I was starving and ordered large pepperoni and bacon pie, order of wings and a 2 liter soda. Was the worst $50 I ever spent. First off, wings were not cooked right and I put in the notes well done with a side of ranch. Wings weren't well done and no ranch. Pizza was disgusting, had a weird taste to it. When I finally thought they can't mess up anything else, the 2 liter coke, had no gas in it, so I checked the expiration date and it was expired!! read more

Mickey's Pizzeria - Expired 2-Liter Soda! - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Best pizza in Yonkers. Mickey's put together a few specialty pizza pies for my daughters birthday party. Toppings dry aged beef (mish i thäte), beef sausage (sudjuk), and pickled mushrooms. We call it the Albanian Pizza. Thank you Mickey's the pizza was incredible. read more

Mickey's Pizzeria - Specialty by Mickey's Pizzeria... Albanian Pizza, god bless the chef. Thank you Mickey's Pizzeria. Best in Yonkers!!! - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

the owner is incredibly disrespectful was rude to my family basically yelled at us. the food isnt even good never again -100/10

I am from the Bronx and by far best pizza in Yonkers. Owner is always at your service and friendly. Gives a generous amount of calamari and with a smile. Pepperoni is my favorite. read more

TRASH. Customer service is garbage. Had me waiting with my kids for 20 mins to say he sold the 2 slices I was waiting for. Disgusting. Veryyyyyyy disappointed and the food fell off anyway. & I GOT THIS SERVICE FROM THE OWNER JAIMIE . Since he wants to act like he didn't see me there. Trash trash trash!!!!!! read more

I really enjoyed the sausage and mushroom pizza here! A local friend recommended this place. The sausage is thick sliced (instead of the usual crumbled type) and the mushrooms are fresh and plentiful. The pizza crust is thick and filling. It's really high quality - when you pick up a slice to eat, the slice holds its shape (and doesn't flop over and spill toppings everywhere). They have a lot of different options (sandwiches, pastas, etc.) here as well! read more

I have been going here since April, and I must say it doesn't disappoint every time I get anything to eat from there. Service is great from all of the people that work there. As well, you can sit down to eat there too. Ambiance is cool. read more

Great customer service ! Excellent food we got chicken bacon ranch pizza and it was amazing and don't forget the garlic knots yummy.. if your looking for a good pizza place this is your spot .. Let's all support local business they need us more than ever . read more

This pizza shop is definitely the better pizza shops in this area. Cooked right fresh ingredients and the owner is a nice guy. The food is delicious.it read more

Mickey pizzeria was the best . I moved back to Long Island craved it even told people about it then recently he's been answering the phone wit an attitude yes I traveled for the pizza and this last time the pizza didn't taste the same as it usually does. I would have dealt wit the attitude for the taste but don't give me a shitty attitude & now your pizza doesn't taste good . I have bad days at work too . I don't take it out on the public . read more

Good Pizza! Got Tortellini Soup and several slices. Went for their Stuffed Garlic Knots but they didn't have any. Decent pizza/food for take out. They were very nice to make fried ravioli for me even though it's not on there menu! read more

See all

Unorganized and inconsistent. Been ordering from them on Grubhub where they had a coupon of 5 dollars off any order of 35. All of a sudden that option is not there so I call them up and the guy says we can get the 5 dollar coupon if we order over the phone. I place the order and the total is the same as what I was getting on Grubhub with no coupon. He sighs and places me on hold comes back and says his system is down to order from Grubhub without the coupon. My department orders from them quite often and have even ordered catering on many occasions. But I will make sure that ends as he was getting agitated instead of trying to figure out where he went wrong with the prices. The food is good but on the principle of the horrible customer service I will gladly spend my money elsewhere. After paying a 2 dollar delivery fee, tax and tip the prices are ridiculous for pizza shop food. read more

