Review #1000!!! Where did the time go?! When I hear the word PIE, my response is ALWAYS, yes please! I seriously could eat sweet or savory pie for every meal and never get tired of it. When I discovered there was a pie specialty place so close to me, I had to try it! I stopped by on a Friday early afternoon. I had never been before, so rather than ordering ahead online to pickup at their convenient walk up window, I opted to go inside. Inside is small but oh so cute. During more normal times it looks like they have a nice little dining area too. I was happy to see they still had a decent selection even early afternoon! The only thing they were out of that I wanted to try was Chicken Pot Pie, but the owner was in the process of making more and even offered for me to stop back a little later. I decided id save that for another time as there was so much goodness right infront of me! I went with a mini goat cheese and sun dried tomato quiche, a mozzarella and pepperoni hand pie, a cardamom cinnamon roll, and a mixed berry mini pie. Each was special in its own way. The quiche had a thick crust, and a moist perfectly cooked filling. The components of it were fresh and delicious. The hand pie was rich with generous filling, and the crust was nicely flaky. The cardamom roll was spicy and sweet. My favorite of all the above was the mixed berry pie. Not only did it have a great crust and nice topping, but the filling was just right. It wasn't overly sweet or gelatinous, just fruity and fresh. I realized as I was eating these items that the crust seemed different than any I had before. I didn't realize until I went back to the website that it was actually gluten free! I never would have guessed! The owner actually locally sources as much as she can, including from her own garden and family farm! The products available do change but range from hand pies, quiches, full and mini pies, rolls, cookies, and breads. The inventory on the website is accurate and updated. Specials can also be found posted on social media. I am definitely impressed with this local gem! read more

See all

Couldn't locate the "Feel Good Food Stop" on Yelp, so I am reviewing under the bakery (The Fork and Pie), which is essentially the same business, just different products (i.e. breakfast vs. pies). You all good with that? All right. Go here. It is the sweetest little shop working it's tail off to please their customers with authentically baked and built foods. There may be a line, or it may take a few minutes to build your sandwich. Chill. This is why you came here. If you wanted a three day old sandwich in cellophane you could have stopped at the Shell station. Her BLT w/ chicken wrap is awesome. So are the baked goods. Secret inside tip- call 15 minutes before you get there and it will be ready when you walk in. But if it's not, relax. She is bootstrapping her business and doing a great job! read more

The Fork and Pie Bakery - The hours are a bit different, so take note. - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Been here once on a Saturday and inventory was limited. The only pie was a blueberry and lime pie with burnt crust. I am not a fan of gluten free crust with oats. It was fairly good except wasn't fresh. I am guessing it was baked on Thursday. At 22 dollars a little high. The 3 dollar cookies were giant and tasty if you dont mind added salt on top. They had chocolate chip and sugar with sprinkles. My wife got the small 7 dollar quiche. It had spples and sausage. Was tasty but high in price. I would like to try again and will uodate my review. I dont understand why the pie crustxwas also very salty read more

See all

A nice little bakery with some tasty treats that my family enjoyed the other day for 'Pi day'.

Under new management judging by signage. It would be unfair to rate them based on my experience 2 years ago. I've heard their gluten free baked goods are awesome for gluten free. read more

So I sent a Facebook message asking about a particular type of pie. The owner responded to me right away... They didn't have it, but they could make me one today. I didn't know what size I wanted, or how long it would take or any of that. She step by step went through the whole process without me in individual Facebook messages until setting up my exact pickup time. Got there it was fresh, hot, and ready, nd so I grabbed two other treats too. The cherry scone, blueberry muffin and my custom Derby pie were all amazing. The scone was crumbly and full of cherries with confectioner sugar on top, the muffin was a little buttery, but mild in sweetness, letting the tart Berry flavors win out. And derby pie is just a great idea. Only thing better than the treats? The customer service! Check them out! read more

See all

This is a placeholder review for this newly opened business in Newtown Good product, but small selection and fairly limited hours. They have both savory and sweet/dessert pies, as well as cinnamon rolls, cookies, scones, bars, and loaves of bread. No donuts, no danish, no coffeecakes, or anything else like that The blueberry lime individual-sized pie I had was pretty good, as was a gluten free gingersnap cookie. A three-bite individual sausage and apple quiche was good but for 2 bucks apiece, not much food for the money I think my favorite item thus far is the pepperoni bread, which I have seen them offer as a loaf and also as individual rolls, about the size of a large biscuit read more

See all

As a former resident of walking cities including NYC and SF, I really appreciate a good bakery where I can get a breakfast snack on the way to work. I started working down the street from Fork & Pie and had to give it a try. I was not disappointed. Their scones and muffins are fantastic and their coffee cake is to die for. I make a point to stop in here every week. From time to time, I also grab one of their delicious sweet pies to share with the family on special occasions. If you are in the area, you should definitely pay these ladies a visit... a true gem in Cincinnati! read more

