Chicken Scarp slice here is delicious. Damn! Also had a potato croquet, which was good too. Service is solid, and the dining area is clean. read more

Been coming to Angelo's for many, many years. This is just a great staple on McLean Avenue is Yonkers. The pizzeria has a very nice, family owned feel with very friendly service. Every pizzeria has their own "slice" or "signature" pizza that they are known for...and every time I pop in here I always go for the "Angelo's Special"! Me and my Girl love this slice! It's got chicken, tomato chunks and broccoli. It's a great pie. One thing I love about Angelo's pizza is the fact that they make a nice and thick dough. Everybody's got their preference and Angelo's make's it the way I like it! They always make a large pie too. You definitely get your money's-worth. They also have a bunch of awesome calzones and rolls to choose from as well. Good food and good service. The only thing that sucks is the parking. Sometimes if you're lucky you might find an empty spot...but most of the time I find myself parking a little far from the joint. But...they also offer delivery as most places do, so that makes up for it in many ways! If you're looking for a great slice...check this place out! read more

Just moved to the McLean Avenue area and had to try the local pizza spots. After trying the three pizzerias nearby, Angelo's Pizza is by far the best on McLean not even close. The pizza really gives you that classic New York taste that you're looking for. The place is always clean inside, and the staff is super friendly. If you're in the neighborhood and craving real New York pizza, Angelo's is definitely the spot. read more

Angelo Pizzeria - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

Great place for pizza selections and Mexican food. Also breakfast and made to order sandwiches. Amazing customer service and very friendly staff. I stop by at least once a week for lunch and pick up something for dinner. I highly recommend this place for your fixings. read more

Best Grandmas pie I've ever had . The lasagna is off the hook also. Make the trip, it'll be worth it read more

Angelo Pizzeria - Best Grandmas pie I've ever had Their lasagna is off the hook also. Make the trip!! - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Had a meatball and spinach pizza. Absolutely perfect. Also had the small garden salad which was very good. Well done. read more

had a very disappointing and uncomfortable experience at this pizza shop. When I came in to pick up my order, my hands were full, and I asked the server if they could help me by placing the pizza in the bag. Instead of assisting, they looked at me and said, "Why can't you put the pizza in the bag yourself?" -- a completely unnecessary and disrespectful response. What made this worse is that I watched the same server bag orders for the white customers ahead of me without hesitation. As a Black man, I couldn't ignore the stark difference in how I was treated. It felt dismissive and frankly discriminatory. This wasn't an isolated incident either. My sister and several of her Black clients have also had negative experiences at this same location. It seems there's a pattern here -- and it's unacceptable. We all deserve to be treated with basic courtesy and respect, regardless of our race. Unfortunately, this establishment has made it clear that isn't a priority. I won't be returning, and I wouldn't recommend it to others. read more

It was a Friday around 5 pm. There was a loooong line. I walked in and ordered after waiting for approximately 5-6 minutes. I ordered a large plain cheese pizza for my two sons, my wife doesn't eat pizza, she might eat the crust once and a while. Well so this where the fun begins.... I waited close to 25-to a half-hour for the pizza to be prepared and ready. Not good turn around time. Do better. Get more people to make pizza, fer christsakes! Do something better. Secondly the pizza was 25$ that's steep. And way too expensive. The pizza tasted good. But again, I wouldn't be quick to order from them again. Plenty of other pizzerias in the area with better customer service and better tasting pizza. Ambiance is nothing to write home about, it's clean, and your avg pizza Parlor looking place. read more

Angelo Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

I had a pepperoni slice. The crust was a little too thick so it was slightly chewy. The pepperoni had no flavor and I didn't taste it on the pizza at all. read more

So far, I love this place. Best pizza in Woodlawn area, excellent customer service. Their spinach rolls, sausage and pepper rolls are great. Salads are fresh. And it's a cute spot. read more

Gone are the pizza only pizza places, set me back to twenty years past, to think and speculate about wings on a pizza parlor menu/board - I'd think you mad, off your tea. And my buddy wanted them, said they were good, I cut him off mid platitude. "I can't convince of this", I've heard of it - but never plucked up the desire to do it, so, I paced his place like Capt Ahab stumping around the quarterdeck of the Pequod. Parking was about as pleasant as kissing a slimy eel, as the blue and whites marched in little concentric circles, eyes upon me. I know the pattern all too well and signalled into the large glass window with fingers and flashing hands, wrist and arm lifts like semaphores. Tipping extra for the interpretation, I sped on off with the sweet buffalo smell permeating from within. Full of flesh, not overly boney - I think I tasted some underlying paprika, a richness under the spiciness - and my deep inhales had my sinuses quickly cleared, eyes slightly teared and my hunger fast awakening. Napkins are a must as all the non dry rub sauces are messy. I like over sauced wings, laying in a pool, thoroughly covered - let them lay and bask in the sauce, a nice Buffalo flavor, spice manageable and noticable and a hint of tangyness. Chicken can be chicken but you want it moist but not wet, it's my opinion the sauce is what matters - and I appreciate the extra sauce so I can roll and twirl the drumsticks then double dip into the blue cheese. Prices were fair, not overpriced - of course there's always room to improve but a good value none the less. read more

