I've been buying my slices from them for over 40+ years , they used to be open late before covid happened, so now I buy 2 pies instead of 1. They still cut the slices decent sized where others cut smaller to try and boost profits. These guys stay true and let their food speak for itself , they also make pasta dishes and sell ices and slushies too, they're a couple of doors down from the gun hill station on the 5 line , check them out they don't disappoint. read more

Pizza was good. The beef patty was good. Service was top-tier. Food is just too expensive in there other than that it's fine.

I've been getting pizza from Nick's for at least 20 years. I've always enjoyed the pizza. I visited recently after having moved. The guy at the counter was eating pumpkin seeds from his pocket. Him needing a snack wasn't the issue- He was spitting the shells wildly towards what I imagine to be a garbage can behind the counter. He then proceeded to take an order and grabbed a slice with the same unwashed hand that was putting pumpkin seeds in his mouth. Why does someone in the food service industry post-pandemic need to be told to WASH THEIR HANDS? I won't be back. read more

Not my go-to Bronx pizza place, but solid slices, classic NYC style. Every time I've went, they've been pretty generous with the cheese and slices are pretty nice-size. But at $4.50 a slice, it's definitely pricey. At $0.50 more, you're in Joe's on Carmine Street territory. The cheese, sauce and crust ratios pull the slice together pretty well and the slice hits the spot. The bottom of the slice isn't really crispy, but wasn't rubbery either. Again, to me it's just solid, standard NYC style. I got a half meatball pie the other day and it was more like a bolognese - chopped meat in a red sauce on top vs meatballs in the traditional sense, either chunks or sliced horizontally like is usually served. I wasn't really crazy about that type of meatball slice (if you consider it that), but it wasn't the worst. Those two pretty big points being the case (price and style of meatball pizza), I'd give them a three but I rate them a four star because they're open late (till 1am last I knew). So it's great for late night pizza. The guys that work there are pretty cut and dry, but nice. You pay a bit of a premium for what to me isn't really justified, but at the end of the day it's an overall good slice and open late read more

Nick's Pizza Restaurant - This is a reheated meatball slice. Cheese is good, solid slice - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

One of the best classic pizza places in New York. On the Gun Hill Road section of the Bronx. This place is classic. Its one of the best old school pizza places in New York. Its been open since 1970, 55 years in a city where many businesses don't last 55 days. Got to go here. read more

Good pizza and friendly service. We were given a recommendation by a friend so we came in and were happy we did. The sauce and crust are fantastic. read more

Love their pizza they use to be open late as well smh wish they still were open late till 1-3 am

So sad .. this used to be a premier pizza spot on the north east side of the Bronx and now it's rundown. The cuts of the slices are not consistent anymore. And to know that you're paying $4.50 for a slice and you may or may not get the right size of a slice is no longer worth it ... then you have a lot of men from shelters hanging around inside there and making it uncomfortable. And most of all the staff is very much so unsanitary. I watched as the same man who is handling the money, took those same hands and tried to serve me my pizza. I had to let him know that I will not accept that because he needed to wash his hands. read more

Nick's is a landmark pizza place that's been serving up uber delicious New York slices for over 55 years in this awesome part of The Bronx. A slice and a Coke after getting off the #5 train is a must do! read more

Absolutely the best pizza in the BX! Ordered a slice with extra cheese & Jamaican beef patty with cheese. Loveeeeeee the slice! Always on point. Patty was ok. read more

Nick's Pizza Restaurant - Slice with extra cheese...topped with garlic powder and Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

In town and needed some good NY Pizza and wasn't sure where to go. Google reviews brought me there and the service and flavor brought me here. When in town again and cracking NY style pizza Nick's will be my choice. read more

Nicks is an absolute CLASSIC! Mark my words, they've been around for literal decades.They have always been a superior quality, great customer service, freshest ingredients. As a self proclaimed "Pizza Snob" I can honesty say Nicks Pizza is who developed my love and pure affection for Pizza. I hate chain pizzas, I am a huge fan of what I call "street pizza" Nicks is what I consider "street pizza". Street pizza is what I define as home style local pizzeria type pizza. Huge slices slathered in a good amount of great sauce and a great amount of mozzarella. I think what set Nick's apart from other pizzerias is the cheese! Their Mozz is some of the best around, delicious and tasty. Nicks once burned down to the ground and built right back up to resume their regular greatness. I have been going to Nick's since I was 6 years old and probably before then. I am closer to 40 then I am to 30 now, so we have lots of history between us. Anytime I'm in my hometown, I make sure I stop in and pick up a slice with mushrooms and shredded sausage. To die for! The crust is soft and warm, thin but no too thin. They are plentiful on the cheese and not stingy with toppings. They almost always toast it right. Beef patties, calzones all made fresh on premises . In the summer the kids line up around the pick up window for Italian ice's. The staff has also grown with them, keeping the same guys employed since they were 18 years old and most who are now 45-50 years old, now THAT is consistency!! read more

