I came here almost a year ago before COVID so catching up on reviewing - the place is full of delicious pizzas - I had the regular slice and Sicilian and they were both very very good - high quality ingredients and pleasant staff - I give them 5 stars not only because the food is yummy but because the crust was done extra and I prefer that read more

This pizzeria looks like a diamond in the rough . The exterior is beautiful along with it's outdoor seating . One can purchase beer in this pizzeria as well and they deliver. The pizza is more expensive than Lil Cesar's but at least it is fresh and delicious. One can also stay and enjoy their slice while watching the news on the flat screen. I like this place . The pizza is authentic. The customer service is excellent because the servers are friendly and comical. A slice is 2.95. I really want to try a chicken parmesan sandwich next time . read more

Fazio's - TV - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Always good! Fun staff full of personality and the pizza is always excellent. Whether you're going for the a regular slice or a square you can't go wrong. The cheese and sauce are quality tasty, they don't skimp on either. Only had one bad experience when they told me and my buddy they were closed early on a weekend and when we were like "oh no, why?" We were totally ignored. Dude was just a jerk. However, I've never encountered him since and everyone else there is a gem. Again, great pizza with awesome everything and great people. read more

I ordered a large pie for 35$ ... the whole bottom is burned. Black. Also it's extremelyyyyy salty! I'm really disappointed. What a waste. None of us enjoyed it. Only touched 2 slices. I almost want to call them back for a refund. read more

Theses are the best arancini, I have ever had, outside of one of my relatives' kitchens or Sicily. The saffron flavor stands up to the Bolognese and cheese. Just the right crispness on the outside with creamy, flavorful Arborio rice inside. Also, the sciacca, like rolled pizza with the toppings on the inside, of the day was delicious with ricotta and sausage. Pizza-wise, we quartered a few slices. I love the broccoli rabe and sausage pizza, but each one we tried was fantastic. The owner, Santo, said that he occasionally makes sfincione, too. I hope next time I'm in town, the stars align for me and he has made it! Friendly staff, fast service, delicious food. This place is amazing. read more

See all

Hard review for me because the slice tasted amazing. Ordered the whole sha'bang. Grandmas, Sicilian, Arancini, etc.. I don't know what they consider arancini, but they gave me what seems like a calzone version of arancini that was barely edible... Thing was huge and not cooked all the way though. Very odd.. besides that the slices were unbelievable good. Although they also forgot a couple toppings that cost $.75-$1 each.. order at your own risk IMO . Probably get overcharged but slices are good read more

For a 95% pizza place this is terrible. Looks good ,tasteless The sauce is so flat The appeal there is no competition so he sells some pizza. Beautiful signage .I can not believe the rudeness of the counter help. I have truly never experienced anything that bad. If he sold the shop or learned how to make sauce and bought some decent pizza cheese this would be the place to go. Now it's the place to avoid Such a vulgar counterman He was screaming F..so loudly you could hear him from the street. Go ELSEWHERE BAD FLAVORLESS PIZZA read more

First time visitor, life long fan. Fantastic pizza. We bucked the cold and sat outside drank a Peroni and ate hot, crispy crusted pie. Recommend to all Brooklyn pizza lovers. Great friendly service as well. read more

This place has good pizza and decent subs. The meatball and chicken park are decent compare to other places.

Do not order online from this place. They take hella long to deliver. Good pizza, but every single pizza crust has always been burnt. I should just order from Roberta's. read more

Fazio's - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Been wanting to go here for sometime and I was not disappointed at all! Great pizza and fib even though it was warm that day (90' degrees outside) there pizza was still tasty! read more

See all

This pizza is always great. I order via Uber eats all the time. My only issue is it would be really great if they closed and sealed the pizza box with a sticker/tape especially when getting delivered so that I know it was less likely to be tampered with. read more

