Wyoming Pastry Shop

400

390

5 months ago

This place is so cute, and the baked goods are amazing and the prices are decent. I work at a local business down the street - a customer brought us in some tea cookies, and I made a trip literally the next day. I got a cotton candy cupcake, a frosted cookie and a cinnamon powdered donut twist. My total was 7 bucks which isn't terrible for the number of items I got. The cookie was the star of the show for me - it was delicious and I would go back for a dozen. The cupcake was moist but was just a basic vanilla cupcake with specialty icing which is probably why it was decently priced compared to other shops with stuffed and fluffed cupcakes. The donut had a good consistency and was still warm. The staff was nice enough but did take some time to come out from the back even though there was about 6 people waiting up front. The coffee must be good because while I was there 4 locals stopped in just for that. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 1

Michelle J.

454

1472

11 months ago

Changed hands recently. I spent $24 on donuts for the office today. I'm willing to bet they were from yesterday. I was a bit embarrassed. They were crumbly and dry. Been going here for 25+ years. Sadly may be my last time here. read more

Wyoming Pastry Shop - Butterfly cookies benefit a family in need until April 15th - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Stephanie K.

157

682

1 year ago

I visited Wyoming Pastry Shop because it came highly recommended, and I was really looking forward to trying it out. Before making the 30-minute drive, I checked both the website and the Yelp page to confirm they were open, and both said they were. Unfortunately, when I arrived, there was a handwritten note on the door saying they were closed for summer break. This was incredibly frustrating and a huge inconvenience. Businesses need to make sure their hours are accurately reflected online, especially on their website and on social media. I understand the need for a break, but better communication would've saved me time, gas and disappointment. read more

Wyoming Pastry Shop - Outside - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sandy B.

1 year ago

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cassandra E.

9 months ago

This place is so cute! It has the old school, laid back pastey ship cham. We have mostly been here for the donuts and breakfast pastries. All of those have been great! Looking forward to trying their adorable cookies and cakes in the future! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Haleigh A.

400

5 months ago

Really bummed at the down turn in quality across the board. I have been a patron of this bakery my entire life and lately everything has been falling short. The cupcakes we picked up today were all dry. The red velvet was especially disappointing. The last couple of custom orders i've put in have had very little thought or creativity put into them. The stock has gone down and what they have does not appear to be fresh. I am so sad to write this review but have been disappointed so many times now. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

VA F.

9 months ago

What a charming little bakery. New owner Catie is a delight. Love the coffee shop feel. A place to gather and enjoy coffee and a pastry. Love the fresh breads and cookies. Always a stop when I'm out that way. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Colleen A.

Elite 26 All-Star

1226

486

3811

2 years ago

Wyoming Pastry Shop - Canola - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Wyoming Pastry Shop - Canoli - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Nancy B.

10 months ago

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Patricia G.

10 months ago

Great selection of sweets! Nice people! The bakery was comfortable and decorated very nicely.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ashley C.

309

950

2 years ago

Wyoming Pastry Shop - Calendar cake , calendar not centered but tasted good . - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Bruce W.

7 months ago

The Wyoming Pastry Shop is a fantastic family oriented bakery with a great line of fresh bakery goods! The staff are great, always courteous and friendly! I look forward to stopping there again soon with my family! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kraig R.

8 months ago

How do you choose which donut shop to go to in the greater Cincinnati area? Each village I felt has one and they're all outstanding. This one especially. Light, fluffy with a great crust. Chocolate long John with custard filling was perfect and the raspberry jelly filled is something I can't wait to eat again. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Milka H.

10 months ago

My fav local bakery and they make my kids birthday cake when I'm not able to make it myself. Their pumpernickel breads, donuts and cakes are just top notch. I miss their hazelnut roasted coffee as is now not offered anymore but is ok, at least the donuts and cakes are still available read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Evan W.

1 year ago

I loved it, we got a cake for my grandpa's birthday from here and it was honestly the best cake I've ever had, my cousin works there so this review is I little bit biased but the workers are super nice. Can't wait to go back read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Deborah B.

11 months ago

They have the best white and Carmel glazed filled donuts. We always get the dog a treat. He loves the donut with the sprinkles on it. I think we have tried about half of their goodies. The staff is friendly and always great to accommodate you. Will always support this bakery, one of the best. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Glenn C.

10 months ago

Everything is fresh. There is a wide variety of donuts and coffee cakes if you go early but they do sell out. My favorite is the caramel gem. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sharmeela S.

203

746

1065

3 years ago

Wyoming Pastry Shop - Dinner cake - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Adam M.

11 months ago

The Wyoming pastry shop is phenomenal. They serves a variety of delicious pastries, and the staff is very kind and very understanding the interior is clean and with a great display for the pastries. They serve a variety of seasonal decorated pastries. And Another positive note is that they allow you to make custom orders like if you need a birthday cake or a custom cheesecake. everything in the Wyoming pastry shop is delicious with something for everyone. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Amy H.

2 years ago

Stopped in at 6:00 am this morning to be greeted by a friend face offering delicious pastries and incredibly smooth and flavorful coffee. It is a great way to start off a rainy morning. read more

Wyoming Pastry Shop - Cream puff! - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

TJ W.

