Love this place! Pizza is always great nice and crispy! The guys here will treat you like family as you walk in. Real warm place with a lot of history! read more

The food was amazing! The beers were cold and the shrimp tasted very fresh! Make sure you book your massage appt with coo coo Michelle @ The time leisure beauty spa & grab a bit to eat AFTER at this delicious pizza place/diner joint! This pizza place was so cozy and family oriented! read more

See all

Unexpectedly stopped in for the first time. Love this place! Everyone is friendly and nice. Pizza was amazing. Great crust and chew. So many great looking pies, it was hard to choose. Tried a Sicilian, an eggplant slice, and a chicken scarp slice. They were all delicious! read more

See all

We picked up slices from here. The restaurant had a very family friendly atmosphere. The grandma's slice was absolutely delicious. It was loaded with super chunky tomato sauce and a fluffy, doughy crust. I was very impressed. I also got a plain slice, which was good but nothing special. Look forward to trying more of their menu in the future! read more

Pizza here is kick ass good . You can taste the quality of ingredients and you can see the pride they take in the product they sell . Guys behind the counter are " service with a smile " and gracious . Place is always, clean and well maintained . Service Is reasonably fast and courteous . These are the kind of businesses I want to spend my hard earned money . read more

Pelham Pizzaria I first stepped into Pelham Pizzeria as a teenager in 1978--and this July 2025, I brought my wife and daughter to share the same magic. I'm thrilled to say, nothing's changed. The pizza is still the best I've ever had, and the feeling? Pure nostalgia. Pino, now running the pizzeria like his father once did, made us feel so welcome. With one bite, I was transported back to being 17 again. Thank you to the entire team for making us feel at home--both in Pelham and back in Chicago. We'll always carry a slice of this place in our hearts. --Robert Zaffino read more

Pelham Pizza - Pure Joy - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

See all

Pizza is sooo good at Pelham Pizza. I think the last time I was here, they didn't even take credit cards. Delicious airy, crunch crust - perfect sauce. And I wouldn't have ordered sausage pie, but that's what my nephew wanted - and it was fantastic! Sausage crumbles were quality. We will order from here every chance we get. read more

Pelham Pizza - Sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

Real family like atmosphere. Cozy settings . Food is excellent and the great friendly service compliments it . Plenty metered street parking in front . Very clean and well maintained place . Definitely recommend it ! read more

Delicious and always GREAT. The service is fabulous, fast, and consistent. Try the spinach pizza - you won't regret it. It is a clean restaurant with a family and Italian vibe. My absolute happy place when I visit family. Also pro tip: they have Pelham pizza gift certificates. I mean, who would not want a Pelham pizza gift certificate? My family loves these. Keep up the amazing and hard work! read more

Good service food is good consistent which is always good . Nice menu to choose from Need some desserts .

The food was great and the service was fast. If you want an authentic pizzeria feel with an Italian accent this is the place. The ambiance was a buzzing pizzeria from old and I loved it. read more

This place has gone downhill the last few years. The pizza is rubbery with not much taste. The slices and calzones look a few days old at times. I have been going here since the late 70s. Now I go elsewhere read more

We wanted an authentic and locally owned pizzeria for dinner and Pelham was all of that! The crust was great and the sauce was especially good. We are we are vegan and we had the arugula salad pizza and it was the best we have ever had. My daughter got the gluten free pepperoni and like ours - it was excellent. We also had their broccoli rabe and that was delicious. I highly recommend! read more

I would never order pizza from this place again. The pizza was cold on arrival, all of the toppings were falling off, the pizza had no cheese, and had a terrible aftertaste. Definitely a waste of money! read more

Pelham Pizza - Buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

Hidden gem. Old style pizza place. Food is very tasty. Place is small, just like home. Very busy but worth it.

