In the evening, if you ask for a slice you get something that's been sitting there all day and never warmed up properly. The service is lackluster and they tend to treat some people better than others unfortunately. No ambiance at all. read more

Crosby Pizza fell off. No effort is put into anything they make. Pizza is not the same as years ago. The sause is bitter. The lasagna is gross. read more

This is some really good pizza. The dough is the best part, light and fluffy... delish.. chicken bacon ranch and buffalo chicken are both good choices. read more

Crosby Pizza Stop - Chicken Bacon Pizza Topped With Ranch Dressing - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Garlic knots was not as I expected. It was not as fresh and probably used old oil. It was lacking flavors. 3.5 for the pizza pie. I love the temperate as it was piping hot. On a side note, I put 3 slices of pizza into the fridge overnight and the next morning I took them out from the fridge. I noticed that the ink from the parchment paper was absorbed into the pizzas... read more

Crosby Pizza Stop - pizza pie parchment paper some ink came off if you leave the pizza in the fridge - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

The pizzas here are ALWAYS freshly made, the BEST tasting in town in my opinion. The size of the pizza is really big too! The service is always great, the guys are fast yet diligent. The last order I placed i also ordered a grilled chicken Cesar salad and it was DELICIOUS! And a great price compared to others places I've ordered from. The shop is a decent size and often has some seating left. Things also look clean and sanitary. read more

Omg the chicken parm was amazing and the pizza is always fresh and hot. Go to this pizza place and you won't be disappointed!!!

The slices are way better than ordering a pie, pizza overall is better across the street and Mangia's. I tried today Sunday 3pm a small pie with pepperoni $24 and picked this up. Nope that's it for me . Strictly slices if any for now on. read more

Crosby Pizza Stop - Small pie with pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Grew up in the area and I've been coming here for as long as I can remember, it stands up to any New York style slice I've had around the city I will usually go for something on the simpler side such as a pepperoni, extra cheese, or bacon slice and always leave satisfied; but they also have a wide variety of out there slices. The mac and cheese slice seems to be the most popular of these, I haven't tried it personally but I've enjoyed the buffalo chicken and chicken bacon ranch slices the most of the exotic ones There are also some doughier options such as a Sicilian or if you're feeling especially glutinous a stuffed slice (almost like a pizza pot pie). While these are still very tasty I think the thin crust options are the move here as the ingredients used besides the bread are so flavorful and in these thicker options it's easy to get lost in the bread read more

Crosby Pizza Stop - Bacon slice and pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Room for improvement. It was a cold day so decided to walk and eat it there thinking I'd have a hot fresh slice. This is a busy Friday night too, but I my pizza was COLD and it tasted old I was really disappointed. I don't think I'll go back because I found another one down the block I like better. read more

I've been coming to this site for 50 years. There have been a few different names, but the quality of food has never waivered. Tiny dining area. My preference is to order a whole pie as it comes fresh from the oven. The eggplant Parm is simply outstanding. Nostalgia not withstanding, I don't know of a better pizza place. read more

I have been coming to this place for years. Crosby Pizza has the best thin crust pizza in the area and there garlic knots are pretty good. A little over priced but the pizza is good with variety of options for toppings and the slices are huge! The staffs here are not rude but not friendly either. As another review indicated it does feel like a "boys club" vibe in there. But if you are around Crosby area and you want pizza, I would stop by here to get a slice. read more

This rating is for their regular slices. I like the fact that they are thin-crust. I like to heat them up at home and add toppings such as pepperoni or broccoli rabe. Also, I almost forgot. Their garlic knots are some of the best I've had. read more

The food is good it's actually one of my favorite pizza places, only thing is the other day I came in and the cook misheard me I said I wanted to pay for my items together, but he heard separate somehow so I told the cashier I wanted to pay together and the guy says "f*cking crazy" he pinned his miserableness on me lol. read more

First visit. Parking is tough, meters mostly. Ordered a chicken roll with marinara sauce on the side. Service is quick at the counter. I forgot the cost, it was very reasonable though. The roll was a good size, about 7 inches fill of cheese, less chicken, and tasted okay. Nothing to write home about. Happy Yelping! read more