The Best pizza I've had in Yonkers hands down. I moved here in August and have had pizza from multiple establishments and have not been fully satisfied. I stumbled across this place on my way home from a long drive and gave them a shot and was not disappointed. Pizza was 10/10 , Wings were 10/10 and customer service was excellent. This is now my pizzeria officially and will be for the entirety of my time in Yonker read more

Oh. My. God. Where have you been all our life? Hands down the best delivery pizza. Ever. We literally work on the same Lake St. But we've always ordered from a Dom and Vinnie's and always hated it. Everyone in the office always complains and no has ever liked D&V's pizza but ordered there by default. But finally being fed up, we tried Mickey's. We didn't think it could be any good because they were too close. But boy was I wrong. Even the picky Italian girl in the office loved their pizza. As for the review, We ordered mozz sticks, a Chappaqua salad, sausage peppers wedge, meatball parm wedge, and a PEAR DELIGHT PIZZA. and everything was so damn good. Pizza was amazing, you have to try it. Pears, gorgonzola, Caramelized onions and brown sugar with a crispy bottom! Oh man I want another slice now but my fingers would get too sticky. Good came hot, with a smile and we will most definitely order here again. It will be our new default pizza delivery spot! read more

See all

If you want a place with a nasty owner this is the spot to be at. The owner is disgusting with his attitude considering the below average pizza and dishes that are served here. read more

They have great pizza and food & excellent customer service! I love the plain slices & chicken Caesar salads & wraps. I am a creature of habit so I always order the same. But the entire menu is great & generous portions! read more

Look, I love the pizza at this place, but the delivery times are ridiculous. Two Saturdays in a row we've had to call to find out where our food was. Seamless gave us a delivery time of 8:25pm tonight. After being told 10 mins ago that it's "5 mins away" we're sitting here at 9:24pm wondering if it's ever getting here. Sad. Guess we'll go elsewhere... UPDATE: Showed up at 9:27pm ICE COLD with ham instead of bacon on the meat lovers that we were specifically told had bacon and not ham. Game over. read more

Needed a New York pizza fix while I was traveling through town and that's just what a got! Solid pizza. Would order again :)

Vegan? Mickey's is actually vegan friendly. I always get their vegetable panini (it's really just a huge sandwhich)...not the Italian one. The other, I can't remember the name but it comes with grilled eggplant (and I don't even like eggplant) arugula, tomatoes, zucchini and spinach. I ask them to hold the cheese and replace it with avocado. So good!!! I usually only eat like half. Then save the rest for later...taste even better when u reheat it on a pan. Sometimes I get the pasta fagioli soup too and it's made with vegetable broth. Yum. read more

Mickeys is the best!!! We order from there more than once a week and everything from there is DELICIOUS! Never disappoints. And they always do right by the customers read more

Mickey's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Don't waste your time. The owner, Jim is EXTREMELY RUDE. It's unfortunate because the food is pretty good. Go across the street to Lake Avenue Pizza. It's just as good and there are more menu options. read more

Been coming here for a year now and its still my favorite spot! Owner is very polite and responsive. Best pizza I've had since Brooklyn. Very fresh, best ingredients and tons of flavor omg you have to try it. Also try the chicken sorrentino, I order it too much lol. read more

Wow! This place is amazing! Great tasting food and great customer service. I called asking if they could make calamari in vodka sauce and it was not a problem! I called another place before them and that place acted as if I was crazy. The food was so delicious. I would recommend the Mickey's wrap, calamari, and the prosciutto garlic knot. I am definitely impressed. read more

See all

Ordered the grandma large pie and it was bomb! Also ordered the Buffalo wings and they were great. Will for sure order again!

Such a great pizzeria! Jimmy (the owner) is truly something special! He has such great customer service skills!! He really takes the time out to get to know his customers, as well as putting his all into such good food! Mickey's catered food for a special event for us, and they went above & beyond!!! Food was fresh, hot, delicious, and the bread was fresh out the oven! Everyone enjoyed every bite! And placing the order with Jimmy was so easy, he took care of everything for me so I did not have to stress a thing! Food is delicious, staff is friendly, place is clean and the prices are great! What more could you ask for?! Definitely a place to try! And you will love!! read more

This pizza place is pretty great. The food was delicious. Only problem is that delivery was a little late.

