The restaurant itself is beautiful. The decor is upscale and gives that classic steakhouse feel, and I liked that there was both bar seating and a more formal dining area. It definitely sets the tone for a nice night out. Also this location is very different from Polaris. The service was okay...not terrible, but not as attentive or memorable as I expected for a steakhouse of this reputation. As for the food... this is where it fell short for me. I've been wanting to try it for a while because I've heard so many good things, so I came in with high expectations. Unfortunately, the steak wasn't cooked the way I prefer, the brussel sprouts weren't enjoyable, and the mashed potatoes tasted like they may have been instant, which was disappointing for a place known for steak.The one standout for me was the meatballs,they were actually really good and had great flavor. Overall, for a birthday dinner and for the reputation it has, our party left a bit disappointed. It wasn't a horrible experience, but it just didn't match the expectations we had going in. read more

See all

The team at Mitchell's Steakhouse is exceedingly friendly and attentive. They definitely take great care of you and make sure you are comfortable. Iced Seafood Tower: The tower would be more impressive with a bit more seafood. The platter contains skinny king crab legs, a lobster tail, raw oysters, and shrimp cocktail. Tomahawk: The 32 ounce ribeye steak is trimmed off the bone and neatly sliced. It is charbroiled for a slight smoky flavor. The steak is pink and tender with a nice snap. Crab Cake: The crab cake has a sweet corn and edamame succotash. read more

Mitchell's Steakhouse - Tomahawk (sorry for the blurry pic!) - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

We went to Mitchell's steakhouse on Valentine's Day. We had a reservation ahead of time. It was packed! But we had a good waiter. I wish they had more steaks to choose from though and they had sides that you had to pay extra for. I got the 3 course meal for the Special - I got the lobster bisque, and the small tenderloin which came with shrimp, and then the Bundt cake for the dessert. Overall it was a good meal! It was a little bit slow because of the holiday so I understood that. But will have to come back soon! read more

Took a colleague to birthday lunch today. The carpaccio was so chewy I couldn't swallow any of it. Server ignored the fact he removed a full plate. Ordered dessert to go joking I was still hungry since lunch was awful and he dismissed the comment. Just opened the bag and this pathetic $13 crème brûlée didn't even have berries (birthday girls had blackberries and raspberries). Boo for Mitchell's. This will be off the list for a while. read more

Mitchell's Steakhouse - Creme Brulee - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Special Moment to share this is the place to go or a romantic evening. Just want an upper scale happy hour this also will fit the mark. Staff is extremely friendly- the main reason l go - sometimes l just like to have great service and Mitchell's doesn't disappoint. Drinks are made very well. The best thing for me on my visit was chocolate mousse and jalapeño scalloped potatoes. My calamari was just ok. I also tried a new dish to me tenderloin duet off prix fix and it was cooked very well. read more

See all

All went well. We made reservations on line on the way to Columbus for a dinner prior to catching Diana Krall at the Palace yesterday evening. We arrived 20 minutes early and were seated immediately. Ryan? Was attentive throughout and made several suggestions that we took while there and the best way to get to the concert afterwards. We order shrimp cocktail and oysters in the half shell. Both were good. She ordered the ribeye and I got the lamb. Both were great. We shared the broccolini and neither ordered desserts. With 18-19 % tip the bill was ~235 which was a bit higher than we had planned. Jazz was playing on the house system and there was enough dampening in the venue that we could easily hear one another. I didn't love the butter for the bread nor did I love the cream sauce for the broccolini. But it was a nice touch to add a small dab of extra horseradish on the cocktail sauce in case u wanted it extra hot!! read more

Mitchell's Steakhouse - Menu - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We came here for a business dinner and had an incredible experience. About 14 people. The process to reserve the room was very easy. Tamara was helpful and showed me all the options we had. When we got to the dinner, the table was set up nicely and the room was beautiful and intimate. Our servers, Lillian and Nick, were complete rock stars and very professional. They quickly got us anything we needed and kept coming around to check on us. They were also very knowledgeable on the menu and wine selections and pairings. The food was AMAZING. Really well presented and flavorful. Only a couple of shortfalls - the lobster bisque was OK, but not the best I've ever had, and no lumps of lobster in it, and the asparagus was not my favorite - too thick and grassy/greenery tasting. Otherwise, the food was so good. I got the filet mignon and it was cooked to perfection. Honestly one of the BEST I've ever had! Lots of flavor and the meat was buttery and easy to cut through. The sides: mashed potatoes, Mac and cheese, and Brussels sprouts were great, too! They had 4 options for our dessert that was nearly impossible to choose from. I ended up with the NY cheesecake and it was to die for. I was so full I couldn't even finish it haha. I highly recommend this restaurant for a business dinner or a date night. read more