This was amazing I have been a food critic for years I have been to thousands of pizza restaurants but this was mah-valous The pizza hits hit the spot big time staff is great especially for Mike aka big papa they are all so nice btw I hope Ryan trahan see this review the point is the place is great I recommend it please come and say hi to Mike read more

Pelham Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

See all

As a Bronx native, pizza has always been a family go to for a quick dinner on a busy weeknight. Stumbled across this gem and was not disappointed. We opted to get assorted slices and sample a few- we were hungry! The buffalo chicken slice was delicious, perfectly spiced and fresh. The plain slice was amazing, you could really appreciate the sauce which was flavored nicely. The spinach slice was great, sautéed to perfection. Lastly, the grandma Sicilian slice was scrumptious. The crust was perfectly crispy but not too hard that you would worry about chipping a tooth. Definitely a family favorite! Plus- the serve wine and beer!! Enjoy! read more

Pelham Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

Excellent food, service and flair. Haven't been here in years and it's far away from me but when I am in the area I stop by. I remember when you opened we tried it and knew it would be great!! read more

Best pizza I've had in New York. Not only was the pizza great, but the service was too. Very great environment and experience overall, was super super pleased. read more

the food is great. the guys behind the counter are friendly funny and make great food! we come here at least twice a month and are never disappointed. the pizza is great, as are the dinner entrees. read more

Always great pizza and fast, friendly service. The tables and floors are always clean and there's good reason this place has a steady flow of customers. read more

My in laws live in Pelham so typically I go there once a week to visit . My husband told me he grew up eating at this pizzeria, I was excited to go . I definitely love me some pizza . You walk in , there is ample amount of seating . I noticed no menu so your not really sure of the prices but it's ok that doesn't bother me much . I got 2 plain slices and my husband got 2 sausage slices . It was ok . Not the best nor the worse pizza I ever had . I was not crazy about there sauce it had pepper in it , I tend to lean towards a sweater sauce and the cheese was very over cooked . There crust was delicious I will give them that . The staff was friendly and the location is convenient with plenty of street parking . read more

Pelham Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

My family and I have been eating here since I was pregnant with my first child, over 18 years ago; No surprise he only eats his pizza and wedges from here. The guys who work there are great. They get to know you, your order, and greet you by your first name. There's room for a sit down meal, nothing fancy but a great family feel with cute booth's. Pelham pizza is the ONLY pizza place I would recommend. read more

Excellent quality food, generous portions at reasonable prices! From the outside, this place looks like a plain-looking slice shop, but it is so much more than that. The service is friendlier than you normally would expect at a place like this, and they even packed up the leftovers for us. That's always a plus in terms of service. I had the fettuccine carbonara, which was certainly above average in quality. I find that carbonara is a difficult and unusual dish to make, so it's a good way to test an Italian restaurant. This place certainly passed the carbonara test. The portion size was absolutely enormous! It was better than the carbonara I had at a certain Michelin-starred restaurant in New Rochelle! I also had the opportunity to taste the fagioli soup, spinach pizza, and eggplant pizza. Everything was delicious. All of this, and the bill was under $50, with the tip included. Can't beat that. read more

That spinach pizza is good! The lasagna is also delicious. The chicken pizza is great. Yummy!!!

This pizzeria makes delicious pizza. The slices are large. there are usually at least 6 different speciality pizzas available besides plain and pepperoni. And the specialty pizzas are delicious and they do not skimp on the toppings. Phone orders can take a while depending on the day/time. The atmosphere of the place is homie. They know their regulars. But are friendly to all. *bonus..... courtesy of Covid they now take cards read more

See all

This pizza shop throws me back to my childhood in the 70's , the pizza tasted so good well this place has one of the best pizza around and not to mention they have home made soups also. The seating is booth style so it's a roomy place they have all kind of selections of pizzas and Italian dishes. I definitely recommend this business if you want a great meal from a friendly staff read more

See all

THIS PIZZA IS SO AMAZINGLY DELICIOUS!! It's so hard to find a really good slice these days!! The crust is perfect! The sauce is not overpowering!! My mom and I both had the spinach slice. I also had one regular slice! I definitely will be back here!! This just might be my new spot. read more

Pelham Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

See all

Fan of PP for 10 years, alway hot fresh and delicious and super nice. Try the Crush Pizza and believe it or not their soups are amazing!

