New to the area so I figured I'd try it because I heard good reviews. I got a Gyro sub. It was really good toasted to perfection... The service was amazing and they have white chocolate macadamia nut cookies that are out of this world. Definitely five stars. read more

My favorite sub shop in door county. Great quality and delicious menu options. I love the fatzo and the super fatzo! read more

Fatzo's Subs & Pizza - Food Court Near Me - Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Pizza sub on toasted Parmesan bread is an amazing sandwich. Friendly staff. Will be back!

Great service. Nice people. Good food would recommend to try it out !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

We ordered a couple of subs and a soup from Fatzo's. Walked in to order, then an employee brought it out to our car when it was ready. Must have been 10min or less. My husband got a hot BLT and I got the tuna. Also tried the soup of the day which was a cheesy vegetable. It was just under $20 for everything. We were pleased with the customer service, quality and taste. They have a large menu including pizzas and salads. Nice location. Masks are still required if you have't been vaccinated, which we appreciated. Recommend. read more

See all

Always a great sandwich and friendly staff. Busy place. I have never had a bad sandwich or Pizza. the Rueban is my favorite.

A regular stop while on the peninsula. Generous servings, always fresh, filling and satisfying. Tried their pizza, total surprise! Great crispy crust, the pizza sauce is packed flavor and perfect spice blend and who can resist the layer of good ole Wisconsin cheese! Best surprise is, it won't break the bank, and incredible value compared with the other sandwich shops in the area! I've always been amazed at the friendly and attentive staff, they are truly appreciative of the customers who frequent this really fine establishment. There are a few tables inside and out for dining. A couple blocks away is a lovely park with tables weather permitting. Oh and the bathrooms are spotless for those who care. I'd be a regular if I lived on the peninsula! read more

The guy who took our order was super sweet! Food came out pretty quick. I had ordered the grilled chicken sub in a tomato basil wrap. The food was amazing and it was really cheap too. 4/5 stars bc they didn't have sprite:( but that's okay haha. Also it was a small little hole in the wall vibes. read more

Fatzo's Subs & Pizza - lunch with da homiessss - Food Court Near Me - Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Fatzo's ... what a great name for a sandwich shop that piles on the meat and toppings. Fatzo's is a few blocks from downtown Sturgeon Bay. Super that a non chain store subway sandwich shop is here at the entrance to Door County. read more

Oh man, this place is a gem -- nice folks, literally the perfect sandwich, and real fair price. Can't wait til I'm fishing again with the gals to hit this spot again! read more

I had called a few days prior to have a lunch delivery scheduled to a Sturgeon Bay Business from living another city . I am a new customer, I did not know what to expect . In the end I couldn't be more pleased, from the first initial phone conversation to the final delivered order . It is very rare that things don't fall through the cracks these days however, your team is exceptional, Everything went as planned ! Thank you so much for making this a very pleasant and flawless experience. I definitely will be back and will refer you as a fabulous place to visit in Sturgeon Bay! Well done ! Five Stars read more

This is my always stop whenever I get to sturgeon bay. Good Stuff. Both cool and hot sangwich! Rocks!..great not so fun because you want your sangwich in your car. Happiness!.. organic sounds, as you put down a dr. Pepper... oishi!.. read more

Came back to the area after a several year absense. I ordered the pizza again. It was still the same good quality, but not over the top. The pizza tastes good, but is on the greasy side. I had red-orange oily residue on my hands with evert bite. I love a thin crispy crust. This one is a cornmeal one. The toppings were fresh and generously distributed. Not a bad pizza for 9 bucks. read more

Fatzo's Subs & Pizza - a pizza on a pan - Food Court Near Me - Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

I had never been to Fatzo's and I'm from the area and it did not disappoint! I asked the guy working cashier what his top sandwich was and he recommended me the southwest chicken sub. He was right, one of the best sandwiches I've had in a long time. The chicken is amazing. 10/10, definitely will be coming back regularly. read more

good food. there service is also good, they deliver and are usually pretty quick with orders

Dry bread, got the super fatzo, 4 meats. Couldn't even taste or see meat So thin. Gave the multiple chances. Always poor. Never again. Wastage of money. read more

A few years ago we stopped by this place to try it out and when we walked in we were informed they were out of bread (how could a sub shop be out of bread??) so we left. A few days ago we decided to go try it out again. This time- they had bread in stock! We ended up with a selection of hot and cold subs and some soup. The whole sandwich is HUGE and is only good if you're splitting it with someone or eating half and saving the other for lunch the next day. The half size was perfect and my sub was delicious. The soup was eh, I had had better before but it wasn't horrible. Overall, there is a good chance we will stop by on our next trip to Sturgeon Bay read more

Fatzo's Subs & Pizza - Menu - Food Court Near Me - Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

I cannot believe that I have been missing this Sturgeon Bay hidden gem for so many years. No more settling for Subway when looking for a sub on the go. Fatzo's offers a great selection of warm and cold subs in either 8 inch or 16 inch. They offer a variety of bread choices including a tasty rye. I look forward to checking out more of their subs on my next visit. read more

