I had the pleasure of dining here for a work dinner. The food and service were on point. We had the spicy tuna sushi, smoked salmon spread, and the steak rolls as our appetizers. All were delicious and the presentation was very nice. Several in our party had the prime rib. It looked amazing. I had the steak and fries. My dinner was fantastic and cooked to perfection. All the plates being carried out to other diners looked great as well. I would definitely dine here again. read more

Fish tacos here are amazing .. prime rib is good as well .. super busy .. parking can be an issue in the evening .. great wine list as well as a full bar .. management is present and attentive bar tenders read more

J. Alexander's - Prime rib - New American Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Very disappointed here also. The said they couldn't accommodate a party of 8. We asked if we could do 2 tables of 4 close to each other and was told no but we could all sit at the bar. This is just crazy to me. read more

So I went last night kinda close to closing but I must admit, the ambiance of the restaurant was so calming. I walked in with my godbrother and our hostess was also our waitress. I can remember her name but her smile was definitely something to remember. She sat us at our table and gave us a few moments to loom over the menu. We ordered drinks right away which were superb. I ordered black beans and rice which was so good that it was so close to my creole mother's. My godbrother had the salmon dip which was really good. We were going to get ye carrot cake but the appetizers filled us up. We weren't very hungry but those appetizers were belly fillers. Jazz music was playing in the background and being a musician, you know I love that!!! The atmosphere was chill mode and soothing. Very classy and nice service. I'll be back to this location. read more

J. Alexander's - Very nice bar setting - New American Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Go here for a martini! Good martinis and good sushi. Keisha was a very nice server-side and the manager was wonderful. We waited awhile for our sushi, and then it was the wrong kind, but the manager came over, apologized for the wait and comped out wrong sushi also brought the correct one. read more

See all

Service is top notch and so is the food. I luckily went on a night where they offered a 14oz ribeye. It was cooked just as ordered and delicious! Drinks were always filled, and our food came out fast especially considering it was during Friday evening dinner rush. I highly recommend making a reservation, as we walked right in and were seated. Parking can be a little cumbersome, so arrive in plenty of time to find a parking spot. read more

Prime Rib was ON POINT! A bit sad that there's wines on the menu that you can't order unless you sign up for some club. I think that's BS. If you want to have exclusive wines, have a separate menu for the exclusive wines. Don't put it on three standard menu. Dropped 1 star for the wine issue. read more

J. Alexander's - Prime Rib! Was very good! Mmmmmmm - New American Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

We had a horrible experience at BJ's Restaurant and Brewhouse at Easton Town Center. We proceeded to literally walk across the parking lot to J. Alexander's Restaurant and explained to them what just occurred and asked if they could accommodate us. There is simply no comparison in the service we received from them. I loosely use the word "service" with BJ's Restaurant and Brewhouse, because there was none. However, the GM and staff at J. Alexander's were so kind, respectful and immediately opened up an area that was closed off, to serve my family. The food was also delicious! J. Alexander's exuded the professionalism expected when an individual chooses to dine out and spend their money, especially in these current times of inflation. The staff at J. Alexander's were compensated very well and I thank them for treating us with kindness and respect! Your staff turned an ugly situation around and made our day! Ashanti VanNoy read more

We go here every two weeks or so and are never disappointed. Love the tuna meal, crab cake, and steaks.

It's rare that I 5 start. And when I do, it's generally from one or more persons that have corrected a prob, or just made me feel amazing. Tonight's rating is, I would say the first, an all around 5 star. Let's go, Alex our server was top notch! Ordered the deviled eggs , you have to get extra cornbread croutons, Prime rib extra cut, dnt pour the sauce on it first before you taste it. Good pick if your hungry. Bout to run to a movie- until next review. Yelp you later read more

