This bar was seriously so much fun! We sat at the outdoor area and Ethan the bartender was just fabulous. The drink selection was great and I enjoyed trying a few of their specialty cocktails. They had two large TVs outside and I was able to watch the WNBA game. We tried some appetizers and they tasted and smelled great. My favorite bar from the weekend. read more

Hill Street - Painkilla - Burgers Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Hill Street was such a pleasant surprise! As someone who is local to door county, I've always been a super fan of the Bayside. Yesterday, however, they treated us like we didn't even exist. Literally someone in our group didn't even get a drink lol. So we quickly cashed out and stumbled upon the cute indoor/outdoor bar/restaurant and boy am I glad we did! Ethan was bartending and he was easily the best bartender we had all weekend. Delicious drinks - I loved the Rum Punch! Fries were deliciously addicting. They have cute beer and shot combos too! So nice you can sit outside at the bar too. read more

Hill Street - Burgers Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Visited with a friend a few weeks ago, and it was delightful. We didn't eat anything (but will definitely be back to try next time!). I've heard their burgers are amazing. Everything smelled great. We did however have drinks. The atmosphere and the vibe of the place - all amazing. This was probably my favorite place we stopped in all of Door Co. Someone is a Harry Dean Stanton fan and it shows. Bar is comfy and never felt overwhelming even when it was a bit crowded. Bartender was super fun and made a fantastic spritz! I also ordered special that was a beer, shot, and a pull tab - very fun and I won a dollar! read more

See all

This has been the best option for this location. It was hat head forever, then some awful taco place.. Hill Street is an awesome local gem that is open later than anywhere I know of in DoorCo. The food is what I'd consider comfort fusion.. they have hangover noodles and fluffernutters on the menu lol. It's very different but everything I've had so far from there has been good, bar snacks, drinks, meals. The weird thing here is the service.. nobody was ever super keen to help or pour a drink. They seem grumpy or unhappy maybe? Not sure, but nobody really makes you feel super welcome if you know what I mean. No servers, it's a sort of self serve place from our experience. The first time we came in when they first opened, the owners were nice and we liked that they were locals. read more

Hill Street - Burgers Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Stopped in here between events and were lucky enough to get seats at a table on the shady side. All the food was wonderful. I was worried about the sauce they offer with their corn dogs, but it was unexpectedly GOOD. The food came out pretty quick. It was a little difficult to get a bartender's eye, so we could order, but it did eventually happen. Glad we stopped here. read more

See all

the fries here. Unreal. Everyone walking by came in after seeing them on our table. So so delicious, served quickly, friendly people. Overall such a good vibe and fun/summery atmosphere. read more

Hill Street - Loaded Fries - Burgers Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

Place has great location. Staff is super nice. Food is solid. Had the burger and split an order of Dirty Fries.

Fun atmosphere and really solid food. Looking forward to my next visit. First time I am finished a burger in a long time. read more

See all

Hill Street is my and my husbands favorite spot in all of Door County! We absolutely love the atmosphere of the outdoor bar and patio. The first time we visited it was early October, slightly too chilly to spend as much time as we wanted so we returned the following summer and it was even better. The bar tenders are great, down to earth and gave great recommendations. Their food is great; fries, noodles, grilled cheese and fluffernutter sandwich all fabulous. We'll be back! read more

See all

Horrible experience. My husband politely asked for a plain bacon cheeseburger (saw a customer photo that read "bacon cheeseburger") and he was rudely told by the bartender, "no moderations and no substitutions." Apparently they only serve exactly what is on their menu as it is. You can't ask to have it served any other way. We immediately left. Ridiculous. read more

Order at the bar and seat yourself..... Food was below average, the "deconstructed "nachos were like a slop read more

Not for me. Will not return. No one to take your order. You have to go to the bar. No substitutions and no ketchup. No exceptions. Servers were kind of snarky about it and kept showing us the menu that had all their "rules." My family and I thought the food was just ok. My meatball sub was a little on the cold side. There are much better options out there. read more

