We had a small family birthday party and were disappointed. The food was delicious not an issue. The service was horrendous. We were promised the room at 4:15 and they didn't clear out the previous party till 4:30 and were still setting up the bar at 5:10 when our guest of honor was expected arrive. Bar service was sporadic and getting anything from the servers was impossible. They cut the cake small handed out pieces then failed to make the cake available for anyone to eat more and top it off the bartender was eating cake a huge piece at the bar. Ok so we had cake however COFFEE goes with cake it shouldn't have taken them 30 minutes after serving cake to get our guest coffee. Then to top it off the cookie platters that were included were sad. 1 red velvet cookie surrounded by 6 chocolate chip cookies 1 plate per table. I'm surprised because I've been here before and never had such a unfulfilling experience. They left us having to get up and continuously ask for refills and missing items. I'm disappointed and don't recommend them for a party. As an addition to the story after they read my review they called and apologized and fully addressed the situation to our satisfaction. read more

Not the best steak this time around but still a good experience. We needed to push the reservation one hour on a Saturday and they were very accommodating. Quickly seated, too. Our fried calamari was great and love the house salad. Just be sure to ask for your favorite dressing as they bring out a standard creamy one that I don't like. My steak this time around wasn't the best. It was definitely overcooked and my tough to cut which was a bummer as it was phenomenal last time. But my husband enjoyed his dish and my daughter enjoyed her chicken parm. The ice cream that came with her meal was fine. The chocolate cake was nothing to rave about. read more

See all

Not sure why people were disappointed! Early lunch warmly welcomed Clean and open space Many selections Piping hot soups Crisp fresh salads Delightful meats with potatoes. Environment was full of holiday happiness/cheer!! Servers friendly Food cooked to requested temperature. Yes there were lines carrots in soup although the base/stock was delightful Desserts were mouth watering Coffee was hot and fresh w cream Costs were comparable to Joelle Shandong without the pretentious feel I left satisfied and would consider this place for a date- family dinner- holiday party or venue for a wedding. Centrally located to all major roads . Ample parking read more

Stoped in to the Irish coffee pub on a sleepy Tuesday afternoon. I was the only one at the bar & a few groups in the dining room but the bartender John was very hospitable. It's a very classy Irish restaurant & bar inside. I just had a small app & a couple beers but I'll be back for sure. read more

The Irish Coffee Pub - Clams Casino & a Smithwick's! - Irish Near Me - East Islip, New York

Excellent ambience/good food/bartenders were a bit stuffy. All n all a good experience read more

Love the food the cocktails And the staff! Always willing to work with you!!!! Had many catered events and always very happy! read more

The Irish Coffee Pub East Islip, NY @theirishcoffeepub The Irish Coffee Pub is East Islip's premier venue with the ultimate dining experience. Their elegant space is perfect for any occasion and has a warm, rustic home feeling. The restaurant offers a variety of different rooms and a great bar area, each creating their own atmosphere. Private rooms are perfect for larger groups to get some privacy! Established in 1983, you know they are doing things right over there! Here they offer both classic Irish dishes like their Dublin Style Fish & Chips, Shepard's Pie, and Corned Beef & Cabbage, as well as Black Angus steaks like their 9oz Filet Mignon, Prime Rib, and NY Sirloin. All of their entrees come with a choice of soup or salad, baked or mashed potatoes (fries or rice pilaf as well), AND a side of vegetables (absolutely love this for a steakhouse). They are also offering a 3-course Spring Chef's Choice for $65.90 - see their website for more details and selections. For dessert we finished with their amazing creme brûlée cheesecake and classic ice cream scoops. This was an amazing meal and dining experience and we highly recommend it to all of you. Come give them a try! Follow us on Instagram at @drinklongislandny for full video and many more spots! read more

See all

We had a wonderful meal here with my family this weekend, and everything was delicious and the service was fantastic. Our sever was a lovely polish lady and she couldn't have been nicer, all the food was excellent, we'll definitely return. read more

On a recommendation from a friend I had lunch today with my mom at The Irish Coffee Pub. The hostess was friendly and welcoming and sat us immediately. Our server Mila came over and welcomed us as well. We ordered some soft drinks and after a few minutes decided on our food order. We had the potato soup served with Brown bread. Caesar salad and entrees were a special of the day fluke oreganato and from The menu grilled sea scallops. Both were served with rice and vegetables. Everything was delicious. Service from Mila and ambiance were excellent. Add this to my list of I will return!! PS. We arrived at 1215. By the time we were leaving at 145 the parking lot was filled. Also a great bar area is in play as well as rooms for events. read more

HIGHLY recommend this restaurant for catering. From the Shepard's Pie to the Braised Steak Burgundy... it was DELICIOUS.