J. Alexander's - New American Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Cold Baked Potato and Hot Carrot Cake. The steaks were delicious, and that's about it. Having worked in the hospitality industry for almost 15 years, I am a bit jaded when it comes to restaurants. I know what it is like to have been a server in a busy, Saturday night, upscale spot. I have seen what a FOH Manager is supposed to do and how to act around guests. After taking my Mother-In-Law out to dinner for her birthday, to J. Alexander's, I was embarrassed. Drinks not only came out wrong to start with, but when we asked about the order, we were told after the fact that a very basic drink (614 - see picture) came with blueberries and mint??? Hey J. Alexander's. Thank God it was my wife's order and not mine because I am allergic to berries and I don't think your first-aid kit has an EpiPen. Server did not apologize but told us that's the correct drink when it is obviously not. Food came out and it was great. Except for the fact that a baked potato was raw. Server showed up at the end of the meal and asked how everything was. Not showing up 5 minutes after the food was delivered to make sure that we were happy with our meals and they were to our liking. Did not see a manager walking around. Touching tables and asking if we were enjoying ourselves is still a thing, right? I don't think I have ever had pre-bused my own table and had a food-runner leave a stack of appetizer dishes when dropping off the main course. I will say the prime rib was very good. We got desert but when it was dropped off the server and food-runner did not bring us utensils. We sat there for 5 minutes, looking at each other and wondering if we would get to eat. Other servers walked past us and didn't even notice. When we asked for forks and spoons, the server (not our server) simply said "Sure". No apology and no mention of it. And the icing on the cake was literally the icing on my cake. Carrot cake with cream cheese icing, served HOT, turns into carrot cake with cream cheese sauce. After 2 bites I pushed it away as I was not about to eat any more. Out server came by and asked us how everything is. I replied with "This is disgusting". She asked "Why?" When I explained that carrot cake is to be served chilled so that the icing is dense and it brings out the sweetness, she simply replied "Our carrot cake is served hot". No apologies. J. Alexander's, you may have a good steak, but your basic server training is very Applebee's. read more

J. Alexander's - New American Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I've eaten here several times but this was the first time I've tried the lasagna. It was amazing, actually the best I've had since Rome in 1993. It will be hard to order anything else when I return here. Service was fantastic as usual. read more

I am not a fan of making a public post about restaurant because I love working in them and have a great respect for what they do. However, when a company does not make it possible to leave a private on line inquiry Yelp is the next best option. The first time my husband and I visited we had a wonderful experience we had a wonderful time! So we decided to bring our children for their birthday's. We booked the reservation on Open Table for our daughter's 18th birthday and son's 17th. I called to confirm the reservation which was under my husband's name and the girl I talked to was not only rude, but specifically told me we needed an easier last name to pronounce after I corrected her 3 times. When we arrived both of the hosts were beyond rude to us and whoever the attendant was on the phone with. I had called twice to make sure that they know that we would be celebrating very big birthday's for our children. When it came down to dessert our server who was very sweet was not aware of this at all?! It wasn't her fault at all. Later this evening I discovered there was bacon in my mashed potatoes of which I have not eaten in over 10 year so I have been up vomiting all night. Who doesn't put a candle in a cake knowing that there are two very important birthdays happening and we were charged for the cake too? Spending an excessive amount of money on a dinner for a TWO special birthdays is just not ok. read more

My husband and I enjoyed a date night here last Friday, very good, last minute decision. We ended up sitting at the bar, the only complaint I had was our salad/appetizer came out 30 seconds before our meal. I only had time to take one bite of the salad which was good before my meal was on top of it. We both had prime rib, mashed potatoes and Mac and cheese, all delicious and came out hot. We tried several cocktails, all exceeding our expectations and delicious. Service a little slow but we were there at peak time, worth the wait for the food and drink we experienced. Thanks! read more

Food undercooked and horrible service with server who didn't want to be there and never checked on us. Had to send back due to rare hamburger meat that was ordered medium well. Not worth the money at this location & disappointed because I like J Alexander's. Don't waste your money at the Colombian, Ohio location. read more

