Super cool and quiet spot! Lots of seating for summer days and nights when you want pizza! I really enjoyed the freshly made pizza it was hot and tasty! The garlic knots were just alright and I could have definitely gotten another flavor of slice inside of Margarita. Overall the food was consumed and I hope to be back again soon! read more

See all

Great pizza! Only $4 a slice! Also got the spaghetti w/ marinara...sauce was good, nothing special though. read more

Pugsley's Pizza - Menu as if June 2026 - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

A good out of the way pizza shop in the Bronx. This is behind other buildings, near townhouses and apartments. Mostly had Fordham college students eating there. I think people only go here because they know about it, or like us, find it randomly on Google maps. There is a little parking lot. The pizza and pasta were both good. NYC style! The restaurant is filled with paraphernalia, photos, graffiti, and other knick-knacks. I don't think that was for show, they just never throw anything out. Even Mr. Pugsley himself was sitting in an overstuffed chair, falling asleep with his X-Mas hat in the front of the store! read more

See all

This place was a little bit difficult, Find, but totally worth it! You have to walk through the back door of the gas station to get to the back alley. The pizza slices were amazing and you can't beat the price! I'll definitely be back! read more

Pugsley's Pizza - Inside counter - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Excellent pizza $20 a pie. You will love it. Should be on your bucket list of to-go-to NYC pizza joints. read more

See all

Great food, great service. Old school NYC pizza! The ambience is fire reminds me of my childhood Days read more

Pugsley's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

It's very good Pizza. The people are really nice. The place is an interesting little hangout. Parking is difficult. Price is a little high. Not much more to say. read more

Back in New York City right after my Italian trip, I visit "Little Italy" in the Bronx and found this fun Italian-American spot selling creative pizza that will surely disgust the Italian nonnas back in Europe. At this spot, a former stable turned restaurant and a favorite of students from nearby Fordham University, I tried pizza topped with penne ala vodka for those dinner nights when one can't decide between pasta or pizza. Someone said, "Great idea, put them together!" Also, I tried a dessert that brought a delicious trouple: creamy Sicilian cannoli, and Nutella spread on top of a freshly baked pizza. I think it's quite poetic . These food are metaphors of how the migrant Italians have culturally evolved in America and particularly in the Bronx __ fun, daring, modern, and still very Italian with a dash of American. #curious_eater #littleitalyarthuravenue #littleitalybronx #little italy nyc read more

See all

Phenomenal, old school spot. Great pizza. The chicken roll was fantastic. Was there for an event in the basement. Great bar and bartender was a good dude read more

When I came in and announced that we were first timers, the extremely friendly Jonathan rang a bell for us. We thoroughly enjoyed a plain slice to start. It's got a thin crust, nicely charred, and the sauce was well balanced, not too tart or sweet. We followed with a penne vodka slice to which I added the recommended hot pepper oil. The pasta was cooked just right and quite tasty and chewy. Finally, I had to try the new tricolor slice - thick stripes of red sauce, vodka sauce and pesto. Delicious combo. Pugsley's is not easy to find but definitely worth seeking out. If you attend Fordham, you already know it, but otherwise, its located in a building that hasn't changed much - outside or inside - that looks like a high school hangout from the 60s or 70s. read more

Great Bronx pizza and nice ambiance. We stuck with the basics - excellent pie! The owners are very nice and down to earth.

best pizza in Bronx and possibly the city ! tasty af great service everyone is so friendly. i have been coming here for 3 years now never a complaint. and they let me bring my bike inside! just the best read more

Great pizza great vibes in the establishment. Great taste amazing cheese and cooked to perfection

I love coming to Pugsley pizza. The owners are awesome I love them the pizza is delicious I love how old fashioned the pizza place is.awesome worth the trip read more

So my pal and I were in the mood for some pizza and I figured we'd go to one of my favorite spots Pugsleys Pizza up in the Bronx. The owner, Sal and his wonderful wife were at the helms this time. Very beautiful and happy couple. They make this spot what it is. We ordered the 10 inch small pie and it was definitely enough for two people. This pizza is so delicious. You definitely have to try it if you're in the Fordham area. Cooked perfectly. Nice andd golden. Perfect cheese to sauce ratio. The sauce is so delicious and crust is nice and crispy. There is no way you can go wrong at this spot. The service is Grand. They are very accommodating. You put your order in and they will bring the pie to your table. They also have other food there and you could order single slices if you'd like. The joint itself is nice and cozy. It's always cool to eat in there. So if you're looking for some really good pizza or Italian food head up to Pugsleys Pizza in the Bronx! All right, everyone, enjoy your day ! read more

See all

Pretty great little place in the Bronx. One slice was definitely enough for me, though I tend to eat a bit less than most. But it absolutely filled me up. My boyfriend's friend treated us so I can't quite remember how good of a price it was. I wish they had better drinks available, and the seating was not very comfortable. Otherwise, quite the little hidden gem! read more