106

247

3 years ago

Early mornings with Wyoming Pastry have been a staple in our family for years. The best coffee and donuts that you could ask for. Always so soft and fresh. Their tea cookies, cupcakes and cakes are always great- having such a wonderful local shop is a benefit to the Wyoming Community as well as people who work or travel through the area. Their staff is always so nice and the bakery is warm and inviting! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Stephanie P.

2 years ago

Both women working looked me up and down as I walked in. They overcharged me for two donuts and a coffee and walked to the back of store when I needed milk for my coffee. I walked out of the shop without coffee so disgusted by my treatment, I will never go back. I live in one of the biggest and most expensive homes in Wyoming and because they judged me on what I had on they lost a customer. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Amanda Y.

Elite 21

144

121

6 years ago

Delicious, very reasonably priced baked goods. I've tried and enjoyed the chocolate fudge bar (fantastic icing!), numerous cupcakes (yellow or chocolate cake with vanilla or chocolate icing), iced sugar cookies, an old fashioned donut, and more. There's a large selection of everything from breads to cakes to breakfast goods. Overall, a great spot if you're looking for something sweet in the Wyoming area. read more

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 7

Oh no 0

Luke V.

2 years ago

I love to come here on Saturday mornings. They have decent service and really good doughnuts. They also have holiday cookies and cupcakes. The only issue is that the building isn't very big and can only support 10-15 people. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dan B.

Elite 24

4 years ago

Everyone in my family loves donuts from Wyoming Pastry Shop, even Sneaky Pete. This week the gals put together a special treat for him, adding bacon for his birthday! read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

David R.

3 years ago

Whatever they used to fry the glazed twist doughnut in tasted bad. Not sure if the oil was old, but had a very bad aftertaste in my mouth. Donuts look great! Wish it would've tasted like it looked. It also needed more icing. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ana Clara S.

5 years ago

Their chocolate dinner cakes are out of this world. My husband and I love it. Everyone is also very nice and helpful. They also open pretty early which is awesome. read more

Wyoming Pastry Shop - a chocolate birthday cake with sparklers - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mesy D.

334

564

6 years ago

My sister and her husband had a small intimate vow renewal. I wanted to contribute and celebrate with them. A close friend and her family uses Wyoming Pastry shop for thier cakes. It's been a few years since I had the pleasure of enjoying it. I ordered an ombre cake in shades of purple. The cake was very pretty. But even better was the cake inside. Yellow, soft, fresh, moist and simply delicious. It was a great hit. I'm so appreciative for the service and for the awesome gift to my family. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Elyse F.

Elite 24

197

1513

9702

8 years ago

Wyoming Pastry Shop is an adorable little pastry shop, located a couple of doors down from the Wyoming Meat Market. The pastry shop is usually closed when we visit the meat market. This visit they were open. We were excited to finally get to try something from them. There are lots of yummy looking pastries, and cakes. We ended up getting a few mini key lime tarts to go. The dot of meringue on top had a nice firm consistency. The key lime filling was not as tart as I prefer it. Crust had a slightly flakey texture. My children absolutely loves them. We look forward to trying more goodies in the future. read more

Wyoming Pastry Shop - Mini key lime tarts - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Bruce L.

6 years ago

Amazing concoctions and even better service. Wanted to get a few sets of cupcakes for a socially distanced wedding shower gift presentation at work for a few team members who got married recently. Turned out better than expected, communication was fantastic and delivery to the car was a nice touch. Delicious work, more than reasonable price and beautiful results make a customer for life. read more

Wyoming Pastry Shop - Bride & Groom Cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Emily G.

Elite 22

238

290

216

9 years ago

This spot and a quintessential Wyoming neighborhood staple! Whether you need a treat today take to the office or your kids have a sweet tooth, the pasty shop has it! You can always count on Wyoming pastry for fresh high quality baked goods. I also appreciate how they staff the bakery with locals- especially Wyoming high school students! Builds great pride in the community! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Zaria D.

228

563

1482

8 years ago

I went in one morning before work. It was super busy which I figured it would be. There were regulars there. Some drinking their morning coffee and chatting. Some grabbing their items to go. There was several staff assisting people and they were moving fast. I took some time to look before I ordered. When the young woman go to me I know what I wanted. I saw one of my favorite sweet treats, cannolis. Not only did they have regular cannolis, they also had the cupcake version. So that was my order. It was not to expensive, not sure what I was expecting. I got my items to go and was excited to give them a try. I must say I was not disappointed. The cannolis taste fresh and was flavorful. I have had a hard time finding spots here with good cannolis and now I have. The cupcake was delicious. The center was like the center of a cannoli. I ate them both for breakfast and was not disappointed. I have heard a lot about this spot and it was a positive experience. I will definitely be back to try other items that they have. Staff was friendly, there was a nice selection, and it taste good. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Amanda M.