Love that this place has gluten free options as well. I tried the gluten free tomato basil pie and the mixed berry pie... absolutely delicious!!!!!! read more

The Fork and Pie Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Pepperoni cheese bread made into meatball hoagie! Love this bakery don't pass it up we did and turned around everything is delicious read more

The Fork and Pie Bakery - Pepperoni Cheddar meatball sandwich! The bread is delicious - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

picked up some quiches for a bridal shower and the process was so easy and the quiche was SO GOOD. the spinach, sun dried tomato, goat cheese quiche is the best quiche i have ever had. literally eating a slice right now. read more

Love this place! My daughter and I stop by this place every week to get their cookies! Our favorite is their sea salted triple chocolate cookie. It tastes homemade with yummy chocolate chunks! read more

Delicious mushroom and asparagus quiche, and berry crumble pie! Picked up both for Mother's Day brunch.

The most amazing cookies and tarts! Stevie worked with me to create a dessert table for my son's wedding rehearsal party. Their desserts are unique and delicious and their customer service is wonderful. I highly recommend Fork and Pie! read more

Let me tell you about one of the best sugar cookies I've had a while, spoiler alert: it was from Fork and Pie. I visited this adorable bakery in Newtown with a friend right before Christmas and I definitely would love to come back. This local biz is true farm-to-table and you never know what you'll see on the daily menu. Sweet and savory pies, photo-worthy pastries, and tasty fresh baked cookies made the decision of what to order quite the feat. I ended up going with a simple sugar cookie, and I'm so glad I did. The cookie was huge and decorated with festive sprinkles for Christmas. The bakery also had a Christmas and holiday cookie special: a whole box of 30 for 20 bucks. My friend took advantage of this great offer after being told that the cookies would freeze well. We just stopped in to get an order to go, but this charming shop also has tables and chairs for dining in. Fork and Pie was a great experience, definitely consider checking it out next time your sweet tooth has a craving! read more

See all

I drive past Fork and Pie at least twice a day and finally dropped in this morning to grab some pastries (because it's Saturday morning and who wants to cook?). It's bright and light and adorable on the inside, but the thing you really notice is the delicious smell of breakfast pies. We got a hand pie, a breakfast pie, and a cinnamon roll and they were ALL outstanding. We decided the hand pie was our favorite (it's a little delicious breakfast empanada) but you can't go wrong with any of them! Great spot, we'll be back! read more

Worth a special trip to Newtown!! (or if you're biking, this bakery is close to the bike trail) These are the best scones I have EVER eaten. Their other products look absolutely delectable too (though I can't stop buying the scones); and they have some gluten free options for those in the need. Fork and Pie is located in a small house on Main Street, and has in and out off-street parking. Yum yum yum, do yourself a favor! read more

My favorite addition to Newtown. I come here almost on a weekly basis because everything is so delicious! You honestly can't go wrong with a savory or a sweet treat! Only downfall is the hours I wish I could cure my sweet tooth more often! read more

Fork and Pie offers terrific pastries and savory pies! I am a fan of their chocolate chip cookies and their brownies too. Their brownies are especially fudgy with a hint of coffee, which I love. Their cookies have just the right amount of sea salt on top. The service is excellent. Stevie takes good care of her customers! read more

Stevie was very accommodating and professional! Fork and Pie was able to use my own recipe for lemon cream pie and make the perfect sheet pies for my wedding, and pretty last minute at that! Saved me from a disappointing snag in our plans. Thanks so much, Stevie!! read more

There are so many delicious items at Fork and Pie, but the chicken pot pie is one of the best comfort foods! Hearty, not heavy and the puff pastry top is heavenly. For dessert, you can never go wrong with a pie or my favorite, the pistachio/cranberry/ginger shortbread cookie. read more

Went there the morning of because no other shop had apple pies to buy while for some reason. Called at 9 and arrived at 9:30. They were great! Pie was delicious and well priced. I'd definitely recommend going here. read more

Went there with my wife...we're in there about 15 minutes...several things came out of their ovens while we were there...mini blueberry pies, and mini Apple pies...got one of each...got some biscotti, scones, egg and sausage savory turnover pies, and a bag of fresh roasted coffee...yeah, couldn't resist...this was on a full stomach...my son nearly cried while eating the Apple pie...grunted most of the way through it. Everything was amazing...note I know what I'm talking about...my late grandma and two late aunts all of Italian descent used to stuff me growing up with their competitive baking. In the 30s through 50s, my late grandfather "was" the best bakery in Methuen Mass. Great stuff...we'll be back soon! read more

I saw them at a local farmers market and bought a couple sea salt chocolate chip cookies and an apple pie. I am a pastry snob and these were exceptional. I will go out of my way to get more of their food. read more

Definitely worth driving to Newtown! Everything we have tried, has been excellent! The scones are my favorite. And the staff is beyond kind and helpful! read more

This was amazing! I had the best cinnamon roll ever here! Such a great location, looking forward to visiting more often! Yummy!