If you come here regularly, chances are you know the staff. They're friendly enough. Pizza has been inconsistent since Covid, but it's never been bad. The people who go here are typically loud and boisterous so be prepared to talk over people. read more

The food is always great!! We love their pizza, soups, chicken..... Definitely worth to try. read more

Those that have been following my Yelp journey, know I'm constantly talking about how great New York Italian food is...and those who know me personally, know I typically do not like pizza... Everyone assumes pizza is "better in NY" --But this restaurant actually proves it. The first thing I do when I touch New York ground is head my way to Pelham and get myself a Slice of one of the ONLY pizzas I enjoy. When you walk in --it feels like family. Regulars and casual diners alike, all talking and laughing-- and the smell of the food is so pleasing you can't help but exclaim "smells good in here!" out loud! The selection is modest --and there is a menu with more than just pizza --but I mean, how could you not get a Slice?! The staff greets everyone, and their attitude is welcoming and warm! Now for the pizza : Crust, toppings, sauce, size, price -- all noteworthy for being incomparable in this area (and the surrounding ones). When I tell you anything you get will taste GOOD... I mean it. It's GOOD. 10/10. Better than any pizza I've ever had. Don't @ me. read more

Pelham Pizza - Tomato Pizza Sicilian Pizza Slice Thai Chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

I come regularly to Pelham pizza and the server recognizes me. It is not fancy, but very homie and friendly. The pastas, soup, and pies are very fresh, savory and delicious. My favorite is the soup and they have a good variety of them. Price is reasonable and they give you complimentary bread to start. It is a great place to get food without hurting your pocket. read more

Pelham Pizza - Sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

See all

Very cool vibe, like the pizza places I remember spending time at in my youth. The pizzas are big, but consistently good throughout.

Best SAUSAGE pizza in the entire U.S.A.! The size, taste, and amount of sausage which Pelham Pizza uses is bar none! There's a bit of an open favoritism that goes on to and for the regulars, one one of my closest friends who was born in Italy and who has lived in New Rochelle for decades told me this was the best pizza in all of Westchester County. The calzones are great as are the garlic knots. Therefore I overlooked the attitudes so as to experience the best pizza recommendation! I will definitely return and I absolutely recommend!! read more

See all

Solid pizza, great local people. Pizza is fine but very kid friendly, especially the cheese. But nothing to write home about

The absolute best white pizza I've ever had in all of New York. Just the right ratio of mozzarella to ricotta, so tasty, light, and airy. I don't know how these guys do it, but the pizza is amazing all the time. Friendly staff, make you feel at home the minute you walk in. Sat at a table, service was prompt and courteous. As a white pizza lover, oil no for the than this establishment~ you won't be disappointed! read more

Pelham Pizza - White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

First time customer. Monday afternoon and the place was packed. Knew at that moment it was going to be a great slice. Had the grandma slice with pepperoni It was delicious. Will be back. read more

I love this pizza at Pelham Pizza the pizza is the best and what I grew up on and it's delicious! Service is always good, same employees since I was a kid! read more

Pelham Pizza - Pizza window - Pizza Near Me - Pelham, New York

I've been going to Pelham Pizza since 1978 when I got my drivers license. The pizza is superb. The staff enjoy working there and treat the customers very friendly. I've had everything on the menu and never had a bad experience. I lived in Pelham Manor most of my adult life. My wife and twin sons absolutely love Pelham Pizza. We moved to CT in 2020 and drive down to Pelham Pizza twice a month for dinner. Westchester County has several outstanding pizzerias. Lately I've been getting the sausage and pepper pizza roll with extra mozzarella cheese. Pelham makes it perfect. My wife and I are Italian and the majority of the staff is Italian. It's like eating with family. I'm 63 now and have been coming here since I was 18. read more