See all

The food was sooo good and very well seasoned. My friend and I decided to try their oysters on the half shell. They had a hint of sweetness to them, so not so bad. I realize I do prefer pacific oysters more. My bourbon marinated steak was very delicious, not medium well as I requested but still good. The vegetable sides(mashed potatoes, creamed corn, and brussel sprouts w/bacon and didn't disappoint. The highlights for me were the peach sidecar and the banana cream pie. I did go back the next day for two more peach sidecars read more

What happened ? I used to love this establishment under original ownership. This experience was pretty average for the price paid. Nice environment. Ordered a seafood tower to start. Reasonable price and ample for two. Crab legs were ridiculously small, but other items were good and tasted good. We did wait almost 30 minutes from the time we ordered to its arrival. Small filet as entree was very tender and flavor was good. Unfortunately it was barely warm, was clearly sitting a while before being brought out. One server covering at least 8 tables with no help for food runners or water / drink help. An impossible task to deliver a higher end experience. Things were so slow and we had to depart to get to a show I gave server my card before the check came so he could run it. Still took 25 minutes for him to return with receipt. Although not a bad experience, it fell very short of what I would expect when spending $250 before gratuity. read more

Mitchell's Steakhouse - Seafood tower with crab - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We came here for my birthday and received fantastic service!! The hosts were very friendly & they even placed birthday confetti on my table. Most of the food was fantastic, and came out pretty quickly. The Caesar salad had a strong vinegar taste to me, but the rest of the food was delicious. We loved the warm bread they brought out in the beginning, with the dessert being the only thing that we enjoyed more. The manager came out to check on us during our meal & make sure everything turned out okay, and the server, Nicole, was very friendly our whole visit. 10/10 would come back here again read more

See all

I was in Columbus for work and was lucky enough to be able to meet up with a friend for dinner. She suggested Mitchell's which was within walking distance of my hotel. I was there in December so the restaurant was decorated for Christmas with lots of white lights, poinsettias, and trees. Add onto that dark wood, crisp linens, and comfy booths and the atmosphere was really lovely. We passed on appetizers and grabbed a couple drinks and ordered the filet with Robuchon mashed potatoes. The steaks were seasoned well and cooked as requested. The mashed potatoes were honestly a joke - I know Robuchon style potatoes are supposed to be super creamy and really a conveyance for butter and cream, but these were super loose and severely under salted. I don't remember what drink I had but remember it tasted good. Service was great and for a slow weekday evening, our server was nice and let us linger since she knew we were catching up after not seeing each other for many years. I've been to numerous "fancy" steakhouses over the years and the food here was nothing special. But the ambiance and great service made up for it kicking up my rating to 4 stars. read more

Really disappointed in our meal last night. The shrimp (in the shrimp cocktail) were smaller than described on the menu, only average in taste. The Caesar salad was very lightly dressed, and the steak was not prepared as ordered. The lamb chops were quite fatty. Nothing we ate was more than average in taste. Our server was very pleasant and attentive, but seemed to have limited wine experience. We ordered a 2018 bottle of wine, but a 2020 was opened and poured before we realized the difference and asked. We were told afterward that the 2018 was not available (& the manager knew this), which would have been helpful to know in advance so we could choose another bottle. We've always associated this restaurant with a higher standard and were surprised by the overall experience. Afterward, we realized ownership has changed, no longer owned by Cameron Mitchell, which may explain the difference. Spent over $350 for the meal, will not return. read more

Exactly what we're looking for in a happy hour with elevated cuisine, reasonable prices and walking distance from the hotel. Get there between 4-6p and you might have the opportunity to be served by Eric the bartender. Personable, prompt service with a smile. Beer is around $4-6. Martini is looking at $10 and the burger for $11. The food was piping hot and served swiftly with any condiment we requested and cooked to order / as requested. Absolutely no issues with the ambiance, cuisine, execution or pricing. read more

Worst service, management, etc. I have ever experienced at a restaurant. Do not go to this place. We had 6:30 reservations and waited 25 minutes on top of this though the table was open. Then our party of 5 ordered and it took 90 minutes for our food to come out. We asked to speak with the manager and his response was atrocious. Literally the worst manager I have ever seen. It absolutely ruined an evening with friends I had not seen in years. Just deplorable. Do not go here. read more