I work at the school just up the road and this is quickly becoming our go to place. Pizzas are excellent!!!! read more

Mickey's Pizzeria - Pepperoni calzone. Yum!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Mickey's Pizza is great!! The food is delicious and the customer service is always good! My friends and I visit on a weekly basis. The pizza and salads are always on point! If you in Yonkers, I highly recommend Mickey's! read more

Great reliable food. I get the penne with meatballs frequently. Comes with 3 tasty meatballs. Its delicious!!!

Mickey's Pizzeria so as good as it gets...Just ordered another pizza from them...can not wait to try some Dinners!!

Great Pizza! I ordered a large sausage and anchovy pie to go. Crust was crunchy and chewy with good flavor. sauce was nice, not overly sweet. good cheese and generous amount of sausage slices and anchovy. While I was waiting the chef and I were talking about food. He pulled a bubbling Grandma Pie out of the oven and cut me a slice to try! Nice people, great pizza! read more

Good food, horrible service. Everytime, I order, they leave you on hold. When they finally get to your order, you have to repeat yourself a dozen times because they are talking to the customers placing orders in front of them. So you can guess how long it takes for your delivery to come.. read more

Their actual burger patty is good, the mysterious bread it comes on is not appetizing at all more fit for an animal with large canines. The french fries are also good and I don't believe I've ever received a soggy batch of them. Wings are not very appetizing too chewy almost raw like but the chicken fingers with buffalo sauce have been a hit. The pizza is also good not a fan of the sauce but better than most. Ordered spiedini once but all I received was a piece of soggy bread with enough garlic to wake Nosferatu. Their garlic knot sandwiches can be good as well. Last couple of times my orders have been a miss so that explains the rating. read more

Absolutely the best pizza in Westchester county. Ingredients taste fresh, crust is right, sauce is to dye for and prices and very affordable. I've got the chicken bacon ranch and Hawaiian and both tasted heavenly. Prices are very affordable and costumer services is amazing... I loves mickeys pizza read more

Great pizzaria with great dependable food and pizza with very personable service. I order here often and am never dissapointed.

GREAT hidden gem for the neighborhood! Their pizza is divine..perfect crust and and if you do not see the topping of your choice (and they have a variety), they will create it for you. Their soups are made from scratch and the pasta fagioli is my favorite. They also serve pasta dishes and other Italian delights. They cater for parties as well as cater in their small establishment and the service is the best! We will certainly frequent this restaurant when in the neighborhood. read more

Definitely a hidden gem for pizza in Yonkers. Was beyond surprised how much I enjoyed everything. Stuffed garlic knots are amazing. Calzone was delicious and pizza is of top quality. Been ordering twice a week for past few weeks trying new things every time the wife and I order read more

Very delicious food and there salads are great . Great service great spicy wings just the way I love em and very good service deff recommend everyone to come eat and great host for pizza party's read more

DEFINETLY you have to come here! In my opinion best pizza sauce I've tasted! Recommendation: if you order a chicken roll or any! Roll at that! Ask them to give you a side of there "pizza sauce" not "marinara sauce"...PIZZA SAUCE to dip and it is amazing...and the rolls are amazing and pizza well obviously you can taste the quality in the ingredients..QUALITY OVER QUANTITY ANYDAY! Here!! Not to mention they have a crazy "Mac Attack" Slice think of it as a Big Mac on a pizza CRAZZZZZY! read more

Horrible horrible horrible service! They hang up on you and then they don't answer you calls. When you order the food, it comes extremely cold! NEVER AGAIN! DON'T ORDER FROM THIS PLACE! They are rude!!!!!!! Specially jimmy. read more