Angelo Pizzeria - Twenty Regular - Ten Hot - Ten Honey BBQ and enough Ranch and Blue cheese to choke a T-Rex - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

4 stars for the food and selections. It would be less based off the service. Naturally during pandemic times, things are going to be different. Like most other places, they have a "no mask no entry" sign in the front. Everyone behind the counter and the "regulars" inside had no masks, so I was the only one with one. I don't see the point in having the sign in that case. But I digress... The selection was pretty good. The garlic knots were tasty and the pepperoni twists were good. The slice was generally good. Yes, not all pizza tastes the same and everyone's preferences are different - but this is a good slice. A good selection behind the glass that didn't look like it was sitting there for days. There was a good beverage selection as well. There are a few tables to eat from and on a nice day during the pandemic, some tables outside. I can't say it felt welcoming in there as the staff behind the counter wasn't the best. Not overly rude, but not the friendliest either - only with their buddies/regulars inside. Maybe it was the time, but it's also no excuse as it's a business in general. I won't hold it against them as I do plan to try this place again and we'll see it if was just the one time. Only street parking is available - main street is metered and side streets are not. Again, the menu and food are good and worth it alone. With too many pizzerias making poor slices, it's a nice change to get a good one. read more

See all

Best tasting plain slice on McLean Ave.... my problem is: THEY DO NOT HOUSE PIES for walk-ins/pizza by the slice. Most pizza places make an xl pie and slice it into 8 slices. When you go in to order a slice, it's usually slightly on the larger size. This place uses a medium (or a small-ish large) to make its counter pizzas. In other words, slices here are on the SMALL SIDE especially when comparing to other local pizzerias. Pasta/marinara sauce is not great. Pasta is always overcooked/mushy. read more

The food here at Angelos Pizzeria Is so fresh and Savory!! They have so many options to choose from here.These people are amazing and the second you walk in they get you situated!. I recommend this place 100% read more

Angelo Pizzeria - A guy waiting for his food - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Pizza had "NY flop". Well seasoned cheese snd sauce. Can't wait to go back aka I'm ordering from here again tomorrow read more

Angelo Pizzeria - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Pizza is the best I've had so far around this area. It's my go to for delivery. I also enjoyed the pepperoni twists which I still can't believe only cost $1. I wouldn't recommend chicken cutlet, too salty in my opinion. Their marinara sauce is delicious which is how I judge pizzerias. Penne vodka was very tasty too. Oh and the potato croquettes are delicious too. read more

My friends ordered pizza at around 10pm for the Mayweather fight hoping for it to arrive by 11. We were pleasantly surprised when the food arrived at 10:45. The flavor was decent nothing to really phone home about. Only issue I had was that it seemed like they rushed to prepare the slices. Some parts were really doughy randomly throughout the pie (which I don't mind too much if the breads good) and uneven coating of sauce and cheese (some parts were just cheese on the bread). It suited the purpose of 'quick late pizza delivery for drunk people' but I wouldn't order again if I'm looking for a quality pizza night with some wine. read more

Angelo Pizzeria - Plain pizza. Thick in some places thin in others..not terrible - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

Purchased a plain slice and soda. Pizza was amazing just perfect soda ice cold highly recommend this pizza spot if you want some good pizza will definitely be back soon thanks! read more

Delicious pizzas, from classic thin crust cheese, margarita, to all toppings, chicken parmigiana heros, calzones and rolls, the area's best!

Just ordered chicken and vegetsbles. Received chicken and an extra salty thing that a totally rude man told me was bacon. Am allergic to bacon John told me it was not his problem. Sad that all Angelo Pizza wants is the money. Will never order from this awful people again read more

This has been my family's go-to pizza spot since forever. It's a nostalgic and reliable NYC slice. It's bigger and heftier than most, with a thick crust. They are a tad heavy handed with the cheese for my liking, but it is the hubs' favorite standard slice. What stands out here are the wings. They are really good for pizza place wings. We always get the "mild" even though we generally like spice. The mild has a unique taste - it's like a hot barbecue. read more

Came into Angelo's for a quick slice while in the area. Just as I walked in a fresh Chicken cutlet pie came out of the oven, so I went with that. Pizza was well made, with good ingredients and they were not stingy with the toppings. Prices were average. I would definitely come back based on my quick visit. Worth giving them a shot. Inside tables were very clean. read more

Stumbled in here while biking expecting it to be ordinary, mediocre pizza, but I took one bite and was wowed! Tasty and great texture. read more

This place is the best thing in the area.The owners are very friendly and pleasant they give everyone of their customers family treatment.The pizza and specialty slices are amazing in taste, also their wings and pasta dishes are great. In the spring and summer you can eat outside.This is perfectly ran father and sons business with a great indoor dining setting which they interact with all the customers in a pleasant and professional manner. read more

