Place is small, seating is very tight. We went in for a quick breakfast on a freezing cold morning and we were not warmer upon entering this place. We got the food to go because it was quite chilly in there. Breakfast sandwiches were okay. Coffee was good. Service was decent, felt a bit rushed. Wouldn't go out of my way to eat here again. read more

Poppy's Cafe - Sausage egg and cheese - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rye, New York

See all

The staff and owner are very friendly and attentive! It is definitely family friendly but it is a bit pricey. They do have sitting on the sidewalk if you don't want to sit inside. My kid was fussy and they had coloring books and toys so definitely ask if you eat inside. We ordered 1 short stack of pancakes with chocolate chips, 1 waffle with fruit (the strawberries were moldy :/ ) , kids size apple juice, cranberry juice and ... which were like $2-3 a pop and a cup of joe. We didn't omelettes which are $19.99 or bacon ... very carb loaded breakfast but came out to be over $50 !! read more

Poppy's Is the greatest breakfast brunch lunch spot in Rye!!! I have been have the Meat Lovers Omelette with a side of French toast for 35 years, and it is always a loving special time at Poppy's!!! I Am A Fan read more

Ordered a simple bacon, egg and cheese sandwich. The bacon was inedible. It was burnt and hard. It looked like it was made last week and reheated several times. The yellow American cheese was clearly processed cheese. How can they charge $10 for a sandwich with cheap, processed cheese? I paid 10 dollars and had reasonable expectations. It seems like because of the location in Rye, NY they overcharged for the sandwich without any quality standards. I took off the bacon and tried to eat the rest. So essentially I paid $10 for egg and cheese on a roll. Absolutely unacceptable. I would avoid this place at all costs. I would not have served that bacon to my dog. read more

Poppy's Cafe - Bacon egg and cheese on a roll. Burnt, hard, salty bacon. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rye, New York

Wonderful service and food! Went with my 5yr old son who got pancakes an i ordered the western omelette. Everything was delicious in this cozy cafe. read more

A totally adequate diner in Rye, if you're passing through. Local, mom-and-pop feel, even if there's one too many punny diner signs.

I Ordered an omelette with broccoli, onions, mushrooms and cheese that cost me $22. It was HOrrible. Let me preface this by saying that we've ordered from them a ton of times and we've eaten there many times and though the service is OK , everybody is very nice. I would say out of everything that I've had there, the burger and chicken sandwich are very good, but the last couple of times I've picked up orders from them for breakfast or lunch They have been subpar and I haven't said anything, because I do not typically like to bash restaurants, because sometimes they have awful days, but the last three times we've ordered breakfast, it has been equally awful Coupled with the fact that they are way overpriced, but that's the area I live in, so it is what it is. I'm old school and believe you get what you pay for, but clearly not in this situation. Here is the moral of the story, if you're going to charge me $22 for an omelette, make sure that said omelette fan freaking tastic and not filled with frozen broccoli, which was cold and melted all of the cheese. MY entire tin was waterI gave the sausage patties to my dog and he appreciated it, because they didn't look appealing and the potatoes looked like boiled raw potatoes with no seasoning on it, and not even a tinge of crisp. In conclusion, being busy is a blessing not an excuse, so count your blessings that you have people coming to your restaurant and ordering from you and do better with providing good service and quality food. read more

Poppy's Cafe - Obviously, you can tell the difference between fresh broccoli and frozen, and you can see the excessive water on the bottom of my omelette. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rye, New York

Go for the Breakfast Special! Great local place that I will be going to again and again.

Very cute spot! It's a small cafe so not much room but the aesthetic is nice. It's decorated with lots of signs related to women empowerment. The food was decent but isn't the best breakfast food I have gotten. The omelet was a little underwhelming but still tasted good. I'd recommend if you are looking a a spot to go to for the atmosphere not food. read more

Nice old school little diner. Has been in Rye for many years. Love the chili cheese omelette

