I have been wanting to try this place for a few months. The other day I finally was able to make the time to check it out. I'm so happy I did! Despite the place being small there is definitely good seating availability throughout, whether at the countertop, high top tables, or standard tables. The staff were very pleasant. I ordered two slices. I got the chicken scarp and a margherita. Both were such great choices! The flavors were amazing for both. I'm looking forward to returning and trying other flavors. They also have calzones, pinwheels, garlic knots, and zeppolis. You can also order pies and slices in advance for pick-up and to take-out. If you're in the area, check this place out! read more

Strictly Pizza - Chicken Scarp Margherita Slice - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

Once again great pizza , service and nice surroundings. Went on a Saturday the place was pumping with people. Great atmosphere there! read more

See all

Went here 2 weeks ago and ordered 2 slices one was the grandma slice. After paying I noticed that they didn't put any of the grated cheese(Reggiano) on it . I asked if they could put it on since it usually is on it. The guy sticks his hand in the cheese and throws it on the pizza. I have been coming here since the place opened and order the same thing every time. I have never seen them do this. They usually use these small tongs. I tell the guy I don't want the pizza after he put his hands in it and he tells me he doesn't handle money so it's ok. It's not ok with me . I was in disbelief because the guys nails are filthy. They are usually very nice especially the owner. Needless to say I'll be looking for another pizza place. Too bad because the grandma pizza is so good! read more

I love this spot for single slices of pizza. There's a lot of great variety, and my kids love watching the pizzas be made. The restaurant is very clean and bright. It has simple decor, but I love the pizza-oriented accents and perching in the window. read more

Strictly Pizza - Caprese and sausage + broccoli -- both good! - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

See all

Sicilian is excellent. Ordered 2x on uber eats. Sauce/dough/cheese perfect combo. Enjoyed sicilian with Jalapeño's. Fast delivery large amounts of toppings. I am very very picky about pizza and specifically love sicilian pizza. This is very good pie. hard to find in area. top choice along with sal's and villa maria for sicilian imo. these guys unique because offer jalapeños for topping (and a great pizza too). read more

Strictly Pizza - Sicilian Pie with Jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

I happened to be in the area and remembered that I have been meaning to stop and try them out. I have been seeing them in construction for soo long so i was happy to see it in action. Strictly Pizza in Pelham Manor is just that, strictly pizza. They have a relatively small menu with various assortments of toppings to choose from. They also have quite a few composed pizzas ready to be ordered by the slice. Since this was my first time there and I wasn't even really hungry, I went for a regular slice, a pepperoni calzone, and some garlic knots. The true test of any pizzeria (in my opinion) is the regular slice, untouched, as is, so you can truly judge the pizza. Happy to report that the pizza was solid. Really good cheese, sauce, and minimal to no flop. Initially I wasn't even going to order one but a fresh pie had just come out as I was waiting to pay for my order so I asked to add one slice to the order. I haven't eaten any of the garlic knots and I only took one bite of the calzone. It looks and tastes like a fried calzone style which I like, similar to Louie & Ernies. The cheese, sauce and toppings seem to be quality and since they only focus on pizza -- they are able to uphold the quality. The inside is very open and spacious with some hi top seats in the front and some bigger tables in the back. The staff was eager to help and answer any questions and they move quick and efficiently. My neighborhood in the Bronx is spoiled with great pizza options so I won't be traveling out just to get it, when I am in the area I will go back if I'm in the mood for pizza. They only have pizza by the slice or pie, rolls, pinwheels, and calzones. read more

Strictly Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

This is a great location and the service and food are just as great we ordered the Marguerita Pizza quick service and reasonable prices Ample siting and decorative room for a small gathering all and all great start to this new location in my neighborhood read more

See all

Pizza is ok, I've had better. Service was great. Nice friendly people. Nic ambience clean and very comfortable read more

Strictly Pizza - Two regular slices - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

My husband stopped by this place tonight to get us a sausage and onion pizza. The crust was hard and tasted burnt and there was not much tomato sauce on the pizza! I've eaten here before but I only bought a slice and it was nice and soft and was good. Tonight was a waste of money. I only ate one slice and did not eat the crust because it was too hard. My husband tried to eat the crust and his temporary crown on his tooth came out. He had to go to the 24 hour CVS to get some kind of dental glue to fix it until he can get to the dentist. That was enough for him to leave that "hard as hell" pizza alone. read more

See all

Was in a rush and really hungry and wanted a quick bite. They have a nice parking lot, went in quickly. Service was really good like super friendly which is always nice, place looks spotless, and pizza is amazing! Probably going to become my new go to when I'm in the area. Wish I got 2 slices instead of splitting this one. read more

Strictly Pizza - Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

Great selection of food. Staff was very pleasant and service was on point. Well worth a trip to Pelham. Pizza and calzone is slightly crunchy. Absolutely delicious! read more

See all

Food is delicious and they have a wide variety of pizza. The staff is polite and friendly. Excellent service

Great service, but unfortunately, average Pizza went there to try their grandma slice in terms of grandma slices. It's probably the lamest.