317

10 years ago

You can feel the tradition and love in this place. As soon as you walk in you're greeted with a welcoming smile. The employees are happy to answer any questions and tell you about their products and are always moving keeping the shop clean, decorating, etc. They all seem to love their jobs. I came to do some social media stuff for work and they were beyond accommodating. They also kept restocking the case which ensured everything was fresh. They have such a wide variety here. They have bread, donuts, cupcakes, cannolis, cookies, cheese pockets, the list goes on and on. The woman behind the counter told me that everything is made in-house from the icing to batter. I got a carrot cake cupcake and it was very sweet but so good. If you want to see some friendly faces and get a sweet treat come here! read more

Wyoming Pastry Shop - Carrot Cake Cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Cindy G.

Elite 18

2567

1022

6622

10 years ago

The cutest little pastry shop you ever did see! Located in quaint Wyoming, this little mom and pop is situated right in the middle of the neighborhood biz strip and is a perfect stop along your walk. They have the standards including: donuts, coffee, cookies etc. and they they have some more exciting items like cannoli's and cheese crowns. Everything is made fresh and they treat you like family when you walk through the door. read more

Wyoming Pastry Shop - Treats for a meeting! - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 6

Oh no 0

Amy C.

Elite 23

328

255

389

10 years ago

Super quaint, old-fashioned bakery with all the classics on hand - donuts, cakes, cut-out decorated cookies and even mini cannolis. My husband and I stopped in to pick up a couple treats as we were in the neighborhood. Growing up nearby, this was the bakery my father-in-law frequented Saturday mornings to pick up donuts for my husband when he was a kid and he has fond memories of the place. I also ran smack into a pleasant childhood memory as the pastry shop had tea cookies with soft icing for sale, very similar to the now defunct Grote Bakery that sold them in my childhood. We also tried glazed and sugar donuts and chocolate cupcakes that were fresh and tasty. read more

Wyoming Pastry Shop - Tea cookies with soft icing. - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Wyoming Pastry Shop - Decorated sugar cookie and chocolate cupcake. - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Tara K.

Elite 17

707

366

11 years ago

Looking to travel back in time to a place where everyone knew everyone else in town? A place where all of the lawns are green and manicured and all of the town's people are smiling and friendly? Well, that's Wyoming, Ohio. And inside of this cute little town, that's easy to miss if you're not looking, is the Wyoming Pastry Shop. It has all the basic necessities of any good pastry shop. The employees are quick and friendly and people seem to enjoy hanging out in the space. If you're looking for a nice escape for the day or even are traveling north from Cincinnati and want to avoid traffic on 75, this place could make your day. Employees aren't allowed to accept tips, which is a practice I'm not normally a fan of--especially when they're as helpful and friendly as the Wyoming Pastry Shop's are. read more

Wyoming Pastry Shop - A winning combo. - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Wyoming Pastry Shop - Wyoming Pastry Shop = love - Bakeries Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Olivia M.

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

131

295

882

11 years ago

So yummy! Such a cute little bakery in the middle of Wyoming. There cakes are absolutely amazing. Had someone bring in one to work for a co-worker and I just had to go back. I got a carrot cake cupcake, which was to die for! I will definitely be back! Get here early though before all the goodies are gone. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Heather L.

Elite 26 All-Star

251

1411

5827

10 years ago

Stopped in while in the area because I heard they had cannoli, which aren't easy to come by in Cincy! What a cute little shop in such a nice little village. Very sweet staff. My cannoli was excellent, I just wish it was bigger (it was a mini). I also tried a cream puff (mini as well) and it truly was the best cream puff filling I have ever had. Can't wait to come back and try some more goodies! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Hollyn G.

5 years ago

My carrot cake cupcake was delicious! Not to mention one of the biggest cupcakes I've had! This pregnant lady is happy!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jared T.

Elite 19

141

219

7 years ago

Decent coffee and large selection of pastries. I tried the pecan danish and I spent the next couple hours recovering from the sweetness.

Business owner information

Phillip R.

Thank You Jared for the 5 stars ! And the nice (and funny) review! We…

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 2

See more reviews

More info about Wyoming Pastry Shop

505 Wyoming Ave
Cincinnati, OH 45215
Directions
(513) 821-0742
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.wyomingpastryshop.com/

Hours

What time does Wyoming Pastry Shop open?

Wyoming Pastry Shop opens at 6:00 AM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.

What time does Wyoming Pastry Shop close?

Wyoming Pastry Shop is closed on Monday and Sunday.Wyoming Pastry Shop closes at 4:00 PM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.

Mon, Sun ClosedTue-Sat 6:00 AM - 4:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Wyoming Pastry Shop take credit cards?

Yes, Wyoming Pastry Shop takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Wyoming Pastry Shop have catering options?

No, Wyoming Pastry Shop does not have catering options.

Indoor Amenities

Does Wyoming Pastry Shop allow dogs?

Yes, Wyoming Pastry Shop allows dogs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Wyoming Pastry Shop have bike parking?

Yes, Wyoming Pastry Shop has bike parking.

Does Wyoming Pastry Shop have parking?

Yes, Wyoming Pastry Shop has parking options. Street Parking

Other Amenities

Is Wyoming Pastry Shop wheelchair accessible?

No, Wyoming Pastry Shop is not wheelchair accessible.