I've eaten here several times. The service is never great but the food is usually good. Today, though, was unacceptable. They were very busy, which is good to see after what restaurants have been though in the past 2 years. I certainly understand that staffing is difficult since the pandemic so slow service is expected. Nasty, rude service is not! The food was horrific- they should have been embarrassed to serve it. Eggs over hard was served like poached eggs. Silver dollar pancakes were served in a child's plate- 5 DRY silver dollar pancakes for an adult in a plastic dish shaped like a monkey. Crisp bacon was so grossly undercooked it was raw in parts. Most disappointing was how rude the waitress was throughout and especially when we brought this to her attention. I will not return. Things could go wrong, people can be overwhelmed, food can be cooked incorrectly but for the waitress to treat us like we are at fault is disgraceful! read more

Poppy's Cafe - a plate with a monkey face on it - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rye, New York

When faced with not meeting expectations, you can "own it" or "pass the buck". Chirping that you're "busy" is not owning it. Especially at a restaurant. Full tables on a late Sunday morning, we waited 10 minutes to sit outside. After another five minutes, we put our order in ~ 2 egg dishes, single pancake and bagel. Then we waited and waited and waited...40 or so minutes later...With my 4 year old questioning where the bagel is and hoping to stave off a melt down, I went in to inquire about the bagel. Gruffly, I was told that the bagel was about to be up now. Two minutes later a *cold* bagel arrives with cream cream on the side. The cream cheese included specks of something, I assume it was bagel but could not be sure. Throughly annoyed (and slightly hangry), my wife went in to pay for the bagel and cancel the rest of our order. At this point, she was angrily told "do you see how busy we are" and refused payment for the bagel. Note: by this point only two tables outside and a few people inside. It was obvious our order never made it to the kitchen. A few further points... the kid bussing tables should not use the public trash bins nor wipe straw wrappers on to the street ~ both seem wrong. read more

Delicious breakfast. Amazing staff. And outdoor seating on a nice sunny day was absolutely perfect read more

Poppy's Cafe - Veggie Omelette with sausage and fruit - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rye, New York

This place is run by some hard working women. With kitschy signs everywhere. I love their breakfast. Best scrambled eggs other then mine and super cheap. And the have diet peach Snapple. read more

Poppy's muffins are magical, plain and simple. Apple is my personal favorite. Be sure to ask for it grilled! I could honestly enjoy half a Poppy's grilled muffin and coffee for breakfast every morning for the rest of my life. Sandwiches are good, as are the pancakes, and you can take anything to go (it's all delicious reheated too)! Accessibility There's a step to get inside and the bar counter is not wheelchair accessible either, but there are tables with removable chairs at the back (though the path there is somewhat narrow. That said, they have a button on the left side of the main door that says "push for assistance" meant for customers with disabilities and/or children. read more

Poppy's Cafe - Banana pancakes - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rye, New York

See all

First and last time I go to poppy's. The establishment lacks decency in their food. I showed up with high expectations thinking it was going to be a decent diner especially with it being located on Purchase st. The breakfast is way over priced for the quality of food you're getting. My $13 breakfast included stale toast which was far from being toasted, my over medium eggs were over cooked and very greasy as well as home fries. You also get a generous amount of bacon however it was mostly black because of how Burt it was. Your breakfast in complimented with a small coffee and choice of stop&shop brand juice. All your food is cluttered up on a medium size plate. Usually your toast given as a side so you can enjoy your actual food. Perhaps they do this to cover up the mishmash. I've had better eggs for half the price. Not planning on coming back. On the positive side- the staff was friendly. read more

With only 9 tables, 4 servers, 1 bus person there is no reason eating breakfast here should take 90 minutes. But that's Poppy's for you. I asked three separate servers for the check. None friendly. Getting the check took 20 minutes and nearly all the tables were empty. One asked me what I had to drink. I had nothing because Poppy's doesn't care about the environment. Drinks are served in plastic glasses and all the disposable items are bussed not to the restaurant's garbage or kitchen, but placed in a public trash bin where citizen's tax dollars pay for the Poppy's refuse disposal. Is that even legal? I can overlook tasteless food and petulant servers to support a family business, but not when the business is this thoughtless when it comes to the environment and the city in which it's planted. read more

Super cute, small cozy little cafe right as you get into rye! I ordered food through Uber eats, the order was wrong, so I went inside and the women greeting me was super kind and sweet! Bacon was extra crispy! Homefries were perfect! Toast was buttery.... my super picky boyfriend even loved it! read more

I used to take my son here for breakfast - about 10 years ago - because we went to a mommy and me class in the area. The eggs were good and it was a decent place to take a young child - but the lady who cooks the food was NEVER friendly, warm or welcoming, EVER. I mean, we saw her 1-2 times a week for about 2 years and she never said one kind word to me or my young son. EVER. Well, fast forward 10 years and here I am again - now with a tween boy and my young daughter - and guess what? She's still really unfriendly. Not even a f'ing smile. Nothing. And food was gross. Flat pancakes, uncooked bacon and cold coffee. Never coming back to this shit hole again. read more

I love Poppy's so much, always go here when I'm in Rye. The food is so good! I always get breakfast. The decor is super cute too!

