I'm inclined to state that Noodle Pudding has been around for quite some time. Unfortunately with no website available (at least I couldn't find it online), I'm unable to actually note when they were established. In addition, I saw some conflicting menu prices and food selections through third party websites which added to some confusion. Here's the lowdown. My friend and I were enjoying a nice (albeit unseasonably somewhat chilly June) afternoon in the DUMBO area. DUMBO with its charming cobblestone layout is a haven for many great restaurants. I was showing my friend around and when a few other options became unavailable as far as dinner was concerned, we landed at Noodle Pudding---actually we were the first ones to arrive. The atmosphere/interior was adorable with exposed brick, a small bar and many tables. Yet, once prime time dinner rolled around, you will find people waiting on a line for a table. All the windows were opened for a semi-al fresco dining experience and as such, we chose a prime table. It didn't take too long afterwards for the entire restaurant to fill up quickly--it's that popular. My friend and I settled for wine by the glass. A rose was only $7 while the house white was $5.00. Great deal. Ciabatta bread was served with a nice side of bruschetta toppings in a small bowl. I nearly devoured two of those small bowls! For starters, we shared a Fritto Misto--with a twist (I'm accustomed to the zucchini sticks that I've always enjoyed)--fried calamari, fried anchovies and fried Shishito peppers (spicy). This was plentiful and quite delicious served with a side of spicy mayo. For main--we selected the same dish which was Rigatoni Siciliana This was pasta combined with tomatoes, roasted eggplant and fresh ricotta. Absolutely filling and tasty. We enjoyed our meal very much. I didn't leave a drop behind on my plate. A few things to note: *no reservations for parties under 6 *cash only (this usually annoys me as I like the option of either cash or credit cards especially if prices are somewhat average/high (and this was true for Noodle Pudding) *open at 5:30 PM for dinner *only one unisex restroom (another slight inconvenience) Because we arrived super early for dinner, there was no wait time; however, I'm not one to stand on line endlessly for a table which is why I'm happy to have experienced Noodle Pudding considering it was my first time. Good food, atmosphere and service. One to try. read more

See all

Best Pasta in Brooklyn!! Please keep in mind that they are Cash only. Not an issue as there is an ATM down the block! The Casio e Pepe was amazing as was everything else we had! Rigatoni with meatballs and Sausage with some Basil and Ricotta as on point! Very filling! Everyone there from the host, to the server to the manager were so welcoming! Can't wait to go back to Brooklyn! read more

Noodle Pudding - Cacio e Pepe and Rigatoni Alla Siciliana - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Excellent service and food was excellent! Noodle pudding was excellent as well as all our pasta and braised ribs. What a wonderful place and service. Lovely atmosphere. Felt like we were family. Highly recommend! Waiter was as so attentive and friendly. read more

Truly my favorite restaurant in Brooklyn (and New York). The food and people are special.

Great place for young people. Older people may feel - on a Saturday night - like they're eating on the runway at JFK or on the platform of the 14th Street subway station. The crowd noise was loud and then the staff turned the music up. I could not hear my dinner companions. read more

Everything I had today was impeccable, starting from the tensor grilled octopus, fried calamari and shishito peppers and anchovies, pappardelle with mushroom and spinach, chicken cutlet, and finished strong with panna cotta. Everything was fresh and hit the note. Boy, must come back! read more

Excellent Excellent Excellent Great food Great Service Great Atmosphere From the waiter to server to busboy... This place is EXCELLENT HIGHLY Recommended Can't wait to go back .... read more

A classic NYC Italian joint in Dumbo, Brooklyn. Noodle Pudding is a word-of-mouth, all cash restaurant that somehow still doesn't have a website in this digital age, but don't let that deter you. Come here for quality ingredients, large portions, and affordable prices. read more

