Doesn't get more authentic than Tommy's Pizza...Tommy was working the counter and the service was fantastic. This spot has the vibe of an old school NY pizza joint, because it IS an old school NY pizza joint. 10/10 would go again and again read more

Tommy's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza, cheese pizza, & Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

Tommy's is another old school cash only pizza joint with that old Bronx vibe. It's not the biggest place but they dishing out big flavor and great pies. Keeping it simple and just making great pizza. There slices have that corn meal crust which adds to the extra crunch. Staff are quick and to the point like everything else in the Bronx and it ain't a bad thing. Was the great lunch a nice sweet sauce can't go wrong with A Dave Portnoy pizza rating as high as they have. Definitely would love some more of there great pizza. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Interior - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

A great neighborhood pizzeria. Looks like it's been around for absolutely ever! Cash only. Tommy himself was making the pizza! It's a small joint full of locals and pictures of all the kids sports teams that they sponsor in the neighborhood. Pizza is simple, with a delicious crunchy crust. We went as a stop on Scott's Pizza bus tour and quickly overwhelmed the space. It was an odd hour so that probably helped and Scott did call ahead for our order to keep up moving and to give them a heads up. All that said, Tommy couldn't have been friendlier. Regulars were friendly and spoke highly of the product. It looks like one of those places where the slices would have been exactly the same 20 years ago as they are today. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

It was good but I found nothing extremely notable about it. The slices have a good size

Portnoy rated this joint a 8.6 for a good reason. I'll leave it in the top 5 Bronx Pizza joints. Fresh hot pizza excellent crust. Staff is friendly and accommodating. Old world Bronx charm. Stools at front counter small booths in the back Open till 11 pm (2025) Very good prices Worth the drive. read more

See all

What an amazing place!!! The people were awesome and the pizza was delicious! The guys there made us feel right at home and they gave fast service!!! We will definitely go back when we are in the area!! read more

Tommy's Pizza - Thanks for the great conversation, tasty food, fast service and making us laugh! - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Great service, good people working there , delicious pizza with no fuss! Love the old school prices too!

Old school traditional New Yawk Bronx no nonsense slice of a beetz. When people come visit me from out of town I bring them to Old School. You step back in time when you order Tommy's read more

Always the best!! Get it crisp!! The service is cordial and prompt!!Pizza at Tommy's is well done. In tasting the Pizza, one can tell that the ingredients used are of prime quality!! read more

Tommy's Pizza - A Bronx Classic That Never Misses I've been going to Tommy's Pizza in Throggs Neck on and off since 1995, and let me tell you--every single time I go back, the pizza is just as good as the last time. That kind of consistency is rare, and it's what makes Tommy's a true gem. This is no-frills, old-school NYC pizza at its best. The cheese slice? Perfect. The cheese calzone? Just as legendary. They don't try to overdo it with gimmicks or trendy toppings--Tommy's sticks to what works, and they absolutely nail it every time. The sauce is flavorful and balanced, the cheese is always on point, and the crust has that perfect crisp and chew combo you dream about when you think of classic New York pizza. Throggs Neck should be proud to have a pizzeria like this--reliable, delicious, and rooted in tradition. Tommy's is the kind of place that reminds you why NYC is the pizza capital of the world. read more

a solid new york slice. nothing too crazy/fancy but hits the spot every time. price is also a little better than most other pizza spots in this economy. the only con is that it's CASH only If craving some pizza and in the area, would def recommend! read more

Tommy's is a hometown local joint with a no frills menu of good pizza. You can order by the slice at currently 2.50 or by the pie. They have a pan pizza with 4 slices for like $7 too. You can eat in or take out. Every pizza is made the way it has always been made with cornmeal crust in the oven by hand. The crust is the right ratio of crispy and doughy with a tasty sauce and good cheese to sauce ratio. You need to make sure that you have cash though since they don't take cards. If you are in the area, check out Tommy's for a slice or a pizza and help keep this neighborhood institution serving up pies for years to come. read more

Tommy's Pizza - a slice of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Their pizza is excellent. Good quality Mozzarella cheese and sauce! I can tell real Italian good quality pizza and this is a good quality healthy pizza..! I highly recommend it! read more

