We came here for brunch and everything was great. It was so nice sitting outside on a cool day. We started with the tuna tartare which was fresh and a large portion. We also had the roasted turkey sandwich which was a nice portion and the turkey was very fresh. My dad had the burger and also really enjoyed the meal. The drinks are also great. I would definitely recommend. read more

The staff was extremely friendly and welcoming. The restaurant was clean and bright. I had the avocado toast with scrambled egg instead of fried. It was so delicious. The pickled onions were a fantastic flavor. I would absolutely return to this establishment just for the avocado toast. read more

Pluses: Attentive staff. The waitstaff is courteous and responsive, walking that fine line between being intrusive and responding when you want them to. I give the good marks in that regard. Cleanliness. It's a nice space, and clean. I used the restroom as well. Certainly looks like they take the time out to keep the place presentable which is not something all restaurants do so it should be noted when you see it. Minuses: Noise: The architecture of the space with its high ceilings is such that it's very loud. This is not the kind of place you go for a quiet meal. It wasn't that every table was occupied when I was there but the noise level was quite high. Honestly, it depends on your preference. It's not a matter of it being bad so much as warning you in advance. Prices: The food was okay. I had an omelet. It was adequate, nothing more. The thing of it was that it was a $20 dollar omelet. In that case I expect them to bring out the hen and show me its pedigree. The food was good, not great, not bad, simply good. I can't really say anything other than that. Given that it's Katonah it may be that it caters to a clientele that doesn't have a problem with that but again, it's not a bargain. Overall, I enjoyed the meal enough but I likely wouldn't go back simple based around the price point. read more

Never sat my party of 3 but sat 2 larger parties ahead of us instead for no reason. First and last time going.

Ordered an omelette and it came out as a mess of a scramble. The chef somehow managed to overcook the eggs and leave the cheese cold and unmelted. Toast was served without any jam. Coffee wasn't good. All around bummer. read more

Went to Jay Street Bistro for breakfast this morning and I had the most delicious fluffy 3 egg omelette with bacon, cheese and tomato I have ever had. Served with hash browns and toast, yum. My wife had cornbread French Toast topped with strawberries. The restaurant itself has indoor and outdoor seating m, is bright inside and is situated on the corner of Parkway and Katonah Ave., with plenty of parking. Our server was a charming young woman who was warm and friendly. Reasonably priced read more

What a delightful restaurant! My girlfriends and I came up for a day trip, and stumbled in here. Absolute gem of a space...their bar was so pretty! Loved that they serve breakfast all day. Their bloody mary hit the spot. I ended up with a grilled cheese and bacon. Generous cheese, crispy bacon, and I loved their homemade bread. This is clearly a popular spot, as it was quite busy even on a Wednesday. Excellent and friendly service, would love to dine here again! read more

This is a cute little place near the train station. On an early drive to Danbury one weekend we decided to stop here for a bit. The place is smallish so if you want a table there could be a wait on a busy weekend morning. We sat at the bar. Service was friendly, although slow and distracted like the guy had something else he needed to do. I was able to order a coffee and a breakfast sandwich. The sandwich was fine, a little extra greasy, but tasty. Coffee was okay. If you're nearby, it's a decent place for a bite. read more

See all

Still serving great food at Jay Street. Best coffee in Katonah. Friendly staff & very accommodating. On the egg sandwich, I asked to swap out the bacon for avocado , the American cheese for cheddar, leave off the hash browns, get the excellent Brioche burger bun toasted and get home fried potatoes on the side. Everything was executed perfectly! read more

Jay Street Bistro - Egg Sandwich with Avocado & Cheddar - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Katonah, New York

See all

Convenient spot while waiting for friends or family to get off the train. Good food, good location, really great outdoor seating read more

Jay Street Bistro - Cobb salad and a shrimp bowl - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Katonah, New York

I always love going to towns I haven't been to in a long time and Katonah was a place I hadn't been to since I was young. I had always heard good things about Jay Street and it was a good halfway point to meet up with a friend. We came here around noon on a Sunday and we had about a 15 minute wait after giving our name to the hostess. (They will call you when your table is ready). The dining room is pretty spacious and they also have space at a bar. We both ordered an omelette. The side potatoes and multigrain bread were a great addition. I also had ordered an iced coffee, which was very good! I would come back here! read more