Fatzo's Subs & Pizza - Inside Fatzo's Subs - Food Court Near Me - Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Warning: Do not order a 16" sub sandwich unless you are super hungry. The 16" subs are really 16" long and are too much for just lunch unless you are starving. The place is clean, the food is served promptly and the help is attentive. The menu has extensive hot and cold subs, half (8") and full size (16") as well as pizza and soup. The sandwiches are packed full of meat. Fatzo's gets 4 of 5 stars and I will be returning. read more

The person at the register was really rude, and expected us to know their process for dealing with orders during COVID - despite it being our first time there. The sandwich we got was bland, and the roast beef was slimy, smelled rotten, and tasted off. It was also expensive. $18.00 for a sandwich and 2 drinks. You're better off at subway. read more

We came here for lunch during the week. I ordered a BBQ chicken sub. The sub was rather skimpy. A chicken breast smothered in BBQ sauce slapped on a bun, I was expecting more on the sandwich, such as cheese, pickles and maybe even lettuce. The BBQ sauce was too spicy for my taste, wishing they would offer a milder sauce. You can get your choice of fries or potato salad, I got the fries. The were good, for fries. The ambience is casual, and the decor is modern. It will be an occasional stop for a quick lunch. read more

Wow! The homemade bread and choices you have on the menu are fantastic!! From the salads to the pizza to the subs, you can not go wrong! Service with a smile and very good to the community! A great place to stop and have a family friendly meal! read more

Stopped in for a quick lunch from out of town. Friendly service, fresh subs and quick in getting our food. All was very good and will be back once in the area again. read more

I was impressed with thin crust pizza even though I prefer a chicago deep dish style.

Best subs in Door County! The club sub is my favorite. Definitely a favorite of mine and our kids.

We ordered their "meaty" pizza with extra cheese. We were a little apprehensive when the crust choices were thin or self-rising. This sounded a lot like a frozen pizza, but there were build-your-own choices, so we thought the pizzas had to be home made. But, our first instincts were right. This pizza was one step above a frozen pizza. Crust like cardboard. Toppings didn't taste fresh. We were very disappointed. Maybe their other food is okay, but we don't recommend the pizza! read more

This place creates personal, homemade sandwiches you never had anywhere else; hot and cold. Paula will serve you and remember your name next time! Death to 'fast food'! This family joint is fast and healthy food. Thank you Fatso's read more

The food was fine. It was kind of slow service considering the simplicity of the food. I wouldn't recommend it to the masses. We just sort of found it while driving through town and looking for a quick bite. read more

I can't recall how we stumbled across Fatzo's, but it's now our "to-go" place for lunch when we're leaving Door County to head home. Bread here is really good which is always a key to a good sandwich. They have a pretty extensive menu, location is convenient and sandwiches are good size. We've learned to call ahead because they do get lines the closer you get to the lunch hour. read more

Delicious subs made with fresh homemade bread. First time eating here definitely will come back. Also has pizza.

No no no, don't eat here, I have tried to like this place over the years. Occasionally my work will bring in free food from fatso and o still bring my own. I don't like the quality or the quantity of the meat you get in your sandwich. Even their new wings are freeze dried!!! read more

This is the place to stop in Door County for a consistently good sandwich at a good price with mostly short wait times. Parking is available right next to the building and there are a few tables and chairs outside in summer. The Door County food scene is horrible since the locals don't understand the quality available outside the area. This shop also has pizza which I don't recommend, but sandwiches are always fresh and carefully made. I have visited this location about fifteen times and there is also a Two Rivers WI location which has similar quality. read more

Not impressed. Stopped in two days ago and ordered three subs to go. They were busy so I expected a small wait (like maybe 10 minutes or so). So I sat and waited patiently with all the other customers. More than a half hour went by and I started to notice that the people who were ahead of me in line had received their food, had eaten, and were getting ready to leave. I went up to the counter and asked how much longer it would be. My subs had been sitting in the small window sill they pass orders through, plain as day. Same window sill that every other customers orders had passed through, and their name was called and they're food served. The window sill could be even two feet long. The clerk's "excuse" was that she didn't even see them, even though she saw every other order that had come through there in more than a half hour. She offered an insincere apology, blaming the fact that "she couldn't see them" like my order was somehow hiding. The tone of her apology was rude, as if she was really saying, "what do you want from me, I have work to do." I wasn't offered a discount or a comped either. Nothing they said our did made me feel welcome, or like they wanted my repeat business. They made me feel like my time and money are invaluable. Working in the tourism industry, I normally recommend this place to my customers, as in the past I have enjoyed their food and normally receive adequate service with the exception of one other occasion which didn't even phase me compared to my experience today. I will no longer be recommending this place nor do I plan on ever returning. The food didn't even taste good after it had been sitting for so long. read more

We always stop here on our way to and from Door County. My kids love it. Great sandwiches, fresh and tasty.

For a quick lunch or dinner, you can't get better than Fatzos! Also great for those who watch their diet. Healthy options at a great price! Once a week trip is a must! read more