Huge fan of their buffalo chicken slices and this grandma thin meat lovers pizza! Loaded with different types of meat as toppings, pretty thin, and great tangy sauce. read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - 39. Grandma's Meatloaf Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This place is so small so simple yet one of the real ones left out there . Good fresh and oil dri of the slice type of pizza love it and the smells of real pizza just hits you when you walk in. read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I've been coming here for 15+ years and I've only had the pizza, garlic knots ( must try), and zepoles. Pizza game on point. Today I decided to try their baked pasta dishes, I gotta say, the lasagna was pretty damn good. Sauce was good, generous with the meat in the sauce, and pasta al dente. Chicken cutlet ravioli didn't disappoint! Highly recommend, rates 8/10. read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

RUDE, UNPROFESSIONAL, used the f word to me!!!!! Long story. A little on tall side, older guy...family Will never go back. And jeez get a makeover already!!! read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - Got 2 slices, fell out of flimsy box in a pile of leaves, which was ok, bc the RUDE moron who sold it to me probably put a whammy on it!!! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I had a bad experience the last time I was there thought I'd give them another chance! WORST DECISION EVER!!!! I mean who burns shrimp parmigiana!??????? This is horrid!!!! I paid OVER $20 for THIS plate???? BURNT shrimp! The sauce tastes like sugar and water! The proof is in the photo! How is this place still open!!!!?? And the guy upfront places it in the brown bag so you don't see till you get home? And that stuck up bitch in the front needs to learn customer service for real!!!! The health dept needs to go check the back the kitchen because if you burn shrimp what is going on back there who's cooking back there a 6 year old? I'm SO done with this place and I'm telling all my neighbors too!!!! The worst pizzeria EVER!!!! Next time I'll go down the block better! read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - BURNED SHRIMP PARM DISGUSTING - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Food is great Friendly service Pizza, wraps and garlic rolls the best. Emilo is the chef and can make anything you request. He is excellent read more

Good neighbourhood pizza spot, cool and friendly stuff. I always regular pizza or Caesar salad.

This review would be 4-stars if it weren't for delivery. The food is good. Had a veggie pie, fried calamari, stuffed garlic knots (which are basically ham and cheese sliders), a chicken Caesar salad, and veal parm with a side salad. The pizza was fine, the salads were good, I liked the calamari though my dad said it was "too bready and overcooked," and my favorite was the veal. Delivery came on time. However, I guess the buzzer wasn't working and the person didn't think to call my cell phone??? He just left the food OUTSIDE...in the middle of a few-hundred unit apartment complex. Thank goodness I checked my texts and saw he left it outside because I ran down so fast. One second later and it would've been snatched 100%. read more

See all

Clean, quick service, and friendly people. luigis remains a local favorite. And for good reason. The penne pie is a must try. Most places don't even offer one. Many of the negative reviews are based on how Uber delivered the food. Ubers bad service doesnt reflect on luigis product. Luigis has their own delivery guys, and they are the best. read more

Guy delivered pizza out OF A MILK CRATE. SIDEWAYS. Our pizza was destroyed. Guy on the phone says, "It's not my problem, it's Uber." Refused to send us a new pizza. GARBAGE PLACE. NO NO NO. read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - Seriously. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Luigi's is a staple in the neighborhood. I go there often. They have a special for two slices and a can soda for 7 dollars running all day everyday. You get good portions and the pizza is delicious. They have friendly staff that is always welcoming. You can carry out or eat in, they have plenty of seating in the rear of the restaurant read more

Pizza here is average. I never thought pizza was really worth the money back then. Definitely don't think it's worth it today, especially getting charged more for paying with card. read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I have to admit, Luigi's is a solid local pizzeria that I had never visited in all of my years in the area. They serve the typical cheese and specialty (ex: buffalo chicken, bbq chicken, white pizza, pepperoni, fresh mozzarella) pizza slices that most pizzerias in the Sheepshead Bay neighborhood sell these days. My wife and I came in on cool Saturday evening at 7pm and there weren't many customers inside, but the employees were still very friendly. We took a quick look at the pizza slices and we both got 2 each. My wife went with the fresh mozzarella and buffalo chicken, while I got the white pizza and bbq chicken. Like I said, it was solid and I was surprised at how fresh tasting the pizza was after heating, despite it probably sitting outside for hours. In addition, the flavors on all of the pizzas were really good - the fresh mozzarella had good tang, the buffalo chicken was one of the better buffalo chicken slices I had in a while, the white pizza was very cheesy and the bbq chicken was interesting, but I loved the combination. There was nothing else really special about the pizzeria, other than the fact that the employees were relatively friendly, which unfortunately IS a surprise these days at local restaurants. The pizza was tasty and good and the prices were typical. I actually would come by again if I was ever craving pizza in the neighborhood. read more

