Reviews here are crazy this is the best bagel in Westchester. Parking and seating isn't anything special, but you can get in and out quickly and the bagels are fresh, fluffy, and delicious. read more

So incredibly rude. I've been here so many times in the past and will never return again. I asked for a bagel and the girl LIED to me saying they didn't have it. When I saw the bagels come out of the oven I asked her to change the order I previously made after telling me they didn't have the other bagels. The girl rudely said no and then ignored me, yelling "NEXT" to the customer behind me as I was still speaking to her. They have no respect and will purposefully overcharge you for things you didn't order. DO NOT come here. read more

Place has bagels and boba!! No way! The bagels were decent and good amount of cream cheese. The owners are friendly and staff are quick! Definitely give this place a good as there is a good variety of bagels and sandwiches! read more

Hand Rolled Bagels - Inside - Bagels Near Me - Rye, New York

Small shop with no seating so grab and go . Friendly staff and a small selection of bagels but more hot or cold sandwich options. Muffins,pastries and grill breakfast items- bacin sausage eggs etc. Tea, coffee and boba tea . The bagels were good. I'm a new yorker so my judgment on bagels is pretty fierce lol. I also expected a larger selection of bagels at a place called Hand Rolled Bagels , but I guess it was more indicative of the methods rather than the specialties. There was also a specialty bagel named a Flagel- a flattened bagel, hmm couldn't get with that just like I can't get into the idea of a scooped bagel. To each their own. I got an Everything bagel with lox cream cheese. A I must say that there was a very generous amount of chuncks of lox swirled in. That honestly won my heart. I despise mingy toppings. Overall a decent bagel. The staff was really sweet and the shop was notably clean. read more

See all

Whenever I fly in to Westchester- I make time to get a dozen or 2 dozen for my staff and friends. By far....the best bagels ! French Roast bagel is a must!!!! Staff is great too. A fantastic value !!!! Keith read more

The best bagels in the area hands down. However they always seem to mess the order up even when I'm the only customer. Ordered a onion bagel with butter received a onion bagel with rasin cream cheese. Ordered a everything bagel with butter recieved a plain bagel with butter. Very frustrating when you're the only customer. read more

It is all street parking but I didn't have difficulty finding a spot. I was helped very quickly but the staff was not welcoming. The location is very small and felt crowded even though there were only 5 customers including myself. The plain toasted bagel was made fresh and came with a generous amount of cream cheese. The breakfast sandwiches look pretty good too. My gripe with Hand Rolled Bagels isn't the food. The prices here are insane. A bacon egg and cheese, two buttered bagels, and 3 small coffees came out to almost $29. Like bro, these are bagels they cost next to nothing to make. The food here is good for a breakfast/ bagel spot. Personally, I think Lenny's is better and they won't bang you over the head. If you don't mind the price you will at least have a good bagel here. read more

A broom closet bagel place that serves a fairly decent bagel with a small - perhaps shrink-flated - portion of salmon that ensures the fish is a garnish but not the main (that would be the tomato). But there isn't much competition 'round here, so what you get is what you get. Skip the fish and the price is probably more in order. All said, the bagels are fairly good: chewy and dense with a good variety of options. No seating: to go only. No pickles, and a few salads, none of which looked appealing. read more

Hand Rolled Bagels - This skimpy salmon portion might feel intimidated by the burly tomato slice. - Bagels Near Me - Rye, New York

See all

Driving thru the area and wanted to stop outside of the city to grab breakfast. We saw this was a quick bagel stop so we decided to try it. My buddy and I both agreed the bagels are very good, fluffy on the inside and crispy on the outside. But the rest of the ingredients left something to be desired. Don't get me wrong, it was still good and I'd go back. But I feel like nyc has a reputation to out of this world bagel shops so this one doesn't blow me away by any means but for $8 it's a solid option. I'm sure their bagels and cream cheese are very good but they have many things on the menu so I have to judge them off of the entirety. The service is straightforward and they take your order and call you when it's ready. read more

See all

Cute little bagel shop in Rye. They have a lot of flavors and also have a variety of deli spreads/salads. I got an onion bagel toasted with cream cheese and two drinks from their cooler (Pepsi and a vitamin water).... My total was close to 12$. I was shocked. The markup on the beverages must be crazy. The bagel was good but Not great. They were generous with the cream cheese. read more

Hand Rolled Bagels - Onion bagel toasted with cc - Bagels Near Me - Rye, New York

See all

They touch money & charge cards and then prepare food wearing the same gloves --- and cash out the next customer & prepare more food (with the same gloves!). This is NOT sanitary. Everyone working here does this! Pluses: The bagels are good (minus the unsanitary preparation). Minuses: The pricing. The sky is the limit. read more

