I love their specialty slices! I had their bruschetta slice and their chicken Caesar salad slice both were so DELICIOUS! It was the first time I ever had a chicken Caesar salad slice, and I was surprised how good it was! The chicken was moist and well seasoned, and the salad on dressing on top was so tasty! I also tried a plain margarita slice which I didn't like. There wasn't enough cheese or sauce on it, and I didn't like the taste on the margarita either. My husband also tried a plain slice and a sausage slice, and he thought they were just ok. They had a big selection of all different specialty slices that all looked great. I'd like to try their bbq chicken slice next time. I'd skip their regular slices, but I highly recommend coming here for their delicious specialty slices! read more

See all

I'm from California and I never had this kind of pizza in California. Very good customer service and super friendly staff. read more

Finally back in town for some gooooood pizza! Dough was perfectly thin but puffy. We tried 4 different pies, everything was just delicious, simple and perfect. I wish we have a place like this in DC. read more

Food service and ownership are all amazing. Go here as often as you can won't be disappointed.

I live nearby and have not been disappointed. This is a great place to eat. However, the drivers need to pay attention a little more. They have girls delivering pizzas in the dark at night that don't know where they're going, especially when they're going to large complexes like Parkwood Gardens on Costa Boulevard it's dangerous over here at night. It's a lot of young kids running around. You could smell the weed when you're walking around please have these girls pay attention to what building number they're going to every apartment has the same apartment numbers but different building numbers very important people realize thatif you live in 4B there's 30 apartments that say 4B the only difference is the building numbers we'd hate to see somebody get mugged around here. The neighborhood is not the best lately. There's 500 units and more here. You shouldn't even have girls delivering late at night. It's ridiculous. I wouldn't read more

Best pizza in Northern Middlesex County and one of the best in CNJ, where I've lived for the past 44 years. Perfect cheese/sauce ratio (not overloaded with cheese) and the sauce is perfectly flavored and the crust is just right, with very little slice "flop." Great garlic knots too. We get pizza there at least twice a month. Nothing fancy about the place, which looks like it probably did in the 70s, but for a pizza place (and most restaurants), I don't really give much of a crap about setting - the food is all that matters as long as the service is at least decent and they're very friendly there. read more

I just happen to stumble into this pizzeria by chance and I have to say. WOW!!! I just had the bacon ranch slice and a white pizza slice. Has to be one of the best bacon pizza I've ever had. Every bite had bacon on it. The slice was a good size, just big enough to enjoy and have room for another. I must say that I'll be back to try the other plates they have here. Highly recommend! Server was super nice as well. 5 out of 5 stars. read more

Menlo Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

See all

Marguerita, plain, and onions and peppers are the pies that we get. They are all great!! A classic, what you would expect, Jersey slice pizza!and everyone there is very nice too. read more

Wow! I just stopped in for a couple of slices and they certainly did not disappoint! Very good pie here and friendly service. I shall return when in the area again. read more

Pizza taste is so mind blowing every spice from the sauce to the toppings to the dough crunchy& yummy. Family owned wonderful feels like you're in a little Cozy restaurant pizzeria in Italy. They also deliver if you're ever having a party at Menlo Park now thank you for being such a finale, outstanding business. read more

Menlo Pizza & Subs - Pizza well done crunchy pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

Was in Newark and needed to head south late on a Sunday night and wanted to grab some Jersey pizza on the way home-this place had good reviews and they lived up to the standard reviewers set. Called to order pick up, just a large cheese, and picked up on the way. Was greeted cordially upon entering, simple transaction, and was thanked by all three working behind counter and in kitchen. Restaurant was mostly empty with only a couple of diners-place was a little outdated, but that added to the charm. Pizza was good, typical NY style. Thin as expected, cheese was decent, sauce could have been a bit sweeter. Crust was about average. Bottom line is I would return if in the area again-I'd rate 7.1 out of 10. read more

See all

Just an update. I ordered the grandma and I was kinda disappointed in it. I opened the box to find that the cheese slid off the pie and it was so wet, and there was no fresh basil. I purchased many grandma pies from other pizza places and it's real mozzarella circles placed in every square, not shredded. And the dough is a little thinner, I received a thick scillian pizza :( They usually make really good regular pizzas as I have ordered "The Works" several times. Their cheesesteak sandwich is delicious tho! read more

