I stopped in here based on Yelp reviews. I had the turkey sandwich which was just about the same as you'd get elsewhere. The price is high for what you get. Be prepared to pay far more than what it's worth because of the location and the seasonality of business in Door County. Based on reviews, I asked for a sample of the hippie bread. It was delish and as another reviewer noted, I bought bread even though I don't keep bread at home! I do appreciate culinary artists and it is evident here in the goods. Long day at Murphy Park with many hours drive home so did not have time or place to enjoy the cookies or folded pie sweet treats. All in all would stop in again to try additional items but am not convinced upon a first try that this is a top tier place. read more

Good food. Lady that took our order was very short with us in a rude way. Charged us $1.72 more than what was on their menu. I'm more than willing to pay for good food but when brought up they told me that they couldn't give me a receipt and that their menu board is getting redone next week. Not sure if the heath department would agree with the open sodas and sandwiches being eaten by the staff in the same area as the sandwiches being prepped. Seeing the staff eat with their bare hands then go prep food to be served without washing theirs hands is a bit off putting. read more

Smaller than expected but quaint little spot. Like most say- the chicken salad was great!

Great food super friendly staff!!! Will definitely be back. My wife and I both had sandwiches and they were fresh and delicious. They included a wonderful carrot cake to help us celebrate our honeymoon. Just great people serving great food. read more

The bread. The soup. The sandwiches. Everything was amazing. Vegetarian options - try the salads! Great staff. Live music out front when we were there (and walk back to the library after you eat and check out the views from the 2nd floor) read more

MacReady Artisan Bread Company - Bakeries Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

This place is an excellent place for lunch. Homemade bread every day. Sandwiches and soup are excellent. The owners are very friendly and actually come out and visit with their guests to make sure everything is okay. read more

MacReady Artisan Bread Company - Bakeries Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

Super good sandwiches and soup. A must to stop and try. A great break away from all the heavy deep fried food.

Came here on Saturday afternoon around 3 pm for a late lunch. Was looking forward to soup on a rainy day but they ran out, so went with the Italian sandwich instead which was super delicious. Unfortunately this restaurant doesn't seem to follow the most strict hand washing guidelines you would expect during a global pandemic (or anytime eating at a restaurant), as the cashier refilled cabinets in the front of the restaurant and immediately touched food without washing her hands. When my friend asked if she washed her hands, she noted she has been using hand sanitizer without offering to make her a new meal, put on gloves, etc. Needless to say we were all really nervous to eat our food. The face mask policy on the door was also not enforced. Would hope the staff can improve their practices to help keep customers healthy in the future. read more

Wow, this place is excellent. We picked up sandwiches here for lunch on the boat and we all Loved them. The homemade bread is to die for and they even had a veggie option for the vegetarians in our group. The pastries and sweets they sell Are all phenomenal. The first time we came i noticed some Cherry tarts but didn't get them. The next day they didn't have them, so I asked and they said they would specially make some for Me the next day! Great service! Go here, you will not be disappointed. read more

Bread is beautiful with a creepy crust and pillowy insides! We tried 4 of the sandwiches and all were to perfection! Staff and kind and gracious, even on a hot 4th of July!!! read more

This place is kind of hidden behind all the big places and it's amazing. The service is really nice and food amazing. I got the soup of the day with bread and it tastes amazing! The soup of the day was noodles, chicken, and mushrooms broth. I don't usually like mushrooms but this made me change my mind. If you are in the egg harbor area this place is definitely worth a visit. read more

MacReady Artisan Bread Company - Bakeries Near Me - Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

Simple but yummy lunch!! I had the ham sandwich on French bread, my sister had turkey, and my mom had the Italian on focaccia. The bread was really tasty with a light but chewy bite, and the sandwiches were just simply, freshly made with some lettuce, tomato, and mayo. We took home a couple of their delicious scones for breakfast the next day (cherry was my fave!). Lastly, the bread pudding is a MUST!! They gave us some caramel sauce for pouring over the top...we shared them for dessert that night with some vanilla ice cream and YUM!! We would go right back for more. Great place! read more

A great lunch spot where you'll get amazing sandwiches on artisan bread. Their menu was small and located on a cute little board near the register. I ended up ordering a hot ham and cheese sandwich and my husband had a turkey sandwich. We ended up trading halves so we could each try both for lunch. Both were yummy, but I think the ham and cheese edged out the turkey simply by the sharp cheddar cheese they used. Portion size was good, and each sandwich came with a bag of chips. We sat outside on the small front porch to eat, and it was lovely. As we were leaving, one of the owners asked how our food was. I thought that was so sweet to be asked. We told her how much we enjoyed the food and thanked her. We were in a bit of a hurry, so I didn't get to try any of the fresh bread , but I really wish I had. read more

They have the best homemade made soups and sandwiches. The chicken salad is amazing. Make sure you stop there when you visit Door County.