Jay Street Bistro - Omelette with spinach and cheese - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Katonah, New York

A great place for yummy and healthy brunches. They offer more than the traditional brunch options, but also have items like matcha latte. My friend especially liked their beef chili. Service was superb. We were the only table that insists on sitting outside on a chilly Saturday, the waiters and waitresses helped to set up a heating fan for our table, and checked on us quite frequently. Would recommend. read more

See all

Great little cafe. Friendly staff, good breakfast. It's in a great area with plenty of parking. It's a good place to start then stroll the streets and shop in all of the fun boutiques read more

Took over an hour to get seated and then when we finally did, it took about another ten minutes for someone to greet us. Food was cold and overpriced. read more

The breakfast was so good! I ordered the "perfect plate" on the breakfast menu which was amazing. The coffee was also pretty good. The bistro interior is very cozy and clean. read more

Jay Street Bistro - Almond Butter Toast - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Katonah, New York

Stopped by for lunch and came upon this cute little spot. It was a beautiful day but all of the tables outside were full. We decided to eat inside. We were greeted and seated right away. Server was nice, ordered our lunch which was phenomenal. The salad I had was so good. Dressing was spot on! We then ordered dessert and it may have been the best tiramisu I've had. So light and tasty. I'll definitely be back. read more

See all

This is a great spot. We were here two months ago after going to the art museum Met my son and his fiancé for brunch. We ordered Prosecco and mimosas. Then pancakes and omelets. Avocado toast with eggs my favorite! The waiting staff kids are so friendly! This makes for an extra special experience! So after dropping in to the Penny-pincher Thrift store we were back for another fix! Same splendid experience! Pancakes are fluffy and delicious. Just so satisfying. Now we have to look for another reason to drive to Katonah! But maybe not!! Great job guys!!! read more

Love love this place! Just moved to Katonah and on a sweltering day (the day we closed on our house), we celebrated here over a delicious caprese sandwich with grilled chicken and a big coffee-Oreo milkshake and vanilla egg cream. Their breakfast sandwich is also the best breakfast sandwich I've ever had - it's got hashbrowns inside snd the whole combo of cheese, egg, bacon, and fluffy brioche is so outrageously great. Wow! Loved everything and would get it all again. The caprese comes with a big bowl of salad with fresh cherry tomatoes and I'm even craving that again. Can't wait to come back and try more. 5 stars!!!! read more

See all

This is the second time I've been here since they had some type of messy change in ownership a couple years back. You could see the tone of the previous owner from my last/first review of Jay Street Cafe. I'm glad I came back to give them another try. They really do a good job with breakfast. In recent memory, I've gotten both the Breakfast Sandwich and the Chorizo Eggs Benny (or Benedict) and they were both excellent options. I like making breakfast on the weekends but on the days where I don't, coming here feels like a treat. The last time I was here their customer service was remarkable. They were quick to accommodate the party of two and a half we were (me, my spouse, and our toddler) even when there weren't enough chairs immediately available to make a table outdoors. They did it without a question. They were attentive when we were seated outside and it started to drizzle. Asked if we would be okay and if any of the folks outside would rather continue their meal inside. Glad they are doing a great job with keeping up with the service here. Happy to come back with friends visiting from the city read more

Small little café in the downtown area of Katonah, right across from the train station. Parking is limited in this area, you may have to walk a bit good amount of indoor seating. Nice, brunch menu. I have the fried chicken sandwich which was excellent, a very healthy portion, although they use chicken thighs instead of chicken breast a bit pricey, but that is what you can expect for that area. read more

Jay Street Bistro - Fried chicken sandwich - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Katonah, New York

Food the was good, but Candace was amazing. We weren't planning on stopping for lunch so we didn't have anything to occupy our toddler-we asked if there was a pharmacy near by so we could by crayons and she actually offered to go out to her car and get us colored pencils. There should be more people like her in the world. read more

We stoped by Jay St Cafe in Katonah across from the Harlem line train station. Katonah is a wonderful town with small specialty stores for browsing. First time we sat at the counter we ordered the Breakfast Sammy it was excellent. The variety of salads is large with very fresh ingredients. Their menu is small but a very diversified selection for breakfast, lunch and dinner. The Wait staff is friendly and attentive to all the patrons. Jay St, is a bright and clean restaurant. At lunch time and especially weekends you can expect to wait a few minutes. Warm weather outdoor seating as well. We have been back a few times and we enjoyed the food each time. read more

