If you like fresh baked goods then this is a nice stop when in Egg Harbor. When I stopped in they had several types of fresh baked scones, pies and cookies....which I was looking for more of a snack than their bread. I had one of their butter cookies which was very good - but everything looked great and the place smelled of freshed baked goodies! read more

Nothing is open in Door County in March. All the signs (well, most of them, anyway) say, 'reopening ... " fill in the date. In other words, sorry, we're in Florida, resting up for the upcoming tourist season in Door County. Ah, but a few are open. And among them are some gems. THIS is a gem. This husband/wife bakery team was the winner of our three day trip to the peninsula this week. They eclipsed a fine meal at Coopers Corner in Fish Creek and equaled the excellent gelato at Jo-Jo's in Sister Bay. They win because they are just such NICE people. We stopped here on our way home to Chicago and I am kicking myself for not stopping on the way in. The shop is the warm, inviting bakery you'd expect, the heavenly smell of it is just the BEST, and the racks and bakery case are full of the most beautiful (and tasty) breads and baked goods you could ask for. We left with buns, dark, dense, chewy pumpernickel bread, French and wheat loaves, and cinnamon rolls. Yesterday. And, already, I'm longing to go back. Pros: just about everything. Nicest couple ever. Great products. Inviting surroundings. More than just bread, so don't be put off by their 'bread only' appearance. Cons: Yes, Door County is pricey. Accept that and the prices here at the bakery are easier to swallow (pun intended). I'm not used to paying seven dollars for a loaf of bread, but in this case, it is WORTH IT. read more

Wow. We went in twice because the hand turned cherry pies were so good! Flaky and buttery and filled with cherry goodness and then generously coated with sugar. Yummmm! The sugar crisp cookie was great too. Carmelized edges were to die for. Chocolate chip cookies were winners too. Still enjoying our fresh bread. Excellent. Great service too. Very friendly. Stop in...you won't regret it. read more

This is must stop for lunch. The sandwiches are fantastic and setting is great to just relax after long day. If you want a little sweets go for blueberry scone. You can eat great food sitting in comfortable seats outside under shady trees. Don't miss this place! read more

Quite possibly the best egg sandwich of my life. Bread was amazing. Taking one star off for price... quite possibly most expensive egg sandwich of life! Great service. read more

Good sandwiches. Bread was incredible. Dad said it was the best egg salad sandwich he had ever had. Only down side was that they were out of the soup special. Staff was also very friendly. Overall, great little sandwich shop in the town of Egg Harbor read more

We were up in Door County not too long ago and had discovered this little gem. We decided to take a chance and try the food. Wow...good food and even better bread. As soon as you walk in, you are greeted with the amazing aroma of fresh baked bread. For lunch we both got a soup/sandwich combo: split pea soup with a ham sandwich and tomato bisque with grilled cheese. Both combos were delicious and didn't make it a rough decision to come back here to eat again. This is the place you go to when you want EXCELLENT, freshly baked artisan bread! Prices are a little steep but the bread is definitely worth it. read more

So many of our favorite places in Door County have closed, it is nice to discover a new great place for lunch! We still like this Bakery. However I have to say their use of plastic and styrofoam is extreme. I'll still buy their bread, but will be less likely to have lunch, buy a coffee, etc. Too bad Door County takes for granted the beautiful setting. read more

Top notch breads and baked goods. We got a loaf of the Italian bread and was great with some olive oil for dipping. The apple muffins are great for a breakfast treat or a snack on the go. Definitely stop in for something sweet and a spot to sit and relax. read more

Very friendly. Delicious homemade soups. The bread is crazy good. And the sandwiches are excellent.

Great grilled cheese! Very friendly staff, a bit expensive but well worth it. Perfect for lunch!

We stopped by before closing and the hospitality was amazing. We were able to try all of the tasty breads and came home with a whole car load! Highly suggest stopping and giving it a try! read more

This place is the best. My wife and I were in Door County for the week and looking for a place to grab a sandwich. What a delight. The Happy Hippie bread is so so good. We got a veggie sandwich on the hippie bread. Very fresh. One the way home we made sure to stop and pick up a loaf of Happy Hippie bread and 2 veggie sandwiches to go. Make sure you check this place out. read more

Really enjoyed lunch here. Freshly baked bread was heavenly and soup devine. The owners are extra special too. We sat on the porch to eat. Our dog enjoyed the wonderful ice cream too! We loved everything here and know you will too! : ) read more

Awesome Door County chicken salad! Friendly/cute atmosphere and awesome customer service.