Overall: great service, delicious food, big portions, GET SPICY GARLIC BREAD. Also cash only. Atmosphere: soft lighting, large and small tables, feels like an authentic local Italian spot. Price: average nyc $$ paid around $40 per person on a date. Portions are very large and they do not skimp on seafood though! Tuna steak: largest tuna steak I've been served in nyc. Comes on a big salad with capers and other veggies. Seafood ragu fettuccine: YES. First Raghu I've had that hasn't tasted only like tomato sauce. The seafood really shines in this and they have so many different types of fresh clams and seafood. Spicy Garlic bread: TO DIE FOR. Both extremely buttery and saucy but also really crunchy-this was the winner of our dinner. read more

Antonio, the chef-owner, does a fabulous job ensuring each delectable dish is done right. Be aware it is cash only. It is a very popular place so either arrive early 5-6:00 PM or be prepared to wait. Everything I have eaten here has been very tasty. There is a good wine list but the house red wine is fine and very inexpensive at $5 a glass or $15 for a bottle. They make their own pasta. Whole wheat or gluten free pasta can be ordered for a small extra charge. The only negative is that it tends to get noisy. read more

See all

Amazing amazing My friend and i just left and we can't wait to return ! We entered and were greeted with such a warm welcome by the friendly Daniel and we were served Dave - who was nothing short of wonderful! He provided great suggestions and we paired our dishes with a crisp vermentino! I selected the Ravi parpadelle and my friend selected a bean pasta dish. She didn't like it but this bitch complains about everything - shocker! We will be returning ! See you soon! read more

Absolutely one of my favorite restaurants in Brooklyn. The vibe is like the local Italian restaurants you went to as an Italian in New York or New Jersey for every momentous family occasion. I bring my parents here often and it's also a great date spot. There is nothing extraordinary about the food or the wine, I've had some hits and some misses, but it's all very delicious and the atmosphere and service is so excellent, it doesn't even matter. I always recommend them and always hear great feedback. read more

Delicious and good sized plates. Nice outdoor seating! Not a fan of cash only but the wines are cheap.

On my trip to NYC, I wanted some Italian food and was recommended this place. As a heads up, it is cash only. I started with the kitchen sink salad which was absolutely delicious. When I asked the waitress what it was, she said it's just a mix of the vegetables the chef gets from the market that day. Whatever market he goes to must be amazing. Then I had the bruschetta and the bread was perfectly toasted and the ricotta on top tasted pretty fresh. After, I ordered the gnocchi with butter and sage. I literally did a happy dance it was so delicious. The gnocchi was creamy and they butter and sage enhanced the flavor of the gnocchi. When the waitress asked us where we lived in the city, we told her we were visiting from out of town and the owner, Tony, walked over, asked us how we liked the food, and asked the waitress to take care of us. We ended up with free watermelon and dessert! I have never been to a restaurant that has had such a home feeling and been so wonderful and welcoming. Highly recommend! read more

See all

This is 100% the best restaurant in Brooklyn Heights. The food was absolutely delicious and everyone there was so kind and friendly.

True regional food made with love and care. It's like a meal you would have in Italy. Staff also excellent. Great great experience read more

Friendly staff. Great food. Great all around neighborhood joint. You won't be disappointed.

Went to this restaurant while visiting Brooklyn. Slightly upscale and boisterous Italian place. As another reviewer stated, the average clientele does seem to be on the older and white side. My friend and I are two younger Asian women and as we looked inside it seemed like we were the only POC there, so I was slightly worried about being out of place. However the service was very good -- our waiter was very friendly, and every other server I encountered inside was great as well. We ordered the spicy garlic bread ($6), their risotto (around $29), and steak (around $33) to share. The garlic bread was very good but very spicy, so be warned. The risotto was also delicious, and there was a generous amount of shrimp in it -- in 2 scoops I counted 6 small shrimps. I thought the steak was cooked well but nothing amazing. For dessert we got the tiramisu to share ($8) and it was also very tasty and satisfied us both. So overall we were pretty happy. This place only takes cash, and the total for us after tax and tip was $100. read more