From out of town. Came here with friends who live in area. Friendly and hard working staff. Great chicken salad sandwiches and exceptional chicken pot pie. Worth the stop in my opinion! read more

We traveled to Wisconsin to visit family and we went to this great restaurant. Fantastic sandwiches and super nice people serving you. The Italian Sandwich; Turkey Sandwich and Chicken Salad sandwiches are amazing. The bread is made there and is so fresh and delicious. They also have pastries including a cream cheese frosted brownie. Even our grandkids loved this place and that says something because kids can be picky eaters. This is a place to try for sure! read more

Tried to eat here earlier today. Sign hung on the door says, We welcome all. We had our 8 lb Teddy Bear dog with us. No signs about animals saying they couldn't come in, remember, "We Welcome All." So I came in holding my dog, and when I got to the counter to order, the young girl at the register gave me the rudest look ever. Then asked me to leave because they cannot have dogs there. That's fine, I understand. However, post it on the door, or ask nicely. So, can't tell you how the food was, girl was too rude to let us eat. read more

The soup of the day is a must have! I ordered a half soup and half sandwich, both of which were excellent. Be sure to also get one of their cookies for desert, they are amazing! Make sure to stop here if you are in the area! read more

Great addition to Door County! Great scones, cookies, bread, coffee and decor! Nice outdoor sitting area as well. Will be back and tell all my friends! read more

Very good bread. We bought day-old cinnamon raisin and have been cherishing every bite. They also had samples of their door county cherry cranberry bread out and that was tasty as well. Also bought a day old semolina loaf...very tough crust, but a good crumb and it made for tasty French toast in the morning. We got there late in the day so our choices were very limited. So for best selection, arrive earlier than 2 pm. read more

Loved it, great for lunch. Charming little place! Soup and sandwiches with tasty desserts. read more

See all

A cute and quiet sandwich shop not too far out of the way. Sandwiches are around $9 due to the freshly baked bread. However, if this isn't a big selling point for you, it seems overpriced. I had the salami sandwich with cheddar cheese, nice and simple, but the bread didn't exactly stand out to me. For the price, I would prefer sandwiches with more unique combinations of ingredients. Despite the price, it's worth checking out for a good bite to eat without a long wait. Super friendly staff too. read more

If you like artisan bread, hearty sandwiches, and a warm family run atmosphere this is the place for you. It's a simple straight to the point place that emphasizes their baked goods. I noticed a lot of people who pre ordered loaves of bread for pickup. It's reasonably priced for door county and will fill you up. I had the hard salami and cheddar sandwich with spicy mustard. It was perfect for an on the go lunch. read more

What a hidden gem in Door County! Everything is so fresh and homemade. Everyone is just so friendly, they make you feel comfortable. Try the quiche! Have them warm one up there and enjoy or take it to go! Wife and I really enjoyed the ham and cheese quiche so much that they are making a larger one for us to take home! Just a wonderful establishment! read more

Fresh hot bread, and lots of varieties! Sandwiches and soup available also. A can't miss spot while in Door County.

Great bread, especially their French and cherry bread. Great sandwiches. Good scones.