Big omelet for about $15 was ok but not great and not great value. Convenient. Waitresses were patient with a loud obnoxious ignorant male at end of counter. read more

Good, hearty breakfast. Pretty decent flavor, good value and plenty to eat. Had the breakfast special, French toast and pancake. Here's the problem. I went with a friend who has eaten there dozens of times and knows the staff and vice versa. We entered, no one said welcome, good morning, nice to see you again. Not a smile or anything close to a pleasant gesture. For the next hour, not a smile or anything resembling decent hospitality. Basically ignored and no one asking how our meal was or few wanted more coffee. So we went to the front counter and paid and even then not a thanks or hope to see you again or how was your meal or good to see you again or have a good day. Not even a smile. We were just taken for granted. Very sad. I hope the owners find this useful and take it seriously. read more

Poppy's is the greasy spoon every town needs. The decorations give it a nice charm. Great for kids. In fact, we had an accident here and the staff could not have been more amazing. read more

Second time here in the year I've been living here in Rye. Friendly staff & good food! read more

Poppy's Cafe - Now this is a classic breakfast. Way to go Poppys! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rye, New York

Great simple place for breakfast. This is an old fashioned and simple local place - like a diner but smaller. Go for breakfast and enjoy the locals scene. read more

Poppy's Cafe popped up my Google map request last Sunday morning in search of a local restaurant to eat in on the way home from the Doral Arrowwood Resort. My info said it was 17 minutes away but suddenly my sister said, "There's Poppy's" and I was ever so glad because it was a perfect place to enjoy a delicious breakfast where you could actually watch the cooking. I'm always cooking and it was nice to watch someone else. Chef Gerri got a work out from us. It seemed we tried everything for breakfast - from pancakes, eggs sausages, french toast, bacon, homefries...I'm always partial to homefries and these were delicious! Poppy's Cafe also had samples of corn muffins and I took one home. It was still moist and delicious two days later. Next time I will buy a few and freeze them. Our waitress, Cindy was attentive and helpful when we couldn't make up our minds on what to order. Poppy's decor was whimsical and everywhere a sign or a picture made me smile. Make Poppy's Cafe part of your itinerary when you are in Westchester. read more

See all

I'm kind of, sort of confused with the reviews that I'm seeing. Stayed over at a friend's place in Harrison and we came here for some food. The place is small, yes.. but the food was delish! Had the Low Carb Omelet and a Belgian Waffle on the side (because i crave this all the time). The omelet was more than enough and filled me up quickly and i need to stress how delicious it was. Oh my! Anytime i think of an omelet i think of Poppy's because this has honestly been the best omelet i've had in a while. I'd totally recommend and would probably make a few more trips to Harrison bc of Poppys. read more

It really is the kind of place you want in your town, a small old school, family run luncheonette. Unfortunately they charge too much for food that isn't prepared with too much excitement. I went with my girlfriend for breakfast and we weren't too impressed. Service without a smile seems to be the way of doing business here. Some very strange decor and lack of any consistency in the plates and mugs seems a little odd. An uncomfortable look on the faces of other patrons as they were ignored or confused by the poor service. It seems like the staff only brightens up for the regulars that sit at the counter. I have been here twice and can say without any doubt I won't be returning any time soon. I'm going to stick to Vinnys Luncheonette in Port Chester when I'm looking for some solid well prepared breakfasts and lunch. read more