Noodle Pudding - Tiramisu - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I have had this place bookmarked forever and I am glad the restaurant was as awesome as I had hoped. The place seems like the quintessential neighborhood spot, it seems like the perfect gem everyone wished they had in their neighborhood and I am almost positive that most of the customers I saw that day were regulars. I also thought the decor was nice, it was very simple yet rustic and inviting. I would definitely try to come earlier since the restaurant gets super packed. The food: Crispy-Fried Wild Caught Whitebaits- This really reminded me of fried smelt but better. They were basically French fries of the sea, you eat the whole thing. You put a little squeeze of lemon and wham-o, happy stomach. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=8pRIHn6vocqhdRS5ZBMifg&userid=Y_iTTjKvV5hLy-880SZzlA Pappardelle w/ Wild Boar & Mushroom Ragu & Pecorino Shavings- The wild boar was my fav dish. The boar was so insanely tender and really reminded me of beef but with a slight gamy flavor. The noodles were really nice and they had a good mouth feel. However, I do wish the noodles were cooked a tad more and had a touch more sauce but overall a must order. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=5X4tsBm7iW3G0Pg3r-xkyA&userid=Y_iTTjKvV5hLy-880SZzlA Tagliata (Sliced "Fresh Meat" Prime Rib w/ Rock Salt & Rosemary- The steak was good, it was nice, tender and I really liked the whole roasted garlic bulb. I also really liked the salt they put on the steak, it was a good quality salt that went well with the steak. But, I did have issues with the end pieces being a tad tough and the slightly burnt flavor that lingered throughout the bites. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=CxIOwgchQln_CbQwPQC01w&userid=Y_iTTjKvV5hLy-880SZzlA Ricotta Cheesecake- The cheesecake was OK, it was kinda standard but I though the piece was really tiny. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=Wuqdg2recPawSSq-fV4KjQ&userid=Y_iTTjKvV5hLy-880SZzlA read more

See all

If there are no credit cards, then I want to see them share the savings. And that is what they do. Pricing is very reasonable for this high quality level. Tonight my wife and I began with Linda's salad that had crisp lettuce, a beautiful tomato slice, and parm in a light dressing. We next moved to eggplant, tomato, and mozzarella, but substituted fettuccini for macaroni. Pasta was fresh, perfectly cooked, and dusted with parm. We finished with the chicken cacciatore, with assorted wild mushrooms, sausage, and polenta. A rich, flavorful entree. The entire meal was perfection. It had been a good 5 years since our last visit, but we have fond memories of that meal as well. read more

See all

Great local spot with amazing pasta! Cash only, but totally worth the trip to an ATM hahaha. Also worth the wait! read more

See all

Absolutely amazing service, wonderful menu, and a great atmosphere. Relatively inexpensive for the area and a lot of changing seasonal dishes. Will definitely return. read more

we have loved this place since it first opened back when we lived in the neighborhood. Great comfy atmosphere, the amazing wall of windows they open up in nice weather and excellent service makes for an excellent experience. Very interesting wine list-- even the cheapest glass, which we tried on a whim, was tasty. House made pasta was scrumptious and the caprese-ish but even better salad special was perfect, well balanced flavors and so very fresh. Wish I had taken a photo. Bring cash, no credit, but so worth it! read more

All I have to say "TOURIST TRAP" be very careful with the menus they bring out, prices are doubled of what's posted on here or on their menu online, Also they only take cash, no receipt either, I think once they realize you are not local they pull out different menus with prices completely different everything in high $20s & $30s $40s, pasta dishes are just ok, don't get trapped. read more

I come here often since I have a family friend who knows the owner, and not once have I been disappointed! We always order the "Trust Me" menu, which is essentially a full course meal that lets the chef dictate what we're doing to eat. There are some consistently good options, and some surprising new variations, but I always leave full and satisfied. Some of the most memorable items that I've had: 1) the pasta (the flavor is amazing) 2) seafood (clams, mussels, fish, scallops, you name it, they're all good) 3) prosciutto (I remember there was one eggplant prosciutto dish that might've been one of the best things I've ever had) 4) the chocolate cake (each bite was heavenly if you're a chocolate lover) Lots of other goodness, but I'll let you explore it for yourself. They do traditional Italian justice. read more