Absurd prices. $32 for 2 bagels with cream cheese , tomato and lox The line was out the door. Service was slow. Bagel was good but not worth the wait and price. Too bad this is the only bagel shop in Rye. Go to Harrison or Mamaroneck instead if you are in the area. read more

Listen, the Bagels were delicious, perfectly cooked. Perfect shape. great size/quantity/quality. Great availability, even late in the morning. The service was fine, too. However, the Coffee was no good, and the Prices are a little hefty. We got 2 coffees, 2 BEC's (Bacon Egg n Cheese) sandwiches on a bagel and 1/2 dozen bagels to go. I think the bill was between 30 and 40 dollars. There is NO Break down on Bagel Prices if you get 1, 6 or 12. That is disappointing. I know bagels aren't cheap, but buying a dozen or a 1/2 dozen should be at least a little bit of a break on price. The small upstairs dining room was dirty and there was no napkins available. I drank a few sips of my coffee and it was so bad, I threw it out. The others I was with ended up doing the same thing (without me saying anything). read more

Why anyone goes here is beyond me. The owner is not nice and the cashiers follow his example. Prices are ridiculous too. I will go anywhere but this place, save your money people. Also, how hard is it to slice a bagel? Apparently very difficult if you ask them. No thank you, I don't like paying for crappy service and mediocre bagels at best. Lame. read more

I ordered an everything bagel toasted with butter. 2 2oz bags of chips and 2 bottled drinks. This large extravagant feast cost me $18.37. While I know prices have gone up, that's just ridiculous. Way too overpriced for okay bagels. It was quick service though... read more

Hand Rolled Bagels - Pictures of my extravagant feast - Bagels Near Me - Rye, New York

Overpriced, bad service, owners don't get it - just focus on extracting as much price as possible. Significantly more expensive than any alternatives read more

This place really has some of the best bagels I've ever had in the area. I had a lox bagel with cream cheese on an everything bagel and it was soft, fresh-tasting, and full of flavor. Definitely try this place out! read more

this is where all the locals know to get bagels. Stop by to try the softest chewiest most authentic bagels in ny. you won't regret it. & yes, like any other busy and popular shop you might have to wait, but it's all worth it in the end. read more

Hand rolled bagels is incredible. They have fresh bagels and exceptional lox!

Delicious bagels but the ordering process was painful and chaotic. Super loud and the lady taking the order couldn't hear me, so she was kinda rude. Overall, it was kind of a stressful experience- because of this not sure I'll go back. read more

The best bagels ever. Better than NYC. The service isn't warm and fuzzy as they have a line out the door everyday. They're trying to be as efficient as possible, but if you are a regular will they notice and are more than friendly. And why you wouldn't want to be a regular once you taste these bagels is beyond me. Plain, everything, BECs, cream cheese are all amazing. read more

Spinach bagels are amazing. The lox is also incredible.

Just ok. The line outside is not justified. Might be because it's the only bagel in town. Expensive. Had a BEC on an everything. Bacon wasn't crisp and bagel felt like it was under baked. read more

I keep reading reviews that say rip-off, and sure, i agree -- a bagel with lox and cream cheese costs how much? (keep reading to find out) -- but let me add to the discussion, whats up with the customer service? Why are you guys so mean? I ordered a lox cream cheese and it rung up as $18 (for reference, minimum wage is still $13.20). I asked whether they thought I ordered something else. They shot me a disdainful look and said 'well if you can't afford it go somewhere else.' Like whoa, this is the neighborhood spot telling me i'm too poor to order a bagel? I said fine to paying $18 for a bagel, certainly being ripped off, but fine, I was hungry. I go to my car and see its a translucent swipe of cream cheese and a pinkys length of lox slapped on. I went back in an asked if they could give me a little plastic cup of cream cheese - i'll put it on myself, and maybe a little more lox if they're feeling up to it. it was an $18 sandwich, ya know? Instead, they refunded me and told me to get out lmao i'm super sad because i used to go to this place for years but after today i dont think i'll go there again. still sad about it tho. read more

I'm really disappointed in my experience with this place. I ordered an egg and cheese on a wrap. I got a positively tiny wrap filled with--another wrap, one piece of cheese and half an egg if not less. My bill was $12.95 for that and a buttered bagel. I won't be going back. Save your money and skip this place. read more

Food: 5/5 Price: 5/5 Small bagel shop in Rye with delicious breakfast bagels. 10+ flavors including rainbow..?! Which tasted delicious. Ordered a dozen to bring abroad, froze them and had it 2 weeks later, tasted amazing! My American comfort food....! Breakfast bagel ($) - 5/5. Poppyseed bagel with bacon and egg. Popping hot, with chewy bagel. So good! Poppyseed Bagel - 5/5. I absolutely love the crispy crust with a chewy interior Rainbow Bagel - 4/5. I know it's just with additional coloring, but it just tasted....different? Cute! read more

