We were so excited to try this place. Worst experience we've had in years! The pancakes were so undercooked that it was literally batter in the center. (I've never seen anything like that before!) The French toast had good flavor, but it was extremely undercooked and still cold in the center! The coffee was cold. We waited 20 minutes for new food and the pancakes were burnt to a crisp and the French toast was soggy (but not as bad as previous order, which was inedible.) Our server was nice, but it took over 10 minutes for her to run our credit card and after that experience we were already running late for our plans. read more

Had breakfast with my sisters yesterday. First, the dining area is big, but not noisy. We were seated immediately and had great service. The Pumpkin Waffle and Pancakes are delicious. Get them now while they are still on the menu. My sister had the eggs & loved the potatoes. My coffee cup was never empty and the Beignets are fabulous, so be sure to get some. We will be back. Thank you. read more

ambience, cleanliness, food and price are outstandin! Ji'm the owner is often there making sure everyone is happy.. ! I highly recommend trying Good Eats!! read more

Typically have pretty good service from the time you walk in the door. I realize they were busy but a smile goes a long way. Waited 45 min to get food. Food is also usually very good but was disappointed this time around. Side of potatoes missing, gravy on biscuits was Luke warm and overall was average. Server at the bar was managing her area well. read more

Wow! Always on the lookout for new breakfast options that aren't just greasy spoon diners, I think I've found a new favorite. Fresh quality of food, options available & preparation more than make up for somewhat higher prices. You are definitely get to what you are paying for with large portions & delicious flavors. Everything was prepared perfectly & tasted amazing. Staff was attentive & very nice. Definitely recommend & will be back soon! read more

See all

My daughter and I had a wonderful experience here today for lunch. We both ordered the avocado chicken sandwich, which was excellent! Our server, Joel, was attentive and very pleasant. I also loved the Chai latte! read more

Really had high hopes for this place. We stopped by on Saturday at 10:30 and were seated right away. I ordered the Brisket Hash ($18) and my husband ordered the Steak and Eggs ($19) and upgraded the side to hashbrowns ($2). I'm not sure what quality of meat was used but it was slimy, flavorless and reminded me of something you would get in a microwaveable TV dinner. There was so much gravy on the meal that the potatoes were just a soggy mess. My husband's meal was nothing to write home about. A tiny cut of steak and the hashbrowns were basically flavorless. We did enjoy the bloody Mary's and felt that they were reasonably priced at $6/each. For over $50 for breakfast on a less than mediocre breakfast we won't be back. read more

Stopped in for breakfast. Everything was great - the Awesome Croissant Sandwich, Sweet Potato Waffle, and Bloody Mary were delish. A solid local joint with unique options that we don't have enough of! read more

Service was a bit slow. I thought it's worth it if the food is outstanding. I was here for breakfast. I ordered the vegetable hash. It was cold. Literally cold. Maybe not enough wait staff? I really wanted to love this place. The decor is interesting and it had a nice vibe. I just wanted hot breakfast. Too bad! The flavors were spot on and they might have a diamond if they hire more servers. People want cooked food served hot, not cold. Tried the "Cinnamon Beignets " they were still raw in the middle. I might try again for lunch. read more

Quality food for brunch. We had the pancakes with real maple syrup and the chicken salad croissant. It was the most delicious chicken salad that I have had in a long time. read more

Good Eats Cafe - Chicken salad sandwich with sweet potato fries - Salad Near Me - Pewaukee, Wisconsin

Really enjoyed trying out this new breakfast/brunch/lunch place! Loved the space and menu-including full bar! They roast their own coffee and know their way around the griddle! read more

My husband and I went here this morning after I saw them on Fox 6. We love going out for breakfast but were hesitant going to a strip mall. I'm so glad we gave it a shot! The service was fantastic, the ambiance is sophisticated yet cozy and the manager, Joe was actively working the room making sure all customers were happy. We each got a special. I got the after workout scramble with mushrooms, spinach and feta and my husband got the pumpkin pancakes. Both were delicious and both were good healthy portions. We each tried a different coffee and liked them both. My husband also ordered orange juice. It's fresh squeezed!! It was so refreshing. PLEASE patronize this establishment! Lake Country needs more fresh foodie establishments. Keep this one here! read more

Good Eats Cafe - After workout scramble in foreground and pumpkin pancakes in the background. - Salad Near Me - Pewaukee, Wisconsin

Thoughtful and creative menu. Everything we ordered was fresh and superb! I had the house omelette and green salad. It was perfectly cooked and the salad was tossed in this refreshing lemon vinaigrette. You can tell they spend a lot of time and love on each plate. My son couldn't get enough of the chicken dumpling soup and my daughter devoured her fluffy chocolate chip pancake. We can't wait to go back. read more

Great hearty breakfasts, the sweet potato waffle is a favorite. They also offer gluten free options, which is much appreciated by my family.