From the Business

Specialties

We are established veteran owned small town bakery with over 84 years in business. We have a large product line to choose from, we can also do custom items for special occasions. We keep the small town mom and pop approach to providing you with an experience you’ll remember.

History

Established in 1934.

Serving the Cincinnati area for over 80 years with quality baked goods. Priding ourselves on giving our wonderful customers great product at a fair price to keep them coming back and building happy memories.

Meet the Business Owner: Phil and Kimberly R.

Phil and Kim are the fifth owners of this bakery. Phil is a graduate of Wyoming high school and U.S. Army veteran. He started working in the bakery in high school cleaning the store and doing evening preparations, after returning from military service, he came back to the family business. Kimberly is a Cincinnati native who started baking and decorating as soon as she could reach the table, working for a local bakery at 18 she developed a solid foundation for decorating and baking, moving to Las Vegas and working in fine upscale desserts she honed her skills and continues to seek new techniques. Moving back to Cincinnati she came to work at the pastry shop where we met and fell in love, it’s been 30 years and our passion is only getting stronger.

More Info

Health Score

Ask the Community - Wyoming Pastry Shop

Do you make an awesome lemon meringue pie? It's for my father's 80th birthday so if it's not your strong suit that's ok but if it is I'd love to order🙌💕. Thank you

I'm not sure. I'd call them. If they do make them, get them. Everything I've had from them have been outstanding

View question details

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Bakeries 5,054 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Brown Bear Bakery

4.8(431 reviews)

8.5 mi•Over-the-Rhine

Okay my BFF and I walked in after getting a pizza near by and we figured why not…read more You step in and you are greeted immediately. The place smells yummy. We got a brown bear butter iced coffee and a molasses cookie. Let me just say the cookie alone is worth driving here. I mean seriously it is the best molasses cookie I have ever had. The coffee is also very good. I would drive back for the amazing customer service and the Cookie. I do want to try other items as well.

Going on a Sunday was definitely a choice, cause there was a line, but it moved pretty fast. I got…read moreone of the seasonals, the cherry vanilla latte, and it was pretty good. Definitely espresso/coffee heavy which I love at times. The blueberry cornbread cake is very corn forward and dense and averagely sweet. The people working were very kind and despite the inside being small, it was pretty packed. Seems like a good wfh spot too.

Ratatouille focaccia and everything bagel croissant

Brown butter latte and banana bread twice baked

See all

Interior

Paris Baguette

4.3(176 reviews)

9.2 mi•Downtown

You can easily spend a lot of money in here as you walk through and see all the delicious French…read morepastries. It is so tempting to grab more than you need especially the delicious "pain au chocolat." It's self serve so be careful!

Really good breakfast pastries and excellent black coffee. Thought it was fairly reasonable in…read moreprice.

The chef working magic

See all

Iced caramel latte

Golden Hands Bakery

4.9(103 reviews)

7.1 mi

This place has some of the best donuts I've ever had. There…read morewas a blueberry one I got that was a mix between a croissant and a donut and it blew my socks off. We were not planning to go here on our way to go ride bikes, and we saw "hot fresh donuts" and a line out the door and made a U-Turn and didn't regret it at all.

We tried Golden Hands Bakery for the first time about a month ago and WOW it is soooo good! We've…read morealready been a second time and it definitely is our new favorite donut shop in town! The inside is clean and bright with bakery cases full of so many yummy choices, it's hard to choose! We've tried a lot of different flavors and each one has been amazing! The custard filled donut is light and fluffy with an insane amount of filling. The cherry thingaling was delicious, you could really taste the cherries in the glaze and they had whole fresh cherries in it as well and the donut was phenomenal; it was a light and airy fritter style donut. Added bonus is that it's a friendly family owned small business, which we love to support!

Chocolate filled donut

So many choices, so little stomach room!

See all

Boosalis Baking

4.9(128 reviews)

4.9 mi

If youre looking for a good snack before, during, or just cause , this is the spot. There's nothing…read morelike a little pick-me-up from Boosalis. It's not a fancy place--but that's part of the charm. What they are is consistent, full of flavor, and always worth coming back to. The bakery window is unmatched, especially right when they first open. Everything is fresh and hits every time. And the owners? Always so kind--it feels like walking into your grandparents' kitchen. Definitely stop by for patties for staff or just a crossainy with your coffee.

So many pass this bakery as it is a small storefront on a busy street but it is worth the visit. I…read morehad a friend who lived in France and he told me their croissants rivaled the ones he had in Europe. Their European breakfast bread with the chocolate orange flavor is so perfect with a hot cup of coffee. His coffee is also so delicious. Some people come in just for the coffee and always get their baguette!

See all

Cafe Mochiko

4.6(234 reviews)

6.7 mi•Walnut Hills

Everyone told us to try this place. We wandered in here…read moretoday and I see what they're talking about. Everything we tried was absolutely amazing. And what a cute little place.

Cafe Mochiko serves some of the best ramen in Cincinnati, and it's traditional and authentic. By…read moreday it's a Japanese-style bakery, and by night it turns into a casual ramen spot run by a married couple who clearly care about the craft. The service is great, and the staff is happy to explain the menu. A few things to know before you go. They don't take reservations. It's a waiting list, and you have to be there in person to put your name down, so plan for a wait at busy times. Prices are a bit steep for a bowl of ramen. Customizing your bowl isn't allowed, and there's no takeout. Dishes also sometimes sell out for the night, so go earlier if there's something you really want to try. Worth it for the quality, but set your expectations on price, wait times, and flexibility.

