Mitchell's Steakhouse Polaris never disappoints! They really care about their guests here. The staff give us exceptional service every time we dine here and the food is always amazing. read more

With the closing of the downtown location we decided to support the Polaris site. Run don't walk as the meal was one of the best steakhouse meals we have had in a long time. Started with a Caesar salad. Then the petite filet duet and filet Maxwell. Added mushrooms and scalloped potatoes- all cooked perfect and delicious. Took home some dessert- Carrot and Cheese cake!!! Needless to say they were wonderful with a port at home!!! read more

What we got for $240 including the tip: -Arrived at almost 3pm to no one in sight for 10min upon arrival - used the women's restrooms- disgusting feces in and splatter on toilets- and no toilet paper! - finally sitting down at the table and greeted by a sweet server. She and one other bartender were the only ones there. Only 1 customer until about 4pm - service was very good - food not so much - orders a cup of French onion soup and two sides - it was very good but received 1/2 a cup. - son ordered a filet mignon and a side and got a filet mignon on a plate no garnish - nothing not even a leaf or a drizzle of fancy sauce for $59 - husband got cheeseburger and fries that was dry - Husband had a coffee and the chocolate mousse - it was overall not the best for sitting at a high top in the bar area and the food we got was nothing special. I think it was the price! It needed to have a lot more flair and not feel like a meal at the old TGIF Fridays - this did not appear to be a high end restaurant it claims to be! Bummed! I should have gone to Hyde Park Grill for lunch. read more

One of the flagship brands of the Cameron Mitchell Empire. Over 100 restaurants across the United States, and we are lucky to have many fine examples right here in Columbus where it all started. It is said that "The answer is yes, what is the question?" The goal is to make a raving fan of every person who walks through the door of a Cameron Mitchell concept restaurant. This location does a fine job of achieving that goal. Parking is easy, the ambience & decor is superb, tables are well spaced, and not cramped, lighting & general mood of the restaurant is unparalleled in Columbus. Notice that I haven't even begun to describe the food, which is well prepared, succulent, and memorable. This is high-end steakhouse dining at a fine level of superiority. Well selected meats, a top-notch wine list, and complementary side dishes, make for an excellent dining experience. The staff are friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable and make for a great dinner or lunch. I have visited several of his restaurant concept locations around the country and if I ever need a default go-to, they are certainly easy pickings. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Food and service were excellent! Would definitely go back. A great place for celebrating. read more

One of my favorite spots to go for happy hour. The service, drinks and food are great. They have a private parking lot so that's easy. In the spring, summer and fall they have a wood burning fireplace with outdoor seating. That's a nice place to enjoy the evening. Today I opted for the Exotic Mojito and my fav, the surf and turf. Perfect portion for me. I love that they remove the entire shell from the shrimp, even the tail so you don't miss out on any bites. The chimichurri on the steak was great. Much thanks to the three people in the bar area for providing great service and getting everyone taken care of. read more

Mitchell's Steakhouse - Exotic mojito - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

My in laws came from California and wanted to try this for my husbands surprise birthday dinner. The manager nicole helped me with reservations and came to check on us multiple times throughout our dinner. Our server Fabio was absolutely terrific! Very knowledgeable about the menu and had many recommendations on different options. Helped my daughter find a good mocktail to try and for me to find a non steak option for dinner. Never felt rushed, he let us look over the menu and catch up with out of town family. Nicole brought us many yummy desserts to try for mine and my husbands birthdays. Steaks were all cooked perfectly and food came out all spaced very well. Restaurant appeared to be tidy and very clean. No dirty tables around. This was our first time here and will absolutely be back! Great food and amazing service! read more

Was disappointed we needed a reservation on a Monday night and had to sit at the bar. The bartender, Michael, took his time clearing off the dirty dishes (but not washing the bar) before coming over to get our drink order. We were celebrating so we ordered a couple of drinks. Both the torched apple martini and peach sidecar were very bitter. We didn't finish them. We ordered food and asked for waters. Food took a while. We got waters after waiting at least 10 minutes. The French onion soup was not great. As for the tenderloin duet, one was medium (as requested), but the other was well done. The steak that came with the surf and turf was rare (had requested medium) and the lobster tail was overcooked and chewy. Their only saving grace was their scallop potatoes. Those were excellent. No one checked on us so we just ate and we never once got refills on our waters. Spent over $200 with tip for terrible service and subpar food. Will not be back. read more

Toughest so called prime ribeye I ever had Better options available Sat at bar ordered and nobody bothered to ask about my steak read more