The common saying "Don't judge a book by its cover" would seem to apply perfectly to Noodle Pudding. However, rather confusingly, Noodle Pudding doesn't even seem to have a cover to judge it by - there's no signage on the front of the store, no clues that inside these doors is a fresh, flavorful restaurant; almost as if you had gone home to your grandmothers and she had put out a place setting for anyone walking in off the street. While most restaurants try to burnish their family focused chops, Noodle Pudding puts it front and center, sourcing in ingredients from local farms in New Jersey and "proudly" not accepting credit cards. We had the fried zucchini flowers as an appetizer, filled with ricotta cheese and lightly fried mixing salty and sweet together. For a main course, I chose the Fettuccine with mussels, clams and shrimp in a shellfish ragu sauce. Amazingly spicy with a full plate of seafood, each piece almost falling out of the shell, and coated in the ragu sauce, I didn't stop eating until the plate was clean. Finally over cappuccinos and espressos, we shared a delicious sweet peaches and vanilla ice cream. read more

See all

I haven't had a meal out this satisfying in a long time. My friend suggested this place for dinner as she had a good experience the last time she dined here, and I must agree. The entire meal was absolutely delicious. That being said, here are some notes about this place: - They are only open for dinner - from 5:30pm - They only take cash - They don't take reservations for parties of 6 or less - They invite you to go and wait for a table After a 45 minute wait for a table, my three friends and I finally got settled into a nice, rear-alcove, corner table. Our waiter came by to recommend one pasta special, but said the rest was whatever was on the menu. We went completely with the menu items, decided to share everything, and ordered the following: - Razor Clams Oreganata (4) - Clean, delicate clam flavor, dressed with a crust of seasoned bread crumbs and a squeeze of lemon juice. Yummy starter! - Crispy-Fried NJ Whiting (2) - Two crispy-fried whole whiting. I took half of one whiting with the head and ate the entire head! That's how delicate this fish was! Delicious! - Fried Calamari with Spicy Aioli and Lemon Wedge - Crispy, nicely-battered, good texture/bite to the calamari without being too chewy. Nicely flavored Aioli to go along with it, but not spicy at all to my palate. - Hand-cut Linguini with Clams, Zucchini, Cherry Tomatoes and Fresh Pepper - Homemade, al dente pasta with fresh clams so clean that they were delicate in flavor. The zucchini and cherry tomatoes added another layer of freshness and texture. The entire dish together tasted more like a light pasta primavera because there was very little clam flavor coming from the clams. It could have used a dash of clam juice, but it was still good. - Pappardelle Alla Vaccinara (oxtail ragu) with Pecorino Shavings - Homemade, al dente pasta coated with oxtail meat stewed tender. A hearty, meaty, chewy, flavorful bite with each forkful. This has a heavier, comforting mouthfeel compared to the pasta dish above. I liked having both of these dishes as a contrast in flavors and textures. - Roasted Whole Porgy - What my friends and I especially liked about Noodle Pudding was all of their locally sourced seafood. Not only do you support local fisheries and eat sustainable species, you eat the freshest caught seafood! This whole roasted Porgy was perfectly cooked! Evenly cooked and slightly crispy skin enveloped flaky, white, tender meat. Simply seasoned with a few rosemary sprigs inside its belly, the meat was still moist but fell off the bones easily. I love fish head, so I picked all of best morsels off of the entire fish head, especially the eyes! Fish lovers will love this dish! Dessert was: - Ricotta Cheesecake - More of a floured cake than a cheesecake, this delicious slice had bits of candied fruit that you would typically find in Panettone. Lightly sweet and moist, it also had bits of lemony flavor, which likely comes from the Citron. A lovely dessert that I would order again. - Panna Cotta with Fresh Berries - Silky, lightly sweet, and light are the best three ways to describe Noodle Pudding's take on my favorite dessert. Everytime I see panna cotta on the menu, I always havta order it. This one did not disappoint! The fresh berries that went along with it were sweet and ripe. A great complement! Overall, I had a delicious time at Noodle Pudding. Needless to say, I will be returning for more. read more

See all

Good I would come again! Service in the location is fantastic and very attentive. Thank you!