Paw paw croissant

See all

Ramp laing danish, kimchi and egg croissant, and bbq pork snow bun

The BonBonerie

4.1(403 reviews)

6.6 mi•O'Bryonville

We live very close to the BonBonerie and I have to resist the urge to go every day very good…read morepastries and I've also done their tea time with some of my friends. Staff is always super nice as well. Highly recommend!

I've been coming here for a couple of years now, and somehow I still leave wanting to come back for…read moremore. The staff have always been lovely, but honestly, it's the sweets and brunch that keep me coming back! They always have seasonal treats and cakes rotating throughout the year, so there's usually something different to try each time. Their cookies are almost too pretty to eat because they're individually piped by hand, which is seriously impressive. They are definitely on the sweeter side, so don't expect a subtle sugar cookie, but they're perfect when you're in the mood to treat yourself. My personal recommendation is the small button cookies. They're so cute, creamy, and pair really well with their teas, especially since the tea helps balance out the sweetness. The sugar cookies have more of a firm, stiff texture, so I personally prefer the button cookies. Their brunch is delicious too, although the wait can be a little longer at times. If you want the full tea-room experience, I highly recommend making a reservation since that's usually where you'll get the multi-tiered tray filled with an assortment of sweets and savory mini sandwiches. It's definitely more of an experience than just grabbing a quick bite. The cafe itself is adorable and has cute decorations throughout, with a separate back area dedicated to takeout sweets. It makes the whole place feel like a little dessert wonderland, especially when they have their seasonal decorations up. Overall, this is definitely somewhere I'd recommend trying at least once. Whether you're coming for brunch, afternoon tea, seasonal sweets, or just looking for a cute spot to catch up with the girls, there's always something fun to eat--and something new to discover on your next visit!

Beautiful tea tray!

Brownie, berry crumble bar, cookies

See all

Biscuits and lemon blueberry pound cake

North South Baking

4.6(54 reviews)

10.2 mi•City West

My local bakery! Lucky for me North South is close by! This lovely place has some of the best…read morepastries. I highly recommend their signature "cronuts" they are a mix of a croissant and a donut, usually filled with something amazing and rolled in sugar. They have savory pastries, and breakfast sammys as well. There is coffee to pair with your pastries. For me, they have never missed.

I visited to purchase pastries for a family get together. The staff was incredibly helpful and the…read morevariety of pastries made it difficult to narrow down decisions. We ordered approximately 10 different options and none of them were disappointing. The pastries were light, full, flavorful and fresh. The pastries I got were supposed to last 4 days. They barely lasted two. Whether you need one or 30 pastries, this is the place to stop in.

Display

See all

Breakfast sandwich

Sebastian Bakehouse

4.8(92 reviews)

4.6 mi

Sebastian Bakehouse is a pastry shop, located in Blue Ash at Summit Park. They offer a variety of…read moreartisan pastries, desserts, and a weekday lunch menu with sandwiches from their sister spot, Alveo. If you're looking to try a new pastry shop, definitely check them out! There wasn't much service that had to do with this besides them boxing up the pastries. And the shop is little inside so don't expect to eat inside either. This is more of a takeout spot.

Who doesn't like French butter and pastries? I'm in love with all of their creations , they lack…read morenothing. You want savory they have it you want sweet they have it . And now theyve added sandwiches and coffee. Get parking look in the bakery window choose and pay . One visit will turn into your weekly routine. I'm glad they decided to bring their creations to blue ash. I've been way more times than I review.

Biscoff Pull Apart

Inside the pumpkin petite gateaux

See all

Two Seven Two

4.7(51 reviews)

6.4 mi

SO delicious! Last time I visited, my friend and I split one savory and one sweet pastry. The…read moregarlic parmesan was delicious, but my favorite was the earl grey orange blossom pastry. The sugar it was rolled in was even infused with early grey flavor! The interior is on the smaller side, but there is seating and Ludlow Square is only a short walk away. Make sure you come early, because pastries do sell out throughout the day!

They have quickly become one of Cincinnati's most talked‑about bakeries, and for good reason. Their…read moreclassic croissant is everything you want it to be, flaky, sweet, buttery, and beautifully layered. The pecan roll is another standout. It is loaded with pecans, sticky in the best way, and easily one of the best in the city. When they're on, they're really on. One thing I noticed was that the setup could use a little refinement. With both coffee and bakery items coming from the same counter, the line gets congested fast and the shop is quite small. A separate line for coffee and tea offerings - they have a bunch - and pastries would make the experience smoother and match the quality of what they're serving. They do offer vegan options, which I personally have no interest in, but just an fyi. Overall, they deliver excellent pastries and has the potential to be even better with a few small tweaks to the flow and menu variety. Still absolutely worth a visit, especially for that croissant and pecan roll.