See all

a simple pizza shop on crosby ave that i visit from time to time when i visit my beloved bronx. not fancy and old school decor which i like , good amount of tables and space to sit and eat with a menu of a variety of pizza and toppings , heros, calzones , rolls, pasta dishes , entress, etc. i prefer my 2 cheese slices and large diet coke as always and i am never disappointed..same guys behind the counter and still remember me and well i still remember the cheerful bunch as well..still good pizza after all these years and glad they are still around. read more

ordered from crosby pizza stop for the 1st time ever just to receive an incorrect order, being transfered 3 different times by employees, while barely explaining the issue with my order that was paid for, whoever it was on the phone was very extra and belligerent. could not get anything out which led to the individual hang up the phone on me. will not recommend this location to anyone. if you feel comfortable eating from a place that cant correct there wrong and also rude to customer go for it. other then that businesses with respect and principals is the way not "crosby pizza stop" read more

Crosby Pizza Stop - a cheese pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Hey peeps! I've eaten here a few times but this time decided to post a review. Open during the pandemic which is great. You place your order inside & wait outside until it's ready. I paid $8 for both pepperoni & plain slices (which looked better out of the oven this photo is the pizza about an hour later). Good pizza for the Pelham Bay neighborhood, not the friendliest pizza shop on earth - run entirely by men under the age of 50 so there's a boys club vibe in there. I also felt I was standing outside a little longer than I needed to and I had to signal to the guy "is my pizza ready?" In any event, I'm a pizza Queen & most likely will order from here again. read more

Crosby Pizza Stop - Pizza Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

The pizza has changed since 2020. I don't know what happened but since moving here, the food definitely tastes different. Prices went up due to inflation. Good spot to order from if you want decent pizza and fast. Delivery guys are nice and I always tip them well. Only ordering from here because Mangias across the street uses too much tomato sauce. read more

There are only so many places I have ordered food from that the deliciousness and quality is consistent EVERY TIME!!!! The Toscana pizza is the best pizza I've ever had. Fresh prosciutto, thin and light and delicious freshly baked crust. Fresh cheese and arugula. Oh baby!! It's my favorite!!!! read more

Crosby Pizza Stop - Toscana Pizza (delivered) - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Amaizing food, fast delivery. I enjoyed it a lot and for sure I will order again and again. The Besttttt read more

Crosby Pizza Stop - Amaizing food , fast delivery For sure i will order again , THE BEST - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

I've been coming here off and on since the late 80's The round Sicilian slice is the staple at this place and always has tasted consistent as the years have gone by. The regular slice is also pretty good. The is a no frills pizza shop which has stood the test of time as a neighborhood staple. read more

Of you're looking for a great regular slice, Definitely check out Crosby Pizza. My bf and I ordered a pie to take back home to Westchester. We couldn't resist but to eat a few slices in the car (because the 17 min drive home was to long of a wait). The cheese was like liquid molten. What a great pie! There's plenty of seating inside, and everyone is friendly / helpful. read more

Pizza is the best in the Bronx, I've been coming to this place for over 20 years does not disappoint good slice, good pie , can't go wrong

Thank you so much for your generosity!!! Pizza was delicious!!!! Nicu and S of Montefiore read more

Crosby Pizza Stop - Thank you for your generosity from the NICU of Montefiore. Pizza was delicious!!! - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

I have ordered twice from here and the pizza is great. Customer service and attention to detail is a plus. Thanks Charlie!

Their pizza comes out just the way you order it every time!! I have lived all over NYC & eaten pizza all over this Great city, but I have to say this little Gem, tucked away in a great area of the Bronx (Pelham Bay) has some of the best pizza in NYC. They don't have some fancy name or a big franchise type outfit, when you come to Crosby's you are like family, you get that old world style sauce, soft yet crisp dough & taste that only a true old school pizza place like Crosby can deliver time and again. You know what to expect every time!! Never had an issue with any of my orders, always on point & can always count on the amazing team there @ Crosby's Pizza to get your order right, they can cook amazing other items as well, their heroes are delicious, the dishes amazing.... everything at this place is FANTASTIC!!! Enjoy, you won't regret it!! Thanks Crosby for all the great meals!! read more

Crosby Pizza Stop is a jewel and I can not wait to go back. It was a remarkable experience. Everything we had here was terrific. Service was fantastic and everybody working here was really nice and helpful. Crosby Pizza Stop is now certainly one of my go to's when I come to this area. read more

Great NY pizza. Great sauce, nice crust and Good cheese. The staff is always warm and kind. Really sweet guys. Been coming here since I was a kid over 25 years read more

One of the best slices in the Bronx, - sweeter sauce, light cheese- good bread--- this is the kind of slice I like- the kind where I can eat 3 or 4 and not feel like I ate mad amounts of bagels. They also gave me a free calender. read more