Treated very rude by manager named Shawn and waitress named Melissa. Shawn was very condescending and disrespectful the way he spoke to me. Melissa was inattentive and tried to basically bully a tip out of us. Terrible experience. read more

I travel for business. I decided to stop in for dinner after a store visit. Being only a party of 1, I decided to sit at the bar. I was greeted within 5 minutes of sitting down and ordered a glass of wine. I looked over the menu and decided to order a sushi roll and the Avocado Bomb which was enough for just me. First of all! The food AMAZING and that's why I gave this location a 2 star review. The service on the other hand was not. They did bring a side plate and soy sauce. The food runner brought the food out to me. No one at the bar asked me how my food was or even offered me silverware. Which I did need a napkin even though I had chopsticks. I needed more chips for my Avocado bomb and the bartender finally came over once I was finished. I gave her my card and asked for more chips. No one asked how my food was or thanked me for coming in. I did leave a 20% tip even though the service did not live up to expectations. read more

J. Alexander's - My receipt. - New American Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Prime Rib & Steak rolls can't go wrong!! This place is worth the money plus we'll priced for the quality!!

This is my absolute favorite when I'm wanting a classic steak and potato dinner. I got the filet with the loaded baked potato. The filet is cooked perfectly with a crust and butter topping that is to die for. The potato is the perfect pairing for this steak as well. We also started with the steak rolls which as basically an egg roll with steak. Absolutely delicious, highly recommend! read more

J. Alexander's - New American Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

This was my first time here and definitely not my last. Came here to visit family and this was a great spot to enjoy a great meal. The ambiance was excellent and so was the service. There is a LONG WAIT!!! Do yourself a favor if there on either Friday,Saturday or Sunday, make reservations. We did and they called us within 5 minutes of our reservation. Upon entering the restaurant, you get a warm feeling of the establishment. The music is good and I truly enjoyed. The waitstaff was actually top notch. read more

Had the steak roll appetizers and calamari , top notch! The steak rolls and white sauce is Highly recommended appetizer. For dinner i ended up ordering their special, a blue cheese encrusted steak. They never asked how to cook the steak so it came out as a medium cook. If u want something different be sure to tell them. The steak was great, blue cheese was excellent. The side was a ginormous baked potato. It was rather dry, not a lot of sour cream. It was all good, and a safe meal, but nothing really blew my mind except for the appetizers. read more

The food here was good. We came in at lunch time. There was plenty of space. I would have considered returning and trying other items in the menu because my wife's burger was really good and my tuna salad was good too, but the hostess was so rude, we have decided not to. She did not greet us when she saw us at the entrance, or come to ask anything, someone else did instead. She quickly pulled menus and walked away. We intuited we had to follow her since she did not utter a word and walked fast past by us. When we left, she was guiding a bigger group and walked over my wife who could not move. She did not respond to our thank you at all and did not even acknowledge us as costumers. This fact alone will prevent me from returning here. Ill manners are just not OK when there are so many other places offering excellent service. The hostess has a very simple yet meaningful job and this woman did not perform any of her duties. The waiter, on the other hand, was incredibly nice and attentive. He was courteous and responsive. We will not return. read more

I enjoy the lunch crowd. Not too loud. Great menu. Try the specials. The wine list is actually very good. The Prisoner is $72 the servers are very good here. read more

Cheyenne is the bomb. She trained my server and he was the bomb & she was so sweet and got my box with no issuers even though she wasn't my server. read more

I'm very pleased with the quick service. They have the best coleslaw. I'm disappointed with them taking the jumbo shrimp off the menu

The food was alright. We ordered Smoked Salmon Caesar's. We always eat at the bar and they have had a policy change. Now you must start a tab for food or pay as you go. Really weird for an upscale place to require such a thing. I felt like I was back on campus in the day. read more

