Pizza Barn lives up to the hype. The slices are huge, the pizza is genuinely good, and the whole experience just feels classic and fun. Staff was friendly, service was quick, and it's one of those spots you end up telling other people about afterward. Worth the trip. read more

the cub, my son Marco, was asking me if we could order some pizza. so we ordered the "thin pie" from 19 frogs . w got their 20 mins later, grabbed some parm crumbs, dumped them on the pizza & the cub and I chowed down on some absolutely fabulous tasting pizza slices! i'd reccomend this place big time ! buon appetito!!! mangia read more

See all

It's an experience and fun challenge to try with friends but the space doesn't feel the same since they moved. Kind of basic pizzaria. When we were there there was an inappropriate show on the tv which was awkward since we had a child with us. Staff was nice enough to change it & accommodating. Pizza's flavor is nothing special just the shape & size of the slice which was expe. Wish they did more interactive things when it came to the challenge in house. My husband finished one big slice while there but it seemed anticlimactic. read more

Pizza Barn - Cheese slice & custom white slice - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

My brother and I were here a few months ago and we loved the pizza! We got the giant pepperoni "slice". The way it was cut in squares reminded me of Tavern Style Pizza. The staff was great and the ambiance was laid back. read more

Pizza Barn - Pepperoni Super Slice - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

I had great expectations of this pizza. I knew it was going to be big, but it was enormous! The pizza is delicious. I love the thickness of the bread and the flavor of the bacon ranch cheese pie. The price of this pizza was over $50. They let you combine different toppings. The service is quite good and the interior feels like a pizza place. Come check out this place. They are open until midnight. Quick tip: order your pizza first and then you get a number to take to whatever open seat there is. read more

Pizza Barn - The super slice half chicken bacon ranch and half pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

You can never go wrong with pizza! Pizza barn pizza always tastes fresh and tasty! I give it 4 stars only because our table wasn't the cleanest However, great pizza! read more

Def a one of a kind experience. The pizzas here are pricey but they are huge! So yummy and the location is nice. Has plenty of seating and directly across from the casino. Def recommend read more

The pizza was spot on delicious and the service was amazing they were very nice. I can't wait to go back again. read more

See all

This is a nice casual spot in Yonkers with New York Style Pizza. It is the home of the 2 foot long slice, which easily fed 5 people we had. They do half topping, so we had half pepperoni and half margarita pizza. I was worried that these slice would be soggy or tasteless since they we so big. I was happy i was wrong. Each piece had a crunchy crust and yummy melty cheese, and I loved the toppings we got. We also had the large 1 pound garlic knots with cheese, which comes with a side of marinara. This was equally delicious. Service was quick. One super tip is this restaurant is byob! I brought a bubbly for the adults to share. I would love to come back again. read more

See all

I came here since I was across the street anyway and knew about it through some social media hype. It has it own small parking lot that has space for about 20 cars. There also street parking. It had a energetic vibe as I walked in and photos on wall and hype all about the Big slice which if you finish, I believe you get a tshirt with bragging rights. I ordered Buffalo wings and counter guy told me mild is spicy (just enough for me). The wings were big and came with blue cheese dressing. Not bad. The price wasn't too bad for the portion. I got 2 slices of pepperoni and 1 fresh garlic slice. The pizza was fresh. It was okay. The dough was not thin enough for me and it needed a more tastier sauce. Would I come back again? Maybe if I'm in the area. They do have a couple of other items on their menu that I would possibly try. The staff were friendly and service was quick enough. I went on a Friday night and the causal restaurant was full with families and couples. It's hyped up but since it's all about their pizza, I've had better. read more

See all

Would like to say that I came from sprain ridge pool. So it's close by if you come to pizza barn. The service from when you enter till you leave is fenomenal, they are interactive and funny. Service is quick as well. The ambiance is peaceful and family oriented. Unfortunately Most of my stars are because the staff was great, I did not like really much any food items and i'm not picky. My table ordered, margarita pizza, stuff shells, garlic stuffed bread, and a custom made philly cheesesteak calzone. Calzone was great. Pizza was ehh, I think it was the sauce. Stuff shells sauce was watery but shells looked really good, very cheese but not for me. Garlic bread was great with marinara dipping. l am open to come again and try different food items, since the place is very loved and the environment is lovely. read more

See all

I drove all the way from Long Island to get this slice because my daughter is a foodie just like her dad and she just had to have this pizza. I gotta say the pizza was good but was it worth me driving two hours in traffic for a slice of pizza I'm going to say no for me but if I'm in the area again I will stop by again. One thing I didn't like was the seating was on the sidewalk and people were walking too close to where we were eating. read more