See all

One of the better pizzerias on Avenue U. They've been around for decades and have been pretty consistent in their products. I came in near closing because I had a craving for garlic knots and the worker there was kind enough to get a new batch started for me since there were only 4 pieces left for the day. They don't have anything unique or a signature like what you would find in the city, but for a pizzeria deep in Brooklyn, they serve their purpose well. Most of their things are just okay quality. read more

See all

Review #567 None Elite Squad I see a 3 star Rating here and wouldn't know why? I mean I am from Cali and maybe thats why everything i seem to taste here taste Amazing! I didnt get to taste the Pizza but I got a Roll..a Sausage Roll. in Cali they're all Called Stromboli regardless of the Flavor..here Rolls. Pies in Cali just normal Pizza..anyways..I have to say it was delicious and even though it was limited with Sausage and it had more Green Peppers than anything..it tasted Great. The Marinara was delicious..the staff were cool..I mean I like it and I would come back to taste that Grilled Chicken Caesar Pizza..Sorry, Grilled Caesar Pie. The reason I cannot give 5 stars is because I got 2 powdered sugar donuts ..I dont know what they're called but they were not fresh and hard as a rock..I still ate them but definitely wouldn't order them again..so im giving them 4 stars read more

Although my preference is for sourdough, slightly blistered crusts, this largely semolina pie was spectacular. Delivery showed up right on time and piping hot. The proximity of this place to my apartment is going to be a very hard temptation to resist. read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - 8. Luigi's Special Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Today I ordered hero from this place and it was the worst ever. Not fresh and very hard to even bite on it Not sure how long ago and when it was made and f how long it was in their freezer. I don't recommend anyone to order any heroes from this place. read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Luigi's is a solid N.Y. pizza place. They've got great round slice, incredible Sicilian squares, pizzas with great toppings that'll rival any pizza shop in Brooklyn. I used to order the chicken Parmesan hero for lunch everyday for more than a year because it is that good. The chicken cutlet is fresh, the breading is crunchy and flavorful, the sauce is tangy, not too much cheese and they bake the sandwich which makes the bread crispy yet soft. The staff are always nice and greet you with a smile and make you feel welcomed and you want to come back because that's what hospitality is all about. They've got comfy booths and TVs to watch while you enjoy your food. When you order delivery, the food comes hot and comes pretty quickly most of the time. read more

Awesome pizza and everything else ,great service ,ambiance calm and perfect,while menu to try

Listen, the pizza here is pretty good (that penne a la vodka slice is so wrong but so right!). But the hygiene/COVID precautions in here are a disgrace (especially in a neighborhood that has had such high rates). No one is ever masking--that is they all have masks pulled down below their chins. Customers are regularly on line without masks pulled up. No pizza is THAT good--see you after the pandemic, Luigi's. read more

4/6/19 So I ordered a shrimp parm hero less sauce. THANK GOODNESS it didn't have a lot of sauce! The hero was salty AF!!!! I took ONE bite trashed it!! I was noticing their slices were a bit salty too! Regardless when I called to inform them... I got..." oh I will tell the cook" SERIOUSLY? Dude I just spent $9.50 for nothing!!!! When I see the owner I'm going to have a talk with him I better get at least a free drink cause I'm done eating there! If you guys like salt and I mean salty as hell!!! No joke like all you taste is SALT!!!! Then more power to you! If there are any customers with high blood pressure issues DO NOT EAT THEIR FOOD!!! I'm so done with this place with all the competition around they too will closed down soon like 1/2 the stores on Ave U! read more

​Food is always fresh and that says a lot . Staff is accommodating and friendly , and there's always a supply of condiments for you to add to your pizza or whatever you like . I like the chicken rolls which are always fresh and crispy . The owner always lets you know that he appreciates your business . I like to drink coffee and I don't think they have coffee there they let me bring it in from the outside . If you are on Avenue you when you want a quick bite this should be your go to place . read more

