Let me start by saying i have only left a bad review, one other time in my life. I dont ever send food back, and normally don't say anything. My husband loves the wings here and has been coming here for years. I have NEVER had what I would consider a decent meal here and today is no different. I ordered the eggplant stack as my meal. It's supposed to have FRESH mozzarella. What I received was three paper thin slices of greasy eggplant with 3 slices of block mozzarella cheese. Cheap, gritty, block cheese. The plate actually had a layer of grease floating on the bottom. The eggplant was cold. The cheese as I mentioned, gritty. I would have said something, to the waiter that took our order, but he never once came back. The hostess came to take our plates, asked me if I wanted it wrapped, and I told her I was very unhappy. She apologized, and took the plate. She came back with the plate still on the bill. The funny thing is, it's not the 12 dollars. Between the complete lack of any service (never asked about refills or came over at all) and the terrible dish, I can't believe they wouldn't attempt to salvage a customer. read more

Environment was nice. The Saturday night DJ was terrible. Do t bother, hit up Babylon carriage house instead

Last night I had a great meal at a new place for me. This is a restaurant for dining, and later a popular pub. I arrived and was taken to my requested table, with A Reserved sign, kudos not something 5 star places even do. I review a restaurant from arrival to departure. So greeting *****. The Hostess and entire staff treated me as. Family Food ****, big thing for me is having food plated and served quickly*****. As there was 3 of us we got to review and sample many dishes. Seafood Appetizer great, friends had potato soup incredible. Also in Addition to Guiness, they had Kilkenny my friends favorite. Main courses I had pasta and seafood dish excellent, impressed me for non Italian place. Also Bangers and mash great, and the corned Beef and cabbage to die for. This place reminded me of my favorite Hotel in NYC where you become family. Also Bartender knew how to make old school old Faahioned, not a popular drink these days. Coffee at end of meal freshly brewedthis is huge for me ends the meal for me like having a glass of champagne!! So for a great Dinner, snacks or late night fun I say go. I am critical reviewer so they impressed me I am sure you will love it. Look forward to returning very soon want to try other dishes. Thanks to entire staff, I am not related to or have any connection to this place. It added a sparkle to my weekend. read more

Great restaurant. Great service. Will not dissapoint. Haven't been here in long time and will definitely be Back.

We came here for the 1st time tonight. It was excellent. We tried the beer sampler. It was a good selection of 3 Oktoberfest beers. We liked them all. I had the corned beef and cabbage and my boyfriend had the filet mignon special. His steak was cooked perfectly and my dinner was great as well. Claire was our waitress and she was lovely. She answered all of our questions and gave us just the right amount of attention. We definitely will be back! read more

jaaammmmmmmmmm packed for AFC championship game. wings were goooooood. definitely NOT MICROWAVED as I read earlier.

This restaurant never ceases to amaze me. The service is excellent and the food is wonderful. Today, had lunch with a good friend, our waitress was Darby and she was excellent in not only providing great service but in being entertaining as well. Lily Flanagan's has never been a disappointment. Would highly recommend! read more

Went here for a catering event (engagement party) and this place was great! Good food (Chicken something, beef something, penne all vodka, etc.). It was an open bar so free drinks are always great to have. Perfect location since it's right near a train station. I'll have to try this place for a happy hour one night. I always here ads on the radio. Gotta try it for a non-event and really see what they have to offer. read more

I came here around 1130 on a Saturday night and I have to say I am pretty impressed. I wanted to get out and dance for a bit and this was the perfect place. The drinks were fairly priced and the Dj played a good mix of music which I always love. Will definitely return read more

I mean eh this place wasn't good but it wasn't bad either, the music was okay, the crowd was nice. I would come here again, it didn't wow me. It's just your average dive bar in Long Island. read more

DISGUSTING! Don't waste your money...worst meal I have had in a long time. Ordered the fish tacos and it was cold, barely any fish and the sour cream had a weird taste. My boyfriend had the chicken parm for pasta night and he and I both were sick at night. Food was slow coming out and staff not very attentive!! Again...DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME OR MONEY! read more

Had a great time there midweek with friends from work. Our server, Alana, was fantastic the whole 3 hours we were there! The gin and tonic I had was good, and the extra limes I requested made it even better. The appetizer sampler was average with mozzarella sticks, potato skins and something else I can't recall. The baked clams were big on the Seafood appy and very good, along with fried calamari and shrimp. I had the special Sirloin meal for Thursday night, and it was cooked very nicely with spinach subbed for broccoli, which is what i prefer with steak. It was delicious Gaelic style with mushrooms, onions and a creamy whiskey sauce. I took half of mine home to enjoy again! The table shared some desserts and they were all yummy in my book! The place got busy and it was hard to talk due to the volume of voices, especially since we were seated at a table in the middle of the room. the booths may be a better choice for a date or if you don't like the noisy atmosphere. We all got there early at 5-5:30, but those that came later had to park on the street, but meters are free after 6....so don't waste your quarters! read more

Food was excellent. Burger night was by far my favorite night! The atmosphere and staff was exceptional! Would come back 100 times!!