The pizza had no oil Or sauce very doughy and lack of customer service Wouldn't return at all rather go to Pizza Hut. read more

Been wanting to try this place a while but always put it off. For my twins bday we decided to try it out. this spot is famous for their superslice pizza. The service and staff were nice. Our waitress was very bubbly and super friendly personality. The huge pizza slice was really cool and very delicious!! Ordered several pizzas and apps and It easily fed our entire group of about 10 with enough to take home. ! It was very inexpensive so that was good. And our desserts(cheesecake and tiramisu)were on the house for the birthday twins. I definately recommend and would come back here, especially with a small group. It's nice and inexpensive casual spot. read more

See all

I need to come back here. This pizza was not only huge, but it was delicious. I heard and tried this pizza a month ago and it's been on my mind ever since!!! read more

Pizza Barn - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

My experience was very uncomfortable. You can have a good excellent product and your customer service be trash !! I came to pizza barn at around 10:45pm , we got our pizza approximately 11:10 pm . We got the super Pizza 2 feet and as we eating and other customers started leaving around 11:25 pm .The workers started cleaning using bleach...packing up the pizza .. turning out lights and turned off the music And we got dead stares pretty much saying hurry up without saying hurry up. The later "waiter " gave us a small ass box so now the pizza looks sloppy inside the box !! For $53 they gotta do better !! Won't get another dollar from me. Food was good ..order to go The signed said open until midnight. They actually closed at 11:25 after that their energy was nasty & rude . read more

Pizza Barn - Classic Round Cheese Pizza with 3 Toppings - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

Passing through and was hungry for pizza in Yonkers. So, we stopped by the Pizza Barn. Very friendly staff with a great attitude. The fresh pizza looked good but we wanted one of the big slices as seen on the many photographs on the walls. It came out in about 15 minutes and was very hot. Took us a few seconds to separate the gooey pieces of the giant slice of pizza. We ordered cheese on one half and pepperoni on the other half. The sauce is mild and a bit sweet, which reminded me of my hometown favorite Detroit pizza. There were condiments bottles of Parmesan, red pepper flakes, salt, black pepper and Italian seasons to put on as we felt our tastebuds would find happy. Fresh soft thin crust as wonderful. I ordered a plain cheeseburger as an appetizer because I love burgers. The cheese was American and was a thick slice of wonderful. Parking lot was right next to the shop and it was easy to find the front entrance. If you are in the area, stop in like we did. read more

See all

Place had been on my bucket list for 4 years and it did not disappoint. I still can't believe how well they cooked the Superslice and cooked it so evenly! Store may not be in a convenient spot, but the experience is so worth it. It's not often you can order 24" slice pizza. I ordered the pepperoni, and it was well cooked. Honestly, it was surprising how well tasted - edges and the middle. Taste is average, so it's easy to eat. Staff is super friendly, and I would get this often if I could. read more

Pizza Barn - Pepperoni Super Slice - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

My love for Pizza Barn is something else... me and my boyfriend came here four times on the same month to try a different flavor cause their pizzas are ADDICTIVE!!!!!! Angel is my main man there, his positive always willing vibe got us to instantly click with him. He's the best person ever!!!!! I can't really explain how good their pizzas are. Just imagine, we came here 4 times within 10 days (calculated the dates on the photos now) just to have pizza, THEIR giant slice, that says pretty much everything. I can't wait to be back!!! Pizza Barn is 100000000% recommended by meeee, and I truly hope you run into the special Angel whenever you visit cause he will definitely make a difference on your day. read more

See all

As they say "Size DOES MATTER", lol.. If you really like Pizza, YOUU MOST COME HERE AND TRY THEM OUT!! Best pizza ever, and even better the Size of it!! You get a Giant pizza honestly for almost the same price as Pizza Hut.. This place is "Giantmazing"!! The pizza is very good and fresh!! And so far is the ONLY ONE PLACE in NYC that has my Favorite flavor a veery DOMINICAN AND UNIQUE COMBINATION "HAM AND CORN". The service is the best part, we have a friend now lol, he became our friend, and everytime me, my sis and her bf visit this place he recognize us, so cool!! VERY CLean! The music is always good, loud enough to enjoy it and loud enough for you to chitchat, the AC is my only concern lol, I'm always cold here! But LOVE THIS PLACE, loooove their service, and their pizza! read more

See all

This is one of the best pizza spots in Yonkers ! They have a huge pizza you can split with your family and very reasonable prices. The sauce and dough are amazing and delicious ! I caught wait to go back and eat more pizza from here soon! read more