Luigi is our go-to pizza shop when we are craving a nice slice of cheese pizza! Prices aren't too steep and the pizzas here are pretty good! With a purchase over $30 (I think) you get a free bottle of soda which is always nice to have. A cheese pie here is $16 so $2 a slice but in comparison to other pizza shops in the area, I'd pay a little more to have a better slice than just an okay slice. I've had their garlic knots here as well- aside from it being just VERY oily, it comes in a decent size and good to have once in a while. read more

i called to put a delivery order the guy was on the phone was so rude and gave me attitude he was huffing and puffing for everything that i asked for my order, then finally i got the delivery then it was super cold i did not eat it, it was a waste of money. NOT RECOMMENDED read more

Terrible delivery experience. My boyfriend and I ordered from Luigi at 10:15pm, and our order arrived at 11pm - 45 mins. being completely acceptable for me, so that's not where my complaints begin. We ordered the following things: A large cheese pizza, spinach roll, caesar salad, garlic knots, rice ball, and zeppoles. The pizza was solid. It was decent Brooklyn pizza. I'd give it a 3/5. There was nothing particularly bad about it, but nothing particularly great about it either. A decent slice, that became more solid once I chopped up some fresh basil, ground some fresh black pepper, and grated some Parmesan cheese. You really shouldn't have to go through such measures for a decent slice, but after ordering an entire large pie - you gotta do what you gotta do to make it enjoyable. The spinach roll was awful. The spinach tasted metallic. It left the taste of a handful of pennies in my mouth. The spinach was either canned and/or overcooked, and Luigi's makes one of the worst mistakes you could possibly make with spinach rolls - the spinach wasn't chopped! So you take a bite of the roll, and pull out an entire wad of 6 inch long pieces of spinach with each bite. Quite uncouth. There was no ricotta in the roll, which isn't a necessity, but is usually a nice extra touch, but the mozzarella in the roll, and the zeppole-tasting dough couldn't make up for the terrible spinach. Shame. The caesar salad tasted quite good. Kudos on the dressing. But the reality is that my order of salad was little more than a foil container full of chopped romaine lettuce, 5 or 6 croutons, and dressing. That really isn't a caesar salad. I went out of my way to shred my own Parmesan into it, grind my own pepper, add lemon juice and Worcestershire sauce - I pretty much paid $6 for a bowl of lettuce with some dressing, and did everything else myself. The garlic knots were good. They were very garlicky, which I enjoy. The dough was soft and chewy. They tasted as they should, and the marinara sauce that came with them was very tasty as well. No complaints there. The rice ball was AWFUL. It was mostly breading. As nice of a size as it was (I'd say about 5 inches in diameter), there was no rice in it! It was about 80% breading, and 20% actual rice and filling. What a disappointment. It didn't taste particularly bad, but I didn't pay for a breading ball, I paid for a rice ball, and it's one of the worst I've ever had. The zeppoles might've been the biggest disappointment. They were cold, hard, and tough. I tried microwaving them to a warm and edible consistency, but they just ended up as chewy as car tires. Plus - huge pizzeria no-no when it comes to zeppoles - they should be COVERED in powdered sugar, and there was hardly any. Long story short, I will more than likely not order from here again. Far too many disappointments, and not enough positive points. The plain slices were ok, and everything else left way too much to be desired. I'd definitely suggest trying another pizzeria in the area if that's what you're craving. read more

See all

7.50 for a salami & cheese hero... The hero consists of one layer of cheese. One layer of salami, and onion, tomato, and lettuce. Basically some bread with a taste of salami. When I called back to ask for a refund they told me they can't do anything and to call seamless. No offer to send a better sandwhich, (I wouldn't want it anyway). And after calling seamless they refused the refund anyway and basically told me to go f myself. So stear clear of this dump. read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - 7.50 for a salami & cheese hero. Please see the attached hero for reference as to what you're getting. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I ordered the "Grandma's MeatLovers" Pizza online for delivery and it came to 20 minutes early which was fine by me. The pie was gorgeous looking,super hot and delicious! I definitely will be ordering from them in the future! 6/1/16: Hey Luigi's & Yelp delivers again this time I had the calamari and of course my grandmas meat lovers pizza. The order timing was perfecto! I love the fact that I can use Eat24 to place my order. read more