Hidden gem. Been coming here since my Lehman days. This was back in the 90's. Top 5 pizza joint in the Bee X, Hands down. Slices are $3 and maintain that Italian flair and culinary integrity. Crunchy crust, modest cheese fill, and oil drippings. read more

See all

If you love pizza, Tommy's pizza is your place. Enjoy tasty and cheesy pies that would leave wanting more. If you are picking up- make sure to call in advance, they are always very busy. That is because their pizza is so good. It is your local place to sit at and enjoy or order to go. read more

I hardly do Updates, but felt this one was warranted. For me, someone who isn't into pizza much, Tommy's I believe is the best in Throggs Neck. Crisp crust, perfect imo tasting sauce, with a nice distribution of cheese and toppings. When you see Cops, Sanitation workers, Traffic Enforcement, DEP, and others line up in front of a spot, you know it's got to be good. They do one thing, and that one thing well. Definitely recommended. TIP: They also sell the occasional Beef Patty. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Pizza box cover. - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

Great spot and great pizza. old school vibe with great pizza and a smaller menu so everything is really good

If you are in the Bronx, this is Classic NY pizza done right! Delicious. Might make you have random cravings. Nice staff.

Well today I went the women at the counter was very aggressive in collecting my money She wasn't very nice and has a attitude she needs a class in etiquette if she is going to deal with the public very turned off by her pizza was good read more

If you want to get a slice of the action, Tommy's in the Throggs Neck section of The Bronx is it. This is the spot for us teachers when we want to have a pizza party for our students because these folks offer reliable service and no-hassle delivery. It's my second Tommy's go-around- with my first being back in the Fall of 2019 when I had quit dairy and tried ordering a cheese-less slice and was abruptly told, "we don't make that". Out I went. My co-teachers recently bought a pie for our students' Valentine's Party and quite honestly- not only did the pie look good, but the 1/2 of a slice I ate, was damn tasty and wanted my own for lunch. Tommy's is small inside- so if you don't want to stay inside, place your order then wait outside until your slice is done. This pizza isn't like my fave Patsy's Pizza in East Harlem- but for Throggs Neck, it's really good. The result is a nice-tasting slice that's light on the sauce AND not overly-seasoned which I truly liked. Another impressive part is that Tommy's Pizza isn't doughy at all- nor is it too thin that droops on you as soon as you fold it by the crust. Just don't try to order salads or pastas; this is an old-school, pizza-only joint. To add, Tommy's isn't flashy or serve Neopolitan pizza- so look past all that- because the pizza is really good. Be warned: service can be market-trader curt. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Bare Bones - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

This pizzeria in the neighborhood is fantastic! I always go for the large cheese pie, crispy style, and it's delicious even when reheated. Great spot for a tasty, reliable pizza every time! read more

Great pizza. A good overall old school slice along with a nice old school pizzeria feel. The guys that work there and always pleasant and looking to serve you. I just wish the pies where 18" and not 16". read more

Nothing beats Tommy's Pizza in the Bronx! Very reliable and delicious! My wife and I love this place, we go out of our way just for his pizza. Very friendly people who treat us like family! Leftovers are great even the next day! And our family always walks away with 4 or 5 pies!!!! Do not let the small place fool you cause there is room to eat inside ! read more

See all

Best pizza in Da Bx hands down! Always been the same and always will be!! TG!!! It's been there forever. Simple and easy menu

I have heard of this place for a while. Finally tried it glad I did. I ONLY like thin pizza. And to make it even better was the corn meal they put on the crust. The pizza was tasty and not soggy. Even after getting the pie home. Delicious for a slice shop. read more

Tommy's Pizza - A pie with some crumbly sausage on it - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Dave Portnoy gave Tommy's an 8.6 and I wholeheartedly agree. Just a small neighborhood place but they sure know how to make pizza. Move over Louie and Ernie's there's room for another great place in Throggs Neck. read more

Service is utter trash! They don't acknowledge you when you come! Never got a chance to order cuz the guy behind the counter was too busy chatting away with customers! read more