The pizza was very tasty my daughter enjoyed her personal pie which was a such a good size by the way! Good job! Only draw backs: The chicken Parmigiana with spaghetti I ordered was just okay, sauce wasn't all that, the chicken breading they use could better and the chicken was a bit hard also. Customer service is very good! The cashier was very helpful and even offered me a can soda for free with my food! Such a sweet and welcoming first impression read more

See all

I was in search of a simple NY style plain cheese slice, and found a perfect one here! Great job. read more

Menlo Pizza & Subs - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

Just great pizza. Deliciously seasoned and cooked to perfection. Exceptional service, Thom the pizza genius was so friendly! I was in the mood for pizza but they have an extensive menu. Going to try a pasta dish on my next visit if I can resist reordering the dynamite pizza. It will be tough!!! A must if you want delicious pizza!!! read more

The thin crust pizza choices were hot and ready to choose from. Mushroom and chicken parmesan were fantastic. Just what I needed for a mid day treat. They were welcoming and friendly. Thank you! read more

Menlo Pizza & Subs - Chicken parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

Terrific service & location but most of all THIS IS GREAT PIE. There's been a big drop off in good pizzerias over the last few years as the old generation retires or passes and the kids have moved on to law, medicine, or other professions. Food service is a tough bloody business: long hours, no paid time off, and cash to watch... but it's practically recession-proof! I hope that the next generation takes on this shop. If you're looking for ambiance and white glove service, go to a sit down restaurant. If you're looking for great pizza and quick, friendly service, GO HERE. read more

Pizza is delicious. Great cheese to sauce ratio, and the cheese is delicious. Not the tasteless stretchy cheese that some pizzerias use. Small parking lot, but I didn't have a problem. Staff is very nice. I will definitely be back when in the area. read more

We got a pepperoni and the works and dined in. Pizzas were good; the crust had the right thickness/crunch. But the works only had 5 toppings. Five stars anyways b/c service was decent and no complaints, especially when our tummies were hungry. read more

I've ordered from here twice and got a Sicilian both times. Sausage - fantastic. It's the crumble sausage which I usually don't like but the flavor was fantastic Pepperoni - not very flavorful and just okay. Cheese and sauce are really good! They make a thick and doughy Sicilian which I prefer to thin and crispy so if that's not your thing, don't order the Sicilian here. But overall, a very solid pizza place for the area! read more

Picked up a couple pies on Super Bowl Sunday, the young lady that answered the phone was sweet and helpful. The pizza was thin crust yet not cracker like-ingredients were fresh and the pizzas were delicious. I recommend this place highly !! read more

First time there took a good look around the place very strange characters. It looks like a makeshift pizza counters looked very dirty to me. I lost my appetite, very dirty. I bought something from there. It did not look appetizing I would not recommend this place I will never go back there again and the Board of Health should investigate that's what I gotta say. I give it zero read more

my first take out. Plain large pie. Decent pie to meet our preference of sauce to cheese ratio (meaning bout even), thickness was on the thin side which I like, not too much crust, they got my request to not cut it correctly. The owners were very friendly and made me welcome. I want to try their cheese steak soon. read more

I have to say this is one of My Fave pizza places here in Jersey that I have come across. Not only is there food really good so is there hospitality! I order from them all the time and one time there delivery was very late even for them, I called and complained and spoke to the owner who told me he would remake my food and deliver it himself after several apologies.He kept his word and delivered the food himself and gave me coupons and told me how he appreciates my business! Don't know what other place would actually do that, But they are really awesome! There is still good people out there who restore your faith in humanity and really care about their customers and this place right here is the example! Soo give them a try cause you won't be disappointed! read more

I've been eating here for years and this place has consistently fallen off the pizza is hit or miss, the Italian hotdogs and hamburgers are no longer good, the worst chef salad I've ever had, ordered a ceasar salad and the chicken was old dry and over cooked. The last straw was the flavorless Turkey and cheese sub I ordered the bread was soaked in vinegar leaving my bread soggy. I'm done with this place I've given them way too many chances. read more

Second time here , first time got a plain cheese pizza which was good. The second I got the buffalo chicken pizza which was very good but for some reason just didn't get that buffalo chicken flavor idk tasted different then how most of the taste. The staff was friendly and nice and gave us paper plates which was nice. Would come back if I'm in the area and want pizza ! read more

