Had to introduce an old friend to Jack Dolans ( who loves Irish and English Pubs) and once again I was not disappointed and Dolans made another convert of my friend. Without repeating my last review both the food and service were outstanding. Once again our server Christine did an amazing job ( serving both the bar and dining areas) while maintaining a welcoming demeanor throughout. Even got to meet the cook who once again visited the tables asking how were the dishes. Corned beef sandwiches and French onion soup were delicious and well portioned as usual. Fantastic local Irish Pub offering outstanding customer service along with delicious food dishes at reasonable prices. A local gem not to be passed by when in the mood for a Guinness, some appetizers or a burger or sandwich. read more

Jack Dolans Irish Pub - A nicely poured Guinness! - Irish Pub Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Truly authentic Irish Pub on Long Island, you come here to get drunk and fat... you'll feel like you're in Dublin. Food is outstanding Traditional Sunday Roast... choice of 1/2 roasted chicken, or beef brisket, or fresh roasted turkey or fresh Irish Ham. Served with all the trimmings Baked stuffed Clams are a must, amazing sandwiches, burgers and homemade French fries second to none. All dessert's are homemade and Guinness Brownie served with soft serve ice cream. Service is outstanding as well, shout out to Kolleen our waitress absolutely fantastic. Clean and decorated still for Christmas, magical night watching snow falling out the windows and the Christmas lights on and tree lit. Highly recommend this outstanding Irish Pub and restaurant where you can find Guinness and Harp on tap to fill your pints. read more

See all

My first time at Dolans..went on Friday night ..there were 6 of us. Service and food were good. I found it too noisey...hard to hear people talking at table..would probably go again for lunch... read more

Sat at bat greeted and asked our name! Service was great did not have to ask for anything. Bartender Bess all smiles. Can tell it is a very local place The food was great had roast beef/ brisket sandwich. Bread was delicious. The meat was well seasoned and plentiful The FfF were homemade and great not to greasy. Small order of Cole slaw but not a deal breaker. Will go back for a try at different menu item read more

This place feels like home. Great beers, friendly staff, cozy, warm and inviting. Great food too! read more

On one side, a neighborhood Irish bar and on the other, a small restaurant. The restaurant is cozy and clean with a fireplace and a big screen tv that has a rotation of beautiful Irish landscapes. The food is very good and the staff are friendly. We frequent this place every couple of months. read more

I love corned beef and we usually do Ben's in Lake Grove. Dolans seemed to be worth a try. Off we went. I had the corned beef, my husband the chicken pot pie. My sandwich was awful. The bread was stale, the corned beef cut in tiny little pieces, the French Fries limp. The chicken pot pie was no better. Drowning in "juice." Service was fine and they seem nice. We shall not be going back. What happened? read more

Went in for a quick bite and beer before a movie. We decided to just have drinks for happy hour, sausage rolls, and pork sliders. Food came out super quick and all delicious! The whole menu sounded amazing and the small bites we had definitely made us want to stay for longer if we did not have somewhere to go. read more

See all

Had a good Irish brunch around St Pattys day. Food was good but do wish the corned beef hash was crispier as menu describes. Overall worth it. Irish Breakfast was great. The blood sausage is totally worth trying and they only give you a small amount so if you don't like it there is plenty else on the plate. Eggs were perfectly cooked. Only dinging the one star for the corned beef hash not being crispy as described on menu and this loud obnoxious guy at table next to us we had to endure during the meal read more

Good food, excellent friendly service, comfortable environment. A nice place to have a meal with friends or family. Unpretentious, and welcoming. read more

The "other" Irish bar I went to in Smithtown wasn't great, Jack Dolans on the other hand was warm & inviting. I wouldn't say it looks like a classic old school Irish bar but it does have a warm, friendly ambiance. The bartender was very attentive and friendly & I love that they have Smithwicks on tap. The chips were warm and delicious and I'm looking forward to trying other items on their menu in the future. read more

Jack Dolans Irish Pub - Awesome warm kettle chips - Irish Pub Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Stopped by for a drink with a friend. Attentive service and pleasant atmosphere. The live Irish music playing in the background was relaxing. read more

Jack Dolan's was a very pleasant surprise. Located in a tiny strip mall on Maple Ave in Smithtown I assumed it was an "Old Man Bar". The place is bright and well appointed. The food was plentiful and quite delicious! We were five adults and an infant and the whole evening was great. I'd recommend stopping in for a meal and a pint! read more