The new Hooks pizza . Blows the old place away !!! Thin, crunchy flavorful pizza. Squares are light and crunchy. Andrew the owner greets every customer, and aims to please . They deliver . A definite try!!! read more

old school phenomenon right here, best by-the-slice pizza in town by far! One of T-Neck's hidden gems in this modernized era but national treasures nonetheless . read more

Tommy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

I'm a little picky when it comes to pizza, the big chain restaurants are NOT true pizza, even though occasionally I'll have a bite of (insert big pizza chain here) that does not mean that I consider that good pizza. I was a bit hesitant to have a slice of Tommy's, family members bought two pies, I decided to try some Tommy's, before I knew I ended up having 5 slices! Yes 5! This pizza is up there with the greats of NY, this is another side of the NY pizza essence, that slice that everyone around the world and across this country want to emulate so bad, but fail miserably. A mix between great sauce that has a bit of tanginess, slight sweetness, hot melted cheese that does not leave that cheese smell, and almost no grease and a mix of crispy crust I'll add Tommy's to my top list, it's up there next to DiFara's, Lombardi's, etc read more

Tommy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

The guy has an attitude had to cancel my order because he gave me attitude Smh at least have some respect for your clients read more

Best pizza in the Bronx hands down. I've been going for 25 years. I'll never eat any pizza ever again.

Good old brooklyn slice. It's up there as one of my favorite pizza's in Nyc. It taste the same each time i go back.

Made a quick last minute trip to NYC and ended up at Tommy's after my 13 year old did some research about where to get a great slice in The Bronx. Tommy's pizza was so good we got it a second time before heading home. Great guys working there and top notch real deal pie! Looking forward to visiting again next time!! read more

Definitely in my Top 3 of Pizza Spots in NYC! If in the area a must stop and grab a slice spot!! Will not be disappointed! read more

See all

Some of the best pizza in the Bronx! The crust is crisp and the sauce is delicious! Even specialty slices are delicious!

I've been hearing about how great this place is for some time now. I was home alone on a Saturday night and figured I'd give it a try. I ordered a small pie with sausage and I have to be honest that I wasn't expecting much, especially after I was handed the box and it felt much heavier than most pizzas I'm used too. As soon as I got in the car I opened the box to prevent any further steaming which is the death of any take home pizza. When I opened the box I was taken back. It was very sloppy and greasy looking and reminiscent of the rubber vomit you used to get in the five and dime as kid. I got home and threw on a hot pizza stone I had going in the oven just to crisp up the bottom as it was in the box and that alone can ruin a good crust. Upon tasting it I was pleasantly surprised as it was really, really good! A bit more cheese than I like but damn good. Don't expect anything fancy from this place. They have pizza and calzones. No salads, no pasta. Just good old school pizza from an old school pizza place. I can't believe I waited this long in life to try this. read more

Tommy's Pizza - Don't let the picture scare you. This is really good pizza with a thin center crust. - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Who wuda thunk a small local pizza place could be this good? Semi-thin crust, fresh cheese and spicey sauce adds up to excellent pizza. Just be prepared to wait when ordereing a pie during peak hours. Worth driving to check it out read more

Tommy's Pizza - Front entrance - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

Local legend. If you want a solace of classic nyc pizza this is the spot . No need for fancy bs toppings . Perfect just the way it is . read more

Tommy's Pizza - Menu 2018 - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

While driving through the Bronx, I decided to make a quick stop at Tommy's Pizza to grab a quick slice before I jumped on the Throgs Neck Bridge. I first heard about Tommy's from Dave Portnoy from Barstool Sports and Lorenzo (special guest on the show) who both highly ranked the pizza. Dave and Lorenzo were both right; the pizza is very good. The sauce is a bit bland, but the corn meal crust and cheese lifted the pizza in my opinion. Now to the service itself...I do agree with all the Yelpers who complained about the unfriendly staff. On my visit, the staff were not even wearing masks (this review was written during the pandemic). Would I return to Tommy's Pizza in the future? If I lived in the area, I'd probably make frequent visits to this place to grab a quick slice. There are other pizza joints in the city that have comparable slices so there is nothing truly unique about this place. If I'm driving across the Throgs Neck Bridge, I'll stop by if I'm craving a slice of pizza. read more