We randomly chose this restaurant because it was near the Babylon LIRR station and there were plenty of cars in the lot. It clearly has an Irish Motif "one hundred thousand thanks". Even though all the tables were taken, the hostess politely asked us to wait while a table was clearing and we were seated quickly. It was a real family friendly atmosphere with lots of kids in the dining room. All the food I saw was fairly generous and seems to be a good value. My wife ordered a Pepper Steak and though it was described as 14 ounces, it seemed bigger and she had enough to eat in and take some home. She also had the onion soup which had plenty of onions and a nice amount of melted cheese. I ordered the Corned Beef Sandwich with french fries and coleslaw. I wasn't thrilled with the coleslaw because I'm used to something more spicy, so I might suggest substituting some other veggie. The staff was nice, and efficient, and I counted no less than 6 large screen TVs, I guess mainly of use when this place functions as a sports bar. Sorry , didn't try the Guinness, but the waiter kept my water glass full. read more

My wife and I held our daughter's birthday party in the party room. The room was renovated, it looks great. The food/drinks was perfect for the party which was during brunch hours. And the service was impeccable, very happy with the outcome! read more

Lilly's never fails to Please!!!! Be it a casual dinner for two, a large dinner party or a catered affair, Lily's staff will be sure you are well taken care of from start to finish! This past year alone, I have had the pleasure of hosting TWO bridal showers here & everyone raved about the food, lovely atmosphere & attentive staff. It was so nice I booked it twice! If you are looking for a really wonderful place for your next event Lily Flanagan's should be on your list!!! As for dinner, on a recent Saturday evening, my husband & I had dinner. We both had the Limerick steak & it was cooked to perfection. It came with either soup or salad, we both ordered the garden salad, delish!! I also ordered the French onion soup, it was so yummy!! Our meal also came with potato & vegetable - I had mashed & they were real potatoes, mashed & DH had baked also excellent. That night there was entertainer who sang Irish tunes & encouraged us all to sing along & everyone did. BTW....15 of us will be going here for dinner the night before my daughter's wedding - the food will be great & Lily's will ensure us a great way to kick off our family's festivities!!! If you are looking for good food & a good time give Lily Flanagan's a try Prices are very reasonable read more

One good pint 'o Guinness. Good food and kids eat free on Sunday nights. Fish and chips and the shepards pie are quite good.

Went last night to the psychic dinner event and it was extremely disappointing. The food was just ok but the psychics were terrible. For $60 u would expect decent food and an okay reading but this woman kept asking me questions to find out information she should be telling me. Scammers rip offs. Don't ever go to one of their psychic nights. Everyone at my table and others I talked to said same thing. read more

I come here on Saturdays for the bar but decided to see how the food was on a weekday worst idea, it's not bad food or service it's that I found a roach crawling around while I'm eating my dinner it's disgusting and I had to leave hopefully someone will see this and call an exterminator for them read more

Most "Cheers-like" bar in Babylon. Not a hipster joint like The Villager. Not uptight like Argyle. Not pretentious like Monsoon. It is just a solid place to grab a beer, meet friends, and get some good food. Consistently good service, menu, and beer selection. Bartenders are especially friendly and get to know their customers. read more

Good food/good club decent drinks nice staff but they have no qualms about making you feel like it's getting time to club lets go. My family was eating dinner there and they started moving the furniture around us. I know you have to but we were already paying and just about to get up it seemed a little rude. But as s club it's pretty awesome read more

Service by Lauren J was excellent. Food was fantastic! Bangers and Mash. Avondale Avocado Chicken Club. No complaints at all. Very enjoyable and will be back! read more

What a great choice! The food was fabulous, but the service was even better! Our server Cassidy was so responsive and had a wonderful personality! We met her for the first time, and she is the reason we will be back! read more

Really good bar and atmosphere. The food is so-so but I generally don't go there for that. I do like the appetizers though. A bunch of TV's for sports and good service. read more

Decent apps. Loved the Thai calamari. Entrees are extreme mediocre even for a pub.