So disappointed- we'd never been here before and had high expectations. Decided to come for my husband's birthday on a Saturday. It was very nice the servers had all signed a card for him at the table- this is a very thoughtful gesture. Our server was very sweet. She'd recommend the calamari. In all honesty... it was awful. It was not your typical calamari- it was huge chunks fried- looked like thick legs, not your typical rings. The sauce did not go well- and in general it was an odd pairing. We ordered the tomahawk for 2 which comes with soup or salad for each, as well as a side of your choice for each. I got the lobster bisque- not a bite of lobster in my soup- just good broth you can get almost anywhere. My husband's French onion was just ok.. The tomahawk my husband ordered medium rare- came out very rare. I had to send my pieces back to cook much more- again, it was just ok. The jalapeño potatoes tasted reheated- probably the best part of the meal was the truffle fries, sadly. My daughter did enjoy her cheeseburger off the kids menu. They did give us a complimentary cheesecake for his birthday- which was nice. Our meal came out to over $200- and we were very disappointed with the food. Soooo the kicker- we weren't too disappointed with anything because we had $200 in gift card to Cameron Mitchell's so we figured whatever it was a bad meal but at least we weren't paying for it. Guess what. Cameron Mitchell's sold earlier this year and I guess it's just Mitchell steakhouse now so you can no longer use the gift cards. That was a huge disappointment because we did not enjoy the meal at all. So over 240 with a tip and the food was just not up to par. We enjoy great meals- but will not be back here. The restaurant was pretty much empty on a Saturday evening, so we should've kind of taken that as a hint. Best of luck- but don't see it lasting. read more

We chose this place for Fathers Day. I was surprised that we were able to get a reservation the same day and very happy I could!! We were seated right away. We ordered meatballs for the appetizer and they brought out a big basket with bread and butter. The guys ordered 10oz filets, and I ordered the appetizer crabcake as an entree. It was delicious and HUGE. I also ordered the wedge salad and it had plenty of toppings. The dressing was blue cheese but had an added "something" that made it extra. So good! We were all so full so we ordered the desserts to go. The service was top notch! read more

Madison was very helpful with our accommodations for our allergies and our food was very good.

While I've been to the Mitchell's Steakhouse downtown before, this was my first time dining at Mitchell's in Polaris. The building has a clean modern look to it and definitely feels upscale as you walk in. The servers are professional and efficient. The menu has everything you'd expect at a prime steakhouse. So far so good. I had their 7oz filet with shrimp, which was cooked medium as ordered. The meat was seasoned well and tender. But it didn't have the nice char on the surface that you'd expect at a prime steakhouse. At $53 for the 7oz filet and an additional $14 for the shrimp toppings, I really can't say that the plate I got was worth $67. (And sides all cost extra on top) At that price point, I would recommend Eddie Merlot's instead. They're literally just a block away. read more

Mitchell's Steakhouse - 7oz oz Filet Mignon & Shrimp - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Had a nice dinner here for our anniversary. Tracey was a great waitress and was very attentive. Also some of the best bread I've had! read more

See all

Went in December for my birthday... service was excellent and had a wonderful steak that I still dream about today!I would go every week if it weren't so pricey! read more

We flew into Columbus and arrived late to our hotel in the Polaris Mall area, Mitchell's was recommended by a friend and we were not disappointed as they accommodated us dispute the late arrival. I had their steak Oscar and my companion had their Salmon, we shared the chopped salad which delicious as well as unique with the hearts of palm, and goat cheese. I tried their spiced prickly pear margarita and it was wonderful. Also tried the first house Cabernet also a wonderful choice. We were full but got their carrot cake to go and it was so big it lasted during our whole weekend trip to Columbus. The tables were comfortable and we really enjoyed our experience! read more

See all

I don't typically leave poor ratings, but when it's bad, it's really bad, and I let it be known. First, it wasn't very busy, yet service was very very slow and inattentive. No idea as to why, but was consistently slow and poor all night. Second, out of the bottle of wine I ordered. OK, I found another. But they were also out of baked potatoes?! Go to the grocery store and buy a bag, Lastly, their only steak sauce was A-1. I don't usually use steak sauce, but when your steak is bad and overcooked, it can help cover up the taste a bit. Lastly, my $70 ribeye was small, thin, overcooked and of poor quality. I was going to send it back, but didn't want o crest a "scene" during a business dinner with clients. . There is no way that is prime beef. And medium means pink center not brown. It was well done plus. Not a good experience and they won't stay in business if they can't get their act together. Sorry, but that's a honest review of a very disappointing evening. read more

The service was great, our waitress, Madison, was very kind, however the food had no flavor, the sauce I received with my salmon was delicious, however they only gave me about a tea spoon of it, they were very stingy with their sauces. Unfortunately, the good service doesn't outweigh the bland food considering the price, I expected it to be spectacular. read more

Mitchell's Steakhouse - Dining area - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

food was great! Madison was a fantastic server! the restaurant was clean and everyone friendly. We will be back!