This place is such a delight. I literal OLD Gem of BROOKLYN. This place should be a historical landmark. I've heard about this restaurant since I was teenager. Old school Italian spot. The food here is hands down the best Italian restaurant in Brooklyn. When you walk in it, it gives you that 80s Italian Soprano having dinner in the dining room vibes. Everything is good here. My favorite dish however is quite simple Cacio e Pepe. It was about 7 of us and we all got different dishes and they were all hits. Definitely a place to take family, a date. This is the time of place were you "Break Bread together."...If you know, you know. read more

Dropped by on Sunday for a 6pm dinner and the location was already jam packed with an hour wait. We managed to get seats at the bar, but definitely surprised at how many people were coming in and out and how busy the place already was for such an early dinner. A ton of families and from the conversations between the staff and the customers, a TON of regulars as well. Noodle pudding has a very homey, loud and lively vibe. The interior is quite cramped as well and there are some long tables that looked communal. They lay paper on the tables and saw customers bringing their own crayons to draw on them. Noodle pudding is cash only which feels a bit ridiculous given the menu items are in the $20+ range. For two people, we got two pastas with no appetizers or drinks, and it came out to $50+ total. Throughout dinner hours there was a pretty constant stream of people coming through waiting for tables, but never got mobbed or overwhelming. Service was a little spotty and very slow, and it felt like the staff were a bit frantic running around. They don't seem to have a website but the menu was different than the ones we had googled online. There is bread on the table that comes with a slightly spicy, tomato olive oil that was delicious. We had the cacio e pepe with short curly noodles (they looked like mini lasagna noodles). Very al dente and heavy on the pepe portion, in a generous portion. They also had a noodle dish in a mushroom ragu that was delicious as well - the mushroom was plentiful in different varieties but not overwhelming. Thought the pasta in the second dish had come a tad overcooked. There is also entrees with meat and fish options, although seemed like most of the tables were ordering pasta. Overall, really delicious pasta and very cozy, lively vibe. Not sure if I would wait an hour for the food here but if you catch Noodle Pudding on a less busy night would absolutely recommend dropping in. read more

Soup to nuts best meal--every time. Amazing cocktails, amazing wine. Fresh pasta and impeccable entrees in a friendly and inviting environment. LONG LIVE NP read more

My friend and I were craving some Italian food around DUMBO and I'm so happy we found this place! The wait was a bit long and it is CASH ONLY. We ended up going to sweetgreen and getting a salad to share before coming back for our reservation. I'm glad we also waited instead of finding another place because of the wait. Everything was super delicious and cooked perfectly. I was especially surprised with the seafood pasta. The seafood was lacking a bit (wasn't as fresh as it could be) but the pasta tasted completely homemade and super flavorful on its own, as if they cooked the pasta in some sort of broth instead of just regular water. The decor is also super cute in the front, you don't even feel like you're in NYC! read more

Noodle Pudding - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Noodle Pudding is a charming rustic Italian cafe with a neighborhood friendly vibe. The majority of its menu is stellar and the prices are affordable, especially considering the location in Brooklyn Heights. It is CASH ONLY and has virtually no signage, so it has absolutely no qualms with doing its own thing. They're family friendly and have a great location near Brooklyn Bridge to continue a nice evening out. On one particular date night we showed up at 6 pm - they do NOT take reservations - but we were lucky enough to get a great table to by the window immediately (which they open up to the street in summer months). Service is a bit rushed, but super knowledgeable and try to give you space to have a good time. We ordered: Tomatoes and stracciatella soft cheese Spaghetti and stewed octopus Salmon and escarole The meal was excellent, with very fresh ingredients, superb execution, quickly delivered plates, and a lovely crusty rustic loaf of bread to sop up all the leftovers. They offer lots of seasonal and daily specials, which is awesome. If you're in the neighborhood and the wait isn't longer than 20 minutes, I'd say this is a great option. read more