Server was very pleasant, but overall service was slow. Food was mediocre, our eggs Benedict were not served hot, eggs were over cooked, and ham was deli meat. Can't rate other meals but this was a one and done for us. read more

Great service and excellent food!! Not to mention their delicious coffee. Love the bright atmosphere and love that it's close to home :)

We went there for breakfast. Not busy. Plenty of wait staff however, most of the time, they (4 waitresses) were huddled around a gentleman at a back table who appeared to be some sort of boss. Coffee was just ok. French toast was run of the mill with orange sauce which was good but would have been better heated up since it made the French toast cold when you poured it over the toast. Omelet was just ok. Nothing to write home about. Berries were good but you had to pay five dollars extra for that. Toast was cold. There was some kind of music in the background but too quiet to discern what it was. Very quiet. Not a homey place. Cold atmosphere. Give me a happy place with decent food anytime. Would not go back. read more

I am a regular customer at Good Eats, I have enjoyed breakfast there with my wife many times. They have many offerings on the menu, so there's something for everyone. The food quality is consistent. I especially like their Crab Cake Benedict and Portabella Frittata. They are not always perfect, but as close as you could get. This is not a fast food restaurant, if you want that, go to Qwik Trip, and buy a sausage biscuit. read more

Not sure why these guys are only at 4 stars and 12 reviews. Had the brisket hash with a Demi glaze on it. Over easy eggs. Out of this world. Can't wait to go back and try something else. read more

The place looks great and has a short menu of specialty breakfast/sandwich options. Great coffee, well-cooked food and delightful service. Will eat again. read more

Second time here. First time was good, but on our second visit we waited 30 minutes to get cold runny eggs, and overdone potatoes. The toast and sausage were good, but the cooks need to learn that eggs over medium do not have clear yolk. Our server offered to have them remade, but this was 10 minutes after being served and we did not want to wait even longer. We probably will not go back. read more

We went in on 1/2/23. They were fairly busy. We asked to eat at the bar. There were 6-8 other people at the bar. A waitress/bartender took our drink order (coffee) and then took our order (eggs benedict and French toast). It took 30 minutes. During that time the person who took our order didn't ask if we wanted more coffee or status on our order. In fact she refused to remake eye contact. Food finally arrived but no silverware. We had to ask the hostess for silverware. Eggs Benedict, English muffin not toasted or even warm. French toast barely warm. Nobody asked how our food was until we asked for a check. Left most of the food. That being said the gentleman/maybe owner did take care of us. We have had solid meals there in the past. read more

Really cute restaurant & a nice addition to the area. I had the flatbread & enjoyed it as something different for breakfast. Husband had the crab cake eggs benedict & enjoyed those as well. Service was very slow on a morning when the restaurant was at maybe 20% capacity. Food was not overly warm & my egg was cooked too long (or was under a warmer too long). Yolk was not runny at all, but thankfully this was not a major component to the dish. I really feel that the food sat for awhile before being brought to the table. All in all, I'll give them another try because I liked the space & the food was tasty even at a lukewarm temperature. read more

Overpriced and under served. We opted for breakfast here after church on Sunday. We knew the coffee was good having been here before. However I opted for a Cafe Au Lait, which was OK but a bit pricey at $6.50, which was not shown on the menu, by the way. I ordered the usual "eggs your way" which I ordered "basted." They came as poached, but I ate them anyway as they were poached OK and I also like poached. I ordered fruit instead of potatoes. The server offered berries for an "up-charge" which I opted for. Later found out the up-charge was $5.00 which seems a bit pricey for a small bowl of strawberries and blueberries. And we had to remind them we ordered berries as they brought the usual melon pieces with the breakfast. My wife opted for the veggie hash, topped with two poached eggs. She said it was good. Service was unfortunately quite slow. We waited quite a while for our food and our coffees. There appeared to be plenty of servers working so we had to assume the problem was in the kitchen. We noticed other patrons also waiting quite a while for their orders also. I would say service has definitely slowed since our last visit here. Wait staff was friendly and interactive, which was appreciated, but we'll have to think twice about stopping again. The restaurant is comparable in menu offerings to First Watch in Brookfield, but serve times here were WAY slower. read more