Pizza Barn - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

Love this place! Not only is the pizza huge it's really good! It's a clean and modern look to sit and eat and the staff have always been very kind. Plenty of options to choose from, you won't be disappointed here read more

Absolutely love it here been loving their food since they were on McLean Ave, the food and the service has always been consistent the ambiance is always good totally recommend them read more

I've been faithful to the same pizza place for a couple of years so the only reason I added this place to my list of places to check out was because of the super slice. I finally got the opportunity to stop by because I was in the area but I was expecting just a lot of mediocre pizza because usually people sacrifice quality for quantity. This was not the case at all I called in my order and it was ready within a 10 min drive. I was greeted as I walked in to a beautiful establishment with a couple of sit down tables to eat and an array of pizza options in a glass. The pizza smelled too yummy to wait until I got home to Queens so I started eating in the parking lot and I did not stop until I was infront of my house. It was so good, even without the toppings. It was still delish the next morning too. The crust is thin and buttery and they use enough cheese and you can taste the garlic in their tomato sauce I'm planning my next trip out there for another slice and recommending it to all my friends. I look forward to going back read more

Pizza Barn - Plain superslice - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

I have had Pizza Barn bookmarked on Yelp for years! I finally got to experience the famous pizza and was not disappointed. I was in an adventurous mood so I ordered half Buffalo chicken and half margarita. This actually itself is GOOD pizza! We came on a Friday afternoon and surprisingly we were able to walk right in and be seated. Our server Angel was such a sweetheart and even offered to take photos of us with the giant pizza. Overall, I was super happy with everything and will definitely come back when I feel like indulging ! read more

See all

Finally made it to Pizza Barn after all these years. They were at another location, but that area is notorious for horrid parking - hence why my lazy self never went. I always planned for it, but then I saw they were moving to a new location and I knew once they moved in and renovated, I would at long last get to try them. Let's get this out of the way - yes, the "Super Slice" is a gimmick. But it's a gimmick which has worked out well for them. I've seen their videos years ago. Most businesses would love that exposure and it's clearly good for their business. Yes, I know how the slice is made - and they've been up front with it in those videos, so not a big deal. Though it has never been that far away from me, I'd have never heard of this place if not for those videos regarding the super slice, so it's good business for them. Just mentioning that for the ones who dismiss this place solely based off that. That being said, I came in the very first day they opened at this newer location. For locals, this used to be DOCS but Pizza Barn completely renovated the building and lot. Yes, they have a small parking lot with a space or two right in front. Place was bustling. I'm unsure if this is the norm or it's because they just opened here - or maybe it was a typical Friday night. I went in the very next day - Saturday - and it was the same. Despite the lines/crowd, the ones behind the counter were very nice and attentive - which goes a long way. Tried the "Super Slice" the first night and came back the next day to try a regular pizza pie. The Super Slice is what it is. It wasn't bad at all. I preferred the regular pie honestly - maybe it's just because I also like crust with my slices when the Super Slice only has 2 pieces with crust. Crust here is thick and I do like it. I've said this in every pizzeria review and I'll type it once again: not all pizza or pizzerias are good. Not everyone's taste buds are the same and people generally have their preferences. But there is a such thing as bad pizza and good pizza. This was easily not the greatest I've ever had, but far from the worst. Both the Super Slice and the regular pie were filling and tasted just fine. The online menu was slightly different than the one inside. They had no take out menus at the time, so I had to just read the one in store. The fridge is limiting, but the Mexican Coke/Sprite is a big plus. As I said, everyone inside was good despite the madness. They have about 6 or so tables inside to dine in. They have the small parking lot and there's about 2 spots in front to park in. Due to the Casino, most of the side streets have permits required, so keep that in mind. There are literally 3 other pizzerias in less than a mile from this location, so they need to keep on their toes here, which I'm sure they will as they've been in business for a long time. Everything was good enough, that I will certainly come back here again. I do want to try their one pound garlic knot and their stuffed crust with garlic. It's easy to dismiss a place over a "gimmick", expect something more, and then say "that's it?" - but the "gimmick" has worked and unless something changes, this place is more than just the "gimmick". Keep expectations in the right place and you'll be fine. read more

Pizza Barn - The "Super Slice". - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

The new location is absolutely stellar! They now have a parking lot, more seats (meaning more space), and restrooms! The staff is pleasant and Of course the pizza is good and fresh! I've always enjoyed bringing friends from out of town but now I feel like I'd be able to go by more often and not worry about a crowd. read more

Pizza Barn - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

I called to place a pickup order on June 20th 2025 for it to be picked up the next day and the guy that over the phone was super pushy and impatient with me to the point where he got a part of my order wrong. I asked for garlic crust on two pies and he kept saying yeah yeah yeah i got everything everytime I read it off again. Got there the next day to see that the crust was regular instead of garlic. read more

