The Pizza Good is good , Prices for pies are great , All good . Location been around for myself 40 years

On Saturday, I knew I would need garlic bread for dinner but didn't want to wait until then to order. So about 3 o'clock while I'm still running around in the neighborhood but almost finished, I walked to order it. I went in about 25 minutes later, and it was all bagged up. read more

See all

The best grill chicken Cesar salad I can't stop eating that salad everyday Sorry when I take the pic the chicken was gone already read more

Caterina Pizza - a hand holding a bowl of salad - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I have had better. Ordered the other day. The food came pretty quickly and it was decently priced but it was lacking. The pizza pie lacked sauce, either that or they watered the sauce down. This is the worst thing you can do to a slice. Only 2 slices in and I couldnt have more. I started to feel the gag reflex coming on. But thats just me. The zeppole were either old and over cooked and saturated with oil or just over saturated and itbtasted like it had seasoning in it. The Mozzarella sticks were ok. Nothing that made itbstand out from other places but thw Marinara sauce was 100 precent great. On Slice this place was rated 5 stars. On google 4 stars on yelp 4 stars so I took a chance but it definitely isnt for me. One of the reviewers said that before they changed owners the food was way better, unfortunately this is my first time so I have nothing to compare it to but based on the recent order, I probably wont order from them again. read more

I've lived two blocks away from this place for YEARS & I've eaten here about 1,000 times +. My elementary school would gift us a slice and a drink for being good students and it added to my love for Caterinas. No other pizza store in New York can compete. Today, I got blessed to have delicious vegetarian pizza with parmesan cheese and a garlic crust for lunch. If you rated this place poorly--please, give the place another try. Come in on a Tuesday's &/or Thursday's for lunch and I am SURE you won't be disappointed. read more

Caterina Pizza - A delicious vegetarian pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is an update to my last review from 2013. As I have previously mentioned, I grew up eating Caterina. Their pizza was always amazing, however, I wasn't very pleased because it didn't taste the same to me. I have recently started ordering from them again and have been very happy with the food. The pizza has been consistently good, as I remember from years ago. The chicken and shrimp parm have been absolutely delicious! Maybe it was a fluke a few years ago but I'm so happy to enjoy Caterina's food again, as I did growing up! Thanks Vito! read more

quick stop pizzeria. this place has been around for over at least 20 years! Back when I was a child, it was really good. A few years ago something changed and the pizza is not so good. My guess is....cheap cheese....or just plain cheap ingredients. Also the customer service has went completely downhill. Rude, grimy looking counter help. I tried to stick with this place until a couple of years ago when the counter dude got super rude with my honey. NOT worth it at all. Its been the same owner since I was a child as far as I know, so would be nice to support this business but there are just to many negatives. Menu: typical pizzeria menu, never any type of good selection with the pizza slices. they have heroes, hot dishes like chicken cutlet parmigiana and baked ziti, calzones, chicken rolls and there zepoles are pretty good when they have them. Price is okay, 5-10 bucks for hot dishes. pies are 13-15 bucks, hero's are 5 or 6 bucks. street parking only. they deliver read more

Yep this place is legit, two slices and a large drink for 7 bucks, the pizza is excellent here, this place was built in 1978 and looks like it never changed, to me that is a good thing, in contrast to more contemporary pizza shops. If I am in the area will go here again. This is why Brooklyn is famous for pizza, old school pizza shops like this one. No frills just great slices and a guy who really makes great pies. read more

Excellent service, excellent food.. A lot of cheese!!!! Yummyyyy FAST DELIVERY. Their lasagna and pizza are excellent, and by the way a lot of food by plate!!! read more

I've been going here since I was a kid. The food isn't as good as it used to be but it's still decent nyc pizza. My biggest issue here is the owner can be weird. Sometimes he's super friendly and other times he's yelling at people to get out of the store-literally. They've had the same owner since I was a kid and he never used to do that...it's like he's off his meds sometimes or something. Turnover is very high so I have to think he treats his employees erratically as well. read more

Ok so they've been closed down for a little I'm guessing vacation if ur really hungry order n pick up delivery takes pretty long but when I tell u the food is amazzzzzzingggggggg and filling. read more

Caterina Pizza - Baked ziti with ricotta omg the best!!! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is a long overdue review from 1982-1985 when I was introduced to the concept of pizza in the U.S. Back then, this pizzeria was run by Sal and Vito. The 2 partners would alternate where one would work one week and the other the next. I deliberately timed my visits when Sal was working since I preferred his pizza's flavoring and texture. Back then, it was 75 cents a slice and $5 a pie for a plain cheese 16 plus in deal, what a bargain! Seeing they are still here, I will make a note to stop by next time I visit NYC Brooklyn for a trip down memory lane. read more

Was introduced to this place about 8 yrs ago ny people that had been going there for, may be 20 years. One of the best pizza. The older gentleman is the original owner and the crew is very nice. read more

Great pizza ! I think this pizzeria has been here for decades. Only local shop for blocks. It's in between the J train of Cleveland and Norwood. A slice is about $2.25. It's a bit expensive but the slices are larger than regular and Taste great. A large pie is $13 which is a good price for hand made and only $2 more for extra cheese. I don't see myself coming here a lot. It's only one of those things I get if I'm with family or friends or if I crave it. read more

