Mizuna was offering a special coursed Valentine's Day dinner, and we quickly made a reservation and waited in anticipation.
The staff was kind and I appreciate that they verified our vaccination status. Two glasses of champagne were poured automatically (which is fine, but we're not drinkers so it went to waste). I have a shrimp allergy which they inquired about and said they were able to accommodate.
But you're really reading this for the food, arguably the most important part of the experience, and simultaneously the most disappointing part of the evening.
To start was a lobster spring roll and Thai tea drink that started the meal off on a cautious note. My boyfriends roll didn't have any lobster, but I'm not sure it would have improved anything about the flavor. The next two dishes, the polenta and the hamachi were arguably the best and most flavorful dishes of the experience, but how could you really ruin fresh fish? From there, it went downhill. The foie gras hummus seemed inventive, but in my opinion was a waste of good foie gras, and the Gerry roll that came next was allegedly a staple of the restaurant, but really just bread. The odd part was that the bread came by itself and it would have been nice to either be paired with the dish before (the hummus) or the dish after (the agnolotti).
The agnolotti was easily the worst dish of the night. It was so bad the couple that sat next to us sent it back. The chef in good faith ended up making a lovely looking tagliatelle pasta for them, which I was envious about because the flavorless, agnolotti drowning in tasteless sauce was not good.
The paella did have a nice flavor, and this dish originally came with prawns, but because of my allergy, they served sea bass. The menu said that the paella was in shrimp and lobster broth, and the waiter scurried off so quickly I couldn't ask to confirm that mine wasn't made with the shrimp and lobster broth, so I took one small bite and slid the rest to my boyfriend. The next dish was a palette cleanser of subpar homemade kombucha.
The strip was next, and if I hadn't heard one of the waiters at the end of night explain the dish to one of the other tables that it was dry aged, I never would have guessed. It was quite chewy and not tender like a dry age typically is. The vegetables served with this dish were lovely, crunchy, and paired well with the sauce and steak.
Unsure why, but the restaurant felt the need to have two dessert dishes. The pre-dessert was probably the second or third best dish of the night and the actual dessert came in close competition with being the worst of the night. I thought the strawberry covered chocolate was inventive and light, just sweet enough to end the meal. The cream puff was overkill and the pomegranate didn't really go well here because of the seeds and the sauce that looks like caramel was not, and horrible to be blunt.
Other than the disappointing food, the service was at a minimum what you would expect at a fine dining establishment. The staff changed our silverware after each course and filled our waters when they saw we were low. My two gripes here were that the hostess forgot to give us the menu for the meal and the inconsistent experience with the explanation of the dish. As a customer who loves food very deeply and is interested in the ingredients and cooking style of the dish, I was upset that some of our dishes were explained well, while others were just sat down on the table. The waiter who served our steak said "here's the NY Strip", whereas one of the tables next to us got this lovely, elaborate explanation of the 45 day dry aged NY Strip.
The cost of the meal was $450 without any drinks. We were aware of the cost when we made the reservation, and I love patronizing businesses with good food, but I felt like I took five $100 bills and threw them in the trash. Honestly, $450 for an "11 course meal" whose food didn't taste fresh with only three good courses out of 11, and of those 11, two of those dishes were dessert, and one of the others was a shot of kombucha? If I was Mizuna, I would quite frankly be embarrassed asking folks to waste their hard earned money like that on an extremely disappointing experience.
When I look at the reviews on Yelp, I'm appalled how many positive reviews there are, so I have surmised that this must be for one of three reasons. First, is that there are people out there that are instantly equating expensive food to be good food. This is not true! Second, is that something must have changed recently or it was a horrible idea to come on a special meal outside of the regular menu, and we are not planning to go back to test that theory, so if you are someone who loves Mizuna and is thinking about coming for a special menu, I would highly advise against it. And third, is that folks have just lost their sense of taste and never regained it back after having COVID! read more