My family had the repast after my mother's funeral here. Norma, the catering manager, helped me with the options and menu selection for it. Once we arrived, she couldn't be more helpful and caring. Her assistant Alyssa went above and beyond to make an emotional day better. The food was delicious and everyone was commenting about it. The service was outstanding and the price cannot be beat. Our family wasn't rushed and everyone felt so comfortable. Norma and Alyssa felt like part of our family. I highly recommend Napper Tandy's for any private event you may have. I cannot wait to go back and enjoy an even better celebration. read more

Nice bar and grill that features multiple party rooms, perfect for multiple types of events. Have been here for a 1st and 4th birthday party, and both were great. They allow soft play set ups inside, which is perfect for the kids. Food wise everything was rather good. The irish chicken and caesar salad were my favorite. Service was decent. read more

The food is ok, I ordered Buffalo wings, not special, not that spicy. The atmosphere is like a college style Irish bar, not a authentic NYC style bar. Just a large open venue with a straight bar front to back. I think seeing palm tree plants inside the front window confused the feeling of an Irish bar. The service was good, 1 bartender & it was a slow Tuesday afternoon with what seemed to be a regular bar crowd, maybe 6 other patrons. It kind of had a cold feel & I wasn't overly impressed, I just gave it 3 stars because there was nothing necessarily bad about my experience but it wasn't great. read more

Napper Tandy's Irish Pub - Bar - Irish Pub Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Went here for a 50th birthday party. Think staff was a tad behind getting things going but one lady in particular was on top of everything, very efficient person. The birthday boy and guests had a great time. Food was good, stuffed shells were the best we've ever had! read more

See all

Hosted my graduation party here last weekend. Great service and great food! Everyone enjoyed the party

Great spot for a party. I had my child's first birthday party here and also attended a friend's child's first birthday here. I also had a small birthday party for my husband here a few years ago at the bar area. They do a really great job with everything from set up, to food etc. They give a lot of choices to choose from food wise and honestly I have been impressed with the food for being an Irish pub. I personally wouldn't come here just to eat, only if it was an event. Just due to atmosphere being loud/bar scene etc. However, awesome option for a nice and affordable party venue! Norma was very nice to work both times and the party staff was attentive. read more

Went here tonight with my husband and sister. We sat at a table for over 20 minutes and no one ever came over to serve us at all. The place wasn't packed, the bartenders looked over at us multiple times and then went right back to drinking and looking at their phones. We got up and left and are now heading to Applebees where hopefully we can get some food, drinks and service. read more

Walked in and waitress and barmaid was no where in sight. Waited at least 5 minutes before someone came around. We ordered drinks at the bar then sat at a table. We were a party of 5. After looking at a menu we managed to flag down the waitress to order some appetizers. Service was so slow and nachos were cold when we got it but pretzel was very hot. Again, had to flag down waitress to order our meal. Service was awful! read more

Our Winter Onederland first birthday at Napper Tandy's was a success. We weren't sure how it was going to go but I have to admit that they did a really amazing job. The staff was beyond attentive, eveyone was commenting how great their were. And the food was very good, everyone liked it and commented that it was great so that was a bonus. Between their decorations and ours the place looked terrific. If you are looking for a place to host and event go see them. We could not be happier with the job they did. Special thanks to Norma, Bill and Alyssa ! They really kept the drinks flowing, I know whenever my wife or I put down and glass, they were handing me a new one. read more

See all

The Napper Tandy's, BayShore offers great service to meet your catering needs. I recently was a guest attending a bridal shower and more recently a baby shower. With both occasions, we were seated upstairs which easily accommodates 50-60 people. There is natural lighting from the side closet to Main Street. The tables were beautifully set and appropriately spaced. TV monitors were made available to add a family vibe which we all enjoyed. There is a long bar area for drinks at one end and coffee at the other end. The food was served buffet style to the opposite end of the room. Everything was delicious, especially the chicken and pasta dishes! Service was well above par and friendly! read more

My ladies golf league had a luncheon at this Smithtown Napper Tandy's today. The food was amazing, the service was topnotch and the room was lovely. Norma could not have been nicer. She catered to everyone's needs Vegetarian, gluten free or whatever they needed Thank you so much Norma WE WILL RETURN!!!! read more

Was truly disappointed in my experience at this establishment last night. It seemed like there was one waitress who served as the bartender/waitress/hostess. Although she did apologize for the slow service as there was a party going on next door, but to wait what seemed like 45 minutes before we ordered our food (after flagging down the waitress) then another half an hour for our food to come, was just a disappointment. And everyone agreed that their food was just "meh!". Don't think I'll be coming here again which is too bad since they're local! read more

Tried to book a party there. The coordinator Norma spoke with me, told me my date was available, went over the menu, and had her bartender show me the room. When I tried to pay my deposit she dodged all my calls and texts . After days of ignoring me, she calls me back to tell me she gave away my party room. Very unprofessional. Days prior, my parents had eaten at the restaurant since we were excited to be having our party there . When they got there, no one was there to seat them. They waited and finally went up to the bartender to ask to be seated. The bartender was acting as the hostess, bartender, and waitress for the entire restaurant. Service was therefore very slow since they had one person working the place. read more

Went there for a baptism party, great food, great service, plenty of room, great atmosphere.