Highly impressed with the fried chicken sandwich I got. It was MASSIVE, yet remained crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside. A lil messy but the wife and I agreed that it was a great choice. Side salad was ok. Could've used more dressing. (And we weren't even planning on coming here! Was gonna check out the Whitlock but their kitchen was closed. Twas a low key blessing) read more

Jay Street Bistro - The fried chicken sammie with side salad - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Katonah, New York

See all

Jay Street Cafe remains my all-time favorite place to brunch locally. Even in the throes of the pandemic, they've managed to come to the table - pun intended! - with innovative concepts and always-great tasting food. Their buffalo cauliflower is a revelation, and their vegetarian chili is incredible, too. I think the portions are perfect, the prices are just-right, and if you're coming for drinks, the pours are super generous. Best of all is that Jay Street Cafe also serves up amazing coffees -- their iced coffee with oat milk saved me when my Nespresso machine was on the fritz -- and baked goods. I bought my son a corn bread muffin, and ended up keeping it for myself. If I didn't care about my weight, I'd eat my way through the meat-free items daily, and would go back for seconds. read more

My wife and I recently dined at the Jay Street Cafe. On this particular Saturday the Cafe was packed and had a single server, Jamie, to handle the customers. She was absolutely amazing. Our order was taken immediately and our food came to us quickly and she could not have been more pleasant. Jay Street Cafe food is excellent that the choices on the menu offer something for everybody. Don't miss this Gem of a restaurant and, if you are lucky enough to have Jamie as your server, you are in for a real treat. read more

Absolutly amazing food, Would definelty reccomend going. The manger that i spoke with was super nice and helpful and was able to throw some jokes. Overall would recommend to anyone in the town or anyone that is up here to visit. read more

Where to start... If you are looking for cusine that is aesthetically pleasing , vibrant and fresh, then Jay Street is for you. Not only is the food beautifully constructed , it is delicious!! Their breakfast is superb, just like their staff. Speaking of the staff, recently me and my partner were seated near a man who appeared to have fallen on bad times. He placed an order , but then stated he had no money. He started to get up to leave, the staff told him not to worry, and served him. They treated him with dignity, respect and did not rush him. In an age when such empathy appears to be lacking, Jay Street demonstrates altruism at its best. So let's wrapp this very long review up. If you are looking for a community driven cafe , that provides beautiful, delicious food and examplifies everything you want in a family run business, then go to Jay Street Cafe. read more

Jay Street Bistro - Potatoes in a delicious dressing / sauce (I forgot what it's called). - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Katonah, New York

See all

Great drinks, friendly staff. Warm, inviting atmosphere! Great hidden gem in Katonah. Don't miss the brunch! read more

Jay Street Bistro - Bar area - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Katonah, New York

There seems to be a new restaurant in this location every couple of years and we decided to try this place today. We came in with a party of 9 and we're seated immediately. The inside was empty with some people sitting outside. The food was good all around and everyone enjoyed it. The reason I'm giving three stars is because there was no service at all. We got our order taken and the next time a waiter or waitress came over was to clear the plates. If the service was average this would be a 4 or 5 star review. It's a shame because we enjoyed the food. read more

See all

Despite the cloud covered skies and impending snowfall, there was nothing but sunshine at the Jay Street Cafe. The sparkly and new space has been completely renovated by the dynamic husband and wife duo, Christina and Matt Safarowic, also owners of The Whitlock (just down the block and consistently excellent). Although it was a busy Saturday morning, we were greeted with a smile by Christina herself. Since there was going to be a short wait for a table, it gave us time to take in the decor. Most striking were the hand painted murals by Eric Drake (Christina's brother) paying homage to Katonah - one depicts the John Jay Homestead, the other the Katonah train station directly across the street. We were promptly greeted by our server. Mimosas to start followed by the Flat White (double ristretto espresso with microfoam-steamed milk with small, fine bubbles and a glossy or velvety consistency) which was made to perfection! The youngest in our group indulged in a hot chocolate topped with a toasted mega marshmallow -- she was hands all ... sticky, delicious, lickable fingers and face. We shared the pancake battered pork sausages with a maple syrup side car for dipping, but I quickly wished I had ordered some solely for myself. The Chef's Hash was a bowl full of comfort food for the belly. The eggs were cooked perfectly as the broken yolks ran down the chunks of corned beef below with plenty left for dunking the hearty grain bread. All breads and desserts are made in house. The French Toast was fluffy, the "Power Bowl" was yummy (AND guilt free), and the atmosphere is heavenly. So here's my suggestion ... Jay Street Cafe for brunch, a stroll up and down the quaint Katonah Avenue, The Whitlock for dinner. I guarantee it will be "a beautiful day in the neighborhood". read more