Pugsley's Pizza - Sausage slice - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

We love this pizzas when we are in the Bronx! Huge slices for great prices. Employees say HI GUYS! :) Nice seating inside and outside. Big enough for a birthday bash! They even have a parking lot. How cool! read more

Pugsley's Pizza - Foods and cheese pizzas! - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Delicious, friendly, fun, great service. All of the food was really good. However, the vodka, marinara, pesto slice was soooooo yum. read more

See all

Very casual pizza restaurant with pizza served on paper plates. When pizzas are done, the chef hits the gong! Thin crusted pizza was our order on this day. read more

See all

Great place! My personal favorite is the penne vodka pizza. Owners and staff are so friendly I absolutely love coming here. Inside there is limited seating but they also have a patio. The decor inside is super sick too. This is a very popular spot for fordham kids as it is practically on-campus lol so be aware of that if coming here late at night, gets crowded. read more

Pugsley's Pizza - penne vodka and cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Stopped by after reading many great reviews on this casual pizza spot. A lot of reviews posted pictures of the Love Pie which is an adorable 10" heart shaped pie. We ordered the garlic bread with mozzarella that came with a side of sauce for dipping. The staff was very accommodating and allowed us to order each personal pie with two different toppings. Overall very solid food, would recommend! read more

See all

My favorite pizza place anywhere in New York. No frills, just a sweet older Italian couple making delicious pizza. My family has been going for years, and the first time we went feels just the same as the most recent time. And the staff is the best. Go to Pugsley's!! read more

Pugsley's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Good god The most adorable owners ever I felt like they were my grandparents Also The pizza was prob the best pizza I ever had in my life in my 30 years living in NY All I have to say. Got the penne alavodka slice read more

I havent been back here in a few years but so glad to see the amazing couple was still healthy and doing well thru covid. My friend and I always have a great time when we come. Pizza is fresh and delicious. (We got the plain cheese pizza and a buffalo chicken slice) They are also very welcoming and let us actually build one of our own pizzas (spread the sauce) then ring their huge gong haha. Def will be back soon. Also, highly recommend for a cute date spot/experience as the couple also ships other couples lol read more

Pugsley's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

A solid pizza stop. I was looking for something inexpensive and on the way from our subway stop to the NY Botanical Garden. I saw Pugsley's pizza on the map and decided to give it a go. It was $11 for two slices of pizza and a diet snapple which worked for what we needed. We ordered, paid, and they brought our food out to us at our table. We got a penne slice and a cheese slice. I wish they had some sort of veggie slice but that's okay. The penne slice was my favorite but that was probably because I had never had anything like it. Pasta on pizza? Revolutionary. Seems like a cool spot especially cause it's close to the college. Kinda eclectic art on the walls and something to look and talk about. read more

Pugsley's Pizza - penne alla vodka pizza left, cheese on the right - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Im from CA and live in CT. I am peticular about my pizza. Hands down the best pizza I've had on the East Coast. The dough was crunching and doughy on the edge the way it's supposed to be. I tried garlic cheese nots for the 1st time and need to find a way to take these back to CA. The decor was rugged and dingy, which added to the great experience I had there!! Chefs kiss food was inexpensive and parking out back. Great place!! read more

See all

CURB SIDE pickup and PARKING LOT available. BACON ...pizza..I ordered the Hawaiian pizza but Pulsey uses bacon which I think tastes magnificent! It was LOADED underneath and on top of the cheese so this was one of the best Hawaiian bacon pizza I've had. Plain slice had the perfect thinness(not too thick or too thin) though the dough was just slightly chewy in texture in the edge but makes for good base without worrying about it falling apart. 4 stars for curbside pickup, amazing Hawaiian pizza and friendly staff. I'll be back! read more

Pugsley's Pizza - Hawaiian pizza (bacon with pinneapple) and plain cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York

Pizza was okay. Dive bar vibes. Friendly staff. Seems like a Fordham local spot for the college kids. Very interesting decor, homey

Pugsley Pizza does indeed have everything you need for an overall experience~ a pizzeria with delicious food, a mobile food truck, a bar/club in the basement and even merchandise! It's as if you're walking into your family's house when you enter, and are greeted by Sal, Pete & Pina. You always feel welcome here. The pizza is delicious, all of it, the meat lovers, pepperoni, white, and especially the Nutella dessert pie topped with cannolis. I highly recommend this place, you'll love it! And don't forget to leave with some souvenir merch~ love the t-shirt with the Sicilian Trinacria logo on it! read more

See all

Yummy pizza and owners were super nice and pleasant. We would definitely return. Available parking as well.

Great pizza! Nothing fake or phony about this place. They do it all right in front of you and just make great pizza.