Was in town this past weekend for a wedding and decided to stop in had a great time. Staff were very friendly and the food came out perfect, me and my wife ordered the Sheppard's Pie and the Ruben definitely try the different bourbons and vodkas. The atmosphere was perfect. Our bartender was Lianna was perfect. If we're ever in that area again we will be sure to stop by again. read more

Jack Dolans Irish Pub - Apple Cinnamon infused bourbon - Irish Pub Near Me - Smithtown, New York

First time there for me. Super clean, warm, and inviting. We ate at the bar. The bartender was a young lady. Friendly attentive and fun. She catered to our every need. We never had to ask for anything. The food was perfection. I had the roast turkey club with fries and tried the potato soup, and my buddy had the club and baked clams. Those clams are amazing, possibly the best I've had. Overall, I'm super glad we tried this place. Left full, content with a smile on my face. Well done, guys.. read more

See all

Great Food!! Friendly Staff! Beautifully decorated! Food is delicious! We have been here several times, The Dublin Lawyer Shrimp dish, Corned Beef, Chicken Pot Pie all yummy. Baked Clams are Out of this World!!! Beers are always a perfect pour & ice cold! We will be back read more

See all

A great cute little pub. that serves huge food portions for a great price served by great people. Will definitely go again. read more

Jack Dolans Irish Pub - traditional Irish music every third Tuesday - Irish Pub Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Seated quickly. Good service. We had the brisket sandwich and the Rueben. Very good. We'll be back.

I went to this place twice, place is very nice, ordered vegetarian burger twice. one time sweet potato burger, its a sliced half cooked sweet potatoes in between bun, second time ordered vegetable burger its a diced carrot bonded with melted cheese. very small portions they change 18$ for vegie burger read more

Love Jack Dolan's The food is amazing. I recently had the Irish Dip which was so delicious and bountiful. My husband had one of the specials, the seafood pot pie. He raved about it. We have been here many times and the food is always amazing. The service is awesome, servers are friendly and on top of their game. Cute cozy Bar and restaurant with a fireplace and super large TV giving customers a slideshow of all of Ireland. The bar area displays sports games. Definitely recommend read more

We took the kids for dinner everything was excellent. It's a real Irish pub. With the flat screen showing shots of Ireland you feel like you are there. Very cozy. Great food and drinks. One side is the restaurant and the other is the bar. Food and service was amazing . Corned beef dinner was huge and very good . We will go back. Great place for families or drinks with friends and family . read more

Had to go back & try the Fish & Chips but I first tried the tomato soup with the recommendation of Lianna which both were delicious & hit the spot. Lianna was so nice & attentive. She worked the dining room like a well oiled machine. Not sure if the gentleman who stopped by each table & asked how everything was, maybe the owner or chef but whomever he was, he was so hospitable. Thank you for an enjoyable dinner. read more

Good French fries but a curt waitress. I had a BLT with Irish bacon that had no taste and looked uncooked. The other person was served a Sand-which with stale bread. 39.00 read more

Jack Dolans Irish Pub - Blt - Irish Pub Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Great food and great service. 2nd time here and they don't disappoint. The Ruben and brisket sandwiches are awesome. Redemption bourbon from the keg is highly recommended. read more

10/10 for food, service, and atmosphere! It's nice to find an Irish pub that actually serves Irish food.

What a great surprise. Delicious food, wonderful service. Try the mussels, the wings and the special holiday cheer martini. All - delicious. My husband had the braised brisket - I got a taste of it and it was gone off his plate. That is how good it was! Can't wait to go back. Thanks to our friends for taking us there. read more

Best Bloody Mary by bartender Kelley! Excellent Irish Full Breakfast! Such a generous amount of food. read more

Most of the food was good except someone in my party didn't like their fish and chips. Now fish and chips aren't hard to make and maybe it was busy and the cook cut some corners or the beer batter wasn't made right but the owner came over and had such an attitude and talked down to the person in my party. Completely out of line. I've been there before with a large party and a few other times but this guy's attitude has me done with this place. It's such a shame to be able to turn that place into such a good pub but not know how to deal with the people that come there. read more

Fish and chips were mediocre. Rubbery / bread like and definitely not a traditional crispy beer batter. Hoped for better. Service was good. read more