I have so many great memories of my grandparents and parents going to dinner here. The food and staff were amazing. Thank you for making St. Patrick's Day amazing! The Irish step dancers, coupled with the music, made this years the best yet read more

Attended a medical conference in a nice room of windows set up for about 50. Multiple rooms that looked as quaint as grammy's tea room. The staff handled the group with ease as this seems to be a popular venue for groups & gatherings. Large parking lot, right off the highway. The standard chicken beef fish choices were prepared nicely and looked quite professional plated. While we would not visit for a regular dinner adventure, I absolutely recommend a gathering or business event here. read more

The Irish Coffee Pub - a table set for a meeting - Irish Near Me - East Islip, New York

Went here once or twice. Over priced for food that wasn't the best. You could 100% get something better elsewhere. Beautiful spot though. That's their only plus. read more

I went to meet girlfriends for a Christmas get together this afternoon. Two were from Nassau County , I m local. Server David was great n kind. Crab cakes were dry n over cooked, soup was terrible n I saw no sign of lobster in it. My meal , braised beef was cold , dry n very little gravy , mashed potatoes were ok with only 3 carrot slices. The best part was the lemoncello cake.They made us rush as we had to be out by 2:30. Funny as no rooms looked full! I wont ever go back to this restaurant. Now I know why I have not been there in year's! There are restaurants out there than this one! Spend your time n money , find a nicer restaurant. The Shed, Karvers, café Joelle, or the view ! read more

Attended my in-laws' 25th Wedding Anniversary on Sunday at the Irish Coffee Pub in East Islip, New York. My first time there. The name was a little misleading. I was expecting at small coffee shop. Nope. I was expecting a small pub. Nope. A beautiful restaurant. A great looking bar. A variety of room sizes. We were in a room that nicely accommodated the 18 in attendance. The service was really nice. The waitress that was running the party was very nice, accommodating and professional. The young waiter helping her was very polite and professional. The food was great. I started with a potato soup - really very good. I'd like a bowl of that a few times a week. A Caesar salad was next to- it was a Caesar salad. Tasty but nothing amazing. My main course was a Prime Rib. I requested and received an end cut - very very good. I don't eat beef very often - but this was really worth it. Dessert was a really nice piece of cheesecake. A really nice meal. I forgot to take photos. Nice bathroom. Plentiful parking. Looking forward to returning one day. read more

Food was excellent, and service very good and friendly. Ambiance beautiful but was very noisy could not talk to family at my table .

This was my first time after the Irish Coffee Pub, although my families been coming for years and with reason. We came for a party in the upstairs, Bay Shore FD Annual Patrol Dinner. Huge party room with dance floor, fireplace and bar. Food was fabulous, buffet style, there were servers moving swiftly about and they were super responsive to any requests. #TommyDuck was the one man band and that's all we needed. The downstairs has a warm inviting atmosphere and what sounded like a live piano playing, can't wait to come back and check it out! read more

The Irish Coffee Pub - #TommyDuck - Irish Near Me - East Islip, New York

We just had a wedding ceremony and dinner at the restaurant. Everything from start to finish was amazing! Wonderful staff to deal with, food and service were perfect! Thank you for making a special day for the bride and groom!! read more

They never ever disappoint. From the onset, their staff are all so friendly & attentive but not overbearing. Their homemade baked bread & scones are all delicious especially the soda bread. Love their Jumbo Shrimp Guinness which comes with steamed veggies & choice of potato. This time I chose for the dipping sauces...cocktail sauce, tartar sauce & their lemon beurre blanc which were all soooo good. Had no room for dessert but they do have a wide variety to choose from along with various coffees. The restaurant itself is really nice with many different rooms within. The weekends are crowded so be sure to make a reservation. Check out the menu & specials online and give it a try, you won't be disappointed. Enjoy!!! read more