I just enjoyed a nice bachelor party boys meal at the lovely Mitchell's steakhouse. Massive props to the restaurant for having solid availability for a large group and being so kind in customizing a message in the menu for our bachelor. I thought the service was very kind and helpful, although it did take a while to get the food. Not a big deal though because I was having fun with my friends! You can tell how much fun I was having because of the picture where I look surprised. read more

See all

Ben our server was on point from the start! Everything came out perfect, hot and tasty! read more

See all

We went for a Saturday night Happy Hour. Well, I think it may be the best HH in Columbus. Elegant setting, excellent food and drinks, excellent service, and valet parking. Give it a go when you have the time and the $. read more

Mitchell's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

If Mitchell's is unable to fulfill their online menu, then don't put it on the menu. I ordered online, and when I went to pick it up, the order was missing half of the items and was cold. I returned to the restaurant for it to be fixed, and they still didn't put all the items that were listed on the online menu. First and last experience with Mitchell's. read more

Our waitress Kelly was amazing for our double date night! can't wait to dine with her again

Second time here celebrating a birthday host was nice our waiter Dillon was great and very knowledgeable of menu and drinks food was delicious great drinks plenty of parking lots of restaurants and plenty of hotels in the area read more

See all

Hosted a work event here and it went very well. Major thanks to Ben and Evin who were phenomenal and patient with our group of 20. Food was delicious and they catered to a few different dietary restrictions, including vegan. Thanks for the great evening. read more

We had an excellent time at Mitchell's steakhouse! The food, the service the ambience it was absolutely fantastic. We ended up reserving the space that was semi private for my sons engagement dinner. It was absolutely delightful. I highly recommend. The drinks were delicious and the servers were kind. The jalapeño scalloped potatoes were so good! read more

Mitchell's Steakhouse - Jalapeno scalloped potatoes - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Very disappointed. We have been to Mitchell's Steakhouse over the years and this is the first time I'm leaving worse than I came in. First of all it was freezing, cold air blowing every where. It took about 10 minutes to be acknowledged once we were seated and the manager came filled our water and let us know the waiter would be by. It was slow service our server was missing at least 3 times when we needed him. We all ordered our steaks medium and they all were cooked differently. My son and I were done eating before the waiter to even come back for my husband to be able to send his back to be cooked longer. This was nothing think the Mitchell's I have known and loved :( read more

Nice atmosphere / Nice bar lounge area. Service is very good. The Take Out ordering system via their website is currently down. I used UberEats to order take out one night to find it is not working at this time. I didn't know until I arrived to pick up my dinner...they can take orders over the phone. I dined here almost every night while staying across the street. The weekday happy hour menu offers a large selection of nice menu items (enough for dinner) and beer, wine drink specials. After a few days of the happy hour menu I moved onto the dinner menu. The seared sea bass and oka king salmon are delicious entrees. For a side item I am hooked on the grilled broccolini. Everything is very flavorful! Treat yourself to a nice dinner! read more

See all

Very nice atmosphere and excellent service. To start we ordered a sushi roll, (spicy tuna) and a couple of cocktails. Both of our drinks were fantastic. We ordered steaks and my filet Oscar was excellent. I requested rare and it was done to perfection. As stated, our server was engaging and very attentive. I think the price is reasonable and matches the quality of food and service well. Highly recommend Mitchell's. read more

Our first time here and everything was amazing! Ben our server was extremely attentive and professional. Food was impressive as were the drinks! Until next time.... read more

Mitchell's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Good but nothing special is my TLDR of Mitchell's steakhouse. I'm not sure many people know, but Mitchell's has a pretty nice happy hour- I believe it goes until 6:30 and has cocktails that are usually $15-16 all priced at $9, and $6/7 glasses of wine and beer. Appetizers are all $11 and under during happy hour as well, including the burger. So, if you're looking for a good burger and drinks for happy hour, you can get a relatively good deal here! Burger was good, nothing to write home about. Meatballs were a tad on the dry side but good flavor-wise. Beef carpaccio was delicious and a large serving. In terms of cocktails I tried, I had the Passionfruit Mojito and the Gin Basil Smash and loved them both- I was worried about them being too sweet but they were perfect and refreshing. read more

See all

I love a good happy hour, and Mitchell's did not disappoint. Drinks delicious and food specials are great. The Korean chicken bites and the shrimp tempura are to die for. Will be back to try the rest of the menu! read more

Mitchell's Steakhouse - Shrimp tempura - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

This was my 2nd time being here and I was very underwhelmed. I appreciate service that allows you to enjoy the experience and conversate however our service was just nonexistent. Our server had way too many big tables and just was not able to give the top quality service you would expect at Mitches. All of our steaks were overcooked, we had to ask about 1 of the salads because everyone received their salad but 1 person and we were almost completed before he even received his. The Lobster bisque was absolutely delicious as well as the crème brûlée. The restaurant is cute and intimate. I wanted an amazing experience for our party but walked away feeling disappointed. read more

Mitchell's Steakhouse - Amazing Creme Brulee - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Excellent and friendly service. There was no wait and a warm welcome. The atmosphere was full of class and the food was delicious. Definite revisit for date night! read more

Went with a large group, but they were on top of service and food. Both were excellent.