The bartender was literally taking shots and didn't look my way for over 30 minutes . Really annoying. And then he served me a drink without any lemon or lime. When I made a face he said, "are you really upset about not getting a lemon !" Um yes read more

Best service around! The bartender was great and super attentive. Only negative experience was an annoying woman yelling at the bartender. It really ruined the ambiance. He definitely didn't deserve her harassment. I think she took my lime...Definitely recommend this place! read more

Very good nachos, so-so on the chicken avocado blt - the chicken wasn't great and the avocado was black.

Most of the time this place is really good. The food is excellent and the drinks are good. My issue is that it gets super crowded and it sometimes takes a while to get your drink. But hey, it's a bar! read more

Food was fine, bartenders pad the bill computer clearly stated $14 for two beers she looked me dead In the face and charged $15 oldest trick In the book, sound system is top notch yet the sound man SUCKS!' Cuts intermission songs b4 they end can't hear singer, leads turned down mix just bad when you inquire he seems as if he took to many pills, oh never shut off jukebox 3 songs totally unprofessional operation read more

I've been coming to this town staple for many years to enjoy a night of dancing, a night of sports or to simply grab a bite to eat. Never am I disappointed. Most recently I held a surprise party for my husband here on a busy Saturday night. Norma and Alyssa were SO accommodating every step of the way. Absolutely loved working with them to pull it off. Would give 10 stars if I could. This is the place to go to make so many great memories. read more

I had lunch in this location 2 people 50 bucks 1 drink. Then have the nerve to charge extra for using credit card, they have raised their pricing because of covid and inflation , understandable , BUT BALSY CHARGING EXTRA USING CREDIT CARD , NEVER GO THERE AGAIN, PLENTY OF GOID PLACES IN SMITHTOWN read more

So let me tell you about "Napper Tandy's of Smithtown". This is a full bar with a kitchen, that accepts credit cards as payment, and shares it's parking lot with neighboring businesses. As you enter, you'll notice that the place has two separate sections. One can be used for hosting events and catering. The other is for the public to use abs watch live sports games. They have about 8 beers on tap if not more, with plenty of bottled beer, canned beer, hard liquors, and wine in-stock. They have a large selection of food to pick from and drink specials. They offerFree WiFi, Multiple Big Screen TV's, and occasionally, they'll have Live Music playing here. There's separate restrooms for men and women, and smoking is done out front, that includes tables and chairs. This place has a cozy atmosphere about it, and is worth checking out. read more

I love the bartender James he is the best! most down to earth welcoming man! Sunday Funday & James!!!!

When I first approached this bar, I was a bit lost. Unfamiliar place, 3000 miles away from home, and there seemed to be a private BBQ event at the front patio of the bar (which I would later find out was for-purchase and everyone welcome). Maybe that's what I get for wandering into a bar in unfamiliar territory, but it really shouldn't be this way, local's bar or not. -=-Venue-=- In this part of Long Island, good old bar and grills are hard to come by which is what first attracted me here. I seated myself at one of the corners of the bar and found myself in some prime real estate since I was in the area closest to the patio. There was plenty of seating elsewhere, but the bar was the spot to be. Service at the bar was a bit of a disappointment. I would not be noticed or acknowledged by the bartender for quite some time. The age group of this bar was mixed from older flojoes to young yuppies but being right in the middle of those groups ended up with myself not so popular with the waitstaff here. When ordering my food, i would not even be sure if my order was heard since i would be ordering and the waitress would suddenly be walking away as i was talking. For the longest time, i wasn't sure if i would get my entire order. My fish and chips came out cold and par in quality, but the French onion soup was cheesy and made the experience a bit better. I would hear conversation of some of the bartenders working in areas where they were not supposed to. Customers being ignored as a result of this is unacceptable. Food is average, and service is below average. So about 2.5 stars. read more

See all

The food is not the greatest or at least even half decent. The chicken was still pink and the lettuce was completely soggy and wilted. All of this was extremely overpriced for the poor quality of food and the long time to make the food. I would not recommend this place at all. read more

Turn the volume down, your losing the Saturday night dinner crowd. Just came back from this pub on a Saturday night. Waitress was totally overwhelmed, going back and forth to her friends she told to come. Pretzel and soup took 25 minutes. Beer took 15 minutes. Just so you know there are about 8 tables in the whole place. Bright side, French onion soup was great, Bavarian pretzel, great. Wanted to order entrees but if I did I wouldn't be home writing this review right now on my couch in my silk boxers. I would still be at nappertandys waiting for food. Time is money, money is time. Blonde waitress very good. Young girl, not good. Time of visit, 8pm Saturday 12/20. Narrow it down owner, narrow it down. I'm not happy. read more