The worse, I guess when you're a regular that's what starts to hAppen. I ordered a pie at 450, I was told 35 minutes( nothing complicated) I was told 35 minutes, if you're busy extra time is understandable. I called aT 555 all I got was the delivery guy left got my pizza at 607 ice cold, with the the cheese and pepperoni all slid off. Thank you Crosby. Many pizza places I in the area!! read more

Been coming here with my grandfather since I was a kid growing up in the Bronx. Hands down the best Bronx pizza imo. Their round Sicilian is to die for and even the regular pie is delicious. When I don't want to be let down this is where I go. Even living in westchester now I still make the trip when I'm craving some real Bronx style pizza. read more

When you pay a high price you expect quality not quantity, my pizza was too greasy and too many toppings.

Horrible customer service.. waited to be served for 5 mins.. got passed up 2 times.. do not recommend..

Food cold . Sauce was cold after them saying it was heated up . Boss tells customers they should eat somewhere else then if my food is cold. Terrible customer service. The employees , including the boss , are very disrespectful VINNY SHOULD STILL OWN IT . ‼‼ read more

Ordered a large pepperoni pizza, waited 50 minutes for delivery, called asking where my order was and was told would be there in a few. Pizza came, paid and tipped the driver. Get in house, open up the box and the pizza crust is BLACK. If I wanted charcoal flavored pizza I would have ordered it, but this was nasty. Two weeks ago I called at 7:31pm, and was told delivery stops at 7:30, I am a regular customer and I'm cut off a minute? But today I figured I'd call and I get burned pizza, how do you send out burned black pizza? This is bulls. read more

Ewww. Not clean and food taste old. I won't give them another dollar. So many better options around.

Time to give a shout-out to the old neighborhood. Back in the day, Crosby Pizza Stop was my go-to joint for a knockout slice. I just loved the taste of their pizza. Still do. And one of the unique things they've always gotten right is the hotness of a slice. You never wind up with a scalding triangle poised to burn the roof of your mouth. At Crosby, it's perfect temperature, perfect taste and perfect foldability. (Don't get me started on bad foldability. NOT cool.) At the beginning of "Saturday Night Fever," John Travolta orders two slices at his neighborhood joint, puts one on top of the other, then folds them together and eats. Now THERE's some maximum foldability! So props to Old School Brooklyn, but BIGGER props (and much love) to Old School Bronx! read more

REAL. BRONX. PIZZA. Ok first time here, soon as we walk in a swarm of customers waiting to be served (good sign). There's a pretty decent selection of flavors. I had a regular slice and a Hawaiian slice - i had to get it. The Hawaiian slice was as it should be -sweet pineapple and salty ham! Plenty of seating inside, the regular slice bought me back to when i was a kid. Not all pizza is created equal. Guys stop reviewing based on factors the place cannot control like PARKING. It's the Bronx...parking sucks everywhere. Well done Crosby Pizza! read more

Let's get one thing straight. A "round sicilian slice" is just a deep dish pizza. But this is one of the FEW places that serves it north of 110 st in Manhattan. In the Bronx one is limited to Margharita slices or the old fashioned NY floppy slice. Usually cooked in a brick or coal oven. Their cheese-less onion, pepper and tomato slice was rich and crispy. Served deep dish style, which I had with cheese. They had a nice variety of simple, gourmet and vegetarian options. If you're in the area, come here! read more

They say a picture is worth a thousand words. Actually, the picture makes it look better than what I saw when I got home. The pan was closed improperly so by the time I got home the order was messy. The paper bag was wet with the sauce and because of the spillage the cloth bag l carried the order in was a mess too. I was willing to accept that but when I saw the wings I became upset and pissed. The wings appeared under cooked with a minimum amount sauce applied. It looked like a shade of pink. I ordered 20 wings subsequently wasted $20 and didn't have the food my granddaughter prefers to offer her. The way it looked I knew she wouldn't eat it or anyone else. Now I'm unhappy and pissed off. I wasted money, paid for poor quality food, and received bad customer service. They've been in the neighborhood longer than I have. I've lived here for 17 years and I've patronized them once before. Since the pandemic I try to patronize different eateries to show support. This decision was a mistake and I won't be going back there again. It was busy and they had staff working but something wasn't working right. Furthermore, the person who completed the order saw the food and wrapped it up as is. Not cool. That is not good customer service and customer service is paramount to me read more

Crosby Pizza Stop - Barely cooked or flavored Buffalo chicken wings - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York