Good Eats, needs a lot of work to live up to its name. Stopped in with the wife on a weekday morning. We were greeted by two nice waitresses who informed us it was only the second day for one and she was training the other. We were only the second table occupied at about nine am. We asked for coffee which seems to be somewhat of a signature item, but it was only OK. No choice of strong or mild variety. The menu sounded appetizing with quite a few choices, all in the general range of $12- 16. I ordered the bagel w cream cheese and salmon, which came with a bit of fruit. I was a bit underwhelmed when it came. An open faced small bagel which was soft and not chewy like most, cr. cheese and some greens and two cherry tomatoes cut in half. Not like any lox and bagel I've eaten. The taste was good, but... My wife ordered a sweet potato waffle. Again, a bit disappointing.first, we needed to wait about 20-25 min. after I was served. For some reason the waffle maker was acting up. We thought the flavor of the two little waffles was ok but they weren't as crusty as any waffle should be. Again a little cut up thinly sliced fruit. They did apologize for the wait and comped a small plate of thinly sliced fruit. As I waited I placed a side order of "crispy potatoes" which ended up as a small plate of about 1/2 in.cubes fried in the deep fryer,$3.50. Not crispy, but brown. Ok. As we finished up, the head cook (manager?,part owner?) came to discuss our meal and really wanted feedback, so I hope we can chalk our disappointment to the recent opening. They definitely needed more work and maybe a soft opening to gain feedback before announcing that they were open for regular business. read more

Can't put your menu online? That is business 101. Hope you figure it out. This is a ridiculous way to open a restaurant.

Just recently went to GOOD EATS for the first time and it won't be my last. The food was amazing. I had the eggs Benedict, one of the best i ever had. My friend had the meat omelette which was great. OUR SERVER Michelle was beyond great. Very knowledgeable on the menu. She made our experience even better. I will always request her when i go back read more

This says staff wears masks. That is not true! When asked the young man said "well we can't or maybe could". We left. We are medical people. This is not acceptable but I understand it is in Waukesha county. read more

The crab cake eggs benedict was very good and the staff were friendly! Seeing the coffee roaster in house was a fun addition!

Went to Good Eats for a lunch/brunch. The food was amazing! All of our entrees were delicious! We had the omelettes, beignets, and mimosas (tequila sunrise and Door County cherry). I will be recommending them to everyone! Can't wait to go back! read more

Very slow service. Pricey. Sat outside. Could use a little more attention. Food was good though.

First time here came at noon, food was delicious but the service was very slow- don't come here if you're expecting a quick in and out! The biscuits and gravy were good but they threw the eggs on top/in so I didn't even get to eat those.. ask for it on the side! read more

We were nervous about going out during COVID but made the right call choosing Good Eats. My husband and I (and baby in stroller) enjoyed a nice brunch here this morning. I had the French toast and he had the egg sandwich. Everything was yummy, but the best part was the pretty and delicious mocha. We were allowed to sit wherever we wanted so we chose the corner of the private room, which made us even more comfortable. Our server (Sadie?) was sweet and very attentive. We will be back! read more

The best breakfast in Lake Country! Awesome service and a fun, unique, and tasty menu. Once you go here, you won't want to go anywhere else. Thanks Good Eats. You're tops with us! read more

No masks being worn...no hand washing. Asked about it and told it was too hot in the kitchen. I'm in the medical field I can't tell my patients that. Good luck hope no one gets COVID like other restaurants and have to close. read more

Bright, modern, attentive and friendly staff, outstanding coffee and great food. What's not to like? I've been a couple times for lunch and once for breakfast, and will definitely be returning more often for the breakfast. read more

Fantastic service (sat at the bar) and amazing food (we split the crab cake benedict). Also it's really cute inside! I only wish it was closer, we'd go every week! read more

The wait was sooo long and we waited for 2 hours the food was cold and there were hairs in my food never going back.

I just discovered this wonderful healthy eating café, a hidden gem in Pewaukee. It is behind the Pick N Save and close to Costco in the strip mall. I had one of the best gluten-free healthy lunch I have eaten and then another time had an amazing breakfast and the best coffee! There is some outdoor seating but the inside seating is large and spacious. I so hope these folks can make it! I don't know them but I do know they opened the week that Covid was announced so I wish them well read more

Great stuff! Friendly owner and staff. Great eats! If you like coffee check this out-some unique and very tasty opportunities! You will enjoy this place. read more