I ate here just under a year ago and I completely forgot about it.....what does that tell you? I'm not sure why anyone raves about this place, occasionally I hear someone give them accolades, but.....really, I just don't have anything positive to say. You might ask say to that; "Well thanks a lot dude, that doesn't help me decide anything". Well....if this place is that forgettable to me, it just can't be good. Compare my other food reviews, pizza especially. I was here before Bloomberg started the rating system so I don't know if they got an A or not, but just look at the photo I took. Look where they keep their pizza....on blue painted wood...that just....oh...you get my point? This place is 100% PASS. Walk 2 blocks east to Trio's. read more

Pizza was delivered late. Delivery man wore no mask. The delivery person didn't even have the decency to bring the pizza to the apartment door. He kept telling me to walk to the elevator to get it. Repeatedly saying that he's double-parked. I speculate that he's just trying to make up time from being late to his other deliveries. Nonetheless, I start walking towards the elevator from the other end of the hallway. Two steps into walking towards him, he puts the pizza right on the floor. I cannot believe someone thinks it's fine to put someone's food, right on the floor -- during a global pandemic. I called Luigi's to inform them of what happened and all I received was an "I'll talk to him about this, sorry this happened". They've just lost this customer. read more

Food is decent. The delivery is always 20 minutes late minimally and the older man who delivers does not want to deliver to your door. He wants you to come to his car. Its 30 degrees out and I'm done doing this. The whole point of ordering out is to get the food delivered to YOUR DOOR. read more

Been ordering here for over 15 years, never again. Ordered a pepperoni pie for delivery and what I received was an abomination. They reheated an old pie that was sitting in the store and threw pepperoni on top. The dough was dry, the cheese was dry, the pepperoni was hardly cooked. When I told them, she had the nerve to tell me that pepperoni is naturally dry. Unbelievable. read more

I've heard about the bad pizza, but personally have never tried it. Too busy loving the chicken and shrimp parm heroes and the pasta bolognese! Those are so delicious that we haven't really explored the menu because we always crave the sandwiches. The pasta is a great value and I usually like to save part of my portion for lunch the next day. The heroes are amazing. The bread is so soft and the perfect amount of chewy. The spices/sauces that are in the hero just taste so good together. I love the shrimp parm with good shrimp that has a good crunch. I recommend those items if you want to avoid the pizza and they're reasonably priced :) read more

GreAt pizza !!!!! The hero's are decent I haven't tried the dinners but I would just stick with the pizza from here read more

I'm minding my business but hungry at the same time. Wanted something quick and light because I'm on a diet.. Lol and I see this pizzeria and I'm like cause I'm on a diet..lol.. I go in anyway, thinking plain pizza (cause you can't go wrong) then ....the beauty that caught my eye.. Fresh mozzarella, basil and garlic pizzachileeee... Deeelicious!!! So serious!! Mouth watering and just plain goodness.. I felt like I was in Little Italy.. So good and ate the first one so quick , I went back in and bought a 2nd one.. Yea.. I know, I'm on a diet..lol And very nice workers!! 5 for me!!! read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - Fresh mozzarella, basil and garlic pizzachileeee... Deeelicious!!! Mouth watering and just plain goodness!! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

A decent pizza place that my family loves to order from. Always made their pizza on time when I said I'd pick up at a certain time.

Had to go inside a second time because the guy "forgot" to cut my slice in half. Then when he cut it he missed. The slice was a 30/70 ratio. The slice overall lacked flavor. Keep in mind they don't have condiments either. Are they against flavor? I don't know how this place is still open. Smh read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - "Hey can you cut it in half" "Sure" - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best pizza ever . I love the sicilian pizza. & the margarita slice u cannot find one tasting this good anywhere!!! Forever one of my go to pizzerias. read more

Not the old-school slice I was hoping for. Crust was very soft, sauce and cheese slipping off the pizza, vegetables very thick and chunky. Edible though not craveable. Other members of my household didn't mind it. read more

Very rude when ordering on the phone I Simply asked to add a water and he said you can't keep adding to your order and was very annoyed and I asked if there was a problem he said yes I said I can call somewhere else then he said whatever you want then hung up on me like excuse me?? Very rude horrible customer service don't go here at all unprofessional!!!! read more

Another order - again no problem; and excellent round pies, veal cutlet parm hero - now they are sending soda on the house, which is a nice touch. Delivery guys always friendly. They do get busy, so there is a wait at times, so what? Beats the others in Sheepshead/Marine Park. read more