Remember the episode of Seinfeld when Poppy doesn't wash his hands? Poppy is kind of sloppy? In Rye, it's a Sejnfeld episode. Kinda gross. Charming from the outside looking in, but the second you sit in this cramped hell hole, all you can do is watch women with long hair and no gloves cook, take money, clean tables, wipe up spills on the floor, and NEVER WASH THEIR HANDS. At least I knew whose head the large black hair in my eggs came from. Inattentive service, mind-numbingly ridiculous set up. I have no idea if the food was good - I was mortified. It was expensive. One plus: the open kitchen meant not only could you see how dirty everything was, you could watch the bus girl try to make pancakes. Over and over. Ruining them each time while a family of five patiently waited. read more

I love this spot but they need to get their hours in order.. they just seem to close when they feel like it..not only did they move their closing time to 230/2 today they decided to close by 145...so annoying (and weather is fine no holiday just regular Tuesday). Why cant they atleast stick to their recorded hours??!! read more

It's a tight squeeze but the food is delicious. Bacon and eggs cooked perfectly, fluffy pancakes and very kid friendly. Friendly service. No hash browns though.. Counter and a few tables make up this cute cozy little diner. read more

Poppy's Cafe - Cute breakfast spot - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rye, New York

One of my favorite breakfast places! Not sure why there are only bad review but if youre looking for a "morning after" breakfast, this place hits the spot. The signs adorning the walls are warnings towards the personalities of the girls serving and cooking. They are wonderful conversationalists....only if you are. The food has a reminiscent quality to something your mom would cook for you. read more

This place is great. Yes it's pricey but worth it because the waitresses are lovely and the food is delicious. It's a coffee shop so don't expect it to be glamorous and you will love it! read more

Poppy's Cafe - Sitting at the counter. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rye, New York

Had low expectations and was surprised how excellent the food was. I am not an easy to satisfy customer and just had perfect meal. Perfectly cooked breakfast - eggs, sausage, bacon, toast. Someone can really cook...I'll be back! read more

Not bad, they have everything for breakfast yes but very basic ( fries, hamburger, eggs ) a kind of homemade fast food, medium service, I had to wait 15 min for a BLT sandwich ... read more

Have now been several times and the egg dishes are just not very good. The yellow cheese that comes with everything is unappealing and cheap. The staff is also rather unfriendly. Would be nice if there were other good outdoor breakfast spots in Rye but unfortunately this seems like the only game in town. read more

I wish I would've checked Yelp before going there. I went there for breakfast yesterday, and the omelette arrived cold and it was so so. The staff looked a bit depressed, and lacked any passion for their job. Another downside were the prices, which were just too high to justify what you get. The light at the end of the tunnel was the Belgian Waffle. I had a craving for something sweet, otherwise there's no way I would've ordered another thing there. It was very nice to be honest. so at least they got that right... read more

This was a great comfortable place to go have a home-cooked breakfast. Greeted with smiles and warm hellos for breakfast. Great cuppa coffee while looking over a nice breakfast menu. I highly recommend this place! read more

I was in Rye and saw this cute little cafe and thought to myself that I must come back and give it a try with my wife. Today I went back with the company of my wife and the place is cute but small. The menu is not vegetarian friendly so if you are a vegetarian this is not a good choice. I opted to have an Iced Tea and a Tuna Melt and Home Made French Fries. My wife had Water and Tuna on Whole Wheat which came with potato chips. The drinks where served in disposable solo cups and then our meals arrived on white paper plates which were secured in a plastic paper plate holder (cheesy to say the least). The tuna melt was more like a grilled cheese tuna sandwich not a classic open faced tuna melt and the home made fries where oily and limp and flavorless (fryer oil was not hot enough to cook the fries properly and they had no seasoning). My wife's sandwich was as expected but the chips looked like a bunch of crumbs from the bottom of the America's Choice Potato Chip bag that they were serving from. We ate our meal and never saw the server again other than her reflection in the mirror as she stood behind the counter stuffing her face and then handling food without washing her hands. No refills were ever offered on our beverages and we had to hunt the server down to get the bill in order to pay for our meal so we could leave. Shortly after leaving both my wife and I began to feel ill and we will always remember them but not for a good reason, "Poppy's will give you the Poopy's". read more

See all

Despite its convenient location, the food is barely acceptable and overpriced. The service is subpar, with having to ask for coffee refills and waitresses that never smile. It looks like the equipment hasn't been changed since the 50s and the rest is a make shift kitchen from Bed Bath and Beyond. Would never go back here. read more