Disappointing experience, AKA how to lose a loyal customer in 30 seconds. Long-time Fazio's fan here--literally the only place I've ordered pies from the last few years, at minumum once a month via the Slice app. Never had a complaint until last night. After waiting over an hour for a pizza, I got roughly the following call from the shop: Me (picking up on the second ring): "Hello?" Fazio's: "This Evan?" Me: "Yeah. I'll be right downstairs." Fazio's: "Actually our delivery guy was already there. He tried to call you four times but you didn't answer." Me (confused, having been sitting there with my phone in hand, waiting for the call): "Oh man, I'm sorry. I'm pretty sure I didn't miss any calls though." Fazio's: "He can come back but he's out on another delivery right now, so it'll probably be around twenty minutes." Me (disappointed, imagining a cold pizza): "Alright, I understand. But just for the record I really don't think I missed any calls." Fazio's (not in a friendly way): "Yeah well, next time pick up your phone." Double checked after he hung up, and I definitely hadn't missed a call--let alone four. Even if I had, this customer experience couldn't have been sh*ttier, especially as someone who's spent hundreds of dollars at this business and never given them a single problem. If homeboy had called me up with, "Hey my bad, we missed your order," or "Dude I'm sorry we're late, we've been slammed all night," my response would 100% have been, "No worries, appreciate the call." And a year from now I'd still be ordering Fazio's pies. Instead I'm writing this review and moving on to a new pizzeria. read more

When one orders soup it should come with bread, or at least crackers, which is what Fazio's usually did before- especially if it is just blah lentil soup and mad watery. However, on this extremely cold day, when I envisioned some warm soup with a piece of bread on the side, the guy didn't put any bread in the bag. When I asked for the bread, I'm told that it's $2 extra! So you mean to tell me you are charging 4.95 for half-ass lentil soup with hardly any vegetables or anything,just a lot of broth and you can't even give me a piece of bread to eat with it?? I won't be returning to that gentrified, burnt pizza baking, no bread-giving, inauthentic shop. read more

When I'm in the mood for pizza I always go for the local small business spots. Whether it's a slice or my favorite sub (chicken parmesan with anchovies) it's always on point. The meatballs also never disappoint. Not to mention the guy that works the register is always super chill and always remembers my weird orders. If the food is good and the service is great that's all you really need. No frills. Also sorry I don't know your name but when you're not working I seldom place an order. Good customer service is rare. read more

Fantastic pizza! I usually get one slice of the (Sicilian) vegan, which is my absolute favorite, along with one slice of whatever vegetarian slice looks most appealing at the time. I usually cannot finished both slices because they're really filling, but I refuse to only get one slice. The staff is really friendly and there's always available seating. Also, they accept credit cards. read more

I have been here twice when I've visited family from the West coast and it is simply one of the best pizza's I've ever had! Flavorful..perfect crunch, balance of sauce and toppings, which are fresh, authentic and creative. They have other great traditional faire if you're not looking for pizza. If you are looking for a traditional NY "bending" slice this may not be the place for you. An amazing Sicilian pizza created to perfection! read more

Fazio's - pepperoni and sausage....extra sauce! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I was craving pizza when I came across this place on a third party delivery app. The pizza was everything I ever hoped for in a Sicilian pie. Next time I will try the grandma slice... cuz whatever grandma's whipping up, I want in read more

I have ordered take out from Fazio's over 30 times now. I have never been disappointed, not even once. My go to order is a large margherita pizza and a side of broccoli rabe. The bitterness of the broccoli rabe complements the margherita perfectly. The broccoli rabe is steamed and sautéed with garlic and olive oil. Once in a while I will also get a slice of the Sicilian. Their version of Sicilian is done perfectly. The crust has just the right amount of crispness has never been mushy. The Sicilian also toasts up perfectly for lunch the next day! Their sandwiches need a little improvement. The bread did not taste home made and the fillings inside were too salty with not enough flavor. Stick with the pizza and broccoli rabe and you will not be disappointed! read more

Decent crust but unless you love or seeking out Detroit style, stick to the concrete jungle's NY style.

This was the first slice I ever had when I moved to New York a few months ago. STILL the best slice I've had. I've been to over 40 pizza places since, I swear, and I haven't had a slice this good in my life. Just the fresh mozzarella cheese slice. Shit had me emotional. This is how pizza is supposed to taste and how you're supposed to feel while eating it. I'm so lucky this is in my neighborhood. If it wasn't so damn cold out I would be coming here way more often. read more

I got the Neapolitan Pizza Pie and added pepperoni. The pizza is delicious, the crust is a little limp, but not soggy or any means. The crust itself has great flavor and is the perfect thickness. The delivery was on time in the window promised. The only reason that I'm give 4 rather than 5 stars is because when you add pepperoni to pizza, you expect at least regular size (bigger would be fine too) pepperonis. Instead I got these mini pepperonis, if I knew that I would have gotten sausage instead. Mini pepperonis are for salads not pizza. read more

Best pizza I ever had! I think maybe ever better than defara's! Service and atmosphere was excellent!