Cacio e Pepe brioche

See all

F & Goode Desserts

4.8(80 reviews)

10.4 mi•City West

Incredibly tasty stuff being made at this quaint little neighborhood bakery. Place has been clean…read moreand welcoming every time I've stopped in. The pastries and cookies are always fresh and delicious. My personal favorites are the lemon bars and snickerdoodles. They also do very yummy carry out pies around the holidays. Last year I tried the pumpkin and pecan and it was the hit of Thanksgiving dinner. I highly recommend F&Goode.

The food was excellent as were the vibes. The staff member was super nice and helped us with our…read moreYelp event. I'll definitely come again!

See all

Cute decor inside

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

6 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Lady W.

7 years ago

Such a cute shop for pastries. I ended up hoarding quite a lot of sweets from Wyoming Pastry Shop. I loved how they present their pastries and it really caught my attention. Each one of the sweet treats is very delicious. Love all their cupcakes, doughnuts, cakes, cookies... ahhh love them all! It's not too sweet for me. The ingredients were blended well together to create a perfectly harmonized sweet treat. I also love the people who work for this pastry shop. Always greet people with a smile. Always eager to help. Always making me end up buying more than what I was supposed to only buy. Lol! Just kidding. Really love their pastries! read more

Jessie B.

13 years ago

I use to stop in mondays when I had meetings in wyoming, I always had a pleasant experience; however, they always seem to have one person working. This usually isn't a problem until there is more than one person in the store. Why this is I don't understand. Once I was in line for a good five minutes some young girl walked by who looked like employee and didn't bother to stop. I even saw her make a phone call on her cell phone. After I saw this I took my business down the street to half day cafe, where they know good customer service. read more

Mary P.

11 years ago

I love this place. They offer delicious, beautifully decorated cookies that are very reasonably priced. I like buying them as gifts or having them on hand at holidays. They always seem to be busy, have plenty of people behind the counter during their peak times, and offer a place to sit and enjoy a cup of coffee or tea with dessert. They've kept their original 1940's - '60's decor, feeling as though you've stepped back into a simpler place and time. read more

Sally N.

179

351

9 years ago

This pastry shop has a big heart & sweet treats to match! My favorite baked good is the "fudge bar" . Anyone who loves chocolate will revel in this chocolate layer cake with fudge filling & frosting. A true delight. The coffee behind the counter is a special blend so little more expensive but soooo worth it. Dark roast with half & half & you're good to go! read more

Echo K.

9 years ago

The Wyoming Pastry shop has amazing sweets from doughnuts to cakes! They have reasonable prices and some killer cookies! It's a great place to go for a sweet breakfast or an afternoon snack! Yummy! read more

Lauren C.

9 years ago

Owner was very unhelpful when a mistake was made on a cake we ordered. I used to order for all of my children's birthdays but will never order from them again. read more

Wyoming Pastry Shop - bakeries - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Cincinnati, Ohio Coffee near Wyoming Pastry Shop

BEST of Cincinnati, Ohio Restaurants near Wyoming Pastry Shop

BEST of Cincinnati, Ohio Things to Do near Wyoming Pastry Shop

BEST of Cincinnati, Ohio Breakfast near Wyoming Pastry Shop

BEST of Cincinnati, Ohio Desserts near Wyoming Pastry Shop

BEST of Cincinnati, Ohio Parking near Wyoming Pastry Shop

BEST of Cincinnati, Ohio Ice Cream near Wyoming Pastry Shop

BEST of Cincinnati, Ohio Shopping near Wyoming Pastry Shop

BEST of Cincinnati, Ohio Cookies near Wyoming Pastry Shop

BEST of Cincinnati, Ohio Thrift Stores near Wyoming Pastry Shop

Best of Cincinnati

Things to do in Cincinnati

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Wyoming Pastry Shop also viewed

NCH Bakery

4.1

(67 reviews)

Oh NCH Bakery- how I love you! If you like icing (which I do!)- this bakery is the BEST! My…read morehusband got me addicted to the tea cookies. The cookies themselves are small and soft... yet the icing is also soft and the ratio of cookie:icing is perfect! The normal sized cookies are always very cute- well decorated. Again- the icing is soft and delicious! I'm not a fan of royal icing, which is what most places around here use to decorate their pretty cookies. I LOVE the fact that NCH uses buttercream. Without a doubt, I believe their cookies are far superior to any other bakery in Cincinnati. The cakes are so tasty, of course including the cupcakes. I love the variety of flavors they always have in their cupcakes. And then... there's the pastries! I'll just say- I've never had a bad one! This place is amazing! The only bad part is how crazy it can get in the small space, but it's for the love of the sweets. So I can't fault that.... I love walking into bakeries and trying the goods. I've tried all the chains around Cincy (Servatii, Buskens, graeter's). I've tried the non-chain bakeries (BonBonerie, Bonomini, etc). I've gone to Sugar Rush multiple times- so I feel familiar with the competition. NCH bakery is my favorite- because it has never let me down.

Now that the new owners bought the bakery. It's a good thing. They're retiring because the quality…read moreis not there. Things are stale.

Holston's Baking Co.