The pizza here is pretty consistent and it's good. Pros: Pizza slices are big They add a lot of toppings The prices are reasonable Right next to the train station They keep late hours Guys are cool Pretty good selection of toppings Cons: Parking sucks They don't take card (that I'm aware of) It gets very crowded Some times when it gets busy you'll get over looked read more

This is a good pizza spot. The sausage pizza was very good. The service was good and business was clean.

Hmmm what can I say about one of my favorite pizza restaurants in the Bronx, NY. Service: The service is quick, so you gotta know what you want to order. Food: The pizza is simply wonderful...a great example of NY PIZZA!!! read more

Nick's Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

Yes Lorrrrrrrd, completely yessssss, my soul says yessssss! I've never had authentic NY pizza. When my sister's boyfriend ordered us a pizza here, I dang on near questioned everything in my life. For the last 25 years (I'm not going to tell my real age, because that's none of your concern ) I have been getting ripped the heck off! As the New Yorkers say "Yo!" This pizza was topped with all kinds of pepperoni and sausage. I don't mean that small rolled up sausage you get from those pizza chains. This was SAUSAGE. The sauce was goot. Not good, but goot. Semi sweet and tangy sauce. The slices are huge, y'all. I mean huge. This place left an impression on me like no other. I think I might start rolling my eyes at the pizza that I have been getting everywhere else. Go to Nick's if you are ever in this area. read more

Great. 2am move, good crust on the Pizza . Helpful staff and good times and vibes. I like the fact that the staff will help you out with recommendations. Very nice and small built restaurant made to serve the masses who love and deserve good delicious pizza! read more

Someone had told me the pizza here is good, so after a 3 hour train ride, I was willing to give it a try! Guess what? The pizza is not good! It's oily and tasteless, and the crust just falls apart from the moisture. $3 a slice. Yes this place is open till 3am, and when desperate, I guess we all make mistakes. I won't be dropping here again tho. Happy Yelping! read more

I have ordered alot of things from here in the past. Love their Sicilian slice though but the over all experience here I can't say it 5 stars anymore. I was here last week. Meat and Cheese calzone was just ok. Slice with Spinach can work though if you come here. Toppings are $1 extra to add to the slice. read more

I love Nick's pizza. It is the absolute best. Slices are huge, cheese amount is perfect and the crust is soft . My son loves it too because he eats from the crust down. Great customer service with a smile. read more

went to try this pizza after a game and I saw rating this pizza shop as very good ny pizza it wasn't even good it was salty to much sauce and felt like it was sitting them for a while read more

$4 for a plain slice of pizza is the pretty ridiculous to me. And if you add toppings, ooof, forget about it. My gf loves this place, but I swear that this price point for pizza isn't worth it. The crust is too chewy and overall not the best that people in the area think it is read more

Venue: Nick's Pizza Decor: Take Out (ish) Service: Prompt! Environment: Around the way Vibe , Local Staple Food: Pizza Prices: The best part of this review! Debbie Downers: Conclusion: TeamPortions!!!!!! Bang for your Buck! Alongside White Castle, the ultimate open late spot to forgive you for your sins spot! Have you ever seen a spot where the ATM shoots out $5 bills... how they do that?!!! The epitome of NY pizza. Late night, early in the day. $3 covers lunch...the way it should be. Huge slices man.. Damn thing be hanging off those paper plates ridiculously. Sherman Klumps style. Nothing spectacular of the pizzas itself, just a whole lot of it and enough taste of it to get the job. The cheese mannnnn damn, it is good. Been around for a long time and glad to see a spot to still be in the neighborhood whether to or from where ever you need to go. Overall: A+ read more