Amazing authentic pizza. Real mozzarella cheese and seasonings that make this pizza better than a basic pizza!

I am impressed, Fazio's was outstanding. We will be making this a regular spot. Every thing we had here was good. They are very clean and the workers were super pleasant. Would highly recommend Fazio's. read more

So we found this place on yelp delivery and after seeing the reviews we wanted to give it a shot. We got the Sicilian for $20, which isn't bad at all. We ordered everything through Yelp which was a pretty great experience. Our food was estimated to take 45 minutes- 1 hour and it got there in about 30 minutes. The pizza was amazing, so amazing that we took the remaining slices back to NC with us haha. I definitely plan to go back to NY soon and this place is on my list again! read more

See all

Good pizza, especially within the neighborhood. But I just ordered a neopolitan pizza pie and arugula salad. Only the pizza arrived and it's cold. read more

Best deep dish style pizza in Brooklyn. Fast service, very friendly staff. Clean and cozy spot! Vegan options as well. read more

A regular spot for our house hold. If you like a thick chewy crust with a bite to it I suggest you get the Sicilian slices. Grandmas is always best. read more

I have gotten delivery and also done pickup, and both times we were happy with our food. Also, the people working there are always friendly and helpful. We love the thin crust and the Sicilian, though I have yet to do a whole pie of a Sicilian. The arugula salad was super fresh with a light and lemony dressing. Great value, and quick delivery! read more

This is my go to pizza spot. Not only do they have amazing pizza slices. I usually get the Neapolitan pizza with pepperoni. Their pepperoni is so good but the real star of their show personally are the arancini balls and the meatball parm sandwich. I'm drooling thinking of eating those right now but they enlighten every single one of my taste buds. Please treat yourself here and you won't regret it. read more

This shithole of a business is an absolute scam. They list their delivery radius outside of what they support on Uber Eats, then after the order starts to be prepared, they call and tell you that you have to cancel the order. Since Uber Eats lists that they've already started preparing the order, even if you cancel you have to pay for it. I called the manager about this and was greeted with nothing except rudeness and lack of desire to help. Avoid at all costs. read more

Yes Fazio's. Drove here from Canarsie because I just liked the vibe and good reviews on Yelp. Construction/sewer break closed the block and Sat dbl parking was like level XIII of Grand Theft Auto Bushwick, but I powered thru adversity like a goddamn Ukrainian window salesman and made it in to a mostly empty but freakishly promising joint. Politely requested margherita slice and Napolitan spinach mushroom shingle which were both eaten on the 4 block walk back to my car and both were spectacular. I dare you to enjoy it more. read more

Fast, clean, and friendly! This place is great!! We had a group of 7 from out of town stop in unexpectedly for dinner and the staff was great, the pizza was awesome and the whole place was clean! The restaurant owner didn't even complain when we all had to ask for separate receipts at the end of our meal! Must try! read more

See all

I am impressed, Fazio's was certainly terrific. First of all, the price is unbeatable. Every thing was fresh, healthy, and very yummy. Bonus that their service is so great, they are so fast and helpful. Overall, we have been satisfy with Fazio's and their service. read more

I randomly found this pizzeria one in Brooklyn. And it's a hidden gem. Owners are super chill and food is high quality.

Santo, going to miss you and the best pizza in the city. The thin crust with kalamata olives is like crack to my wife and I. And we did our best to copy your arugula salad recipe. When we serve it to friends, they never fail to gush how amazing it tastes! It was my lucky day when moved within walking distance. Best of luck getting through these crazy times! read more

Although delivery service is good the quality is very inconsistent. Some days the pizza is saucy and other days not so saucy. Some days crust is thin and crispy and other days not. Chicken parm loaded with cheese and very little marinará. read more

Fazio's is simply awesome. The menu is amazing and the atmosphere is perfect. Fazio's has a fantastic Sicilian Slice, try it I believe you would really like it, I certainly love it. All of the staff are very helpful - you definitely feel welcome and looked after. Yes, Fazio's actually care that you are happy. read more

I was super excited to try Fazio's, but unfortunately I was really let down. I ordered An eggplant parm hero and a white Sicilian slice- my eggplant parm had NO cheese whatsoever (?!) and my slice was in the oven for too long bc the edges were hard as a rock. I'm giving it 3 stars because I feel like the slice can redeem itself? but overall it was a really disappointing experience. read more