4.5

(29 reviews)

We have been enjoying Holston's for a while. Every time we visit, we intend to take a photo & leave…read morea review. The problem is, we end up hoovering the slice before we remember. Today, we exercised a bit more self control. My hubby and I visit weekly. We get 2 slices, different flavors. We plan to try them all. There are so many flavors!! The cheesecake is divine!! Haven't had a flavor we have not loved. A couple I HIGHLY recommend are the blueberry crumble and the lemon supreme. If you are more of a rich, decadent flavor... the chocolate crunch and the peanut butter cup. Wednesday is buy one slice, get the second 50% off.

Holston's Baking Company is a cute little shop with big flavors, and it completely lived up to the…read morehype on our visit. While the space itself isn't large, they had an impressive selection of cookies, cakes, and cheesecakes for a Wednesday afternoon--plenty to tempt you the moment you walk in. I went straight for the bourbon caramel swirl cheesecake, and that's when things got even better. The girl behind the counter casually mentioned they use Weller's bourbon . Even better? She proudly said she gets to eat whichever flavor she wants. I joked that sounded like a great perk--she laughed and revealed she's actually the daughter of the owners. Loved that little personal touch. My wife is more of a traditionalist and chose the original cheesecake with caramel swirl. She said it was incredibly creamy and very good. Mine was just as creamy, with a noticeable punch of bourbon flavor balanced perfectly by the caramel, and finished with a crispy, satisfying crust. Bottom line: definitely good, definitely delicious. This is the kind of place that makes you plan your next visit before you've even finished your slice. I would absolutely return for another piece (or two) Unfortunately, I ate my cheesecake but I snap a photo. I couldn't wait! lol!

Oliver’s Desserts

3.9

(42 reviews)

Great tasting and looking treats. Fair prices Staff very knowledgeable Display case very prettyread more

Absolutely the worst coffee I've ever had. It's basically just dirty water with a hint of burnt…read moreflavor. The artificial taste is overwhelming, and I can't believe I paid for this. It's clear that no real coffee beans were used--just cheap, watered-down nonsense. Save your money and skip this one!

Sweeterie

4.6

(42 reviews)

Loved stopping here for an afternoon pick me up. Enjoyed a…read morecupcake with peanut butter icing. Space was clean and well decorated. Nice selection of cupcakes, and cookies to pick from. Served quickly and enjoyed the conversation. Will definitely be stopping again!

Stopped in as I was exploring the neighborhood. I was welcomed by friendly service and I left with…read moresome delicious cookies! I ordered the pecan raspberry, peanut butter toffee, and--while they were all yummy--my personal favorite, ginger molasses.

Little Flour Baked Goods

4.0

(25 reviews)

I called several bakeries a few weeks ago looking for custom cookies for my daughter's law school…read moregraduation. One bakery told me they couldn't make cookies because it was Mother Day's weekend, even though I was picking the cookies up the Friday before. A few other random bakery calls were not very helpful. Then I remembered Little Flour and so happy I did. The cookies were absolutely beautiful and tasted divine. They were a huge hit at the party. On top of that, the price was much more reasonable than my first choice, a well known, local bakery. Highly recommend!

This place is a northern Ky treasure Thanks Elizabeth and staff for making the cutest cookies and…read morecupcakes for my daughters wedding celebration Also your caramel apple cupcake is fantastic

Little Dutch Bakery

4.5

(34 reviews)

Some of the best glazed donuts in the donut making business! My kids say they're as good as any…read moredonut they've ever eaten and my co-workers agree.

I was really excited to try this bakery for the first time, especially because I love supporting…read morelocal bakeries rather than chains. Unfortunately, my experience was very disappointing. I ordered 8 donuts for $15: two lemon-filled, one chocolate-iced yeast, one pink-iced yeast, two blueberry cake, one pumpkin cake, and one chocolate cake. The pumpkin cake donut was about the size of a bangle bracelet, extremely small, dry, and completely lacking in flavor. The blueberry cake donuts were the same--small, thin, dry, and practically flavorless. The lemon-filled donuts were okay, but they seemed to have more filling than actual donut. Overall, the donuts felt undersized, as if not enough dough was being used to make a proper, full-sized donut. For the price, I expected much better quality, flavor, and portion sizes. I was genuinely looking forward to trying this bakery, but unfortunately, it did not live up to my expectations. Based on this first experience, I would not return. It's disappointing when you're excited to support a local business and end up feeling let down instead.

Busken Bakery

4.3

(18 reviews)

•$$$

The gals behind the counter were friendly and patient and answered every question that we had about…read moreevery donut and pastry. The donuts and pastries are big and taste very fresh. The butter muffin was so yummy and gooey on the inside. I learned today that they even have a drive thru!