See all

We had the green bean app, the Jay burger and the fried chicken sandwich. Everything was so yummy. The coleslaw was amazing. Don't let your fries get cold, they were amazing when they came out. The staff was friendly and very attentive. We got there and there were a few people eating outside. The decor is very modern but the seats were comfortable. The chair was easy for my elderly aunt to get up. read more

After many years of bad restaurants popping up in Katonah, Jay Street has finally filled a void. Food is well priced, and a trip here is always worth it! read more

So just had breakfast here. I have been here a couple of times. Amazing bacon, egg and cheese on a toasted brioche. Cut bacon. Aioli etc. also Cornbread French toast is another winner. read more

We really enjoyed the food and experience there. The food was very good. We devoured the Buffalo cauliflower and I had the falafel burger and it was very good and filling. Service was good as well. Definitely recommend read more

Jay Street Bistro - Buffalo cauliflower - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Katonah, New York

Looked like a nice little place in a cute little town. Lots of outdoor seating but it was cool so we sat inside. Limited inside seating. I got the pancakes, my daughter got the blueberry pancakes and my husband got the French toast. The pancakes were so dry. We use almost a whole bottle of syrup. The blueberry pancakes had maybe three blueberries in them and six thrown on top. The French toast was okay but nothing special. Water glasses were very small and were only refilled once. No ice. Diet Coke was flat with a. Strange taste. Wouldn't recommend. With so many diners around I'd stick with one of them. read more

After driving by many times, we finally set aside a day to try Jay Street. We arrived around 12 for brunch. We were told it was a 35 minute wait for 3 people. No problem, we popped into a couple local stores to kill time. After 40 minutes we asked how it was going. The hostess said people wouldn't leave so still will be a while. After around an hour and 15 minutes we were called that there were seats at the bar if we wanted those. We were starving so that's fine. Service was good, multiple servers checked on us and were pretty attentive. Our group had the Reuben, fried chicken sandwich and cornbread French toast. The sandwiches were enjoyed. Small portion of warm, floppy fries. Cornbread French toast was good but very small portion with no sides. Very high prices for a small brunch. My husband got a milkshake and we saw the server/busboy make the shake, top with whipped cream, pour the rest from the blender into a small glass, top with whipped cream and walk off drinking the small glass of milkshake without handing off ours. We watched the whipped cream melting on his milkshake as it's sitting just out of reach. It was pretty funny, but if you're gonna drink the leftover shake at least give us ours too! I know it's not a diner where they give you the whole shake but I just thought it was odd that it was drank right in front of us. Overall, a decent spot but not worth the price. Probably won't return. read more

I visited this place for the first time during a trip upstate. I was seated immediately but no one came to take my order. There were several servers standing around and only two tables of customers. I waited for 16 minutes finally the hostess saw that no one came over and she took my order. While I was in the restaurant no one approached my table for anything not even to bring the check. Luckily A family was seated next to me and the waiter approached them as they sat down to take their order. When The waiter was done I asked if he could please bring my check. He helped another table, poured drinks twice and went to the rest room then roughly fifteen minutes later he put the check on the table. Smh very disappointed. I don't think I've ever gone to a restaurant and been completely ignored the entire time. I could not even get water because no server ever came to my table and that was kinda shitty and if I'm being honest a little hurtful. read more

Jay Street Bistro - Smoked salmon toast - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Katonah, New York

The last time I went to this Cafe was a few years ago, we had a nice breakfast there. I don't know how it is now, the food and service was pretty good as I recall. read more

Favorite breakfast spot around! I've had almost everything on the menu, and all has been delicious. Great for lunch or brunch as well. Love this place! read more

Delicious food, great service. Was surprised my food came out super fast despite the gorgeous, busy day.