While shopping on Arthur Avenue I decided to try the pizza at Pugsley,s.Cozy little place near Fordham University.I had a plain slice,which is gigantic,with homemade hot peppers oil.Delicious.Sal,the owner was one of the most down to earth people I have ever met.Thank God places and people like this are still around.Love to bring my father.Great experience.Pizza was fantastic. read more

Bronx Pizza this place makes pizza with love and use high quality ingredients so far this is my favorite Pizzeria in the Bronx , its old school with a great vibe and service. Great crust with sauce and cheese ratio and use best olive oil from Sicily my parents birthplace go and enjoy a great NY slice here read more

See all

We Love Love Love Pugsley!!! Thank you so much for having delicious pizza!!! Queens and The Bronx Love This Pizza!!! read more

Another stop on finding the best pizza in the west Bronx landed me in Pugsley's pizza. Supposedly, a Fordham University staple. I went early almost right when they opened shortly after 11 to avoid any crowds which was a success. When I arrived, there was only one person in there. A older gentleman who looked like a local due to the cook being on the first name basis with him. This was my first time entering Pugsely and I found the decor charming. Old school but charming. A lot of pics of customers on the wall, police officers and odd old school lounge bench areas for eating and a dining room table looking area that you would find in your personal home. I walked top the counter and ordered, behind the counter was a older man named Sal. He was the owner. SO that was cool. I ordered a large half Meatball pie and told him this was my first time. He told me through a heavy accented English (he's Italian) that he would make me " a beautiful pie" . I went to go get a sit and he started making pies but then he gave me a slice on the house , I don't know if it was because I would wait for him to make an entire pie or was it because it was my first visit but it was appreciated. While I started to eat the slice of cheese, he yelled over do I like spicy, I told him yes and he just pointed at a bowl of chili/jalapeno oil . I put some oil and jalapenos on my slice, and it was amazing. the slice was good , but putting this concoction on my pizza elevated it. Was unlike anything I remember putting on a slice. I think the bowl of oil was a "If you know, you know" thing because I later had another person ask for it , because I had brought the whole bowl to my table greedily. So now finally the pie. The pie was good. I ordered a half meatball but was disappointed with the lack of explosive flavor in the meatballs. I was expecting it to be something more special than normal meatball coming from an Italian restaurant. There was nothing wrong with the pie but nothing amazing. Everything was solid tho. Crust, cheese and sauce was good. What made it better for me was the addition of the chili sauce/oil! That made it more delicious. What also made the pizza experience good was the restaurant itself. Its local, its cute , its authentic and the fact that the owner was there turning out pies was an great experience. read more

See all

This little hidden gem will knock you off your seat. It's hidden behind the main road of Fordham road, right next to Fordham University Campus. Small pull in parking lot in front to accommodate about six cars. Outdoor and Indoor seating available. Outdoor seating only available until 10pm. Don't let the old looking decor distract from the taste of their pizza. Pizza was amazing! My Sicilian was well toasted, just enough dough, tasty sauce, I haven't had pizza like this for a long time. Husband and Wife duo are sweethearts. If you have the opportunity to stop at Pugsley's don't miss it! EVERYONE LOVES PUGLEY'S!!!! read more

See all

I've been going there for at least 15 years . The pizza is very good and tastey. The service is also good. Once I was there and the guy and I were talking so much, I forgot to pay him. I felt so bad the next day I went back and paid him he was so surprised. Great pizza. I recommend the shop. read more

The best cheese pizza I've ever had. The buffalo chicken slices were delicious and the chicken tasted so fresh. Super friendly service by the husband and wife. They make slices to order. Very old school, very authentic. The guy (sal) is quite the character and you can tell he's proud of his pizza shop! Interesting interior decor- you can tell they're a staple among the community. The hot oil/pepper mixture was delicious as well if you like spice! The owners let us all hit the gong which was super cool. The best restaurant experience I've ever had. I look forward to coming back again. read more

See all

There is no place on earth like pugsley pizza. While it serves the primary function of a Fordham hangout, anyone would be well served to come here and try those absolutely stupendous chicken rolls. If you don't eat meat you should still stick your head in here to meet the Natale family, especially Sal, who has a poet soul and won't hesitate to share it. This pizzeria is an expression of his joie de vivre. It's one of my favorite spots on earth. read more

I happen to have stumbled across this place by happenstance. My friend and I were hungry for some pizza and he pulled this place's name on his phone. I heard about this place but never had the chance to go. Unfortunately for us upon arrival we got totally lost and confused because all we saw was a gas station and several businesses. But just then we saw a group of college kids walking through a side way and we said to ourselves, "these kids must be going there and let's follow them." And surely enough they took us to the promise land. It was a magical place where there was just all college kids lined up just to get a slice or two. We followed and it was the best decision ever. Not only the environment was appealing but their pizza is out of this world! Hands down one of the best I have ever tasted. TOP 3, if not TOP 1. The consistency, the level of flavor, the ratio all were beyond their means. I definitely want to go back. read more

Pugsley's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bronx, New York