Hand Rolled Bagels - Breakfast bagel - Bagels Near Me - Rye, New York

The service here is so horrible. I have the entire conversation recorded so if anyone wants it let me know. My 2 year old whined a tiny bit because she's 2. I speak to my daughter like a human being with respect because im a good person. The employee SCREAMED at my daughter and said "HEY! Stop that right now and get in your seat!" Mind you she was already getting in her seat but it takes a minute because she's still learning how. I explained that you do NOT scream at someone else's child. My poor baby was crying and so embarrassed. Everyone felt uncomfortable. The "owner" said it's my fault and children aren't allowed to yell in public. So parents beware, don't let your child even speak in here while waiting for your mediocre bagel. I demanded she apologize to my daughter and she did but it isn't over. I want her and the owner to be as humiliated as my daughter was. read more

Hand Rolled Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Rye, New York

Totally ripped me off. I asked for whitefish salad, egg salad, and chicken salad. I said I wanted the next size down from the empty container on the counter. The man didn't respond and filled the containers out of my line of vision. They were not the minis but the next size up, that is, the size that I had said I didn't want. When I protested, he said, "That's the smallest size." So I told him to hold back the chicken salad. For the small containers of whitefish salad and egg salad and a small plastic bottle of OJ, he charged $32. I was in a big rush; he had filled the order already; and I was taken by surprise. I didn't want to make a fuss, so I just paid up. A normal shopkeeper would have shown the empty container to me before filling the order since it was obvious that he did not have what I had requested. He manipulated me and I fell for it. And the food didn't taste that good. read more

Really good bagels, stopped here randomly on a trip and it turned out to be a fantastic choice, would recommend!

Great bagels and spread, but the experience from the employee service folks was subpar at best and isn't worth waiting in a line for.

Having never been much for bagels these sold me! Flavorful. Light, for a bagel. Friendly service. read more

Everything we ordered was delicious! Great prices. However lacking customer service. Very rude staff!

Management at this place is awful, very rude not friendly at all. I asked once why doesn't anyone answer the phone he said we don't have anyone to do that, and we don't have to. Food is so so and overpriced. I will never come back again. read more

Handrolled Bagels is the glue that keeps Rye together--or rather, the cream cheese. Not only is the food absolutely divine, but the staff adds an exceptional flavor that lox spread just can't beat, although theirs comes pretty close. My usual is a plain bagel with lox spread, an order I'm sure they know very well. When the bagel is warm, it makes me feel grateful that I am alive in this world. The lox spread isn't too heavily mixed, and maintains the perfect amount and distribution of lox. I have so much admiration for this establishment, may it take over the world one day. There are other bagel places around, and in New York you can't be too disappointed; however, should you ever be graced with the honor of patronizing this promised land, never forget what heaven tasted like. Much love, Rezzy read more

Excellent bagels we took a dozen to go too and disappear in no time definitely comming back read more

Hand Rolled Bagels - Cinnamon raisins bagel with cream cheese and lox - Bagels Near Me - Rye, New York

Folk wisdom says it's the water that makes NY bagels so much better than anywhere else. I do believe hand rolling is part of the secret but not sure what other alchemy makes folks run thru the door of this place one minute before closing time to grab the last everything bagel. I can also recommend the black and white cookies. read more

Hand Rolled Bagels - Black and shite cookies make me happy. - Bagels Near Me - Rye, New York

I was looking for a fresh bagel on my way home from the airport and this place didn't disappoint. Soft, warm and delicious. read more

Hand Rolled Bagels - Garlic bagel toasted with veggie cream cheese. - Bagels Near Me - Rye, New York

I've been working on Julie Killian's campaign for NY State senate for a few weeks now. I've tried bagels in Westchester, Eastchester, Harrison, and Yonkers. However, nothing matches the deliciousness of the bagels that I found at the shop in Rye. I usually get the bacon, egg, and cheese w/ avocado. Its outstanding. The staff was so kind and even embraced my Samsung Pay app. They welcomed me each time I returned and treated me like family. It's amazing how amazing a small town bagel shop can be. P.S. They have rainbow bagels. read more

Hand Rolled Bagels - My usual. The bacon egg and cheese on a rainbow bagel with avocado. And I can't forget the black coffee. - Bagels Near Me - Rye, New York

Wow! What fast and efficient service. The mini everything Flagel I got was great! Toasted with scallion cream cheese - a win. $3.50...little expensive for the quantity and size. read more

Went two days in a row because I thought what a nice place. I ordered a plain bagel with scallion cream cheese and bacon. First time it was plentiful and worth the $8. My most recent visit I ordered the same thing and what I received was a bagel with very little cream cheese and literally two small pieces of bacon... I went to talk to who made my sandwich and instead was rudely interrupted by a lady who i assume is the owner asking me what she owed me and through the money at me... I will never go back. Neither will the people I tell. RUDE! read more