See all

Absolutely perfect dinner for four in a Wednesday night . The room is lovely and inviting. Waiter Jacob was outstanding and made sure we all had everything we needed to enjoy the meal. Perfect dirty martini, delicious corned beef and cabbage for me, and 2 guests enjoyed the salmon. My partner enjoyed a chicken dish. All the meals were brought to the table hot and placed in front of us simultaneously. Very impressed with the care the staff took to get hot meals to the table. The bread basket comes to the table first, filled with scones and brown bread like your Irish grandmother would make. We crowned the meal with a trip to the bar for Irish coffee. So wonderful to have it made right with a proper float of semi whipped cream. The bartender is gracious and very capable. Thank you all for a perfect dining experience. read more

The Irish Coffee Pub - Irish Coffee - Irish Near Me - East Islip, New York

See all

Every year they have many amazing celebrations. The one we look forward to the most is the Yuletide. It's a gathering like no other, it's not read more

It's been a while since I've been to the Irish Coffee Pub. I've been there many times for catered Holiday Events and it was always spectacular! They also have a very nice bar when you first walk in . Besides catered events they have a main dining area . This was my first time having dinner here .The room is wonderfully cozy , the mellow lighting and the lit fireplace gave it a warm comfortable feeling . Everyone is so attentive and professional . Our server Denise was very friendly and pleasant . She kept coming back to check on us if we needed anything else and to ask if we were enjoying our dinner . And yes we were , it was so good ! We took our time ordering , chatting and enjoying our evening and never once felt rushed . After ordering our drinks they came by offering some delicious dinner rolls and scones . We all ordered the special , Chilean Sea Bass scampi combo with clams and shrimp , which was delicious , served with your choice of baked or mash potatoes , vegetables and a Garden or Caesar salad . I had the mashed potatoes , they were so creamy and nicely seasoned . Everything was very well prepared and the fish was perfectly baked , tender and flaky ! The prices are a bit steep but once in a while or for a special occasion it is worth it . Next time we'll try going for lunch , the menu is a little more affordable and similar to the dinner menu . read more

See all

The Irish Coffee Pub recently hosted my parents 60th anniversary party. From start to finish the level of service and competence was unsurpassed. My mother made initial contact with Steven. At the time of her inquiry she had already unsuccessfully attempted to secure a venue for the event at several establishments. From their first conversation Steven assured her that everything would be taken care of and he went above and beyond to deliver on his promise. My parents were in Florida and were unable to deliver a deposit from that distance. Steven insisted the date was secure and there was nothing to worry about. He advised my mother to review the menu in advance so she was prepared to plan the remainder of the details. When my parents met with Steven he could not have been better. He asked all the right questions and gave my parents great guidance choosing the menu. He asked if there would be children attending, and informed her there would be a kids menu available for them at no additional charge. After the menu was completed my mother had concerns about one of her choices. Steven made the change to the menu without hesitation. He did a great job of recommending seating arrangements based on the number of guests and the layout of the room. When the day of the party arrived Patrick oversaw the event. Patrick continued Stevens excellent level of service throughout the day. Everything was absolutely perfect. Every request was met without issue and Patrick and the staff were happy to accommodate. The staff was absolutely perfect. From the servers to the bartender everyone was professional, accommodating, and genuinely contributed to making the special event a wonderful experience for my parents. It obviously goes without saying that I highly recommend the Irish Coffee Pub for any event. Their level of service absolutely can not be matched for any event that you may plan. read more

The Irish Coffee Pub - Irish Near Me - East Islip, New York

Solid place! Had a work dinner here a few weeks ago on a weekday--lots of spacious parking and was immediately seated. Service was attentive; the dining room was well lit and nice. I got the escargot as an appetizer and the shepherd's pie for my entree. Food is solid and portions are decent, but a bit on the expensive side. Overall, I had a nice time. read more

We were lucky enough to have some Irish Coffee Pub catering on Christmas Day. Our family loves the braised steak burgundy since it's so tender and flavorful (it can also be prepared gluten free), the roasted potatoes, and the grilled vegetables. Their dishes help to elevate our Christmas dinner and satisfy a variety of palates. read more

Impeccable service, excellent food and a warm, inviting atmosphere. We each had the chef special which includes an appetizer, a soup or salad and a main. We all loved our choices. Some of the selections we had were grilled romaine with Gorgonzola and bacon, tuna tartare and baked clams for appetizers; beef barley soup and house salads for the second course and halibut, rack of lamb and surf and turf for the main course. They have lovely desserts as well and, of course we indulged. Finished the night with Irish coffee. We will gladly return. read more

Would definitely recommend food was excellent. Every single thing we ordered was delicious from the soups and salads and appetizers right down to the dinners. We look forward to coming back again.. read more