See all

This is a neighborhood Italian eatery in downtown Brooklyn just shy of the bridge overlooking Manhattan on the other side. I walked in around 6:30 PM and already it was filled to capacity. It fills up fast, so its best that you do call ahead for reservations as its a popular eating spot. I went with the Tagliatelle Boscaiola (wild mushrooms). It was such a aromatic and savory dish. The mushrooms had a distinct flavor to them and it seeped into the pasta. I requested to add extra grated cheese which added a creamy texture to the whole pasta. For dessert, I kept it simple tonite and went with the Ricotta cheesecake. read more

See all

This spot was delightful. The lasagna was just right and the environment made it that much worthwhile. Will come back again.

Noodle pudding is a bright, rustic restaurant near DUMBO with delicious and affordable Italian food. I can't comment on a ton of the food - everyone got the Cacio e Pepe! It was delish. Just enough cheese, asparagus, and we all got an egg in the middle (it was extra $). Service was awesome. We had a server who joked around with us and was overall very cool. We had some house vino with our meal, and bread is complimentary. A nice sit down spot after a walk across the BK bridge, or a night out with the ladies. Great bars nearby for after too. read more

Noodle Pudding - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Delicious pasta at a surprisingly affordable price for the city. We liked our green pasta with lemon a bit more than the special pasta we tried, but that's a bit of personal preference. Excellent fresh pasta overall though! Not sure why this place is cash only. It's definitely large enough that you would expect them to take credit cards. read more

See all

3.5 stars for food but rounding up because we had great service for our rowdy bunch and they happily took us in fairly late in the evening too. The cocktails we ordered weren't the greatest, a little harsh from lower quality liquor I assume, but they got the job done. We all ordered some kind of pasta dish and were satisfied enough. Amazingly, the garlic bread with Calabrian chili may have been my favorite part of the meal (it was really good!) while the arancini were a decent app as well. read more

Crazy name for a great restaurant! So warm and inviting and friendly. We thank Will, the awesome bartender, who made a tough day end so well with his service and professionalism and innate kindness. Nice salad starter, simply dressed with oil and balsamic on the side. Fresh cracked pepper. Simple. Delicious. Accompanied by some crusty bread with a nice red and yellow tomato nd herb dipping sauce. Tagliatelle with an orange tomato sauce and fresh herbs was light and fresh and exquisite. Total winner. Duck breast with a hint of fresh orange glaze was perfect temperature and rich. Total winner. Will suggested, and offered tastings of a couple of nice wines to accompany. Much appreciated, and the suggestions were spot on. Prices were fair. Food outstanding. Service exceptional. Ambiance warm and inviting. Cant wait to go back. Mille grazie! read more

Really enjoyed visiting this area of Brooklyn and trying out this Italian restuarant! The restaurant was decorated with a fall/Halloween theme inside that made it an even more fun and interesting place to eat. The service is what I call "typical" for an old school Italian restaurant, which means it was efficient but somewhat gruff. They bring bread and an olive oil dip to the table, but we also ordered the fried calamari for an appetizer. The calamari was pretty standard, nothing great or bad about it. We ordered the house wine to drink and for $15 it was surprisingly drinkable. With a group of friends I could easily see ordering a few bottles for the table and your wallet won't be in pain. For entrees we ordered a gnocchi with butter and sage sauce, and something similar to a rigatoni with short rib, ricotta, and basil (don't remember the specific name). The gnocchi had a perfect texture, but the sauce was very plain and could have used a lot more seasoning. The short rib ragu was excellent, and the ricotta was a perfect match with it. If I am ever in the area again I would definitely try this place again, and order some more of that cheap house wine and short rib ragu. read more

Noodle Pudding - House red wine - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all