I order two pizza and beef party and they didn't even cooked my beef party right. Fucking blasters I'm going tomorrow to complaint and get my money back. Money wasted in food that I'm not eating. Meat and cheese was uncooked smfh read more

Angelo Pizzeria - Uncooked meat and cheese ...shit was cold as fuck - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

Who comes to New York and not eat pizza?!?! Pizza was the first meal I ate when I arrived in New York. It's a small pizza shop that also offers delivery. I selected the cheese pizza, which it has always been suggested to me to try a simple slice of cheese pizza in determining good pizza. The pies are pre-cooked, so warming time in the oven didn't take long at all. It was good, but I've had better. I even ate the crust which was a shocker, so I would definitely say they have good dough. read more

Angelo Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Yonkers, New York

The pizza in Angelos never disappoints. It's very yummy and has the perfect balance. My nephew is also a big fan of their pizza. Brought my uncle here and liked the chicken Marsala. The prices are modest and service is quick. The guys don't really smile but their food is good. I recommend the manicotti, chicken parmigiana, lasagna and stuffed shells. Delivery does take long. I usually pre-order and pick up or stay in. read more

great pizza, great wings/fries but everything else from here is mid and the customer service is terrible but there pizza is actually super good and there wings so i gotta give them four stars read more

Okay before I bad mouth them...... I have to say, their crispy chicken wraps are beyondddd amazing!!! The only reason I'm not giving 5 stars is because the service sucks. I can't even express how many times I have called an order for delivery and asked for ranch dressing on the side, only for them to get here and not have any ranch on the side. It has happened over 8 times now and it's really annoying. Besides that, food is awesome. read more

This place never disappoints. I have been enjoying pizza from this place for almost my entire life, and you can ask my family and friends about it and you'll always get told that there is no other pizza place like it. A great menu and choice of pizza, great service and clean packaging. This place has nothing to not like. read more

I am reluctant to write this review because I don't want everyone to know how amazing this place is!! The pizza is made with fresh ingredients and the penne a la vodka tastes like homemade too! Their prices are great as well. I called them day of for catering and all of the food was delicious! This place is fantastic and probably one of the best Italian restaurants around. read more

The first time I came in here, I only got a chicken parm slice. It was thick and I really like thin slices (what do you expect from a New Yorker?) and so I was expecting to not enjoy it as much. Just say I got two slices after that. Their slices are thick but super crispy crusty and pretty amazing I have to admit. The staff there is really nice too and usually you can find parking outside at one of the meters, or if not, on the side streets. read more

Honestly? Their Pizza is JUST okay. It's cliche to say, but I've experienced so much better in the city. The only reason people eat here is because of the location; when there's not that many pizza options and every place seems to over the same thing at different prices, you go with the closest and cheapest thing. And their service freaking sucks. I mean, I never have a "confrontation" with them so to speak, but hot damn, talk about rude and dismissive. If you want Pizza done way better in McClean, go to Sophia's. read more

Nothing beats a plain slice of pizza in my opinion and I can't think of too many places that have as good a slice as Angelo's. I grabbed a quick slice today at this modest looking pizzeria and I was impressed. Angelo Pizzeria will be visited again when I'm in Yonkers! read more

I've been going here since November 2019 and it has always been the same regular store. Ok food thats overly priced with rude and unwelcoming staff should probably get some younger faces behind the counter instead of a bunch of italian geezers its past your time man pass down the torch. read more

Perfect pie! You can't beat this place. The dough is cooked perfect, the sauce has the right amount of zing, the cheese is toasty, and it all blends perfectly! They have the standard, NYC pizzeria fare too. The Jamaican patties, pepperoni rolls, heroes, and whatever else. It's not a big place inside, and don't expect to bring a huge crowd with you. There's no fancy decorations, there is no server, there's not a lot of decorations. There's not even a lot of seating! You come here just for the food. It's a neighborhood joint. Don't come out of your way for this place. If you happen to be close, it's worth it. Be nice to the Irish. This is their territory. read more

My first time here and the customer service was good. The pizza was mediocre, but I was told the salad was good ( wasn't me that ordered it). I would give it another try. read more

If you live in Woodlawn, this is where you should be ordering your Pizza for delivery. Their large pies are very large, 8 slices, NY style pizza. The dough is what makes this pizza great, and they tend to use the sauce sparingly so it's not as soggy as other NY pizza places. The hot wings are pretty good too, usually get a large pepperoni pie and 10 wings for about $20 total delivered, not a bad deal ! read more

I just came here for the first time. And I have to say, I will definitely come back. they have a great eggplant sandwich that is out of this world. People are friendly and it feels like it is a place family could gather. read more

I walked in with my dad and for starters, the pizza didn't look all that good but we decided to get two slices because we were starving. They said there was a $20 minimum when using a credit card. I have never heard of such a thing, $10 yes but $20?? Really?? So how much is a pie? Probably less then $20. That's awful and the guy there working was rude, nasty and had an attitude problem. You'll be better off going to another pizzeria up the block. read more