Crap. I used to live in the area in 2009..it was nothing but slimey pizza that had the cheese fall off by the time you got home. In late 2017, i saw someone eating a slice here and the pizza looked in tact. I started coming again. For 2 months it was good but as of now (feb 2018), theyve returned to the old model aka cheep slimey cheese that peels off like a scab and falls right off. Typical cheap bronx, cancer inducing, p.o.s. food, processed quickly for the 2+ million ppl smashed into the crowded borough. And lol at anyone who thinks this is authentic italian pizza. Look @ my review for "Pizza Del Sortidor" in Barcelona and see what an actual brick oven wood fire pizza, made by italians, looks like. read more

Nick's Pizza Restaurant - Regular cheese pizza. Cheese falls right off. Doesnt stick to bread. Abomination - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

Absolutely love Nick's pizza! I am not in the area but when I am I definitely make sure to come here! The slices are HUGE and so delicious! This pizza is worth every single cent! The staff is really nice too! Definitely a place to stop at read more

Authentic Italian pizza you remember from child hood not the new artsy reap you see everywhere. They even have a gumball machine and real fountain fruit punch and grape and slushies read more

Nick's Pizza Restaurant - Sicilian yummy - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

The best amazing pizza super Italian cheesy crust is amazing pizza is fresh fyi they only accept cash no credit or debit cards but omg I loveeee it read more

Best slice in the bronx hands down. Cheesy, tasty, saucy and huge what else can u ask for? Nicks is a landmark u need to visit and visit and visit again. read more

Nick's Pizza Restaurant you are truly remarkable, I had a lovely experience here yesterday. Loved the atmosphere, and style of the decor. They have a marvelous menu also. The staff is incredible; accommodating every request with a smile. You won't be unsatisfied. read more

I used to frequent this establishment years ago, and decided to go back and try the pizza, again. It was pretty good. Not as amazing as I remembered it, but still good. read more

One of the best spots for great pizza! Cool guys. The slices are huge well worth the 3 bucks read more

The best pizza in NYC I promise you I swear this pizza is so go so fresh you have to taste it to believe me I live all the way Queens and I drive all the way here if I want pizza . I had nicks pizza for the first time like eight years ago and this is the ONLY PIZZA I'll eat. I rather drive from queens to the X for pizza and I have never been disappointed read more

It aint what it use to be sadly to say. And, I'm strictly talking about the quality of the pizzas not the insane 4 bucks for a plain slice. Nicks use to be the go to pizza spot uptown but recently I ordered pepperoni, plain, and Sicilian slices for the kids and I and they were all lacking in taste. The dough was still raw and rubbery on the plain slice, and the tomato sauce lacked flavor. Idk what happened to this spot but I hope they find their groove again. Ive been coming here since the late 90s/early 2000s :(. read more

I've been coming here for over 30years. I grew up in the neighborhood & went to Jr High School with Nicks younger sister. The style & taste of Nicks pizza hasn't changed much to me..I mean I still love it immensely and still call it the best pizza in New York City! I don't care what anyone says..$3 and all that ;-) Ciao bello... read more

I agree with the previous review, because $3.00 is way too much to charge, especially in the Bronx. Slice of pizza in Manhattan generally cost around $2.50. I could have probably understood if Nick's Pizza was the 'best thing on earth', but it definitely is not at all. The pizza they sell have too much cheese - this is overpowering the dough, which is not acceptable at all. To add to the matter, the cheese tastes synthetic...can you believe synthetic cheese? Nasty! I cannot remember the last time I've been in here. Maybe their other stuff taste good, but I'm not trying them. Pass by here everyday and I see people in here - hey, whatever they like to eat, that is their business. read more

The favored pizza shop of my youth! I will always stop in for the cheesiest Sicilian slice or fat stuffed calzone in the NE Bx read more

Everyone is right $3 a slice is ridiculous for their pizza, but on the other hand its not bad, just not worth $3 especially if you add toppings which are a $1. But for my old stopping ground its still quality pizza, a few yelpers are right the pizza was alot better a few years back. Either way your up in the Northeast section of the BX give it a try you won't be blown away but you will be content. read more

$3 a slice? Sorry but this isnt the city. In fact, the city is cheaper. This spot was good. Its been a neighborhood staple for years until they sold the place. Unless its life or death, stay away. read more

Large Old school New York slices. So much flavor. The location is nothing to look at. Standard inner city pizzaeria. Not much else to order but the slices. The garlic knots are pretty good as well. Just remeber when younorder from here keep it simple stupid. read more

BEST PIZZA IN THE BRONX!!! I moved to VA, CA and then to CO, came back home to the Bronx YEARS later and it had the same taste!!! I live in Pelham Bay now, not close at all, but if they delivered I would pay extra!!! read more