My wife and I had a great experience at Jack Dolan's Pub! I'm confident we found our new go-to gem. It was our first visit here and we only visited the "grub" side, not the "pub" side. The ambiance is very comfortable with brick, dark wood furniture, and rustic light fixtures all feeling very authentic. The service was not like a "waitstaff" taking an order, it was much more welcoming and personal. We even met the owner's family. They are lovely people and we really enjoyed learning a bit about the business. Now, the food. Outstanding describes the quality and also that it really stands out from other examples of pub fare. First, the pint of Guinness was properly drawn, in my opinion. I had the Shepherd's Pie (beef). The gravy was exceptional and the ground beef was clearly high quality. My wife had a chicken sandwich and the seasoning was delicious. We shared the brownie for dessert and it was awesome. Strong cocoa taste, fresh ice cream and homemade whip cream. Great presentation, too. I think what impressed me most was that I got a very authentic atmosphere and a take on the recipes that really elevated the meal. I can't wait to try the fish and chips. Full marks! read more

We have been in search of a great Irish pub since we moved out here a couple years ago. We came here for my daughter's birthday last night - it was a party of 11. The food was delicious and the drinks were great! My husband's pint of Guinness was poured just right. The wings were some of the best I've had out- crispy with sauce but not too saucy and the baked clams were amazing and had a lot of chopped clams along with the breading- very yummy! The shepherds pie was a great portion and made just right- everyone who ordered really enjoyed it. The burgers were big and juicy and cooked just the way everyone ordered them. Bangers and mash was delicious and the fish and chips were the best I've had in NY. The cod was flaky and fresh and not dense or dry! The waitress was wonderful! I'd highly recommend this place. We've finally found or go to pub restaurant! read more

The food here is amazing! You have to try the chicken pot pie with the flaky puff pastry. So filling and so good. The baked clams have a great texture and bite to them especially with the bacon. Even the grilled cheese was amazing and I don't usually order a grilled cheese when eating out. Definitely need to try this place! read more

Jack Dolans Irish Pub - Parmesan grilled cheese and tomato soup - Irish Pub Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Wow! Food is AMAZING. All of it on the menu from appetizer to entrees to dessert. We are a party of 14 and the server took our orders without writing anything down. IMPRESSIVE. We did feel slightly rushed, as everything came out so quickly. read more

I love what they've done to the place-to make it more than just a bar. The dining room is very cute and Irish themed. I've eaten here twice and the menu is hit and miss. The Irish BLT sounds like a good idea but the bacon is fatty and uncooked. The fries and cocktails are good though. The next time, I got the potato & leek soup, which was ok but could have used more flavor. The wings were very good but my daughter did not like her chicken & avocado sandwich. They have a nice dessert menu. Overall, a decent place but has to work out the kinks. A little pricey too. read more

I visited this Pub for first time today with a previous visitor. If you enjoy onion soup as I do you'll love their Irish Onion soup. The cheese on top of this texcellently prepared Soup is super tasty. it's a full meal in itself. read more

Loved the shepherds pie and chicken pot pie! My wife loves the marinated skirt steak! Great food !

Food was greasy fried crap! I know not to expect much from pub food, but this was horrible! Terrible drinks, and the owner was as personable as a rock! Always drinks stumbling out, not good for neighborhood! Old Street is a much better choice read more

True feeling of an Irish Pub. Friendly atmosphere and great food. An ideal place for a family gathering.

So let me tell you about "Jack Dolan's Pub". This is a Pub that accepts credit cards as payment, and shares it's parking lot with neighboring businesses. As you enter, you'll notice that The Bar Area is located on the left hand side of the wall in a ]-shape. They have about 8 beers on tap, with plenty of bottled beer, canned beer, hard liquors, and wine in-stock, with Homemade Vodka Infused Liquor. They have a limited selection of food to pick from, such as Chophouse Angus Cheeseburger, Spicy Jamaican Beef Patty, Corn Dog, Chicken Pot Pie, Chicken Melt, and Chicken Noodle Soup. They offer an ATM, Fireplace, Free WiFi, Multiple Big Screen TV's, Touch-Tunes, and they play QuickDraw here. There's separate restrooms for men and women, and smoking is done out front. This place has a cozy atmosphere about it, and is worth checking out. read more

Went to dinner there for my sisters birthday and couldn't be happier! Both the food and service were excellent. I couldn't recommend this place more. read more