkins and always provide plenty. Only thing is they don't like to take credit cards, so I need to make sure I have cash for 10+ pies. read more

This place is cash only. I was in the neighborhood for the weekend and my friend told me about the chicken rolls here. Really tasty pockets of chicken parm+ cheese with good flavors. The prices and menu items they have online are not reflected in the store, so coming in, you might not get what you expect. Call ahead. Kind of expensive for what it is, but I enjoyed the pizza dough and the cheese. read more

Original Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I'll start off by giving woke Yelp 0 stars for not including this place when I typed in pizza. Instead leading me to another pizza shop that looked suspect. I asked the locals which led me here. Seems like I don't need yelp anymore. As far as Original Pizza, had a regular slice and a spinach roll. Both were excellent. Well prepared and fresh. Service was friendly and quick. They're still not allowing in door dining. read more

Best pizza in canarsie. Penne a la vodka is really good too along with the grilled chicken ceasar salad. Always good service. I vome here about every other week. Only complaint is that its crazy expensive. But thats the price you pay for really good food. read more

Original Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Loved Originals since I was a kid, pizza is delicious and the service is great. Whenever I visit home, I make sure to hit up this spot. read more

Original Pizza - Cheese Pie - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Every time I go in there there is someone who has their mask under their nose. This is a year until the virus. One time a kid putting paper plates and napkins. And breathing on it all Another time a cook. And the manager stuck up and said they were 700 degree ovens. No. That is foods safety. The could be fine up to $1000. They need to cool down step outside. This is the coolest kitchen I have ever been in. And yes. I am a Culinary graduate. I am not going in their no matter how many years I have gone there. You can not speak to the owner. I know the owner will not be happy when he reads this. . So this is to you... the owner. Your manager should not be in customer service. And apparently he does not care about food safety. They also allow People in with no mask or mask under their nose. They must me. And they are slapping the face of first responders who are taking care of so many who do not wear their mask. Shame on this place a community restaurant. read more

Original Pizza is really the only pizza shop in the area so it's very popular. The pizza is very regular and nothing special. Hits a quick pizza fix if you have a need for one. $3 for a cheese slice was kind of wild though. read more

The pizza here is sooooo good! Like seriously. I've been to this place a few times since I live in the area and I am always satisfied! My daughter loves the pizza from here too! They have pretty good customer service and they are usually really fast paced. When you walk through the door they acknowledge you immediately (which all places SHOULD do) and they like to get their customers in and out in a timely manner. I ordered two slices from here earlier this week and I was not disappointed! They also have all the toppings at the counter that you could think of. The only con I have is that the place does look a little dingy. Could use some new uniforms for the staff and some updates. read more

Original Pizza - Delicious!!! Sorry I took a bite first... couldn't wait! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

You know it must be good when it's a weeknight, after 9pm and there is a constant stream of people coming in. Was in Brooklyn for a wake, wanted some famous Brooklyn slices before I went home. Very good. Just know it's cash only, and no alcohol. Really wanted a beer with my slice. read more

Original Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best Pizza in Brooklyn, definitely original. I usually never eat the crust but the entire pizza is delicious Definitely recommend this spot. I give them Five stars read more

Original Pizza - My mom and I love stopping in to have this tasty original Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We always order from them when we celebrate birthdays. The pizza is always hot and fresh and absolutely delicious! One of the best in Brooklyn, hands down. It also doesn't hurt that you don't have to have cash on hand for deliveries as they will take card information over the phone. How convenient! read more

This is my SPOT!!! Every time I visit my mom in Brooklyn, I grab a pie. To me it's the perfect pie, service is great and quick! No nonsense, no frills just a great pie! read more

1000% hands down the best pizza in Brooklyn! I've been eating here since my childhood & i have had tried several different places. Original's is really one of a kind read more

This place is a landmark already! It's well known....I use to go with my hubby. It was good big slice's not my favorite and they use to have really good Ice's too read more

Pizza is inconsistent. Sometimes thick, other times so thin there are holes in it. Sometimes tasty, other times so greasy I have to soak up the oil with a napkin. Which I find extremely gross. And at $4 a slice, no longer the pizza place for my family. read more

Service is always pleasant, but sad to say the pizza here has fallen off. Very bland no flavor in the sauce even after adding spices. The price for a regular slice is just absurd $4.25?!?! read more

Best puzza in Canarsie hands down !!!!! Wish they would Julienne fresh oregano instead of using whole leaves though read more

Went here for my sons birthday . He wanted their buffalo pizza. We ordered 4 pies. This place is always busy. It is cash only . I read a review and it spoke about cards etc. Thats wrong they only do cash. Any way because I called the order in - it was ready quickly with in my arrival. The staff is friendly and nice. This pizza is worth the travel from queens to brooklyn. Yup that good . Also try the garlic knots or pepperoni rolls. You wont be disappointed. read more

I had time to kill awaiting the arrival of a flight at JFK, so rather than sit in a cell phone lot, I pulled off the Belt and headed into Canarsie, Brooklyn. After a walkaround on Canarsie Pier, I headed into town looking for some real Brooklyn pizza. Original Pizza was nearby on Avenue L, and I found a parking space almost directly in front. It was a pretty big place with plenty of sitting room and a large working kitchen behind the glass counter. I ordered two plain slices and a Cherry Coke and waited for the reheat to be ready. The slices were large with an excess of mozza oozing over the edges. The crust was firm and crunchy, although not overly tasty. There was a constant oil drip from overuse of an olive oil finish and the sweating cheese. It wasn't the best introduction to the home of the pizza pie, although it was good enough for a local parlor in the neighborhood. Perhaps a freshly made pie would showcase their talent more than a 2 slice and drink special, but this was a cornerstone of their menu, and should represent their core competence in pizza making. Don't let pies sit around for hours, and the result could be improved. Staff was fine. Place was clean enough. Price was about right @ $6.50 for the meal. Wouldn't hurry back. Loved the double parking thing. That thing could get ugly. read more

Original Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I must admit is the best pizza you will ever eat in NYC. I just don't get is the sauce or the cheese. Is hard to pick, because the combination taste sooooooo good! Is hard to say, "one slice please...," because after that you will end up eating a pie afterwards. Pros: Good service Great whole pizza pricing Fast delivery Friendly Cons: No credit card machine unless you charging a high amount read more

The pizza is good. The crust is baked to perfection and the cheese isn't overwhelming. It's a neighborhood fixture and I've been coming here forever. Ingredients are fresh and its tasty as I said prior. Swing by and try a slice or two (because who can really only eat one slice) read more

Original Pizza - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York