I don't understand why there are so many complaints about the "no modifications" rule. It's clearly listed on their menu and on their website. Personally, I wouldn't want to make any modifications as the food was fantastic the way it was intended to be prepared! We ordered the Old Man and the burger special - California King Burger with French fries. My fiancé still raves about this burger and says it's one of the best he's ever had. We loved that they are dog friendly and have casual, relaxing patio right in the heart of Fish Creek. We will definitely be coming back on our next visit to Door County. The only feedback I'd suggest is having ketchup. For a restaurant specializing in sandwiches and fries, you think ketchup and mustard would be a given! Or, at least offer extra complimentary sauces from their homemade selections. read more

See all

Wow the drinks and service were great!!! We were able to sit with our bulldog and take in the scenery! Try the ELDERFLOWER SPRITZ!!! Amazing!!!! read more

Hill Street - Burgers Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

Had hangover noodles - corn dogs and she hulk salad - amazing food! AMAZING service Busy lunch time / food was served immediately- drinks were quick & cold. We loved this place. read more

Their no substitution no modification rule is weird. They wouldn't even hold the mayo on my wife's fish sandwich.

The patio is nice. You have to order at the bar which can be a little irritating on a busy day; however, they bring the food to you so that cuts down on the annoyance. Good cocktails. Decent beer selection. The day we went the menu was just tacos. The chicken tacos were $8 for two and had they been a little fuller, I wouldn't have minded the price so much. It was grilled chicken, pickled onion, guac, pico de gallo, and cilantro. There was a ground beef version, too. And there may have been a nacho option. The service was good despite the crowd. We came here because someone recommended it based on the food in the interior space, but on this particular day, there was just the one menu. I overheard someone saying the interior menu is only in play on Tuesdays and Thursdays. read more

I am an admitted burger snob. Hill Street does it well. Great crust on each patty. Good balance between amount of beef vs bun. Fries have wonderful seasoning. I'd recommend to anyone that asks. read more

Fun! Lovely spot in fish creek with great outdoor vibe. Delicious drinks and food and GREAT service. The outdoor vibe is nice- has both sunny and shady spots- tables on the patio and seats all around the bar. Our bartender and Scotty were wonderful, attentive and nice. Ordered the Elderflower Spritz (which was expensive for $16- but they do let you keep the rest of the canned bubbly) and a beer- they had Mango Cart on Draft . We ordered dinner: deconstructed nachos (the queso and beans are vegetarian - a huge plus!) which had a nice hot spice to them ). Asked our bartender for dinner rec for me (vegetarian) and she suggested the Charlie Brown. Glad I ordered- never had anything like it- what a fun combo of flavors with the peanuts and charred broccoli. read more

Hill Street - Elderflower Spritz, Charlie Brown sandwich, deconstructed nachos and bar peanuts - Burgers Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

We bought pull tabs from the bar on a Thursday and came back to redeem them on Saturday. The bartender berated my 73 yr old father, swore at him, asked how old he was and called him stupid saying he was trying to rip off his business. Subsequently I went back and asked him to verify the tickets, to which all were from the bar. I didn't receive an apology and was questioned why I would leave the bar with them. Absolute jerks. read more

We loved Hill Street. We were walking around town and thought the patio looked nice so decided to give it a whirl. We parked along side on the street. The bar had a few seats open so that's where we sat, but there were some tables open with nice umbrellas. You have to order at the bar, they don't have table service! We ordered drinks- I had the Paloma and my husband had a pale ale beer. The Paloma was great! I ordered the Old Man, which is a fun BBQ fish sandwich and man it was JUST what I needed. So good, light, full of flavor. My mouth is watering again just thinking about it. Other orders in my group were the hot chicken sandwich and the burger of the day (not sure if that is on the rotation). Both of those had good reviews, and the burger was especially a hit with everyone who had it! It was a bit sloppy but so delicious. Service was fast and great- the bartender Logan gave us some awesome recommendations around town. I would definitely recommend stopping here if you want a nice, chill spot to hang out for a bit. They have a small menu full of variety. They don't make any special requests or changes to the menu items because of how small the kitchen is, just be aware of that! That was fine with us because everything sounded so amazing. They also don't have ketchup or mustard and make their own sauces in house- another huge plus for us and we had no problem with this. They have fun cocktails and a good handful of beers to choose from. Would recommend! read more

Hill Street - Paloma - Burgers Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

Great spot in Fish Creek! We were passing through and stopped to have lunch on their patio. Simple menu but the items offered were creative and had a culinary spin on your standard bar food items. They don't serve ketchup but they make up for it with a disco sauce which was delicious! Service was great! You have to order at the bar, and although it was busy the bartenders were attentive and friendly. Well done Hill Street! read more

See all

This is the worst restaurant i've ever been to. The service was horrible. 0/10 do not recommend.