We had the best waiter we've probably had anywhere ever. I'm not sure what his name was, but if you go here ask for the guy from Staten Island. This was probably a 3 star review with just an average waiter, but he elevated the whole experience and subsequently the rating for us. Outside of that, the food was sus, I had the wagyu strip which had absolutely excellent flavor but was extremely difficult to chew. I ended up having to abandon half the steak, which stinks for an $80 cut of meat. And while the mashed potatoes had excellent flavor, they were like warm at best. The salads to begin the meal were actually very good. And while I'm not usually a bread guy, the bread here was irresistible. We skipped dessert and I'm sure it would have been excellent. My daughter did love her filet and she's a filet connoisseur! I do think we would give it another shot, and I'd probably just go with the filet next time myself. The ambiance and atmosphere are top notch too, a beautiful setting. read more

Went here on 7.8.25 for our wedding anniversary. We ordered French onion soup and the cheese was hard. I ordered sea bass and it wasn't fully cooked. My brussel sprouts were hard and not fully cooked. My husband had a steak (it was ok). His French fries were cold. The service was really slow and the restaurant was empty. Extremely disappointed to spend $200 and leave hungry. read more

Formal atmosphere but fun and inviting!! Our serve ,Lillian, was great! Good food and fast service . read more

The meatballs And prime burger we ordered from happy hour menu were great. However, the service was far from stellar. 1- the waiter guy did not introduce himself. 2- he spelled my husband's wine and then told him, "I've been doing this 20 years... There's plenty of juice left in that glass." 3- the salad we ordered did not ever appear and was not on the bill, so apparently did not get ordered. 4- my husband had two glasses of wine and the waiter charged him for three. 5- the waiter did not return to check on us, so we went to the bar, asked for a to go box, and got the tab corrected with the help of a very nice young lady waiter. Quite disappointing!! read more

This is my favorite place to go for special date nights. The food was excellent and our waitress Tracey was awesome. It was my birthday and she made me feel very special. The chocolate cake is the best! read more

Mitchell's Steakhouse - Chocolate cake! - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Food was ok Service was horrible. Sat at the bar for happy hour and seen a lady that makes a drink that I enjoy, very well. Asked her to make it and got ignored. They had another bartender make it and I sent it back because... it was not good. I asked the lady why she wouldn't make it (I've been to Mitchell's many many times and even have a loyalty card, so she knows who I am and she also knows I enjoy how she makes the drink) she stated she was "busy." I simply said you could've come over and stated that and I would've waited. Mind you, I'm asking her this while she's finding things to do behind the bar. Moral is... make the damn drink for a regular. Instead, you waste alcohol and get a bad review. I do not recommend this place at all. Instead go to Mitchell's ocean club (not affiliated, thankfully) in Easton and enjoy an upscale experience and not a low class one such as Mitchell's Steakhouse Polaris. read more

I have always enjoyed the Polaris Mitchell's location. It is super swanky and high end. The restaurant is dimly lit which provides for a romantic and intimate ambience. This restaurant also boasts a great cocktail selection. I highly recommend the Old Fashioned. It is tasty and high quality. For dinner, you've got to go with the steak. Their steaks are amazing! I went with the filet mignon and it was cooked to perfection and I loved the seasoning. They also have a great selection of delectable desserts to satisfy your sweet tooth! I definitely recommend this restaurant! read more

See all

No longer a Cameron Mitchell's restaurant, and it shows. The biggest disappointment was the poor service and attention that you would expect for such a high price establishment, especially compared to what we've experienced at other Cameron Mitchell restaurants. If our server said "my apologies" once, he said it 20 times. We did not get the sense he was new, just not of great caliber. It wasn't until the third time we asked that he cleared off dirty dishes from previous courses, and still did not take them all. That's basic server 101. There's nothing like trying to enjoy your main course or dessert with dirty plates and dishes from the previous courses on the table. The quality of the food was inconsistent. Appetizers and side courses were delicious, but we went there for the steaks and were let down. I had the bourbon ribeye, and my daughter had the fillet. We were both surprised at the toughness of the cook, especially the fillet. Our server told me I would be impressed with the marbling on the ribeye, but candidly it ended up more gristle than marble. it's not often my daughter and I get a chance to go to dinner together and with a more than $200 price tag, I was certainly expecting more quality and care for their reputation. Next time we will stick with proper Cameron Mitchell restaurants. read more