WE love this place. Located in the Heart of Egg Harbor tucked just east of highway 42 and south of County E... I recommend their Door County Chicken salad sandwich. I love it on any of their home made breads. I have been coming for a few years now and just love sharing it with friends. They have 1/2 sandwiches available for a lighter appetite... but my husband and I split one and it is just right for a light lunch. My husband tried the Tuna and loved that, We went back several times on our last visit. The bread is delicious and the location has plenty of parking. You can sit inside or outdoors under the shade of the trees. Be sure to stop when you are in Door County. Stop for Lunch, to eat in or take... and grab a loaf of their bread while you are there. You will be glad you did and you will be a return customer like we are! 2 thumbs up! read more

Stopped in this past Saturday to order a chicken pot pie for pick up on Sunday. I ended up ordering a 1/2 Braunschweiger sandwich and a cup of mushroom bisque. The soup was delicious and the sandwich was a treat! Couldn't leave without a huge molasses cookie, and I'm glad I did-Yum! Now back to the pot pie, the crust was flaky and homage and the filling was loaded with tender chicken and delicious as well! One other thing, the staff were very friendly and helpful! read more

Bread was great and the staff friendly, but food is overpriced, no salads are offered, greens were wilting (they reimbursed us and we're apologetic), there was no espresso machine, and the chairs outside were very dirty. Dissapointed. Will be a good place if they raise their game. read more

Simple yet tasty sandwiches, great for a quick lunch. We sat outside and enjoyed the music in front of the shop. Sandwiches are large and could be shared if you're looking for something lighter! read more

The best bakery with delightful owners doing all the baking. We enjoyed fresh French bread toasted with fresh tomatoes . All the sandwiches sound divine & raspberry scones filled with raspberries were light & fluffy. Coffee is organic free trade & the setting charming. If you are ever in the area give yourself a treat & stop for delicious bread in many forms & good coffee. read more

Nice stop for lunch. They even made a grilled cheese sandwich that was not on the menu. Super friendly people!

We each ordered a half egg salad sandwich with a bowl of soup (my partner got the black bean, I got tomato). Cost was $10 each which initially I thought was a bit steep. However the half sandwich was quite large and made on freshly baked bread, and the bowl of soup was also generous. A tiny cup of cole slaw was also included. Everything was DELICIOUS and was actually a good value for the price. We also enjoyed some of their ice cream. Extra good! I would definitely return and highly recommend. You won't be disappointed! read more

I had an OUT OF THIS WORLD cherry chicken salad sandwich on sunflower flax bread. The portions were very generous, and the bread was amazingly moist. I also had their creamy tomato soup, with some fresh parmesan chucks of cheese in it! Mmmm-mmm! I've been here before, and will definitely be back. I tell my friends and family to be sure to make it a stop when they travel in Door County. The married couple who run the place (and make the bread, etc.) add to the pleasant ambiance. You can sense their love and enthusiasm for what they do. read more

Loved the bakery. My husband and I were in the mood for some soup so we ordered the soup and bread. Wow! The soup was great and we got a variety of their fresh baked breads. Our favorite bread was the whole wheat Happy Hippie. We liked this bread so much we bought a loaf to take home. Friendly service from the owners. You can tell they take pride in their business and provide great customer service. read more

Sandwiches pretty good. Not worst...not best. Alot of meat, average on overall flavor. Priced a bit high for what you get. Service very slow. I suspect customers in the shop play second fiddle to take out orders. Took us 35 minutes to get 4 sandwiches read more

Wonderful bakery! Their breads are amazing, and their cookies are even better! The cranberry cherry bread makes the best French toast you will ever have. I am also partial to their chicken salad, the dried cherries make it different from any other salad I have had. The owners are super friendly, and greet many regulars by name, but treat everyone like an old friend. Their butter crisp cookies are my kryponite, they are sooooo good! They recently started offering par baked pot pies, those make an amazing meal, too. Come for lunch and take supper with you, and grab something sweet for a snack! Fun, homey location featuring local art, fabulous smells, and phenomenal baked goods! Well worth the traffic to go to Egg Harbor for them! read more

We got to the store about 3 minutes before they closed for the day. The owner and her mom were wonderful! They made me sandwiches for my family and even though she was sold out of some items, she figured out a terrific veggie sandwich for us! The bread was terrific and the raspberry scones were incredible! I highly recommend this sandwich shop! read more

Most adorable and welcoming owner/couple EVER- I wish I could be friends with them! We weren't planning to have lunch quite yet, I just wanted some coffee, but once we entered it was clear we needed to try their bread. I had the tomato Parmesan soup and my hub had the egg salad sandwich. All super yums and we can't wait to go back! read more

We were in Door County last weekend and stopped in for lunch on Saturday. Amazing food and great people! It was so good that we ordered a chicken pot pie and loaf of bread to take home to Chicago. Had the pot pie last night, wished we lived closer! read more