Visited Busken Bakery for the first time on a recent trip to the Cincinnati area with some of my…read morefamily. We were in town to visit other family members who are local to the area, so we stopped here to pick up some treats to bring along with us on our visit. Busken Bakery is a third-generation, locally owned business in Cincinnati that has been around for nearly 100 years. They have 4 locations listed on their website, with one of them being in Eastgate/Batavia. The selection here includes a variety of homemade breads, cookies, cakes, donuts, pies, and more. Various coffee and other drinks are also available to enjoy with your treats. This location specifically is in the Eastgate/Batavia area, at the intersection of Glen-Este Withamsville Road and Old State Route 74. The storefront is the right corner unit in a small strip mall-type complex called Glen-Este Village Centre. As someone who is not from the area and had never been here specifically, it is relatively easy to navigate to. Their branding is visible on the larger sign for the shopping center, which can be read from the road. Parking here was no issue There are two rows of parking spaces at the front of the shopping center. It was not at all crowded in the complex at the time of our visit, so we easily got a parking spot just steps from the bakery entrance. Our visit here was around 12:40 PM on a Saturday in September. I am assuming the crowd for this place comes in the morning time, given the type of business it is. There were no other customers in the store at the time of our visit. The bakery also has some aspects of a cafe. There are a few bar-height tables, four-top tables, and even a kids table available for patrons in the front of the store. It would be nice to grab some goodies, a nice drink, and hang out for a little bit in the space. They even had some different reading material available for free, too. We took some time to look around at all of the different items in the bakery before deciding what we wanted to order. They have a few bakery cases at the counter filled with different cookies, dipped treats, and other pastries that can be purchased individually or in various quantities. Behind the counter was a selection of donuts. The pre-made cakes sit to the left, and are displayed so it is easy for the customer to see. Throughout the store, there are different tables and displays with the breads, pies, pre-packaged cookies, and seasonal items. I loved the nods to the Cincinnati area all around the space, including the Bengals-themed cookies, the "Chew Dey" sign, and the variety of orange/black/white items to choose from. It was fun to look around at the different items and decorations the staff put together. On the left-hand side, there are a few different coolers with a variety of cold drinks. Also, there are coffee urns with self-serve hot coffee. Greeting cards, candles, and other retail items are in this space as well. The family we were going to visit has a few young children, so we chose to get a tub of the Original Iced Cookies that were pre-packaged. They were decorated as yellow smiley faces, and were a nice size for a child or for an adult as a little treat. We liked the taste of these, and they lasted for several days afterwards. The cookies in the case looked delicious but with the nut flavoring and our particular occasion that we were buying them for, we decided against them. I personally would have loved to try them, as they all looked and sounded so good! Overall, there was a healthy selection of items throughout the store. I thought they would have more variety in terms of cookies, as it seemed like there were only a few different kinds. Same sentiment for the breads. I am not sure if it was just because we were there later in the day, or if that is the way it always is. Maybe next time I will need to stop earlier to get the full experience in this regard. The staff were attentive and helpful. Since we were the only ones in the space, I think they were overly-attentive at points, but that is fine. I am more of a shop on my own-type of shopper, so not my favorite when employees are watching my every move. However, I understand they are simply doing their job and we essentially had their undivided attention. Glad that we found this local bakery to stop at during our trip to Cincinnati! Their products were good, the storefront was decorated and appealing, the staff were all friendly. I would love to return in the future to try more of their items, including these infamous donuts I have been reading about here in other people's reviews. Would recommend giving Busken Bakery a try if you find yourself in the area.

Amaezing Sweet Shoppe

4.4

(12 reviews)

Wow! What a gem Amaezing Sweet Shoppe is! I am glad I found it. I have been wanting to visit once I…read moresaw that they offered fruit mousse entremets. However, they offer so much more than that! They offer coffee, milkshakes, ice cream, baked goods, cakes, and even have cake decorating classes. They also have a drive-thru, which makes a quick trip easy. I stopped in with a plan to get fruit mousse entremets for myself and my family and I did exactly that. I brought home cherry, peach, lemon, and blueberry fruit mousse entremets. They were delicious and tasted just like the fruits! Everyone in my family was happy and wants to return to Amaezing Sweet Shoppe. They were light and incredible! They have cute coffee stirrers, which I got for my mom's upcoming birthday. They have multiple flavors but I chose chocolate and salted caramel. I liked that I had the option to buy small treats, as well. The owner was very sweet and helpful. She is gifted at her trade and very skilled! I plan on visiting next time I'm in town. I have definitely found a new favorite spot!

The cake I picked up was average and there wasn't a variety of options. I was looking for a sweet…read moretreat. I did realize I needed to order a head of time.

Eliza Jane’s BakeShop

4.6

(7 reviews)

Had a chance to try this bakery at the Taste of Cincinnati and it did not disappoint. The bourbon…read morepeach cobbler sundae was MAGNIFICENT. The warm crumble topped with delicious peaches and cream melted in your mouth. This is a must try dessert!

Went on a beautiful Saturday afternoon to Findlay and found this cute shop. The very last slice of…read morehoney vanilla cake (the sales clerk said it was the last of an extra from their flavor of the month for April) smiled at me and decided it would be the cake to celebrate my birthday! The sales person was lovely and friendly and I was happy to take the beautiful slice home to have after dinner. However, the cake was obviously past its best by date. It was dry and warming in the microwave (my typical approach) did not help. The flavors were lovely but the cake was way too dry to enjoy. I was so disappointed both by being served cake that had seen better days but also the lost opportunity to find a place in Cincy I loved to get cake from, especially given how cute the shop was.

Sweets By Ladawn

4.2

(51 reviews)