We went here with our friends for dinner during restaurant week. We all ordered from the restaurant week menu, which was $40/person. For the first course we got lobster bisque. The bisque was delicious, but I felt it could have been creamier with a bit more lobster meat. We got the braised short rib with gnocchi and vegetables. The short rib was melt in your mouth and delicious. We ordered sides dishes separately as an extra cost to our order. We got mac & cheese, corn, and mashed potatoes. The sides could definitely be a bit more dressed up. I found it odd that there was no actual steak to order from the restaurant week menu. If you are going to a steakhouse, you mainly want to try steak. All other $40 restaurant week steakhouses had steaks offered on their menus. The main entree choices had short rib, salmon, shrimp linguine, but no steak which was a bummer, especially for the price. We got creme brûlée and warm butter cake for dessert, and both were delicious. I found the cake to be a bit too rich for me, but loved the creme brûlée. Overall, a very fulfilling meal and would like to try to their steak sometime. read more

See all

Excellent food at service. Old school steakhouse kinda vibe in a modern building. I feel like the lower reviews were from people who are very price point conscious. I would eat here again, and take people here. I think you would get great food and great service. If you aren't willing to pay for that, this isn't the restaurant for you. Maybe try there through the week happy hour menu if you are looking for value. read more

Dined at Mitchel's Steakhouse a couple days before Christmas to celebrate with the family and it did not disappoint. Lillian was our server and she did a fantastic job with recommendations and ensuring we had a smooth dining experience. I had the oysters, cesear salad and the scallops and risotto. All were amazing! read more

Jamie and the team are AWESOME! Special thanks to Chef Tony !! Our ninth annual Christmas Eve dinner at Mitchell's. read more

had a great experience at this restaurant. The food was absolutely delicious--flavorful, well-prepared, and beautifully presented. The dinner ambiance was equally impressive, with a warm and inviting atmosphere that made the evening feel special. Perfect spot for a relaxed yet refined meal. Highly recommend! read more

Steak was absolutely cold. It took over an hour after ordering our food to be served by far the worst steak I've had at any steakhouse. It was so bad I didn't eat anything and still had to fork up a bunch of money for a meal I didn't eat. Go somewhere else, it's not worth the wait or cost. read more

Found that on Friday they have happy hour starts at 12, small menu, we had the Prime burgers & they were really good also have drink menu for HAPPY HOUR? Good find! read more

Steaks were cold when it came to the table, the server asked if we needed something else and we said our sides. Side were cold as well. The manager came over and offered to remake my filet and reheat my dates strip steak. My dates steak returned with no sides and nothing for me. We asked if we could eat our entire meal at the same time not piece by piece when they came out. The table side butter was still solid and not melted. We were through sending food back to get a hot meal we just wanted to leave. When spending $325 (tip included) expecting hot food shouldn't be that much to ask. Lost our business. read more

We just had dinner. Omg. The food was so average. My steak tasted like WalMart. The menu said Prime Ribeye..... absolutely not. Am I going back. NO. read more

The strip steak was incredible. We also had creamy jalapeño scalloped potatoes, and delicious oysters. Our server Tee was amazing. Last, I had a fantastic apple Manhattan smoked tableside. read more

Mitchell's Steakhouse - Smoked apple Manhattan. Delicious. - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The ambiance was wonderful! We had a phenomenal time, and our server was great. However the quality of food was subpar. I with a party of 10 for a gift exchange and the table had a wide variety of food ordered and there was an issue with 6 of the 10. I had a simple Caesar salad with pan seared salmon. There was no seasoning on the salmon and the small piece was over cooked. The lettuce was mushy, but the dressing did have great flavor, it was just tough to get thorough the soggy lettuce. The lobster Mac and Cheese only had shaved lobster on top and no lobster through out the dish. Also it was cold. read more

Food was top tier and our waitress, Tracey, was the best! Loved everything about our visit. We will definitely be returning. The vibe was very classy and cool- great ambiance. read more

Our experience here was top tier and that was thanks to Tracey. Our food was so good and made so well and Tracey was incredibly nice and very efficient, so a big thank you to her! read more