Caterina Pizza - The paper tri fold menu. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Been here a few times, heroes are great the meals come with a lot of food food! I'm addicted to the garlic bread but most of all the Pizza is better than most spots you'll find in Brooklyn. Oh and the price is fair, you won't be getting ripped off. read more

Caterina Pizza - Only place in cypress hills you can get one of these guys. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Horrible customer service. I ordered a chicken cutlet sandwich and a regular slice. There was no one there. It got crowded with customers after 5 min. While I patiently waited for my food, they took a few orders including a group of officers that walked in and served a customer a slice (that I was already waiting for, not too big of a deal). What pissed me off is that after waiting over 20 min, the group of officers were served a fresh pie while I was still waiting on my slice and chicken sandwich. How??! That was ridiculous and rude. I didn't even bother waiting for my food and walked out. read more

I recommend the penne vodka. The pizza is soggy and the pepperoni rolls have more cheese than actual pepperoni.

The pasta and pizza are good The older gentleman is very very nice. So are his crew. This place has been here since I was in H.S 20 yrs ago.

I am VERY picky about pizza so take this with a grain of salt But I'm not a fan. The tomato sauce was bland and minimal and it was too cheesy and dripped oil. It also folded over and wouldn't keep it's shape. All this said, it's not the worse pizza and the guy behind the counter is nice but I havent yet found a good pizza spot in cypress hills read more

We order baked ziti it was so delicious and the best part it was only 6 dollars. The owner is friendly. read more

Caterina Pizza - Baked ziti - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

You can't go wrong with the pizza from caterina. This maybe the only pizzeria around the neighborhood that is worth buying. The beef patties with cheese were also good. read more

i love the pizza here is\ good but the only thing that i dont like about the pizza is that it doest have enough sauce and im a sauce lover so it taste like dry pizza which i actually dont like staff is really friendly my baby sis loves the pizza here love it delicious yummyyyyyyyyy yea you got that yummy yummy yummy yummy yummy yummy :} read more

Not much to say. It's a pizza shop. The pizza is good. The music was. Skittle louder than I like but that's a personal thing. The shop isn't cute or anything but they seem to have a lot of choices, seating and the food is good. They have Apple Pay. read more

I always order delivery from here, one of the best pizzas around cheese or pepperoni. Their Pastas are also good

The best pizza in the neighborhood by far. Caterina's pizza is a family owned pizza shop which has been around for years and after on slice you will see why. The pizza has jus the right amount of everything. They also have a ziti which is awesomely delish. You have the option to call for pick up in eat in or have you food delivered. I suggest ordering before you really get hungry because delivery sometimes takes a while. Totally recommend Caterina's Pizza you can't go wrong. read more

I 've had pizza here for last 10+yrs but recently have been a little disappointed. Pizza has been delivered sticking to box and sometimes on cooler side! read more

Very great pizza place. Their pizza is amazing and the people working there are nice. The place is clean and nicely organized. They have a large menu selection with reasonable prices. They accept credit cards as well as Apple Pay. Minimum purchase to use credit card is $10.00. Highly recommend. read more

My boyfriend's brother at one time worked at Caterina's decades ago. This is a mom and pop pizzeria which I love. Their pizzas are delish! My favorite is the mushroom pizza and Sicilian slice. The beef patties are good too! read more

I've eaten at this restaurant since I was a boy it felt really good to bring my son here, BEST PIZZERIA IN BK,BY(& NY,NY) HANDS DOWN!!

I have been ordering from here forever. Extra cheese and pepperoni, calzones salads boom shockalaka. Great look

It use to be good pizza but my last experiences were not as great! Cold pizza and old cheese! The cheese stunk!

I went there 1/21/2014 and ordered Baked ziti with ricotta cheese during the snow storm. this dish was extremely delicious to cater to my taste buds. I enjoyed every fork full. And am looking to return upon my next visit to New York City from Norwich, CT. This place of business is on my speed dial and i am in NYC weekly. Keep up the good work. the staff was pleasant as well as there service. read more

Love them! Order all the time, yummy tomato sauce. I love their vibe, reminds me of the pizzerias I went to when I was a kid growing up here. Nice people too. read more

I've been going here about 7 years I love the place The food is excellent and the customer service is great I like the Baked ziti

My son and I love going there, but when we see that the owner is not there we just keep it moving! The food is definitely good and fairly priced. But again, when the owner is not there do expect to pay more, as it's obvious that they charge more when he's not around. And it's ot the regular employees doing it, it's his relatives. They're gonna run that place into the ground!!! read more

After moving out to Broadway Junction I quickly realized that there are very few decent dining options in the area, that's why this is such a great find, and they can deliver to me on Vanderveer! I can't say if it compares with the best pizzerias in all of Brooklyn but it's way better than anything I can get delivered from Bushwick. The ricotta I got on my pie was excellent quality, good crust too... read more

- Tonight i decided to stop and get a slice and i first comment when i walked in was how clean it was but my mind changed quickly. The employees didn't even attempt to wash their hands and i witnessed the employee drop cooking tools on the floor and and without washing it he just placed it back on the table. That will not only be my first time there but also my last. read more

I just needed some Cheap food and thats exactly what i got. the order was quick but i wasnt too impressed with the quality and the service. I dont think i'll be coming back anytime soon. Not impressed at all. read more

Pizza was good but gosh darn it, it took the delivery guy 45 min to get to my house. I should've picked it up instead because it was only a 5 min drive time. read more

i like the peperoni pie that they mak, other than that it's an average pizza shop