See all

This is one of my favorite restaurants. If I lived closer, I would come here more frequently. As soon as you walk in, you get a comfortable and welcoming vibe. The staff goes above and beyond and you never feel rushed (even when they are busy). I wish I remembered the servers name! He was awesome and I loved his Irish brogue. The food is fresh and delicious. In my recent visit, I enjoyed the cheeseburger with caramelized onions and fries but it seems like you can't go wrong with anything you order. Every dish I have ever tried has been delicious! Yum! Can't wait to return! read more

The food is delicious! I had Shepard pie which was such a huge portion that I had to take the rest home. The wait staff is attentive and friendly. Great atmosphere and I will definitely be back. read more

Busy, busy restaurant with multiple common and private rooms. You definitely need a reservation on the weekends otherwise there may not be any room for you. Our waitress was on point and very accommodating to our large group. Credit cards have a service charge. Large parking lot. Food was prepared fresh and served hot. Prices are a little bit higher than other places. Plenty of Irish meals as well as regular food items. We heard that there potato soup is well known. Definitely a great place for lunch, dinner or brunch. read more

See all

My friend and I went here for restaurant week and were extremely disappointed. Our drinks were great but the food was terrible. The fact that everything took a long time would have been fine if the food came out great but both of our dinners were extremely dry and over cooked. The desserts were also old and dried out. We will never be going back there again! read more

Excellent food , superior staff ALWAYS. A great. I've attended a few parties here, too... and the quality and hospitality never dips. A truly warm, cozy feel and food that is enjoyable. read more

Went there for the 1st time with a group of friends for dinner. Had a great time, the service was great, the food was fantastic and the service was outstanding. I can't wait to go back! Very friendly staff! read more

Went there tonite for St Patrick's Day, big mistake, very disorganized bad service, didn't eat my entree it was terrible loin of pork, also they took our reservation 10 days ago and when we arrived our group of 4 people were put on a communal table with 6 strangers, no one there realized that they would all be sitting with people that they've never met, all in all a terrible experience will NEVER go there again read more

Okay I was totally misled by this name because it certainly did not feel like a pub. I came here the other day for a bridal shower and contemplated dressing up because I thought it was an actual pub. To my surprise, I was guided through this maze of various different banquet halls and ultimately got to the room for the shower. It was a beautiful, brightly lit dome shaped room, surrounded by a bunch of windows. The down-side, (upside for some people) was the fact that the acoustics in the room was absolutely WILD. You could hear everything that someone is saying on the opposite side of the room, crystal clear, as if they're speaking into a microphone. It was super bizarre but kinda cool too. I was able to join in everyone's conversations with my back turned so gossipers beware! On a more important note! The food! The Caesar salad was delicious and I finished most of my plate, which really says a lot because I hate eating salad. Throw enough dressing on and I'll consider it. I ordered the herb crusted salmon and it was very tasty! It had just the right amount of fat in it and the sauce that came with it was a nice tangy addition to salmon. I ate every bite of the salmon, even though I was stuffed from my appetizers. I can't speak for the price since I didn't see a menu but taste is fantastic. Decor is beautiful as well so I'd imagine this would be a great spot for any event venue. read more

The Irish Coffee Pub - Herb crusted Salmon - Irish Near Me - East Islip, New York

The food was great. I have to say it is so pretty with the beautiful Christmas lights outside. And the place is actually huge inside. The service was great. They were very nice read more

See all

Delicious food as always. Service was great and staff was very friendly. Tried the stuffed shrimp and was delicious. Deserts were good too. My favorite is the house salad with their yummy dressing read more

Gonna be forthright here. My husband and I were arguing and we were disruptive. I'm so apologetic and I want to say thank you to the staff for being so kind and professional. I really am sorry and you guys were so good. I hope I didn't ruin your night. Food is always delicious and service so good. read more

I've dined at The Irish Coffee Pub more times than I can remember. I had my wedding catered by them off site at a beach and they did an impeccable job. The only issue I had was that I missed the cocktail hour. I heard it was amazing! My stepfather had his retirement party there, it was beautiful, food amazing. My sister planned a surprise birthday party for her husband, and again, amazing. And I've done many intimate dinners there as well. Now I live out of state (sniff), planning on going "home" for Easter where the family will be eating dinner guess where? I'm so excited! :) read more

Food is always delicious. Service is excellent. The restaurant can be quite noisy but we keep coming back because we enjoy the food.