I am in town, attending a conference for a few days and thought I would order a delivery of food from Mitchell's to my hotel. I selected the Steak Diane, hand cut fries, and a piece of their carrot cake. The 2 inch thick New York strip prepared Diane style was nothing short of fabulous. The steak was a perfect medium rare and the Diane was rich and a beautiful accompaniment to a terrific piece of beef. The hand cut fries were very good as expected. Finally, the layered carrot cake was moist and delicious and came with a side of caramel sauce. The cream cheese frosting was unbelievable with the caramel! I wish I could have gone to the restaurant but the next best thing was to have had their food delivered. read more

See all

Not what we expected for money spent. $235 for 2 people is not what we normally spend.

This was the worst dining experience! We arrived early for our reservation early and were told it would be no problem. Service was very slow even though they were not busy. Took about an hour to get any bread. We had a couple of drinks while relaxing and enjoying the atmosphere. Would have been nice to have some bread with our drinks. When we finally ordered our food it came out cold and not very good. The manager finally stopped at our table and asked how it was going. When we told him the truth, he got upset and made it seem like it was our fault. Very unprofessional! If you want a fine dining experience, go to Hyde Park. It is about the same price and the service and food are exceptional! read more

Good food, less than expected service. We had a family birthday get together for 16 people. Set the initial menu and place setting count. Worked with the catering manager Tamara. A change in the headcount, a change in one menu item, and scheduling for the cheese and vegetable trays were communicated to Tamara via email ten days prior to the event but never communicated to the serving staff. We were short a place setting, an item was served rather then its replacement and the appetizer trays were not available for the cocktail hour until asked where they were. Tamara pitched joining the Landry Select Club for the Birthday benefit. The club information was communicated to her via email but never provided to the wait staff so no credit was deducted from the bill. Nor was the evening's bill credited to the Select Club without an email requesting the credit be applied. Lillian did a fine job tending to our group. The food was as expected. No issues there. Forewarned though, double check any communications you have with Tamara that the information is actually making it to the serving staff. Otherwise you will need to deal with it the evening of your event. read more

We came here on a Saturday evening for their happy hour. This is one of the best happy hour deals in the city! Everyday?! AND $6 drinks. It can't get any better. We started with the calamari and it was delicious. We asked for bread, and their bread is so salty, which I personally adore. Next was the tuna tartar. The amount of tuna was great! Rarely do I say we could've used more wonton chips! Next was the shrimp and steak. I will probably skip this one next time as the meat portion is smaller and there are other fun apps to get. The burger looked amazing and is such a steal. Definitely give it a try! read more

Mitchell's Steakhouse - Tuna tartar, Oz Filet Mignon & Shrimp, bread - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Excellent food; great staff; wonderful atmosphere. I absolutely loved the salmon with crab meat and the tomahawk steak with jalapeño scalloped potatoes and the butter cake. This place is a must visit. read more

The service was really good. He was really nice. The food was all right. Definitely mediocre steak. The interior is nice, I definitely think there's better options read more

Very odd dining experience. Labor Day 2024. Our server was great. Very attentive. However, all of our steaks arrived barely warm and the "table side" potato could not melt the congealed cheese sauce. Expensive and not worth it read more

We overall did not have an incredible experience for spending over $200 on a dinner for 2. We came to celebrate a special anniversary dinner, and there were too many things that went wrong to salvage the occasion. We showed 5 minutes before our 7PM reservation, and weren't sat until 25 minutes after our reservation was supposed to be for. Our drinks weren't made correctly, which was for something simple (bloody mary), and our server was tied up with a large table most of the night. They brought a totally different side than what we had ordered. It took longer than normal for both appetizers and the main courses to come out. And when we had voiced our frustration 2hrs and 15 minutes into dinner, it still took us 25 minutes to get our dessert boxed up and pay our bill. We came back to Mitchell's because this is the place our relationship officially started. We appreciated management comping the dessert (and including an extra one), but we will probably not be coming back for a while. There are so many nice steakhouses in Columbus, and we want to be more thoughtful of where we choose to spend hundreds of dollars on infrequent, special occasions. read more