Came here for dinner this evening. This location is relatively new and it's very nice I liked the bar setup they have and the modern furniture they have. The staff were very friendly and our waitress Sarah did a wonderful job. We started off with spinach con queso spinach dip which was really good, one of the best spinach dips I've had by far. For entrees we got the steak rolls with Mac n cheese and the bacon burger. The burger was also one of the best burgers I've had in a long time and it was very big! Can't wait to return try one of their steaks. read more

See all

I took my mom here for Mother's Day today. She got the rotisserie chicken, I got the crispy chicken tenders and dad got the prime rib medium. The rotisserie chicken was dry, and the prime rib came out well done somehow. My crispy chicken fingers were excellent but they came with Cole slaw that was dry and Unflavorful. It was a pile of shredded cabbage wet with milk and poppy seeds sprinkled atop. A gnat later landed on the coleslaw and it blended in with the poppyseeds which was unappetizing. My broccoli was difficult to cut even with a knife. We were starving so we ate the food (not the cole slaw) but the meal made us sad bc we've had some very excellent meals here. Service was excellent as usual. read more

We got seated as soon as we got there. Only thing that really sucked was lighting, very hard to read the menus because of it. The food wasn't bad but was really salty. Would have liked to have a sweeter side dish. The waiter we had was a very nice gentleman. read more

Our server was just "meh". She was not attentive at all. She poured water on half our table, and never bothered to wipe it up. And when we told her about it, she said not a word. Not even a "sorry". My pork tenderloin was good. The smashed potatoes that came with it was just ok. Not much flavor to them. My husband's grilled chicken with broccoli and rice was good. And our crunchy shrimp roll was the best part of our meal. I may try them again at a later date. Maybe. The experience wasn't worth the money we spent today. read more

I enjoyed dining out especially J Alexander'sDeviled EggsFilet MignonRotisserie Chicken

Consistently excellent service and food. The aesthetics are beautiful and the atmosphere is relaxing. The staff actually remembers our names and is very helpful to give us everything we need. I have never had anything but excellent food and drinks at this location. We enjoy their burgers, steaks and prime rib. I would only recommend that they add some ciders to their beer list - like Strongbow or Angry Orchard. read more

This place used to be great! Not anymore. Painfully slow service. Mediocre over priced food. Staff including management have an attitude. Last 2 visits have been the same. Disappointing and $130 meal. read more

Usually go to the one in Worthington, but decided to stop at this one, since we were up here at Easton. Good choice. I had a martini to start. Of course, we had the deviled eggs, and I had the special, Cajun trout. She had the roast beef dip. We both loved our main courses. I think they have the best fries. Waiter was excellent. Took home some carrot cake. Everything was first rate for us. Would recommend this place, especially for lunch... read more

4-5 months ago I had a first bite of their rare juicy prime rib at this location from my coworker's and it was amazing! I went last week to now called Redland used to be J Alexander but now it's changed at Crosswood in Worthington n tried out their prime rib medium well not as I expected thinking, it's too cooked because it's chewy. It's OK but maybe I didn't get it rare!Their menus seems very similar. Not what I expected. So then today I decided to take my daughter out for dinner for our mommy n daughter day out with her @ Easton for our holiday. WOW! Once we got our ENTREES at a 45 mintues of wait and wasn't even that busy! Her burger was fine but fries was soaked in salt and my prime rib was way over salt. So many months of waiting and money wasted....I wouldn't recommend it. read more

Boy I tell you I'm getting sick of this place and the service. Never and I repeat never try to order takeout from this place unless its 1pm. The parking situation is awful and there are no designated places to park for carryout orders. Then when you cant find parking valet threatens to tow you. You have to place an order at the busy bar for your carryout dealing with the shenanigans of the busy restaurant and bartender. Not to mention the rude patrons sitting at the bar not helping you to squeeze through to place a take out order. I will never dine here again. I'm over it. read more

Love the menu and ambiance at this location. My favorites are the Steak Wraps, Cheese Dip and the Steak Maui. The service is always top notch, servers and bartenders. I would definitely recommend. read more