We were in town for the half marathon & decided to go to MacReady's for a quick bite after the run - apparently everyone else had the same idea & the sweet lady behind the counter apologized profusely, offered us what she did have available & I can tell you it was the best egg salad I've ever had on the most delicious bread imaginaeable . My husband also raved about his grilled cheese : agreed it hit the spot after running 13.1 miles . Thank You MacReady's - we will most definitely be back . I'd give 6 stars if I could read more

Incredible and friendly service, one-of-a-kind and delicious cookies. Anything and Everything you order is so good!!! Will go back every time we are in egg harbor!! read more

Loved it! Ate lunch (soup and sandwiches....so delish) and then brought a pot pie home for dinner. The crust on the pot pie was amazing. Super friendly owner who was a pleasure to talk to. Would highly recommend. We will definitely return. read more

Stopped in for lunch with the family. I had the chicken salad sandwich and tomato bisque soup; both were delicious. Even though is was simply a soup and sandwich it was one of the best meals I have had in Door County. Every one else in the group really enjoyed their meals also. The staff were friendly and welcoming, will definitely go back. read more

Bread is so delicious and the owner so generously let us sample some of the bread. Prices are a little high for bread but it is good. Definitely going back for more! read more

This little breadsmith is beyond perfect. The warm welcome is wonderful. I always want to buy something, whether I need a loaf or not. The fact is I know that they have a great thing going here, making superior artisanal breads and baked goods, and they're doing it all with a smile. They offer you a taste of the daily loaves, and you are then stumped by what to purchase. Everything is delicious. I am partial to the hippie bread that is full of seeds and grains. With its name and its ingredients, I feel like I am not indulging. Rather, I feel like I'm enjoying wholesome, baked-with-love food. You feel the love that comes from the proprietors. I will return here again and again, especially for my new favorite, the raspberry scone. It is gnarly looking with its cobblestone exterior, packing the crunch of a biscuit. The interior is soft, chewy and slightly sweet. I am that much more excited to return in August to try the blueberry one! read more

What a disappointment. Surprisingly unwelcoming service, no choice of breads for sandwiches, and no lettuce and tomato as advertised. First and last visit, there are way better places to eat in DC. read more

Fantastic bakery with outstanding sandwiches. Definitely a must-stop when traveling through or near Egg Harbor.

This was a Wonderful Stop! Food was delicious and plentiful. Be sure to buy a loaf of bread to take home with you. Great friendly people in the shop. read more

I'm addicted to their cherry cranberry bread! This place makes the best sandwiches ever (again, because of the fresh bread). Yummy soups too with all fresh ingredients. I often take a loaf of the "Happy Hippy" bread home to dinner (a darker seeded bread) which becomes the highlight of our meal. read more

We stopped in because we wanted to make some really good grilled cheese sandwiches for dinner. Asked what they recommended to use, after a few suggestions they started cutting us samples of different breads. All of them were excellent, we ended up with a French Bread, a Multigrain Bread and a buttercrisp cookie as well. Service was outstanding and friendly. I believe it was the owner who even gave us tips on things to see. When we make it back to Door County we will be back again. Loved this place, could window shop all day. read more

What a great little place to grab lunch. Fresh made breads, made on sight. Had made soup with a good hearty sandwich. It was a total pleasure to visit. read more

Absolutely sublime. Bread, hospitality, ambiance. Check, check, and check. This bakery kicks ass. My favorite was the pretzle bread, but that's a german bias. The semolina was another standout. The morel mushroom cheese was perfect. Mmmmmm. When people are this kind and talented it begs for a return visit. Next time I'm in the area I will be making a special trip. read more

We went here 3x in one week because it was the perfect lunch. Saying that, the most memorable thing we bought was the brioche cinnamon roll, not too sweet and the perfect amount of cinnamon. Don't miss the chicken salad with cherries or the egg salad. The bread is superb and they have a dark sunflower bread which is the best moistest dark bread I've ever had, and goes very well with the chicken or egg salads! Then there is the staff, incredibly pleasant and accommodating. Would like to see Izze drinks here ! read more

Just ok, the ladies working were very friendly and kind and the bread was good, but the sandwiches themselves were overpriced and they didn't have any lettuce or tomato as advertised, which when there are only 4 sandwiches on the menu, (they were out of a few kinds,) seems like an easy fix. I'd go again if I only needed a loaf of bread but there are better places for lunch. Friendly service though! read more

My family and I stop here every year and the sandwiches and tomato soup are excellent every time.

We were in Door County a couple of weeks ago, and stopped at MacReady Artisan Bread Company our first day there. We loved it so much that we ended up eating breakfast or lunch there five out of our seven days in Door County, and took some bread home with us! Can't say enough about how nice everyone was, and everything we tried was outstanding. Make sure to try their soups, my husband said their tomato parmesan soup is the best he's ever had. I wish we were closer so we could go there more often; definitely a go-to place in Door County, you will not be disappointed!! Thanks Mike & Jenny! read more