It's a pub...It's a bar. And they are super friendly when your friend is incredibly drunk and decides to dance on the bar top and then well...you know how nights like that end up. They gave us heaps of water and stayed open longer so that we could sort ourselves out (oh yeah, there was some pantslessness going on too for the Birthday boy). All in all, a pretty great time. Actually, I'm happy to give 5 stars...I've also eaten there recently and while nothing with the food was stellar (typical pub grub), the combination was worth it! read more

Napper Tandy's Irish Pub - Chicken salad!!!! - Irish Pub Near Me - Smithtown, New York

My Saturday experience here was fabulous. There is one bartender that brightens up the room with her positive attitude and kindness. You can always find her with a smile on her face. The entire staff really put an A+ effort into serving me and my colleagues. If you go here make sure you ask for Sophie! You will not be disappointed. read more

Terrible experience. Went there with my boyfriend and his friend to have a couple of drinks and dance our night away . No matter where we stood by the bar we were ignored several times . Unbelievably rude woman (bartender) with short light brown hair in a ponytail was emotionless when my boyfriend and i tried to ask for a drink and when i asked for a manager i was looked at like i had 3 heads . We ended up leaving and going to the Nutty Irishman in Farmingdale definitely more of a reputable bar than what this bar came out to me . Do not go here if you want to waste your time and be disrespected !!! read more

100% beyond impressed with Napper Tandy's! We celebrated our daughters 1st birthday there today and it was amazing. The service and food were incredible, from start to finish. Every guest was blown away by the food and the beautiful party room. It was everything we wanted and the staff was so attentive. I would highly recommend to anyone looking for a party venue-affordable, beautiful, great service, delicious food, fun and relaxed atmosphere. read more

Napper Tandy's Irish Pub - Irish Pub Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Nice atmosphere. Took a while for someone to come over and assist us. Ordered the burger, because I figured it'd be safe. Asked for medium rare. Came back medium well. Overcooked the bun (didn't want the bun toasted). Overcooked the fries. Mentioned to the waitress and she just gave a look. Guess they feel like it's bar food, so I shouldn't expect much? Well, then charge less for it and I won't. Most likely will not return. read more

James is an A+ bartender. I'd recommend this establishment solely based on his friendliness and upbeat attitude/customer service. Do you wanna have a good time? Go check out Nappers when James is working. read more

Good food, service was ok. The bad thing is that I was charged the full price of the meal when I specifically told the waitress that we were splitting the bill. So my advice be careful going to this place and check your checking account after eating here. Had to go through my bank account to hopefully get this resolved. Called and left contact info for a manager, and never got a response back. read more

First time here for a fundraiser for a good friend/coworker and had a great time, I understand they did a recent renovation and the room that we had was awesome! Flat screens everywhere huge bar, great lighting and stage upfront , some people commented on the service but luckily our bartender was awesome and so was the food actually! I would come back here if I was ever in the area! read more

Napper Tandy's Irish Pub - Pretty good portion of wings! good crunch good meat, didn't really care for the blue cheese though. - Irish Pub Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

I was excited to try this place but it fell short. First, the live music was terrible and incredibly loud. We had to scream over the music to have dinner conversation and we were not seated close to the entertainment. The nachos came and the meat on top was mushy and unseasoned. I ordered the goat cheese salad with grilled shrimp. The shrimp tasted like burnt seafood and I believe they mixed blue cheese with the goat cheese, which totally ruined the taste of the goat cheese. My husband ordered a steak sandwich which he enjoyed (I did not taste it) The service was slow, but friendly. The thing that got me the most was the ants. At the end of the meal when they cleared our plates, a group of ants had covered our napkins. On closer inspection (with our phone lights) we saw them crawling all around the ketchup bottle. We paid as quickly as we could. I would never go back. read more

Decent place. Make sure you sit at the bar or you will not receive any attention. Server took over half an hour to acknowledge us sitting at her table. Showed up rarely and never gave us utensils for the food we ordered. Water was scarce when we ordered it and the demeanor of the staff was sub par. Over wheelmen and confused. Asked us if we wanted change on a large bill. No where near a 15 percent tip but still received it for ignoring us. One bartender actually decided to show us a good time and was compensated according to his attentiveness. Expensive for no reason and horrible service. AVOID!!! read more

Recently watched football here and caught up with a few friends. Good specials on a Monday for the game no complaints. Solid wings and nachos , I don't know you could fuck up nachos anyway but Nappertandys did not disappoint . We will be returning for the playoffs hopefully . read more

Nice place, but the overwhelming smell of bleach forced us to leave. The bartender was nice, the paper menu was another turn off. Finally as we were getting ready to leave we noticed a broken tv in front of us, and miraculously there was a aged lemon peaking out from behind it. Might give them another shot but not for lunch! read more

Napper Tandy's Irish Pub - Irish Pub Near Me - Smithtown, New York

horrible. dont go here for wings or any food. they think their name gives them clout. wrong. their kitchen staff should be ashamed of themselves. have some self respect and put some effort into your cooking and food. Ill eat dirt before this food again. read more

Went there after work on Sunday night and James the bartender was awesome! We didn't know what to get for food and he recommended the quesadillas, the Mac and cheese and the pretzel which were all great! Definitely will be back read more