Overall, a great experience in taste and service (only one caveat). We highly recommend! Total cost for all $138! Great buy for all we got! 1 Cindy's Lemon drop Martini w/1 refill that came with it 1 DOUBLE Tito's vodka w/olive 1 Water w/lemon (came w/extra thick glass bottle that kept refills cold) 2 Glasses of "Four sisters syrah" 1 app of Smoked salmon spread appetizer w/thin toasted bread slices) 1 app of wood-grilled zucchini slices, longer style slices 1 House salad w/light blue cheese dressing (we shared) 1 Prime Rib, Rare, regular cut w/horseradish, au jus & wild rice orzo side 1 Prime Rib, Med-Rare, regular cut w/horseradish, au jus & steamed broccoli 1 Key Lime Pie (Huge and share-worthy) 1 Fresh French pressed coffee (share-worthy) in metal pot w/ ceramic cups Service was superb. Ordered an appetizer, drinks, salad, entree, dessert, and coffee. * APP: Smoked Salmon spread and thin bread to spread on. I have a gluten sensitivity so I ordered the wood grilled zucchini to go with the salmon and it was fabulous! * SALAD: Regular w/homemade croutons, greens & a light smattering of blue cheese dressing, one was enough to share. * DRINKS: Cindy's Lemon Drop martini & a double vodka with olive for my husband, & extra water w/lemon. Martini w/sugar rimmed glass was tasty! Came with one extra chilled martini in a small glass for a refill. Two glasses of "4 sisters syrah" inexpensive & GREAT! (We will be buying a bottle soon!) Fresh French Pressed coffee w/dessert was bold and smooth. * ENTREE: We had the prime rib, regular size. Rare & medium rare. Hubby subbed mashed potatoes w/wild rice orzo (cold-style w/cilantro, fresh corn, wild rice, orzo, w/light oil-based toss etc) was EXCELLENT!!! Will order again! I subbed broccoli instead of potatoes & it was large portion and flavorful & healthy. Prime rib was to die for w/au jus! Get the horseradish sauce! It was also phenomenal w/prime rib & au jus! DESSERT: Key Lime pie w/graham cracker crust was HUGE (share it)! Filling which tasted almost cheesecake-like richness and a mild but prominent lime flavor. Excellent! Hubby had a few more bites but we were stuffed & took it home. Now, the ONE caveat: The appetizer was brought first. THEN our entrees, FOLLOWED by the salad about 2 minutes after our entree was brought?!? My husband was a bit disappointed by the salad FOLLOWING & on top of the main entree of the night. Service was fast, but a bit too fast for the salad/entree timing. The main server may not have been in-sync w/another woman who brought some of the food. We didn't fuss and made it work. But it was to note. * Noise level was MODERATE for a Sunday Night. I can see Friday and Saturday nights to be very loud though. * The bar is noted in center of the establishment, shaped like a horseshoe, tables & booths situated on outside of bar area cordoned off from bar area w elevated flooring and rail. WILL HIGHLY RECOMMEND! read more

I have spent each of my recent birthdays celebrating at JAlexanders. This was the first time I felt like cooking at home would have been better. Our food took a very long time to come to the table, when it did, it was cold. I ordered the "lightly" breaded shrimp, which had so much breading that I was able to scrape some off and there was still a coating that remained. Even if the food weren't so bad, our server, who refused to make eye contact made the experience even worse. There were times it seemed as though she wanted to avoid the table not serve us. This was a disappointing visit, hopefully, not the new norm......I hope the style and ambiance that I have learned to love returns soon!!! read more

Brought our family here for our daughters 23rd. Amazing service from Ashley! Great food and atmosphere per usual. Loved the vibe, volume, ambiance...everything ! All three steaks had too much char unfortunately. All were cooked properly, just a little too much char. Will not deter us in the least! read more