This place is ALL about the likes!!!! The customer service and excitement were lacking . That along with the taste of the pizza is sub par. Please, do yourself a favor and take your 24in slice to go. Carry your box, post a pic for social media, and eat it at home. We shared a 24 inch Napoli pizza. This slice was supposed to have 240 pieces of small pepperoni. But we asked for less. The guy who took the order said you will have to pay the $40 despite not wanting them on your pizza. It wasn't a problem. However, the drink options are kept in one fridge with individual options like Pepsi, Snapple, Martinelli Apple Juice, seltzer water etc. When I inquired about ice, He said we don't have ice at all. Now, who drinks a beverage without ice in a restaurant setting?! There is one man who serves your order and cleans the table. Although, you would think he was a waiter. read more

Pizza Barn - Seated and waiting for our order. - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

Great customer service. Great pizza!! Lots of options. Never disappoints!!! Everything in this pizzeria is GOOD!!!

IT WAS AN EXPERIENCE!!! BUT THAT's All!! As i said, i have been following them for a while. Drove all the way to Yonkers to get my GIANT slice. Well they are extremely busy, there was a line when we arrived, and there was still a line when we were leaving. FYI, there is a wait at least 40 mins for your order!! Make sure check what you ordered before you leave, because they made wrong orders for many people as we were there. Also we ordered Chicken parm slice, we got a cheese slice. We walked to the counter, they gave us the wrong order, they got the pizza back!! I DON'T KNOW WHAT THEY DID WITH OUR PIZZA, ESPECIALLY BECAUSE OF THE PANDEMIC, YOU SHOULD NOT TAKE ANY FOOD BACK FROM CUSTOMER, HOPE IT IS DISCARDED. Then we got our chicken parm slice. There was barely chicken pieces on our slice, didn't want to complain, because it took us an hour and twenty minutes to get our slice back. Also, i get more chicken on my regular slice at ROCKY's II on second avenue New York. Giant garlic cheese knot was the best for the meal! Pepperoni giant slice was good, pepperoni was extremely salty than any other pepperoni you have, and very spicy!! Won't be back, it was an experience!! read more

See all

Conveniently located near the highway, Pizza Barn has all you need to satisfy your hunger. Famously known for their Super Slice, which is 24 inches of cheesy, saucy, and crusty goodness. Their menu is adorned with many options, from pizzas to pastas, appetizers, and desserts for your choosing. Let's talk about customer service... AMAZING! We were greeted instantly at the door and presented with menus. Less than 10 minutes later, the food was brought out. Pizza Barn has a great environment and is perfect for family nights! Things to know: Empire City Casino is located right across the highway Opened Monday - Saturday 11am -10pm EST Dine-in, curbside, and no contact delivery options available. What's on my table? Half cheese and pepperoni Super Slice (Be sure to try Mike's Hot Honey on your slice!) read more

Pizza Barn - Half cheese/ Half Pepperoni Super Slice - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

We had a heart pizza! Half cheese half Pepperoni It was huge for 2 people! I loved the crust and cheese! Parking was great! Staff was nice! Good seating! read more

See all

Delicious pizza in huge portions! The restaurants portion itself isn't very big but serves its purpose... the place is conveniently located and has parking.. read more

Pizza Barn - Giant slice - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Had to stop by after 20 years out of state and the pizza was sooo good , have kids bring them they will love the 2ft slice read more

Pizza Barn - 2ft slice with pepperoni and some snapples - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

The pizza is awesome here. Definitely worth it and fresh! Service is quick and if you have to wait it's all because it's made to order. Cranking out large pies that barely fit in the box !! Very low key dinning if you decide to stay and enjoy a slice straight from the pizza oven Give them a try! You won't regret it! read more

Great place for a unique pizza experience. Order the mega large slice. It's not the best I terms or composition and ingredients but it's worth the novelty and trip. read more

My favorite pizza place in Yonkers! The superslice is the absolute best. The service is nice and the staff is friendly. Your order will be ready quick! I highly recommend. read more

Pizza Barn - Pepperoni Super Slice - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Umm i finally decided to give this place a try! My cousin came with me because i knew i wasn't gonna finish it on my own lol...we got a half plain half olives mega slice...the pizza was just ok. I honestly think they should have left it in the oven a little longer to give it a nice crisp crust but the cheese and sauce didn't do it for me...I'll give it another shot maybe in the future and hopefully i can update this review read more

The food is real good I was passing by this place for a year. So today hungry I'm getting a Calzone with sausage. This was the best Calzone I've ever had it's amazing read more

See all