Lilly's has great beer and food. The bartenders do a great job and there is almost always a soccer game on. Monday night burger night is great, the Shepherd's Pie is great. Can't go wrong here. read more

Great atmosphere for family dining as well as hanging out with your friends! Happy hour & dinner specials everyday, as well as live music & DJ over the weekends! Steak tippery tidbits is my favorite & the bartenders drinks are always great! Favorite place to hang out with friends, grab a bite & a drink, & catch up! Definitely recommend! read more

Loved this place when my friends and I came in December for my friends 21st Birthday. The drinks were amazing and never too strong. We did not sample the food though. We are going back to celebrate my 22nd on Friday but this time we're havig dinner first. You can come to this place and never be disappointed because all the employees are so friendly and helpful. read more

I have been to Lily Flanagan's Pub twice and was not very satisfied with my stay. It is a cool atmosphere but it is an odd crowd. There are people my age (22) and people in their 40s and 50s. The music is not so good, depends on the dj I guess. I wish there were more drink specials as well. I think with better drink specials and better music would make it more lively. read more

As an Irish-American Long Islander there are few places you'd expect to be a dependable source of Irish music, culture, and festivities on St. Patrick's Day. Lily Flanagans Irish Pub should fall into that category but sadly it could not be further off the mark. To walk in to the pulsing bass beats of 90s rap and devour corned beef to the backdrop of the Fresh Prince theme song is a disgrace. Still they get 2 stars because the food is spot on. Next time I come for the great food I will consider myself forewarned about the unforgivably disappointing atmosphere. (Sad bagpipe music playing in my head) read more

Bartenders are inconsistent bouncers are inconsistent good music but for the most part your paying to dance with teenagers $5 cover charge gotta hand it to the DJ bc he's the only reason I'm sure people come in here didn't really try the food but all other services are horrible coat check girl even went on & said well just ask another bounced about reentry she was cool but that's really about it honestly they are lucky they have a good DJ & coat check girl read more

Went last night for dinner food is decent nothing to rave about ,stay away from the blarney roll if you know whats good for you .The Staff was very friendly and service was great our waitress could not have been nicer thats why I gave them four stars .Great Salads and burgers ! read more

This was the first time coming here that my husband and I was discriminated on multiple times based upon our clothes( skinny jeans ) and race by the workers after 10 PM even though we were there since 7pm celebrating a 40th birthday party. Once my husband questioned the bouncer on what was wrong with his outfit he clearly stated that his pants were too big and that he had to pick them up . Now when you have a skinny person with skinny jeans fitted to the Waist, how much more do you want them to pick them up? And for that , which was questioning the bouncer, he got kicked out which escalated further in the parking lot. I believe your staff should be reevaluated on how they talk to people before judging.( follow up; we were told the reason why my husband was man handled by bouncers because ' they've seen his type before so that's why they were watching him for any reason to escort him out .' That's the answer I got from supposedly the owner who came out , Its company policy .) smh read more

Great food! Fun atmosphere! Manager Joe Kennedy was friendly and helpful! Looking forward to going back again soon!

Always have a great meal at Lily's. The service is great and Its a great place with a warm feel. From the appetizers like the calamari to the main dishes you cant go wrong. Delicious mashed potatoes! Music in the back room on Friday night is nice and not loud in the dining area. On Saturday the Irish singer is a nice touch. read more

Had lunch today with large family group at Lily Flanagan's. Everyone enjoyed their meal. Our waitress Marissa provided excellent and friendly service read more

I'm not sure what happened to Lily's, but the bar has gone extremely south. I used to frequent here when I was younger , there was always a big crowd, the food was excellent, the service was amazing, I went here tonight to get a beer with my friends and this was by far the worst. I ordered a Stella and it was piss warm, when I asked the bar tender why , he said cause the humidity was effecting the temperature of all their beer, so I asked him if all his beer was warm and he said yes most likely. I ended up getting another beer and it was an ok temperature. For my food choice I got a blarney roll which is a filo dough rolled with corned beef and sauerkraut...this was mushy, but the potato salad that came with it was great. I also ordered some wings which were a little overlooked. My friend ordered chicken fingers and as a joke he hit me in the head with one of them to demonstrate how extremely hard they were, he didn't finish them. My other friend ordered buffalo chicken dip and I decided to give it a try and it was literally like eating a chicken flavored paste. It's tough to see an establishment I went to as a kid go so far downhill. I hope this review can give them a little insight on some much needed improvements. read more

Great atmosphere, great food and specials! Happy hour on fridays is always a blast, live music, great drink specials and a complimentary buffet! Very friendly and welcoming staff!! read more

Delicious food and Nick the bartender was so welcoming and friendly! He will be our post-run stop on Monday nights from here on in.

Came in for the Jets game yesterday.. even though the Jets lost, the day was still a win because the wings were really good and the bartender, Darby, was amazing! Best cosmo ive ever had. Will be definitely be back with friends! read more