Their rules are weird. Something fishy about not being able substitute or modify a meal. People have allergies or simply don't like certain things. The only thing that caught my eye was broccoli. Had to walk out. read more

We just happened to walk by this cute little outdoor bar and restaurant and decided to stop for some bloody Mary's and mimosas before shopping. What an adorable little gem! Even though it was chilly outside, they had outdoor propane heaters, and the decor and menu are eclectic and modern. The drinks were delicious and we wished we were hungry because the menu looks fantastic. Definitely worth a stop! read more

Hill Street - Cute view from the bar area - Burgers Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

Disappointed that they wouldn't even remove the egg for someone who's allergic to them. Looks like a nice place but we walked out upon seeing their inflexible no substitution/no modification policy. Customer lost. read more

Ordered the She-Hulk salad. Out of the four ingredients listed, it was missing two of them (the snap peas and the cucumbers.) So, I was given a $14.00 bowl of lettuce with dressing and an egg. The server disappeared for so long, I could not get it corrected before we had to leave for the event we were attending. read more

This place is always amazing. I'm glad they have the no substitution rule because I've been forced to try things I normally wouldn't. I've been extremely surprised and happy with my meal every single time. This is the new best place in fish creek!!! Service is always friendly and the ambiance is to die for. Warm and cozy in the winter time! read more

I have to go along with seems like the majority. I totally understand no substitution but to leave off something which really goes to his bottom line is not understandable. Peanut allergies don't want mayo or lettuce but you have to take it is crazy, across the street at bayside get it the way you want and that's where I went. read more

Stopped in for an afternoon Bloody Mary! Service was efficient and tables were cleared to accommodate rotating groups. The outdoor patio was very pleasant to enjoy on a busy Saturday! read more

Hill Street - Bloody Mary - Burgers Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

This place was EXCELLENT. Friendly staff, a really great outdoor atmosphere to sit and enjoy dinner, and the food was DELICIOUS. The Bahn Scott is a must get: candied pork really makes it stand out. Highly recommend. read more

Hill Street - The Bahn Scott: Candied pork, pickled smoked onion, jalapeño kettle chips, cilantro, mayo, and lime on a hoagie. TRULY excellent. - Burgers Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

Overall, a decent meal. I ordered the Krugan burger and my husband ordered the sweet/heat chicken sandwich. My burger had really good flavor. The meat was crispy on the edges and the bun was toasted. The chicken sandwich was supposed to be spicy, but my husband said it really wasn't. Some cons: sandwiches didn't come with a side and ranged from $14-16 each. Pretty pricey. Fries were $6 and a basket full, but ~$20 for a burger and fries was steep. No ketchup- they "don't believe it" the bartender said. Fries did come with a reddish sauce. Probably Mayo, ketchup, and other stuff mixed together. We sat on the patio and the truck noises were loud going down the street. read more

Truly bananas that you can't ask them to hold something from a sandwich even due to an allergy. If the kitchen is so small and that's an issue then why don't they serve the sandwiches open faced so people can adjust the sandwich to their preference/taste/allergy. read more

Took my wife and son to this place, Seemed like a nice little place. When we went to order all I asked for was a plan hamburger for my son. The guy told me he couldn't do that. I even offered to pay full price for their burger but with nothing on and he said there was nothing he could do. I find this ridiculous but if that's their policy then they can deal with this review. We got up and went across the street where everything was fantastic. I even got a plain hamburger for my son. read more