I got a slice and a Cesar wrap. Service was great and food decent. I will have to come back and try more. Items. Maybe I didn't pick wisely

Best little hidden place! Pretty much passed it on the way here! I absolutely recommend this place! We had the philly steak sandwich and the large is HUGE! I'm from Florida and I've never seen a philly sandwich that big! It was exciting and it tasted PERFECT!! Don't miss out on this gem! I'm surprised at how empty it was though the phone did keep ringing off the hook.. to go orders must be more popular here read more

The pizza is ok. I had the margherita and it was pretty bland. My second slice was the grandmas and that was much better. This is a tough area though we have some really amazing pizza! read more

Delicious. Very professional staff and the food is amazing. My favorite place to bring my friends and family for all occasions. read more

Menlo Pizza & Subs - Seafood combo - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

Get the Cheesesteak!! Perfect philly style cheesesteak and tasty, unique slices!Super friendly service and many clean tables in side. Very Italian, family run business. For my Jersey Shore fans, Vinny has been here and I feel like I met his family (the emolyees) read more

Menlo Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

See all

Drove pass by here so many times going to Menlo Mall and never realized there's a pizzeria at the corner. Thanks to other yelpers, I found this little gem. It's a small shop and there are few parking spaces available. The shop has few tables and a television but I decided to order out. I order a large cheese pizza pies and it was really good. The crust was just amount of thickness and crispy. The service was quick and very friendly. I definitely will come back to try other food. There's subs, pastas and salads. read more

Awesome customer service at Menlo!!! On the road was driving back from New England area and went thru Jersey and of course being a Jersey girl just had to stop for pizza!!! Yelp brought us here. I was desiring a margarita pizza but Menlo did not have any margarita slices available so the sweet staff member named Elise said the chef could make me a personal 10' inch pie and happily I accepted!! The pizza came out with a nice basil aroma and sweet tangy marinara sauce. Kudos to the chef!! The staff were wonderfully warm and kind. Elise rocks!! **Have fun in Chicago!! read more

Menlo Pizza & Subs - Margarita - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

Just may be our place for pizza. Pizza is amazing. Right across from Menlo mall. Kids love it. Friendly environment read more

Menlo Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

I've passed this pizza place for years and never took a second look because the signage is not very inviting. I decided to try the pizza today because of the great reviews. The person who greeted me was super friendly, inquired if I needed plates and thanked me for making the trip since I opted for pick-up instead of delivery. The restaurant itself looks clean and has plenty of seats. I ordered a large pie $15, 1/2 mushrooms and onions and the other half pepperoni. The mushrooms & onions slice could have been more flavorful since the cheese was not salty and the sauce was a bit bland. The pepperoni slice was much better since the meat added to the taste. I like the dough since it reminds me of a local pizza place that was the best in town, but has since changed owners. However, the dough was a bit chewy for my taste and seemed to take more effort to finish the slice. I want to give this place a 2nd chance since most people that have written reviews have complimented this establishment. Maybe next time I'll try the pasta dishes. read more

See all

Solid pizza and sub shop. The service is amazing, there always kind and nice. The subs are great. Pizza and salads were good too. Honestly great for the price. No reason not to come. read more

This spot is one of my family's new favorite pizza spots! The whole crew is very welcoming and seem to know their customers. Their pizza is just right, super tasty and isn't too salty. The crust is my favorite: thin & crispy! There's not much seating inside, but I don't see it ever getting super packed since most of their "traffic" seems to be to go orders. We're definitely going to be ordering from here again! read more

Menlo pizza specials have been amazing, delivery is 100% on point the coupons make it reasonable. Definitely recommend.

The best pizza and cheesesteak ever Went there the other day Great stuff and great food read more

Disgusting food! Totally threw that sad looking Buffalo wrap with soggy lettuce and tomato in the trash. It's a shame because I have been coming here for years and the place has Deff gone downhill after covid. My usual is a cheesesteak with the works plus potatoes. I would have never thought their wraps would be as terrible as it was, they weren't even wrapped properly only had a piece of foil on it and parts of the foil were in the food as well. My go to place for wraps is La Rosa , I'll definitely be driving the extra 5 Minutes next time for a good quality wrap read more

Menlo Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

See all