Upside down slice is amazing! Could not recommend more! I've been stopping by Strictly Pizza for months and not once have left disappointed. read more

Signs all over the restaurant say a plain slice is $3.75. Okay. When they served me the slice, they told me to pay when I was done.. ok, nothing unusual there. But then they charge $4 for the slice. It's $3.75. Why pull this thievery? Why mess with people like this? Why not just say the slice is $4 and then CHARGE $4? Why deliberately lie to each customer coming through the door? What a dump. The decor looks like somebody ordered the kitchen from IKEA. The pizza itself was okay, but why overcharge people? Don't piss on my leg and tell me its raining. Just charge what the damn thing costs. It's a shame, because the place is very convenient - but it's just rude. If they need an extra quarter for a phone call or something, just ASK. Don't demand it once the pizza is already eaten. Weak. read more

Interesting new spot. Pelham and Pelham Manor are overrun with pizza shops, so this is just getting ridiculous. Regardless, this location rates a solid 5/10 on food, 8/10 on service and 10/10 on ambience and street appeal. This store is shooting for a trendy insta spot vibe, the pizza is not spectacular it's just pizza, service was pretty decent greeted upon arrival but the order took far longer than anticipated, lastly the store is very clean and very presentable. Overall on all factors I believe a score of 7/10 is fair. There are better pizza spots at this point. read more

I too have great pizza in my area. but Strickly Pizza's calzone is high quality ingredients. The broccoli rabe taste fresh and was cooked perfectly. And the chicken and mutz outstanding. I love that the calzone doesn't taste doughy. it has a nice crunch to it. it's definitely worth a trip for me. A job well done! read more

Grandma Sicilian pizza is the best and my kids love the garlic knots and marinara sauce. The place is clean and very bright and the service is very friendly. read more

love this place. I live walking distance. This pizza is soooo good! I always get the grandma pie or the margherita pie. Try it! It is delicious! read more

Excellent pizzaria coming from a Brooklynite. One of the best buffalo slices I've ever had. Atmosphere is beautiful, clean and cozy. The staff is extremely friendly and funny. Can't wait to come back! read more

The food was average at best, and I think expensive. ,almost $7 for a plain slice and a can of soda. But the staff was nice

I just stopped in for a regular slice and a Corona beer. The pizza was excellent, just the way In like it, oven fresh, thin and crispy crust. Only minor gripe might be price, running steep everywhere I'm afraid. One slice and a beer was $10. Price charged was higher than listed on the wall, even though a recently opened business. read more

The pizza was tasty--fresh and not oily. It felt lighter than a typical slice and wasn't too filling. I had a Margherita and an upside-down Sicilian, which usually have less cheese than a regular slice. read more

Great pizza. Great service. We come here all the time and it's always great. Really good ny pizza.

The pizza was pricey but it was worth it. Did not get to experience the service and ambiance since the pie was a pickup.

Went in not expecting too much... one bite was all it took. This is the best pizza outside of the city, and better than a lot of pizza I've had in the city. A perfect simple cheese slice is all you need. A little pricy, but it's so good that I didnt feel ripped off. Oh, and don't sleep on the garlic sauce. But, you will be tasting garlic for the next two days. read more

Horrible negative stars Nice inside but the pizza not good people very nice Nothing left to say read more

Very bright clean establishment. Pizza is really good. Friendly service. Yum yum yum................................................................................................................................................................................................................... read more

Regular pie was excellent and also the upside down pizza too. The people are friendly and helpful.

un lugar limpio , tranquilo y la pizza deliciosa la verdad que buenos sabores probamos 3 tipos de pizzas y todas con muy buen sabor la que estuvo con un aroma espectacular fue la de camarón bien rellena , la atención muy educados los caballeros el lugar limpio y pues tranquilo fui con mi pequeña familia y salimos satisfechos y con sabiendo q regresaremos en algún momento ya que el servicio fue muy bueno y su ambiente de la misma manera . read more

Strictly Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

See all

I just had their Scarpiello pizza and it's excellent, I also had their shrimp scampi pizza and it's on a different level, truly excellent pizza and an extremely clean establishment. Service was excellent as well. notice the word excellent showed up more than once. 5 stars read more

The place is clean and bright. Since it was my first time there I decided to try a regular slice with no toppings so I can gauge the quality of the pizza. From one to ten I would rate it a 6. Being a native New Yorker pizza is mainstay in our food system. They need to both work on the sauce to make it tastier, and the cheese to make it more appealing. The service was good and they have restrooms. read more

Pizza was absolutely fantastic. Everyone there was extremely nice and friendly. Will absolutely be back. Best pizza I've had in the area.

The most beautiful pizzeria with the most delicious pizza. The service is excellent. We drive 30 minutes because we love it so much. Definitely recommend Strictly Pizza. read more

The place itself is new and modern. It is very clean and decorated beautifully. The pizza itself is only mediocre at best. I wanted so much to like it but it is just not worth the trouble of getting there. The service is excellent and friendly which is why I gave 3 stars. read more

Extremely long wait, needs more Management with online orders, hope to see an update.

I am at the pizzeria. I had garlic knots and a grandma slice. It was delicious. My husband had plain and sausage slices, and they were great!. read more

Clean, professional serving delicious crispy thin crust meat lover, peperoni and garlic knots....

the best new pizza shop in the bronx!!! the pizza is verry veerrrry good. the place is beautiful.

amazing food super nice staff. amazing place to stop from coming home from the airport. 100 percent would have again do recommend when coming from the airport. 5/5. read more