Stopped in to try this place the weekend before Memorial Day. Bartender was super unfriendly....pointed to a sign and said "there are the specials"!. We ordered a basket of fries and the nachos. We received a tiny container of orange sauce with our fries called Hill street sauce. It was OK. I asked for ketchup and the bartender pointed to a sign that said "no ketchup". What kind of place doesn't have frickin ketchup??? So, we asked for more "street sauce" and got about 1/2 ounce. Got charged $1.00! By the way, beers were $8! Decided to cut our losses. Went to Bayside where same beers were $5, much friendlier staff and the place was packed. Will not return to Hill Street. read more

I wouldn't waste your time or money here. Don't go here if you want anything other than what they have on their menu. My wife is gf/df and they won't modify anything, so we won't go back. My food was average at best. There is plenty of better options in Door County. We will see if they will make it. Rude staff and owners. read more

The food was legitimately delicious. My wife and I split the Harry Dean chicken sandwich, and we agreed it might be among the best chicken sandwiches we've had. Our 7yo had the HS Grilled Cheese, and that was also really good. The "Hwy 42" sauce that comes with it kind of reminds me of the sauce that comes with Chik-Fil-A sandwiches. It works. The menu declares right in the middle, so that it cannot possibly be missed, no substitutions or modifications. They're serious about this, almost to a fault. I listened to the owner's interview on the Door County Pulse Podcast (worth a listen, Carlos Bandidos gets name-checked! https://soundcloud.com/doorcountypulse/no-blues-at-hill-street-with-scott-watts) and he explains the thinking behind that policy. It kind of makes sense from a business perspective. We got the nachos for my 10yo and asked for no beans. Wouldn't do it. Luckily, all the toppings come on a separate platter, so no big deal. To me, it would be better to just not add the beans to that platter when you know they're just going to get thrown away. It was pouring outside the day we visited, so we sat at one of the five booths in the indoor bar attached to the back. It was cool and quiet, which we appreciated. The Bob Ross Channel was showing on the tvs. Who doesn't love Bob Ross? My 5 star review is specifically related to my experience at Hill Street on Friday afternoon, July 28, 2023. The following is completely separate: Some people have mentioned the owner's responses to reviews on Google and Instagram, and they're... interesting. And unfortunate. Kind of a "F--- your feelings" attitude, especially when ketchup is the topic. (interestingly, I haven't seen him pop up here on Yelp, although he specifically mentions Yelp in the podcast I referenced above) People who complain are derisively referred to as "Pattys." Maybe it's a shtick? Maybe he's trying to channel some kind of insult comic? Unlike the Hwy 42 sauce with the grilled cheese, it's not working for me, but there seem to be people who find it amusing. I spent a good amount of time working in hospitality, including a couple of locations in Door County, and it would never occur to me to address customers the way he does. "Never make the customer feel stupid" was a lesson I learned early on. I don't feel, though, that those interactions are a reason to not enjoy the food at Hill Street. Just don't go in expecting to have ketchup on your burger or any kind of customization. read more

Wonderful rum punches. Great sandwiches. Deconstructed nachos were awesome. Sauce with fries is wonderful. Fast service. Great atmosphere. Try the Banh Scott & Harry Dean Sandwiches. You won't regret it! read more

Hill Street - Rum Punch - Burgers Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Hmmm. Where to start. Really dumb menu. There is no way to remove nuts from a salad for allergy reasons. No dressing substitutions of any kind. If you like marshmello on your food, it's for you. BTW, don't ask for salt or pepper, none on premise. The staff is friendly, but they can't give customers what they want. If you leave a review, expect a venomous counterpoint from the owner. read more

Been here three times now... The Good: Great outdoor bar and atmosphere. The smashburger is killer. I have an unhealthy obsession with crinkle cut fries and their's are outstanding (I didn't care for the seasoned salt. Plain salt would be better in my opinion, but I'm a bit of a purist.). The Bad: Stick to just drinks on Sun/Mon when they only serve tacos. They aren't very good. The Ugly: No Miller Lite. Just an odd choice. When there for lunch on Thu, I was one of four people I personally witnessed trying to order a Miller Lite within about 15 minutes. You're in Wisconsin guys. The no ketchup thing is also just a weird gimmick. Those fries I just raved about were screaming for it. I'd suggest you try to be noticed for what you do offer, not for what you don't. The place has a lot of positives and potential, though I suspect the owners' arrogance and attitude will probably screw it up. read more